The Head and the Heart

Self-burned copies of The Head and the Heart in handmade denim sleeves were being sold at shows within a few weeks,[9] and soon local record stores Easy Street and Sonic Boom couldn't keep them in stock.[10] After a "feeding frenzy"[11] of interest from record labels and managers, the band signed with Sub Pop in November 2010.[12] Sub Pop remastered the album, expanded it with a studio version of their traditional concert closer "Rivers and Roads", and re-recorded one song ("Sounds Like Hallelujah"). The album was re-released in CD format, and for the first time on vinyl LP, on Record Store Day 2011. The band is signed with Heavenly Recordings in the United Kingdom and Europe.[3]

The band toured extensively through 2010 and 2011 in both the United States and Europe, and opened for Vampire Weekend,[5] The Walkmen, Dr. Dog, Dave Matthews, The Low Anthem, The Decemberists, Iron & Wine, My Morning Jacket, and Death Cab For Cutie, as well as headlining their own shows. In March 2011, Seattle's City Arts Magazine named them "Seattle's Best New Band",[13] and the band made their network television debut on April 21, 2011 on Conan.[14] The album reached the Billboard 200 Album Charts at #110 and the record stayed on the chart for ten weeks.[15]

The band's second album Let's Be Still was released on October 15, 2013.[16] Recorded in Seattle and produced together with Shawn Simmons, the first track, "Shake," was aired on the August 5, 2013.[17] Frontman Johnson said of it "...this is the first time that we produced as a full band. This one is everyone's influences equally present and prevalent throughout the album".[18] James Christopher Monger of AllMusic said of the album: "The group's predilection for heartfelt, Avett Brothers-meets-Fleet Foxes roots rock is apparent right out of the gate with "Homecoming Heroes" and "Another Story," both of which utilize familiar folk-rock architecture to spin earnest and familiar tales concerning the two body parts from which the group takes its name."[19] On November 2, 2013, Let's Be Still reached number 10 on the Billboard 200 albums chart.[15] The band spent much of 2014 touring in support of the album.[20] Thielen spent time writing for other artists, including Mavis Staples,[21] while she married fellow musician Matt Gervais.[22]

The band released their third studio album, Signs of Light, in September 2016, and toured in North America and Europe following its release.

In the middle of 2015, Johnson and Russell began the writing process for the third album at Montecito Heights in Los Angeles.[20] The band continued recording for much of the year, it was announced in March 2016 that Johnson would not feature in the touring plans of the band and instead do his best to manage his drug addiction.[23][24] He was replaced by Thielen's husband Matt Gervais.[25] In September 2016 the band released their third album Signs of Light.[26] It was preceded by the single "All We Ever Knew".[27][28]

The band toured throughout 2017 with performances at Coachella, Red Rocks Amphitheatre, Hinterland Music Festival, and Lollapalooza.[29][30]

On March 14, 2019, the band announced their fourth album, Living Mirage, would be released on May 17, and the first single "Missed Connection". On April 5, the band released a second single from the album, titled "Honeybee". They also revealed a March 21 livestream performance at The Belasco in Los Angeles, CA.[31] The band announced a spring/autumn 2019 tour that consists of 38 North American shows.[32]

• "No One To Let You Down" (Sub Pop Records, Please To Enjoy: Terminal Sales Vol. 4 Sampler, 2011)[55]
• "What Are You Doing New Year's Eve?" (Holidays Rule)[56]
• "Don't Forget Me" (Sweetheart 2014)[57]