Already Platinum

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[5]
Robert Christgau	C[6]
Entertainment Weekly	B[7]
Okayplayer	[8]
Pitchfork	7.5/10[9]
Rolling Stone	[10]
Spin	[11]
Stylus Magazine	B+[12]
USA Today	[13]
Vibe	[14]

Already Platinum garnered a positive reception from music critics who praised Slim's vocal delivery and the Southern production. AllMusic's Andy Kellman praised Slim's delivery for being more charismatic than Lil' Flip and Mike Jones, and the production work from both Mr. Lee and The Neptunes, concluding that "Already Platinum is one of 2005's best rap albums."[5] Evan McGarvey of Stylus Magazine praised the Neptunes' production for evolving with Slim's Southern drawl and delivery, concluding that "After years of singles that people called "infectious" and "club-ready," they take Slim Thug and his dashing uniqueness and carve diamonds. This [album] isn't a musical highlight reel, it's watching artists shuck off personal curses and step into their own skins."[12] Vibe contributor Rondell Conway wrote that, "Slim's worldly sensibilities make the pensive moments on the album both heartfelt ("Dedicate") and heady ("The Interview"). All the while, he keeps his Teflon status intact–without telling any tall tales."[14] Rolling Stone's Christian Hoard called the record "a popwise bastardization of the Houston rap scene's round-the-way charm", praising Slim's "down-home brassiness" delivering "brawny boasts and mesmerizing refrains", and the Neptunes' "arty minimalism" being better than on previous outings.[10]

Entertainment Weekly writer Michael Endelman gave note of Slim having a "steady, linebacker-strong flow and [a] baritone" throughout the album but gave credit to the Neptunes for giving him "spacious and stark beats that are equal parts frightening and funky".[7] Steve Jones of USA Today said that big names like T.I. and Jazze Pha didn't turn the attention away from the main artist, saying that "Slim [Thug]'s confident, laid-back deliveries keep him from being overshadowed."[13] Chris Ryan of Spin commended Slim for lending his voice to the Neptunes' atmospheric production, saying they "contribute some of their most adventurous work yet."[11] Tom Breihan of Pitchfork was critical of most of the tracks by the Neptunes, saying they "lost the gleaming, clattering swagger they once had, relying instead on bloodless synth lines and itchy, nattering drums" and that Slim's performance on them suffered. But said that the tracks by Mr. Lee ("Diamonds" and "3 Kings") were the highlights, concluding that, "On tracks like this, Slim sounds prehistoric, like he's always existed, like this voice has been echoing over canyons and through caves since before time began."[9]

Sample credits

• "3 Kings", samples "Secretary" by Betty Wright.[15]
• "Diamonds", samples "Top Notch Hoes" by Pimp C.[16]
• "The Interview", samples "The Newness Is Gone" by Eddie Kendricks.[17]
• "Miss Mary", samples "A Moment with You" by George Michael.[18]
• "I Need A...", samples "Out There" by Willie Hutch.
• "Dope Man", samples "Just to Keep You Satisfied" by Marvin Gaye.
• "I'll Show Ya", samples "Stay in Love with Me" by Trinere

Credits for Already Platinum adapted from AllMusic.[19]