Election Night (American Horror Story)

On election night, Ally Mayfair-Richards is horrified as Donald Trump is elected President of the United States. Ally's wife Ivy comforts her. Elsewhere, Kai Anderson is delighted by the news, remarking that "the revolution has begun". Kai's sister Winter, having worked for Hillary Clinton's campaign, is devastated. Winter expresses her fear and Kai contentedly notes that everyone is afraid. Ally’s irrational fear of clowns resurfaces when she catches her son Oz reading a Twisty the Clown comic. Kai attends a city council meeting about security for a local Jewish community center. Tom Chang, a city council member and neighbor of Ally and Ivy, belittles Kai and the motion for increased security is unanimously passed.

Ally speaks with her therapist Dr. Rudy Vincent about her fears. She credits Ivy and Barack Obama’s presidency for the previous assuagement of her anxiety. He suggests medication and a social media purge. Later, Ally visits a grocery store and becomes increasingly paranoid as she shops. In the produce section, she witnesses a pair of clowns having sex. She wields a bottle of Rosé to defend herself as clowns start to pursue her. She eventually flees the store and calls Ivy in a panic. She crashes her car after a clown pops up in the backseat. At home, Ivy relays that there is no evidence to support Ally's experience in the store. The next day, Ally and Ivy discuss the state of their shared business, a restaurant called The Butchery on Main, and their marriage. They encounter Kai on the street, who unapologetically spills hot coffee on them. Later, Ally and Ivy interview and hire Winter as Oz's new nanny. Privately, Kai interviews his sister, who reveals her deepest fear is of him. Kai harasses a group of Hispanic men on the street by yelling racist slurs and throwing a urine-filled condom at them. The men proceed to beat Kai up while an unseen party films it.

While Ally and Ivy have a date night at the restaurant, Winter attempts to desensitize Oz to violence by showing him videos of murders on the dark web. In a moment alone, Oz peers through his bedroom window and observes a group of clowns (the same ones Ally saw in the grocery store) exiting an ice cream truck. Meanwhile, the date at the restaurant falters when Ally claims to have seen another clown. Ally and Ivy arrive home to a cordoned crime scene. Tom Chang and his wife are dead. Oz claims to have witnessed the clowns murder them. Winter dismisses Oz's recollection, claiming that he has an overactive imagination. Detective Samuels rules the Changs’ deaths as a murder-suicide. Later that night, Ally shocks and screams in terror as she discovers a clown in her bed.

"Election Night" was watched by 3.93 million people during its original broadcast, and gained a 2.0 ratings share among adults aged 18–49.[2]

The episode received positive reviews from critics. On the review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, "Election Night" holds an 85% approval rating, based on 20 reviews with an average rating of 7.83 out of 10. The critical consensus reads, "Filled with paranoia-fueled chills, 'Election Night' launches another unpredictable, satirical season of American Horror Story."[3]

Matt Flower of IGN said the episode was off to a "promising start" and praised its use of satire and post-election paranoia, though criticized it for "being reductive and toothless" at its lows.[4] Daniel D'Addario from Time praised the episode for feeling like a horror story, the cinematography, and the performances.[5]

However, Laura Bradley of Vanity Fair criticized the episode for the "uninteresting, tired interpretation of politics". She criticized the characters of Ally and Kai and the simplistic theme of fear, but called the performances "nuanced and sardonically witty". She concluded by finding it hard to enjoy the season with the "lazy, cynical political allegory."[6]

• "Election Night" at IMDb