1916–17 Harvard Crimson men's ice hockey season

With many of the players from the consecutive championship teams returning, it was a bit galling for Alfred Winsor to watch his team play so poorly in their first game against the Boston Athletic Association.[1] Despite the loss of wingers Kissel and Bliss[2] the hard practices arranged by Windsor seemed to wake up the Crimson and the team responded with a convincing 7–2 win over the Boston Hockey Club.[3]

After the winter break, Harvard played their first official game of the year, trouncing MIT 8–0. After a second shutout, this time over Dartmouth, Harvard left its home rink for the first time to play Princeton. The Tigers played Harvard tough all game long, attacking the Harvard net whenever they could. The first half ended with both team tied at 1, and the staunch defensive work from both goaltenders continued in the second half. Just when it looked like overtime would be needed, Princeton captain Schoen scored the winning goal with 15 seconds to play, putting a wrench in the works for Harvard's championship hopes.[4]

Before the rematch Harvard faced Queen's and were able to exact their revenge from a year before with a 5–1 victory. Harvard flipped the script against Princeton by scoring first and keeping the pressure on the Tiger net, but Schoen scored twice in response to give Princeton a 2–1 lead at half. Harvard was undeterred and scored three times in the third period, carrying the play for most of the second half. Schoen completed his hat-trick late in the game but it was too late to change the outcome and Harvard tied the series to keep their championship window open.[5] A week after a shutout of McGill, Harvard began their series against Yale in New Haven, and once more the Crimson offense couldn't get on track away from Boston. Yale's goaltender, York, stifled Harvard all game long, leading the Elis to a 2–0 win and the first shutout of Harvard by a contemporary in over seven years. The victory was the first for Yale over Harvard since February of 1914, but the Crimson would still have a chance to redeem themselves before the season ended.

While Harvard was eager to even the series against Yale, they had to play the rubber match against Princeton first. With the game at home Harvard had the advantage, and a sterling effort from the defense allowed Wylde to record his fourth shutout of the season and gave the series to the Bostonians.[6] With the Tigers thus defeated, Harvard was two wins away from another intercollegiate championship and after they evened the series with Yale by another shutout, it appeared that they were heading for a third consecutive title. Unfortunately, their final game against Yale took place at the New Haven Arena, with a rink much smaller than the Crimson were used to at the Boston Arena. With the captains for both teams sitting out, the Elis relied on their speed and tenacity to keep Harvard at bay. The tactic worked and Yale were able to shut Harvard out for the second time, winning the series 2–1.[7]

Because Princeton had triumphed over Yale, the three teams found themselves locked in a three-way tie in the IHL standings. Rather than try to determine a sole champion the tie was allowed to stand, leaving 1917 without a team able to claim the intercollegiate championship.[8]

Wylde tied his program record with 5 shutouts on the season. His 10 career shutouts was an unofficial team record until 2005.[9]

Less than a month after the season ended, the United States formally entered World War I. As a result the ice hockey program was mothballed until after the armistice was signed on November 11, 1918.

No.	S/P/C	Player	Class	Pos	Height	Weight	DoB	Hometown	Previous team
		William C. Appleton Jr.	Senior	D			1897-03-15	Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts	Noble and Greenough School
		Edwin O. Baker	Senior	C	5' 11" (1.8 m)	170 lb (77 kg)	1896-02-21	Cambridge, Massachusetts	Cambridge Latin School
		Robert Baldwin	Senior	C			1895-04-09	Wellesley Hills, Massachusetts	Volkmann School
		Edward B. Condon	Junior	C			1896-01-31	New York, New York	Pomfret School
		Thomas H. Eckfeldt	Senior	D	5' 11" (1.8 m)	164 lb (74 kg)	1896-01-28	New Bedford, Massachusetts	St. Andrew's School
		Thomas K. Fisher	Senior	C			1894-01-11	Clinton, Massachusetts	St. Paul's School
		Robert E. Gross	Sophomore	RW			1897-05-11	West Roxbury, Massachusetts	St. George's School
		Gustav Kissel	Senior	RW			1895-03-03	Washington, D.C.	Milton Academy
		Alan R. Martin	Junior	G/D			1894-10-18	Toronto, Ontario	Cambridge Latin School
		John E. P. Morgan (C)	Senior	D	5' 9" (1.75 m)	160 lb (73 kg)	1895-08-09	Lenox, Massachusetts	Middlesex School
		William O. P. Morgan	Junior	LW			1895-05-14	Chicago, Illinois	St. Paul's School
		George A. Percy	Junior	C	5' 8.5" (1.74 m)	158 lb (72 kg)	1895-05-12	Arlington, Massachusetts	Arlington High School
		Theodore H. Rice	Junior	LW	5' 11" (1.8 m)	155 lb (70 kg)	1894-05-24	Dorchester, Massachusetts	Noble and Greenough School
		Thomas C. Thatcher Jr.	Junior	RW	5' 11" (1.8 m)	170 lb (77 kg)	1896-08-12	Nahant, Massachusetts	St. Mark's School
		Greenough Townsend	Senior	C	5' 8.5" (1.74 m)	145 lb (66 kg)	1895-03-04	New York, New York	St. Paul's School
		Henry K. White	Sophomore	D	6' 1" (1.85 m)	153 lb (69 kg)	1897-02-23	Brookline, Massachusetts	St. Paul's School
		John Wylde	Senior	G	6' 0" (1.83 m)	149 lb (68 kg)	1893-08-26	Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts	Noble and Greenough School

[10]

[11]