Daniel LaPlante

LaPlante lived with his mother and stepfather. While growing up in Townsend, LaPlante was sexually and psychologically abused by many adults in his life. LaPlante's father was responsible for the majority of the abuse.[1] He also struggled with school. He was diagnosed with dyslexia at an early age, and his classmates called him “creepy and weird”. As a teenager he was referred to a psychiatrist because of his abnormal behavior, his appearance, and his lack of hygiene.

As a teenager, LaPlante spent his evenings breaking into homes and taking the owners' possessions. He would sometimes move items around in the victims' homes to show that someone had been there without making it blatantly obvious.[1]

In 1986, LaPlante obtained a phone number and address that he thought belonged to one of his previous burglary victims. The house in fact belonged to a family of three: Brian Andrews and his two daughters, Annie (15) and Jessica (8). Taking special interest in Annie, who was around the same age as him, LaPlante began to frequently call the house to speak with her. Annie assumed that a mutual friend gave LaPlante her number.[1] After several phone calls from LaPlante, wherein he described himself as athletic and good-looking, Annie agreed to go out on a date with him. As he severely misrepresented himself, the date did not go well; LaPlante also fixated on the recent death of the girls' mother to cancer, and took great interest in hearing about the death. These factors led Annie to decline a second date.

Reacting poorly to this rejection, LaPlante subsequently broke into the Andrews' home, found a crawl space and lived in the walls for two months, tormenting the girls with tapping sounds and mysterious writing on the walls. Eventually, the father encountered LaPlante in Annie's room wearing a dress and wig and carrying a hatchet, with which he attempted to attack Andrews. The police investigated and found LaPlante, who was arrested and charged with several crimes.

Afterwards, LaPlante was placed in a juvenile facility, where he stayed until October 1987. The following month, LaPlante returned to burglary, stealing two handguns from a neighbor's house.

On December 1, 1987, LaPlante entered the Townsend home of Priscilla Gustafson, a nursery school teacher. Gustafson, who was pregnant, was found face-down on her bed, her pillows covered in her blood. LaPlante had raped her and shot her multiple times at point-blank range. LaPlante drowned both of her children in separate bathrooms.

A few towns over from Townsend, LaPlante kidnapped a woman in her car, though the woman was able to escape. LaPlante was discovered hiding in a dumpster two days later. The police took him in and inspected his clothing. They found a hair on his sock that was a match for Abigail Gustafson, Priscilla's daughter. A year later, LaPlante was sentenced to three life sentences for the murders of the Gustafsons.[1]

On March 22, 2017, a re-sentencing hearing for LaPlante was held at Middlesex Superior Court in Woburn, Massachusetts. LaPlante asked for a reduction in his sentence.[2] At the hearing, it was mentioned that during his first appeal, previous court rulings were cited saying that juveniles convicted of murder should be given a meaningful opportunity to re-engage with society.[2] There was also a new law allowing “juveniles convicted of murder with extreme cruelty and atrocity to ask for parole after they’ve been behind bars for a minimum of 30 years.” The judge, however, gave LaPlante the maximum penalty of 45 years after a forensic psychiatrist evaluated LaPlante and found that he was not remorseful for his crimes.

LaPlante was featured in Season 2, Episode 1 of Investigation Discovery's Your Worst Nightmare series "Bump in the Night."[3]