Potterless

Schubert wanted to start a podcast and was looking for a popular topic that many people felt passionate about.[1] He “knew people have incredibly strong feelings about ‘Harry Potter,’ but I hadn’t read the series,” and he believed that an adult reading the series would be an interesting topic for listeners.[1] In an interview with The Rowling Library magazine, Schubert explained the origin of the name "Potterless" as a double pun based on both Pottermore (now Wizarding World) and the fact he had not read the series and so was Potter-less.[2]

Schubert started the podcast assuming his snarky remarks as he criticized the books, counterpointed by his Potter-fan guest's defense of the books, would be entertaining listening. He did not expect to enjoy the books but ended up enjoying them.[3] According to TU Delfts' Delta, the podcast was conceptualized as one that would "pick apart the story and dethrone it from its lofty perch" but turns into one that "celebrates as the story gets richer."[4]

Schubert began reading Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, and the first episode of the podcast launched in October of that year.[5] Episodes were initially released bi-weekly, but the release schedule was switched to weekly in 2019. The last book material was covered in episode 89,[6] after which Schubert began covering the Harry Potter films and spin-off materials such as Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.[2][5]

Each episode of the first 89 is dedicated to a chapter or chapters of the book series in chronological reading order.[1] Episodes are approximately 60 minutes in length, and consist primarily of Schubert and his guest(s) summarizing the plot and providing commentary.[7]

Recurring segments include British Quandaries, in which British citizen Dottie James answers questions from Mike and his American guests regarding British-isms and whether things such as treacle tart are British or magical in origin.[3]

Schubert donates a portion of his Patreon revenues to charity.[7]

Potterless has charted in the US top 40 for Arts and Entertainment podcasts and US top 60 for comedy podcasts on Spotify.[8][9] It has been featured by Buzzfeed in lists of recommended podcasts.[10][11]

The Post called Potterless “the perfect podcast for anyone who has wanted to reread the series but doesn’t have the time… [it] provides listeners with opportunity to recall the first time they read the books and follow along on the beautiful journey of listening to someone else do the same.”[12] Brighton Journal said Schubert's "genuine enthusiasm for the books is charming."[3]

MaineCampus called Schubert "cynical" and "too critical."[13] The Student said Schubert's "complete lack of understanding of everyday British words and phrases threatens to irritate rather than amuse" and that the series might be better led by "a Brit."[14]