American Pie Presents: Girls' Rules

Now that it is their senior year, four teenage friends named Annie, Kayla, Michelle and Stephanie band together to get what they want. Annie is a virgin who is trying to lose her virginity to her boyfriend. Stephanie is a confident lacrosse player who is blackmailing her school’s perverted principal into retiring by recording him being chained up and whipped by her. Kayla is insecure about her boyfriend cheating and constantly goes through his phone asking if she is the best girlfriend he has ever had. Michelle is a sex toy expert who prides herself on her education. They all make a pact to get what they need this year. Along comes Grant, a handsome new guy in school. He meets Michelle first as she is rushing to class, as she is distracted by the sight of him, she runs into a door and he helps her.

Kayla's boyfriend breaks up with her and as Grant witnesses this, he offers help in making her ex jealous. Stephanie is playing lacrosse and meets Grant by knocking him to the ground during a play.

Michelle takes Annie to a sex shop to buy her first toy, a vibrating set of panties. Annie uses the toy later that day while having phone sex with her boyfriend. Grant and his mother Ellen come over to introduce Ellen to Annie’s single father Kevin, who tells Grant to go upstairs and meet his daughter.

Michelle and Stephanie end up liking Grant and employ ways to win his affection. Michelle, playing the damsel in distress trips and falls into a locker in front of Grant. He takes her to the nurse and Oliver, the principal's assistant, a nerdy boy who has a crush on Michelle, helps out. Stephanie goes to Grant's friend Emmett (her old childhood friend who she had a falling out with) and asks for his help and offers him $100.

Annie runs into Grant in the library and they team up to study and slowly start falling for each other. Kayla and her ex-boyfriend start having sex regularly. Stephanie and Emmett spend more and more time together to help her win over Grant and start falling for each other. Things come to a head at Ellen’s house party when the girls realize they all know and have crushes on Grant. Grant says he has a crush on Annie and they kiss. She feels guilty and goes to see her boyfriend Jason who is in college and catches him getting a blowjob from a girl. Initially angry, she feels relief because she realizes she has feelings for Grant.

Ellen helps Michelle realize that Oliver is the perfect guy for her as he also has a love of John F. Kennedy and when doing an imitation of his speech she realizes she likes him. They all go to a party thrown by Stephanie in an attempt to get together with Grant. Realizing that Grant likes Annie they call off the pact. A fight breaks out when Stephanie gets called a slut and Emmett defends her, which then causes Stephanie to punch the assailant and throw him out. Emmett and Stephanie kiss, realizing the whole time they had feelings for each other. Kayla and her ex-boyfriend Tim get back together. Michelle and Oliver end up together. Jason shows up and tells Grant about the pact. The girls all go to the pajama prom together and help Annie win back Grant. He shows up and they kiss. Their friends set up a tent on the football field so Annie can finally lose her virginity. They all end up having sex with their respective partners.

• Madison Pettis as Annie
• Lizze Broadway as Stephanie
• Piper Curda as Kayla
• Natasha Behnam as Michelle
• Darren Barnet as Grant
• Zachary Gordon as Emmett
• Camaron Engels as Tim
• Zayne Emory as Jason
• Christian Valderrama as Oliver
• Sara Rue as Ellen
• Ed Quinn as Kevin
• Danny Trejo as Janitor Steve Garcia
• Lucas Adams as McCormick
• Patricia Elliott as MeePaw
• Barry Bostwick as PeePaw
• Rasheda Crockett as Rose
• Tatiana DeMaria as Lead Singer

After the success of American Pie Presents: The Book of Love, writer David H. Steinberg was hired in 2010 to write the next movie in the series entitled American Pie Presents: East Great Falls centered around four male students at East Great Falls High School who all fall in love with the same female student. Universal Studios hired new writers starting in 2017 to flip the genders of all the characters.[5]

On Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 30% based on reviews from 10 critics.[6][7]

Robyn Bahr of The Hollywood Reporter wrote: "Dashed together by a male director, two male screenwriters and a half-male producing team, the film appears to be the cinematic equivalent of two straight girls making out at a party for some bro's attention."[8] Teo Bugbee of The New York Times wrote: "The original American Pie was tasteless; this version is flavorless."[9]

• American Pie Presents: Girls' Rules on IMDb