Tom Sawyer (1956 musical)

Luther’s teleplay begins with Tom and Huck making plans to steal away to the graveyard at midnight to cure Huck’s warts by hurling a dead cat into the freshly dug grave of Old Hoss Williams. Later, Tom falls in love at first sight with Becky Thatcher as he sees her skipping rope with her friends, Amy and Susie. As Becky goes inside, she casually tosses a flower to Tom, who sits, lovestruck, beneath her window, until a housemaid dumps a basin of water on him. That night, in the graveyard. Tom and Huck witness the murder of Doc Robinson by Injun Joe, who is helping Robinson and Muff Potter in a grave-robbing scheme. Tom and Huck swear to remain silent about what they saw, fearing Injun Joe's retribution. When Becky accidentally tears a page in the schoolmaster's biology book, Tom takes the punishment -- eight whippings -- and wins her love. They share a kiss and become "engaged." But Becky spurns Tom after he reveals he and Amy Lawrence were previously engaged. Heartbroken, Tom rounds up Huck and Joe Harper and heads to a nearby island, where they plan to live as pirates. Free to do as he pleases at last, Tom swims, plays, learns to smoke a corncob pipe (with Huck's encouragement) and enjoys the leisurely life for three days. But he secretly travels back to town to look in on Aunt Polly, who is grief-stricken and certain he has died. Soon after Tom returns to the island, a fierce storm hits, giving the would-be pirates second thoughts about staying. Afterward, the boys return home in time to crash their own funerals; the townspeople were all convinced they had drowned. Muff Potter is accused of the murder of Doc Robinson, but Tom testifies Injun Joe, also in court, was responsible. Before Injun Joe can be seized, he hurls himself through a courtroom window and escapes. Tom and Becky make up in time to attend a picnic at McDougal's Cave. While they are exploring the caverns, Tom and Becky run into Injun Joe, who is using the catacombs as a hideout. Injun Joe falls off a cliff, allowing them to escape, and the town rejoices as Tom and Becky return home.

The teleplay may have differed from what was actually broadcast: A preview in TV Guide listed "You Can't Teach an Old Dog New Tricks," a humorous solo for Aunt Polly, and "My Love Has Gone Away," a ballad for Becky, in the program of songs to be performed, but neither of them are included in the original teleplay.

Variety raved, calling it "a captivating musical stanza" and noting that "(m)uch of the story was told in choreographic pantomime routines that were imaginatively staged against suggestive backgrounds designed by Thomas Hart Benton." Sharpe "played Tom with a convincing boyishness and was excellent in a couple of vocal duets with Bennye Gattnes, as Becky, on 'What Do You Kiss For' and 'Please Make Up.'" San Francisco Examiner critic Dwight Newton called the show "a 60 minute folk song. ... The TV show -- brushing briefly over the book's highlights -- had one thing in common with the book. It was something you'd like to look at again. And again." Newton also praised John Sharpe for "creating television excitement in the title role."[6] Walter Hawver of Knickerbocker News hailed the show as "a television gem, an operetta in concept, pure entertainment in execution."[7]

A stage adaptation of the show, with the script rewritten and expanded by Richard H. Berger, Peter Gurney and Edward Reveaux, had its world premiere at Starlight Theatre in Kansas City, Mo. in July 1958. It starred Randy Sparks as Tom, Richard France as Huck and Virginia Gibson as Becky.[8] It attracted more than 40,000 ticket-buyers in its initial run[9] and was revived the next season with Sparks, France and Gibson repeating their roles.