A Broadway Musical

The creators hoped that the backstage story about the making of a musical would cash in on the success of A Chorus Line as well as the popularity of the black-themed musical, including Brown's own The Wiz, which was still running at the time. But Brown's much-criticized book is a clichéd spoof of show business lawyers, idealistic young playwrights, glitzy Las Vegas performers, blue-haired matinée ladies, and the black-themed musical itself. The Wiz proved to be Brown's only success.[1]

Following a dismal October–November tryout with Helen Gallagher and Julius LaRosa at the theatre in the Riverside Church in Morningside Heights, the producers fired most of the cast and creative personnel, including director/choreographer George Faison.[2] Gower Champion was called in to rescue the Broadway-bound production with only a month to go, but he feared that the show's defects were too serious to remedy and insisted on receiving a "Production supervised by" credit only.[1]

After 14 previews, the Broadway production opened and closed the same night at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre on December 21, 1978. It lost $1 million.[3] The cast included Patti Karr (replacing Gallagher), Alan Weeks, Larry Marshall, Warren Berlinger (replacing LaRosa), Loretta Devine, Jackée Harry and Tiger Haynes.[4] A cast album was recorded during a live performance in December 1978.[5]

In 2017, Feinstein's/54 Below in New York gave a concert presentation of A Broadway Musical, directed and produced by Robert W. Schneider. The cast included Clifton Davis, Jason Graae and Kyle Scatliffe.[6]

• Richie Taylor's Lawyer – Sydney Anderson
• Rehearsal Pianist – Gwen Arment
• Policeman, Nathaniel – Nate Barnett
• Eddie Bell – Warren Berlinger
• Stephanie Bell – Gwyda DonHowe
• Shirley Wolfe – Anne Francine
• Richie Taylor's Lawyer – Michael Gallagher
• Melinda Bernard – Jackée Harry
• Sylvester Lee – Tiger Haynes
• Louie – Reggie Jackson
• Maggie Simpson – Patti Karr
• Kumi-Kumi – Christina Kumi Kimball
• James Lincoln – Irving Allen Lee
• Richie Taylor – Larry Marshall
• Junior – Robert Melvin
• Richie's Secretary – Jo Ann Ogawa
• Jake – Martin Rabbett
• Lonnie Paul – Larry Riley
• Big Jake – Albert Stephenson
• Stan Howard – Alan Weeks
• Smoke & Fire Back-Up Singer – Loretta Devine

Strouse wrote (in his memoir) that this was a "show he was proud of" because he and Adams had wanted to write a musical about their experiences with Sammy Davis, Jr., about white people writing for a "big, black musical star". They envisioned it as "funny, ironic ... and filled with life's imbalances."[7]

Mel Gussow, in his review for The New York Times, wrote that the idea was to write a spoof of Broadway intrigue and duplicity; "cynicism is rampant." There are jokes about blacks on Broadway, Jewish theater party women and lawyers with "steel clauses." The lyrics are not funny. Finally, Gussow wrote: "The cast performs with eagerness, even as the show sinks."[8]

Julius Novick of The Village Voice called it "the best Broadway musical since Platinum,"[2] a disaster that had opened the month before. Critic and theatre historian Ken Mandelbaum has described the show as "a genuine turkey... hopeless... [a] well-meaning but fatally underpowered evening. The Charles Strouse-Lee Adams score had its moments."[9] Mandelbaum noted that "the characters were all clichés. ... A shallow treatment of a theme with potential ... was capped with an absurd ending".[2]

• Not Since Carrie: Forty Years of Broadway Musical Flops by Ken Mandelbaum, published by St. Martin's Press (1991), pp. 136–38 (ISBN 0-312-06428-4)

• Internet Broadway Database
• Recollections about the show from co-producer Garth Drabinsky
• A Broadway Musical Off-Broadway at Lortel Archives
• Charles Strouse Official site