Cole Deggs & the Lonesome (album)

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
Allmusic	[1]
Country Standard Time	negative[2]

Giving it three-and-a-half stars out of five, Thom Jurek of Allmusic said that it was "a promising first set by a band with a unique sound; they can sing, write, arrange, and play the hell out of their instruments while being uniquely themselves."[1] Jeffrey B. Remz of Country Standard Time was less favorable, calling the band's harmonies "workmanlike" and the songwriting "predictable". He thought that the song "I Haven't Stopped Hurtin'" was the best song on the album because the band "cut loose" on it.[2]

1. "Girl Next Door" (Cole Deggs, Mike Geiger, Trey Matthews) – 3:38
2. "I Got More" (Jim Collins, Rivers Rutherford) – 3:29
3. "Out of Alabama" (Angelo Petraglia, Dave Berg, Hillary Lindsey) – 3:03
4. "Twelve Ounces Deep" (Matthews, Tony Ramey) – 4:18
5. "The One That Got Away" (Berg, Rutherford) – 3:41
6. "Huggin' This Blacktop" (Deggs, Matthews) – 3:45
7. "Makin' Nothing Out of Something" (Deggs, Matthews, Geiger) – 3:41
8. "Do You Ever Think About Me" (Chris Lindsey, Aimee Mayo, Anders Osborne) – 4:52
9. "Everybody's Beautiful to Someone" (Rutherford, Tom Shapiro) – 3:51
10. "A Girl Like You" (Deggs, Jimmy Wallace) – 3:59
11. "I Haven't Stopped Hurtin'" (Phil O'Donnell, Ronnie Rogers) – 3:35