Wilson W. Hoover

Hoover was born to Elizabeth (Morrison) and David Hoover in Iowa during 1849. Details of his early life have been lost. Hoover was admitted to the California bar on January 14, 1873. He lived for a time in San Jose, California before moving to Gilroy, California in early 1874.[1] 1880 census records show he was working as a lawyer.[2] Hoover and his wife, Mary, had a son, Floyd, on April 3, 1874. The boy died before reaching two months of age.[1] The couple had a second son, Harold.[3]

President Chester A. Arthur nominated Hoover to replace William Henry Stilwell as an Associate Justice of the Arizona Territorial Supreme Court on July 20, 1882.[4] Senate confirmation came on August 7 and Hoover arrived in Tucson, Arizona to take the oath of office on September 2. As Hoover had been in Washington during the confirmation process he returned to California to settle some personal matters, returning to the territory to begin a district court session on September 25, 1882.[5] At the end of the session he reported to the United States Attorney General that he had tried 23 civil cases and reached a final verdict in 44 criminal trials.[5]

During his confirmation hearings, Hoover had provided testimony in prosecutions related to the Star route scandal.[5][6] As a favor to the Justice Department, he returned to Washington D.C. in mid-November 1882 to provide additional testimony.[5] Hoover arrived in Prescott, Arizona Territory on January 4, 1883 for the session of the supreme court that had begun three days earlier.[7] The session adjourned on January 8 before reconvening in Tucson on February 23 and ending on March 6, 1883. No opinions written by Hoover from the session survive, but the territorial press were impressed by his demeanor and legal ability.[3]

While Hoover was traveling, Captain W. H. Seamans began efforts to have the new judge removed from the bench. Seamans had lost his job as Justice Stilwell's court clerk when Hoover took office.[5] In addition to charges of misconduct while in office, Hoover was accused of being an associate of a "professional confidence man".[8] Upon learning of the efforts, Hoover and his friend began a defense against the charges. In response to various letters to Washington and circulated petitions, the territorial bar discussed the issue during their January 1883 meeting and reported there was no basis for the charges leveled against Hoover. A vote during the bar's March 1883 meeting likewise rejected the accusations against the judge.[5] Following the usual practice of the day, the United States Justice Department sent an agent to investigate the accusations against the judge.[3] The investigation resulted in Hoover being suspended on March 23, 1883.[9]

After leaving office, Hoover remained in Arizona Territory and practiced law in Tucson and Tombstone. During the mid-1880s, Arizona experienced an economic downturn, resulting in a glut of practicing attorneys. During early 1886, Hoover's wife and son moved east and the former Justice dissolved his legal practice by the end of the year.[3] He settled in Brooklyn and opening the legal firm of Hoover & Sparrow in Manhattan.[3] Hoover died in New York City on February 22, 1926. He was buried Hancock, New York's Riverview Cemetery.[10]

• Goff, John S. (July 1968). "The Appointment, Tenure and Removal of Territorial Judges: Arizona-A Case Study". The American Journal of Legal History. Temple University. 12 (3): 211–231. JSTOR 844126.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
• Goff, John S. (1975). Arizona Territorial Officials Volume I: The Supreme Court Justices 1863-1912. Cave Creek, Arizona: Black Mountain Press. OCLC 1622668.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)