Murder of Colette Aram

Colette Aram left her home in Normanton Lane, Keyworth, shortly after 8pm on 30 October 1983 to walk the one and a half miles to her boyfriend's house. She was usually collected by her boyfriend, but his car was off the road. She was last seen at about 8.10pm turning into Nicker Hill where she stopped to talk to a group of friends, and witnesses reported hearing a woman screaming followed by a car driving off at speed shortly afterwards.[5] The alarm was raised when she did not arrive at her boyfriend's house, and after a series of frantic phone calls, police were called at 10.30pm to help family and friends search for Colette. At 9am the following morning her naked body was found dumped in a field about a mile and a half from where she had been abducted. She had been raped and strangled.[6]

Police launched a murder investigation, and on 7 June 1984 the murder of Colette Aram was the first case to be featured on the newly launched BBC television series Crimewatch, a programme which reconstructs major unsolved crimes with a view to gaining information from members of the public. As a result of the appeal, police received 400 tip-offs and were able to eliminate 1,500 suspects from their enquiries. However, the killer remained at large. The case was featured for a second time on Crimewatch's 20th anniversary show in 2004.[7][8]

In 2008 advances in forensic technology allowed Nottinghamshire Police to put together a DNA profile of the killer,[1] and officers appealed for members of the public to come forward with the names of suspects who could then be DNA tested using a mouth swab. A similar appeal had been made in the hunt for the M25 rapist and had proved successful.[6] Police received more than 100 calls from members of the public.[7]

In June 2008 a young man, Jean-Paul Hutchinson, was arrested on a motoring charge. DNA swabs are routinely taken from anyone who is arrested, and his DNA was a near identical match to the profile of the killer of Colette Aram. However Jean-Paul was only 20 years old at the time of his arrest and DNA swab, so he had not been born at the time of the murder. The match provided the police with the breakthrough needed to solve the case.[9]

Paul Stewart Hutchinson, father of Jean-Paul and then aged 50, was arrested and charged with the murder in April 2009. Originally Hutchinson tried to blame the murder on his brother Gerhard who died in January 2008 and who had been cremated[10] but DNA tests ruled Gerhard out as his DNA was held on an hospital blood sample and didn't match that left at the scene.[11][12] Hutchinson was held on remand after his arrest and entered a plea of not guilty on 5 October[13] but changed his plea to guilty at a pre-trial hearing on 21 December 2009.[14]

On 25 January 2010, Hutchinson was jailed for life with a minimum of 25 years at Nottingham Crown Court for the murder of Colette Aram. Colette's mother Jacqui Kirkby said Hutchinson's sentencing brought some relief, but the family next needed to know why Colette was killed – a question Hutchinson refused to answer.[3] At 8am on 10 October 2010, Hutchinson was found unconscious in his cell at Nottingham Prison. Paramedics were called and tried to resuscitate him.[15] Hutchinson died at 9.58am in an ambulance on the way to hospital. It is believed he took an overdose of medication but a post mortem examination was inconclusive.[16]

• Antoni Imiela, who was caught using a similar DNA profiling method
• Murder of Hannah Foster
• Murder of Jacqueline Thomas