James T. McDermott (judge)

James Thomas McDermott, Sr., was born in Philadelphia in 1926, the son of Harry Aloysius McDermott and his wife Helen Genoe McDermott.[1][2] His maternal grandfather, James Genoe, was a Philadelphia Police captain, a fact later said to have contributed to McDermott's law-and-order approach on the bench.[3] His mother, Helen, was a vaudevillian singer and actress before her marriage and entertained the troops in World War I.[4] His father, a clerk and bartender, died in 1954.[2][5]

McDermott earned a bachelor's degree from Saint Joseph's University and a J.D. from Temple University Law School.[6] He was admitted to the bar in 1951 and practiced in the field of labor law at the firm he co-founded, McDermott, Quinn & Higgins.[7] He also taught classes on legal evidence at St. Joseph's and on commercial law at the American Institute of Banking.[7] In 1954, he married Mary Theresa Bradley; they remained married until her death in 1974 and had six children—five sons and one daughter.[8][9]

McDermott entered the political arena in 1958 when he ran for the Republican nomination for the federal House of Representatives from Pennsylvania's 3rd district. He won the primary easily over William M. Phillips, a former city councilman, taking 85% of the vote.[10] In the general election that November, however, McDermott lost to the incumbent Democrat, James A. Byrne, by a 63.5% to 36.5% margin.[11]

In 1962, McDermott ran for city council at-large. The race was a special election, called when councilman Victor E. Moore resigned his seat to become head of the Philadelphia Gas Works in September 1962. Because of the short time between the vacancy and the election, ward leaders picked McDermott instead of holding a primary.[12] That November, McDermott lost the election to the executive director of the Philadelphia Parking Authority, Walter S. Pytko.[13]

1963 Philadelphia mayor election by ward (Tate in blue, McDermott in red)

McDermott was the city Republican organization's choice for mayor in 1963, and he easily defeated three independent candidates in the May primary.[14] The Democrats nominated acting mayor James Hugh Joseph Tate for a full term, and a close race was expected.[15] McDermott campaigned on a reform platform, saying that Tate had worked to sabotage the good-government reforms of the Joseph S. Clark and Richardson Dilworth administrations that had run the city from 1951 to 1962.[16] Tate responded by contrasting his experience with McDermott's and touted his endorsement by the AFL–CIO.[16] McDermott said that Tate "has never been off the public payroll in twenty-five years" and criticized the mayor's refusal to debate him.[16] The election was closer than the one four years earlier, but McDermott still lost by more than 66,000 votes.[17][18]

McDermott continued his private law practice after his mayoral election defeat. In 1965, six new judicial positions were added in Philadelphia's division of the Court of Common Pleas, a trial court of general jurisdiction; Governor William Scranton named McDermott to one of them.[19] He and the other five new judges were nominated to full ten-year terms at the election that November. All six were endorsed by both parties and unopposed for retention in office.[20] He easily won another retention election ten years later, in 1975.[21] In his time on the bench, McDermott became known as a "hanging judge" who imposed harsh sentences on the criminals convicted in his court.[3][22] He imposed the death penalty thirteen times in his fifteen years as a trial court judge.[3]

In 1979, Mayor Frank Rizzo—then term-limited—encouraged McDermott to enter the mayor's race that year as an independent.[23] A few days later, McDermott took himself out of consideration, citing the tremendous cost of starting an independent campaign just two months before the election.[22]

Two years later, McDermott announced his candidacy for one of two open seats on the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. As was common with judicial races at the time, he ran for both major parties' nominations, but remained a member of the Republican Party.[24] He captured second place in the Republican primary—good enough to be nominated—and third on the Democratic slate—falling just short.[25] In the general election in November, McDermott took the top spot with his fellow Republican nominee, William D. Hutchinson, winning the second open seat.[26] The victories gave the Republican Party a 4-3 majority on the court.[26]

In 1983, the Philadelphia Inquirer published a series of stories accusing McDermott and other supreme court justices of conflicts of interest.[6] McDermott sued the newspaper for defamation and won a partial victory after a seven-week trial in 1990.[6] The following year, he won another ten-year term on the high court.[3] McDermott's $6 million verdict against the Inquirer was still being appealed when he died suddenly on June 21, 1992, at the age of 65.[6] After a funeral at St. Augustine Church, he was buried alongside his wife at Saints Peter and Paul Cemetery in Marple Township, Pennsylvania.[3]