Cody Asche

The Phillies drafted Asche in the fourth round, with the 151st overall selection, of the 2011 MLB draft.[4][6] In 2011, the Phillies moved him to second base for his professional debut the Williamsport Crosscutters of the Class A-Short Season New York–Penn League. He struggled there, posting a batting average of just .192. After the season, he was moved back to third base. In 2012, he hit .349 with the Clearwater Threshers of the Class A-Advanced Florida State League, and was promoted to the Reading Phillies of the Class AA Eastern League, where he batted .300. Using his combined stats from all levels during the 2012 season, he led all Phillies minor leaguers with a .324 batting average, and 168 hits; his efforts earned him two Phillies Minor League Player of the Week selections (one in May and one in August), and a Minor League Player of the Month selection in May.[7] The Phillies assigned Asche to the Peoria Javelinas in the Arizona Fall League after the season for further development, and he played in the league's all-star game and led the league in doubles with 11.[7][8]

Keith Law, a minor league talent evaluator for ESPN, derided Asche as a prospect both offensively and defensively, noting that he likely would not be much of a power hitter and was a questionable defender. Nevertheless, Baseball America rated Asche as the Phillies' seventh-best prospect after the 2012 season.[9] After the 2012 season, another analyst wrote that Asche had an "average" body for a baseball player, commented that while he had limited power potential, he could be a solid contact hitter because of quick hands and "incredibly sound" hitting mechanics, but was a "terrible" defender with a "fringy arm". Subsequently, however, he improved defensively to become "passable".[10] In 2013, Asche played for the Lehigh Valley IronPigs of the Class AAA International League (IL). He was named to the IL team in the Triple-A All-Star Game.[11] After batting .295 with 15 home runs and 68 RBIs for Lehigh Valley,[12] and being named their Player of the Month for July,[13] the Phillies promoted Asche to the major leagues on July 30.[14] One writer found it "mildly surprising" that the Phillies called up Asche rather than Maikel Franco, a fellow third base prospect who most thought had far more potential than Asche.[9]

Although Asche was a non-roster invitee to major league spring training,[7] the Phillies called up Asche to give him "an extended look" at the third base position, particularly in comparison to Franco. On July 30, 2013, Asche was called up by the Phillies, who quickly installed him as the team's starting third baseman. Upon his call-up, some scouts compared him to Chase Utley, particularly his demeanor. Asche hoped to emulate Utley, noting, "I can only hope someday I can be compared to that guy."[15] As a hitter, he is better as a contact hitter than a power hitter; defensively, he made improvements, which (at the time) brought him accolades from then-Phillies manager Ryne Sandberg.

On August 8, Asche went 3-for-5 with a double, a home run and two RBIs. He had a two-run home run to right field in the fourth inning to give the Phillies a nine-run lead. It was the first home run of his big league career.[16] On September 6, 2013, Asche hit a game-winning two-run homer to lead the Phillies over the first-place Atlanta Braves.[17] Asche concluded the 2013 season with a .235 batting average, 5 home runs, and 22 RBIs at the major league level.[18]

Entering the 2014 season, most writers thought he had earned the starting third baseman's job. Bill Baer, a writer for ESPN, NBC Sports, and Baseball Prospectus, noted that not only had Asche earned a starting spot, but that his 2013 success helped the development of the team at large. He explained,

"Last year, the Phillies went into the off-season looking at a weak free agent market for third basemen and no realistic internal options. The Phillies opted to trade for Michael Young, which did not pan out. Considering the way Asche has played in a month-plus, the Phillies don’t have to worry about third base at all this off-season. Even better is that Maikel Franco will get a chance to prove himself at the Triple-A level over an entire season. Had Asche not been an option, the Phillies may have gone with another stopgap solution, and that could have motivated the Phillies to rush Franco along faster than necessary," – Bill Baer[19]

Phillies manager Ryne Sandberg also called Asche the leading candidate for the job, noting that he would be the Phillies first homegrown third baseman since Scott Rolen.[20] Most were optimistic on Asche's development, though noted he is another left-handed hitter in a lineup dominated by lefties, featuring only one-to-two righties.[21] The Phillies ultimately demoted Franco, and Asche was named the opening day starter at third base.[22]

Asche began the 2014 successfully; on opening day, he went three-for-four at the plate (3 hits in 4 at bats), scored four runs, had a double, home run, and two RBIs.[23] However, over the first month of the season, he struggled, which led to frequent replacement in the lineup by either Freddy Galvis or Jayson Nix, particularly against left-handed pitchers.[24] None of the trio produced offensively, which led to suggestions within the media the Phillies should promote Franco.[25] On May 6, however, he had four hits in four at bats, including a game-tying grand slam in a game against the Toronto Blue Jays, though the Phillies ultimately lost in extra innings.[26] He struggled mightily in the field on May 13, committing three total errors, two of which occurred in an inning during which the Angels scored four unearned runs. However, after that series, Asche bounced back against the Reds in a three-game series during which he went 7 for 12 with six RBIs and three extra base hits, including a three-run home run.[27] On May 25, he was placed on the disabled list as a precaution due to a strained left hamstring.[28] As the season progressed, Asche was the regular starter, and ultimately, he described his season as "satisfactory", with room for improvement, while Crashburn Alley's Michael Baumann called Asche's season "encouraging and disappointing at the same time."[29][30]

Asche began the 2015 season among the team's hottest hitters, and a mainstay in the lineup as the team's starting third baseman.[31] However, in late April, he began working on skills as an outfielder, ostensibly in preparation for the arrival of minor league prospect Maikel Franco, regarded as a stronger defensive third baseman.[32] In fact, the Phillies optioned Asche back to Triple-A on May 12 to accelerate his development as a left fielder, as Franco was hitting very well in the minor leagues, and could be ready for a promotion. Although surprised and disappointed by the move, Asche sought to trust the organization and play wherever it needed him.[33] Ultimately, Asche struggled to find playing time during the remainder of the season, although MLB.com writer Todd Zolecki said that Asche would be given an opportunity in 2016 as the Phillies like his makeup, but the burden will be on him to produce results to justify the playing time, given the amelioration of other options at his positions.[34]

Asche struggled to establish himself throughout the 2016 season, and ultimately the emergence of Franco at third base forced Asche permanently into the outfield, where he struggled to produce after returning from an oblique injury that sidelined him until June.[35][36] He stayed with the major league team from June 2 through August 9, but was optioned to Lehigh Valley upon the return of Peter Bourjos. In the minor leagues, he hit .302, earning a September call-up, but he did not earn significant playing time throughout the remainder of the season, and ultimately, his season ended with a "disappointing" stat line of a .213 batting average with four home runs and 13 RBIs in 71 games.[18][37] The Phillies designated Asche for assignment after the 2016 season, and he became a free agent.[38]

On January 6, 2017, Asche signed a minor league contract with the Chicago White Sox.[39] During April and May of the 2017 season, Asche appeared in 19 MLB games with Chicago, batting 6-for-57 (.105) with one home run and four RBIs. He was outrighted to the AAA Charlotte Knights on May 16, where he batted .292 in 87 games, with 14 homes runs and 57 RBIs. He became a free agent after the season.

On December 14, 2017, Asche signed a minor league contract with the Kansas City Royals that included an invitation to spring training.[40]

On April 4, 2018, the Royals traded Asche to the New York Yankees for a player to be named later or cash considerations.[41] He was assigned to the AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders, where he batted .169 in 16 games. He was released on May 1, 2018.[42]

The New York Mets signed Asche to a minor league deal on May 3, 2018, and assigned him to Triple-A Las Vegas.[43] In 89 games with Las Vegas, Asche batted .230 with 10 home runs and 38 RBIs. He became a free agent after the season.[44]

On February 6, 2019, Asche signed a minor league deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers.[45] He was released on March 27, 2019.

On April 15, 2019, Asche signed with the Sugar Land Skeeters of the Atlantic League of Professional Baseball.

On May 3, 2019, his contract was purchased by the Boston Red Sox;[46][47] he was assigned to the Class AA Portland Sea Dogs.[48]

On December 20, 2019, Asche signed a minor league deal with the Minnesota Twins. He became a free agent on November 2, 2020.

When Asche reached the major leagues, he was regarded as having decent potential at the plate, perhaps comparable to Mariners' third baseman Kyle Seager.[49] While he hit for power in the minor leagues, his big league power was expected to be adequate, perhaps averaging 12–14 home runs per season. Baseball Prospect Nation reported that he "gets pull happy when he sells out for power and ultimately swings too hard at times."[50] Like most left-handed hitters,[51] Asche performed better against right-handed pitchers than left-handed pitchers, hitting .238 off the former and .219 off the latter in the major leagues during 2013.[52] FanGraphs columnist Michael Barr summarized Asche's offensive potential by writing, "He's certainly not going to be a world beater, but having double digit home run and speed potential while hitting something in the .275 range is likely the kind of hitter than many of you could use at third base."[49]

Though as a minor league prospect, analysts derided his defensive potential, with one calling him "terrible", he progressively improved.[10] Late in 2013, Sandberg commented on his defensive improvement: "I see tremendous progress on his footwork out there, his reads on balls, his quickness, his reacting to the hops and getting the hop he wants. It looks like he's really worked on his glove play, just using the glove along with his strong accurate arm. It's a very true ball that he throws over there. It's got a lot on it. I've seen a lot of improving developments since I saw him in mid-February. He's come a long way."[53]

New Phillies' bench coach Larry Bowa said, "(Asche) reminds me of a younger Chase Utley, he gets real mad when he misses a ball, he wants to make every play, he wants to go out and work, you can't hit enough groundballs to him ... he's got a great attitude ... that kind of energy can invigorate a ball club."[55] Marcus Hayes, a writer for the Philadelphia Daily News concurred with Bowa's comparison of Asche to Utley, calling their similarities "eerie", and writing, "Already, Asche's solution to failure is to ignore fatigue; to work harder; to improve at all costs. His objective is not necessarily to hit home runs, or to hit a big payday, but, rather, to make sure he can beat out a ground ball in late September. Sound familiar?"[3] Sal Rende, the hitting coach for the Phillies' AAA affiliate, noted that Asche also has solid intangibles, including makeup and work ethic, garnering yet another comparison to Utley. For his part, Asche said that while he appreciates the comparison, he wants to be his own player.[56] Asche's determination and work ethic contributed to his fast ascent through the Phillies minor league system.[57] He is a perfectionist, who recalled a game in which he made three fielding errors as his most memorable game with the big league Phillies.[54]