2016 Citronelle homicides

In the early morning of August 20, 2016, a male assailant entered a residence in the 1700 block of Jim Platt Road about 4 a.m., in a rural area west of Citronelle. He killed five persons who were sleeping, including two married couples, one including a woman who was five months pregnant. He used a variety of weapons, including an axe and guns.[1] He kidnapped Laneta Lester, his estranged girlfriend, and an infant of her brother and his wife;[2] he took them with him to his father's house in Leakesville, Mississippi, about 30 miles to the west. Later he released them.

Lester returned to Citronelle with the infant, where she went to the police department and notified authorities about the killings.[1] She said she had been abducted by her estranged boyfriend, Derrick Dearman, and that he had killed the people at the house. The police found the five bodies at the crime scene. They said it would take time to process the crime scene. Initial reports said Lester had escaped from Dearman, but she and the infant were reportedly released by him.[3][4][1][5][6][7]

Investigators said that residents had made a 9-1-1 call from the house about 1 a.m., a few hours before the killings, and reported that Derrick Dearman was on the property. Officers responded to the house, but found no evidence of him on the wooded grounds and left.[5] Investigators initially believed the attacker had used an ax and several firearms that were in the house in the attack, and that the killings were committed in the process of an attempted burglary or abduction.[8][9] Police found two firearms and a "bladed weapon" at the house.[10] The attack was described as the worst mass killing in the history of Mobile County.[11]

On August 22, Dearman was extradited to Mobile, Alabama, to face trial.[16] While being escorted to an administrative building, he reportedly said, "Don't do drugs", apologized, and said he turned himself in after realizing what he had done. He later apologized to Lester by name and described the victims as friends.[15][2] The following day, he said he was on methamphetamine at the time of the killings, and blamed the influence of the drug on the killings.[12]

On August 31, 2016, Dearman was charged with six counts of capital murder (one charge for Chelsea Reed's fetus, under Alabama's fetal homicide law[17]) and two counts of abduction. He pleaded not guilty to all of the counts.[7][8] It was classified as capital murder first, because it was associated with attempted burglary, and secondly, because two or more persons were killed in commission of the same crime.[18]

A couple of weeks after the murders, the Turner house burned down.[2]

Dearman was assigned two court-appointed defense attorneys. In mid-August 2017, Circuit Judge Rick Stout, at the request of the state, ordered Dearman to receive a mental evaluation, to be completed by the state of Alabama. It was intended to cover three topics: Dearman's competency to stand trial, his mental capacity at the time of the crimes, and his intelligence quotient (IQ). Around this time, one of his attorneys resigned from the case. Dearman objected to having his IQ and competency tested, as he had not made a plea related to either. He tried to establish limits to such testing, but the court denied the motion. The judge was to receive the results of the testing and review them before sharing with the prosecutor and defense.[19]

In September 2018, Dearman pleaded guilty to the charges of capital murder and kidnapping.[20][21] Under Alabama law, because of the capital murder charges, he was still subject to a jury trial, with the potential of receiving a death sentence. He had fired his two court-appointed attorneys before entering his plea. The judge ruled that he was fit to stand trial.[22][23]

At the jury trial, Dearman was found guilty on the six capital murder charges and first-degree kidnapping counts, and the jury approved the death sentence. This was affirmed by the court on October 12, 2018, and Dearman was sentenced to death for these murders.[24]