Toda bracket

See (Kochman 1990) or (Toda 1962) for more information. Suppose that

${\displaystyle W{\stackrel {f}{\ \to \ }}X{\stackrel {g}{\ \to \ }}Y{\stackrel {h}{\ \to \ }}Z}$

is a sequence of maps between spaces, such that the compositions ${\displaystyle g\circ f}$ and ${\displaystyle h\circ g}$ are both nullhomotopic. Given a space ${\displaystyle A}$, let ${\displaystyle CA}$ denote the cone of ${\displaystyle A}$. Then we get a (non-unique) map

${\displaystyle F\colon CW\to Y}$

induced by a homotopy from ${\displaystyle g\circ f}$ to a trivial map, which when post-composed with ${\displaystyle h}$ gives a map

${\displaystyle h\circ F\colon CW\to Z}$.

Similarly we get a non-unique map ${\displaystyle G\colon CX\to Z}$ induced by a homotopy from ${\displaystyle h\circ g}$ to a trivial map, which when composed with ${\displaystyle C_{f}\colon CW\to CX}$, the cone of the map ${\displaystyle f}$, gives another map,

${\displaystyle G\circ C_{f}\colon CW\to Z}$.

By joining together these two cones on ${\displaystyle W}$ and the maps from them to ${\displaystyle Z}$, we get a map

${\displaystyle \langle f,g,h\rangle \colon SW\to Z}$

representing an element in the group ${\displaystyle [SW,Z]}$ of homotopy classes of maps from the suspension ${\displaystyle SW}$ to ${\displaystyle Z}$, called the Toda bracket of ${\displaystyle f}$, ${\displaystyle g}$, and ${\displaystyle h}$. The map ${\displaystyle \langle f,g,h\rangle }$ is not uniquely defined up to homotopy, because there was some choice in choosing the maps from the cones. Changing these maps changes the Toda bracket by adding elements of ${\displaystyle h[SW,Y]}$ and ${\displaystyle [SX,Z]f}$.

There are also higher Toda brackets of several elements, defined when suitable lower Toda brackets vanish. This parallels the theory of Massey products in cohomology.

The direct sum

${\displaystyle \pi _{\ast }^{S}=\bigoplus _{k\geq 0}\pi _{k}^{S}}$

of the stable homotopy groups of spheres is a supercommutative graded ring, where multiplication (called composition product) is given by composition of representing maps, and any element of non-zero degree is nilpotent (Nishida 1973).

If f and g and h are elements of ${\displaystyle \pi _{\ast }^{S}}$ with ${\displaystyle f\cdot g=0}$ and ${\displaystyle g\cdot h=0}$, there is a Toda bracket ${\displaystyle \langle f,g,h\rangle }$ of these elements. The Toda bracket is not quite an element of a stable homotopy group, because it is only defined up to addition of composition products of certain other elements. Hiroshi Toda used the composition product and Toda brackets to label many of the elements of homotopy groups. Cohen (1968) showed that every element of the stable homotopy groups of spheres can be expressed using composition products and higher Toda brackets in terms of certain well known elements, called Hopf elements.

In the case of a general triangulated category the Toda bracket can be defined as follows. Again, suppose that

${\displaystyle W{\stackrel {f}{\ \to \ }}X{\stackrel {g}{\ \to \ }}Y{\stackrel {h}{\ \to \ }}Z}$

is a sequence of morphism in a triangulated category such that ${\displaystyle g\circ f=0}$ and ${\displaystyle h\circ g=0}$. Let ${\displaystyle C_{f}}$ denote the cone of f so we obtain an exact triangle

${\displaystyle W{\stackrel {f}{\ \to \ }}X{\stackrel {i}{\ \to \ }}C_{f}{\stackrel {q}{\ \to \ }}W[1]}$

The relation ${\displaystyle g\circ f=0}$ implies that g factors (non-uniquely) through ${\displaystyle C_{f}}$ as

${\displaystyle X{\stackrel {i}{\ \to \ }}C_{f}{\stackrel {a}{\ \to \ }}Y}$

for some ${\displaystyle a}$. Then, the relation ${\displaystyle h\circ a\circ i=h\circ g=0}$ implies that ${\displaystyle h\circ a}$ factors (non-uniquely) through W[1] as

${\displaystyle C_{f}{\stackrel {q}{\ \to \ }}W[1]{\stackrel {b}{\ \to \ }}Z}$

for some b. This b is (a choice of) the Toda bracket ${\displaystyle \langle f,g,h\rangle }$ in the group ${\displaystyle \operatorname {hom} (W[1],Z)}$.

There is a convergence theorem originally due to Moss[1] which states that special Massey products ${\displaystyle \langle a,b,c\rangle }$ of elements in the ${\displaystyle E_{r}}$-page of the Adams spectral sequence contain a permanent cycle, meaning has an associated element in ${\displaystyle \pi _{*}^{s}(\mathbb {S} )}$, assuming the elements ${\displaystyle a,b,c}$ are permanent cycles[2]^{pg 18-19}. Moreover, these Massey products have a lift to a motivic Adams spectral sequence giving an element in the Toda bracket ${\displaystyle \langle \alpha ,\beta ,\gamma \rangle }$ in ${\displaystyle \pi _{*,*}}$ for elements ${\displaystyle \alpha ,\beta ,\gamma }$ lifting ${\displaystyle a,b,c}$.

• Cohen, Joel M. (1968), "The decomposition of stable homotopy.", Annals of Mathematics, Second Series, 87 (2): 305–320, doi:10.2307/1970586, JSTOR 1970586, MR 0231377, PMC 224450.
• Kochman, Stanley O. (1990), "Toda brackets", Stable homotopy groups of spheres. A computer-assisted approach, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 1423, Berlin: Springer-Verlag, pp. 12–34, doi:10.1007/BFb0083797, ISBN 978-3-540-52468-7, MR 1052407.
• Nishida, Goro (1973), "The nilpotency of elements of the stable homotopy groups of spheres", Journal of the Mathematical Society of Japan, 25 (4): 707–732, doi:10.2969/jmsj/02540707, ISSN 0025-5645, MR 0341485.
• Toda, Hiroshi (1962), Composition methods in homotopy groups of spheres, Annals of Mathematics Studies, 49, Princeton University Press, ISBN 978-0-691-09586-8, MR 0143217.