José Bretón case

In September 2011, Ruth Ortiz Ramos told her husband, José Bretón Gómez, with whom she had two children, Ruth and José, 6 and 2 years old respectively, about her intention to divorce him; José Bretón conceived the idea of murdering the children, his children, as a revenge against his wife.

Bretón committed the crime on October 8, 2011, having picked his children up the day before to take to Cordoba to spend the weekend.

In order to carry out his plan, José Bretón decided that the most appropriate place would be the estate of his parents, known as Finca de Las Quemadillas, in Córdoba. Also, he decided that the suitable date would be on October 8, 2011, because that weekend he would be with his children.

For that purpose, he started a series of preparations. Thus, as a medical psychiatrist, who had already treated him three years before and with whom he had recently consulted, had prescribed him the tranquilizers Orfidal and Motivan. José Bretón bought these on September 29, 2011, in order to be able to send the children to sleep and murder them easily.

Between the 15 and 7 October 2011, once executed his lethal action and with the intent to make disappear the corpses of his children, José Bretón collected firewood in the smallholding and bought over 270litres of diesel fuel in large quantities in a petrol station from Huelva.

At the same time, José Bretón came up with an alibi for the disappearance of his children and decided to pretend that he had lost them in a park. In order to be able to offer some information about the alleged disappearance, he carried out a kind of experiment with his nephews, the children of his sister Catalina Bretón and his brother-in-law José Ortega, on the morning of October 6, 2011, leaving them on their own for a few moments when he was taking them to school.

On October 7, 2011, José Bretón picked up his children in Huelva and went with them to Córdoba. They first went to his parents’ house and then to his sister’s house, where he left them. From there, he went to Las Quemadillas, his estate, to get the fuel he had bought that morning in Huelva out of his car’s boot and leave them there.

Cordova's City of Children, the playground where José Bretónn claimed to have lost his children.

In addition, Bretón suggested to his siblings to go in the afternoon of October 8 to the “City of Children” with their respective children in order to give a better coverage to the loss simulation of Ruth and José. However, they didn’t set the appointment completely. He told his mother that he wouldn’t be able to go to her house for lunch on that same day as he was going to meet some friends, which was untrue.

In the morning of October 8, José Bretón and his children went to Catalina’s house, where Bretón stayed with them and his nephews until 1:30 pm, while his sister and brother-in-law were doing the shopping in a hypermarket. When they returned, José Bretón's brother-in-law took him and his children to the grandparents’ house to pick up his car. Once in there, José Bretón stopped by just enough time to make his family believe he was going to have lunch with some friends, which was false.

When he left his parents’ house, José Bretón, along with his two children, drove to Las Quemadillas with his car. During the journey, or when he arrived to the state, he supplied both Ruth and José with an undetermined number of the tranquillizers Motivan and Orfidal, in order to facilitate the children’s total drowsiness and/or death. Once they arrived at the estate, at about 1:48 pm of that day, José Bretón phoned his wife again, without being able to contact her, so he decided to continue carrying out his purpose.

Afterwards, according to what he had already planned and meditated, he prepared a kind of a funeral pyre. He had already arranged its essential elements in a new place of the estate, among several orange trees and without visibility from the outside. He laid his children down (it has been impossible to determine whether they were dead or alive), together with a metal table with the board upright, covering practically the whole length of the minors and the pyre itself, and set a large bonfire. He quickly stoked the bonfire with firewood – about 250 kilograms – and gasoil – about 80 liters –, which reached temperatures up to 1200 °C, achieving a similar effect to that of a crematorium. Given the magnitude of the temperature, the flesh of the children's bodies disappeared quickly, leaving only a few remains of bones. José Bretón remained by the stake until 5:30 pm, fueling it with diesel oil (an accelerator) in order to keep the temperature high enough to completely scorch and make his children’s corpses disappear.

Right after, José Bretón drove to the neighbourhood of the City of Children. At 6:01 pm he parked by 300 meters distance. He texted his brother Rafael Bretón, making him believe that he was with his children near the park and then he did the same with their mother, who called him from her house. When José Bretón thought that enough time had passed to make the fictional disappearance of his children credible, he called his brother Rafael at 6:18 pm, telling him that his children were lost. He made several phone calls to some relatives, thus making his brother and his brother-in-law go to the playground to start the search.

Around 6:41 pm, José Bretón called the Spanish emergency number 112 and notified the disappearance of his children, provoking the intervention of the police. He went to the Cordova police station at 8:43 pm to file a report of disappearance. Thereupon, the judicial proceeding started, despite knowing the fact that there had not been such disappearance, but a murder.

Francisco Etxeberria, anthropologist who made the second expert report on the remains found at Las Quemadillas at the request of Ruth Ortiz.

On one of the first reports of the judicial investigation, Josefina Lamas, the forensic anthropologist of the Scientific Police who analysed the several remains of the bones found in the bonfire of Las Quemadillas, deduced that those bones corresponded to the remains of animals,[1] specifically rodents and small carnivores.[2] This report delayed substantially the resolution of the case. The mother of the children, Ruth Ortiz, requested a second expert report to the anthropologist Francisco Etxeberria, who revealed the existence of human bone fragments (which could correspond to 2- and 6-year-old children) in the remnants of the bonfire.[2] A third analysis carried out by José María Bermúdez de Castro confirmed that the remains were human. As a result, Josefina Lamas was dismissed and the investigation concluded.[3]

The judge José Luis Rodríguez Lainz of the Audiencia Provincial of Cordova, in the image, instructed the case.

Bretón's trial began on June 17, 2013 in the Audiencia Provincial of Cordova with the election of a public jury, consisting of seven women and four men. Bretón denied killing them or supplied them pills. Ruth Ortiz, in a statement said she decided to divorce Bretón because her life was unhappy. When Bretón informed her that the children disappeared, she knew that she wouldn’t see them again.

The petrol station workers from Huelva testified in court whereas Bretón's parents and siblings refused to testify. Bretón's brother-in-law claimed that while he did not think Bretón would have killed the children, Bretón was responsible of their vanishing. Some residents around Las Quemadillas stated that they had noticed an unpleasant burnt smell, but did not see any column of smoke. Ruth Ortiz’s cousin, who had visited Bretón while he was in remand stated that Bretón had told him not once but three times that he had killed the children. Psychiatrists and psychologists who examined Bretón diagnosed that he did not suffer any mental disorder. Experts and medical examiner analysed the bone remains and indicated they are of human origin.

On July 8, after the final reports were given by the Public Prosecution Service, the private prosecution and the defence, Bretón pleaded not guilty. On her behalf, the public prosecutor claimed that there were obvious evidences that proved that Bretón had murdered his children in the cruelest possible way and then he burnt the corpses.

On July 12, the jury decided unanimously that Bretón was guilty[7] and condemned him to 40 years of imprisonment (20 per murder).

Bretón’s defence appealed the sentence from the Audiencia Provincial of Córdoba to the High Court of Justice of Andalucía, emphasising the chain of custody of the evidences. The High Court of Justice of Andalucía rejected the appeal in November 2013 and confirmed the 40 years of prison sentence imposed by the Audiencia Provincial of Córdoba.[8]

The defence decided to bring an appeal to the Supreme Court of Spain, which rejected it unanimously in July 2014.[9]

The Audiencia Provincial of Cordova reduced the original sentence from 40 to 25 years of imprisonment by motion of the defence.[10] Bretón was convicted for three different crimes (two murders and a simulation of kidnapping). Article 76 of the Spanish Criminal Code was applied.[nota 1]

• Asunta Basterra case

• This article is a derivative work from "Los niños de Córdoba: cronología de la desaparición de los hermanos Ruth y José" by 20minutos.es journalists, available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported license.
• This article contains text from the Sentencia del Tribunal del Jurado 1/2013 de la Audiencia Provincial de Córdoba, de 22 de julio de 2013, in public domain.