Cuttin' Grass, Vol. 1: The Butcher Shoppe Sessions

Simpson announced the album's release in October 2020 during a livestream concert. Recorded at the Butcher Shoppe Recording Studio, the album includes various bluegrass musicians such as guitarists Tim O'Brien and Mark Howard, banjoist Scott Vestal, fiddler Stuart Duncan, and mandolinist/backing vocalist Sierra Hull. The album consists of bluegrass re-recordings of previous songs in Simpson's catalog, including not only those from his solo albums, but also those from the band Sunday Valley, of which he was a member prior to beginning his solo career.[5]

Stephen M. Deusner of Pitchfork rated the album 7.4 out of 10, stating that "As a country artist, Simpson is determinedly subversive; as a bluegrass artist, he’s incredibly conservative. There are none of the abrupt stylistic changes that made [A Sailor's Guide to Earth] sound as big as the world and none of the sonic experiments that made [Metamodern Sounds in Country Music] such a trip. Simpson can’t quite sustain a double album in this style, and Cuttin' Grass loses some steam toward the end. However, there are more than enough bracing moments here to make you wonder what Volume 2 will sound like".[5] Stephen Thomas Erlewine gave the album 4.5 out of 5 in the review for AllMusic, concluding that "Part of Simpson's appeal lies in how he blurs genres, so it's a bit ironic that this single-minded collection is one of his best records, but it is: it's an album where the joy in the music's creation is palpable and infectious."[6]

All songs written by Sturgill Simpson.

1. "All Around You" – 3:09
2. "All the Pretty Colors" – 2:18
3. "Breakers Roar" – 2:29
4. "I Don't Mind" – 4:29
5. "I Wonder" – 3:14
6. "Just Let Go" – 3:02
7. "Life Ain't Fair and the World Is Mean" – 2:00
8. "A Little Light" – 1:44
9. "Life of Sin" – 2:17
10. "Long White Line" – 2:21
11. "Living the Dream" – 2:30
12. "Old King Coal" – 2:52
13. "Railroad of Sin" – 2:12
14. "Sitting Here Without You" – 1:55
15. "Sometimes Wine" – 3:55
16. "The Storm" – 2:31
17. "Time After All" – 2:14
18. "Turtles All the Way Down" – 2:18
19. "Voices" – 3:37
20. "Water in a Well" – 3:46

Per Bandcamp.[7]

Musical

• Mike Bub – upright bass
• Stuart Duncan – fiddle, background vocals
• Mark Howard – background vocals, lead guitar, rhythm guitar
• Sierra Hull – mandolin, background vocals
• Miles Miller – percussion, background vocals
• Tim O'Brien – background vocals, lead guitar, rhythm guitar
• Sturgill Simpson – vocals, rhythm guitar
• Scott Vestal – banjo, background vocals

Technical

• Richard Dodd – mastering
• David Ferguson – producer, engineer, mixer
• Sturgill Simpson – producer
• Sean Sullivan – engineer, mixer