Extreme Makeover: Home Edition

Despite the show's positive message, EM:HE was the target of considerable scrutiny by much of the media on a variety of issues, including ethics, authenticity and most of all, the alleged foreclosure 'crisis' which several of the show's recipient families faced in later years.

Ethically speaking, the show has often been criticized by some viewers and the media for unnecessary contributions and glorifying excessive suburban lifestyles, such as in a Mother Jones article that questioned giving a 6-bedroom, 7-bath, 7-television house to a family of 4 in Kingston, WA.[7] However, ABC countered this criticism by explaining their approach towards building homes for each family was to do so in a manner which best suited their own individual needs, noting the sizes of many of the homes is due to the fact a considerable majority were built for either exceptionally large families, families of individuals with certain accessibility needs and families who ran various types of organizations or small businesses out of their homes, the latter of which was the case of the Kingston home. ABC responded to the Mother Jones article by noting they had failed to mention that particular home was also a functioning bed and breakfast.

Authentically speaking, one such claim was frequently made against the show's lead designers, particularly Ty Pennington. At several makeovers, they have been criticized for never doing any work at all, and just being there to put on a show. In 2007, during the makeover for the Carter Family in Billings, Montana, a local radio DJ accused Pennington of using a spray can of grease on his face to make it look like he was really working, only to be confronted over the air by Pennington himself, who called in from the construction site.[8] The largest piece of evidence to prove the design team's contribution to the house and the family is a severe hand injury that Ed Sanders received during a 2006 makeover in Ohio for the family of Jason Thomas. While creating a wood carving of the American flag, Sanders removed part of the guard for a hand-held wood grinder, which led to him slicing one of his hands open.[9] Sanders took a leave of absence for nearly an entire season to recover.

In an article entitled "ABC's 'Extreme Exploitation'", The Smoking Gun published an e-mail sent on March 10, 2006, from an ABC employee to network affiliates, relaying a message from the program's casting agent detailing specific tragedies and rare illnesses sought by the show. Included were a "Muscular Dystrophy Child", a "Family who has multiple children w/ Down Syndrome (either adopted or biological)" and a child with Congenital insensitivity to pain with anhidrosis. This last request included a parenthetical remark stating, "There are only 17 known cases in US - let me know if one is in your town!"[10] This e-mail has led some major media networks and blogs to accuse the show of opportunism in seeking out the most sensational stories in a push for higher ratings.[11] [12]

Another criticism aimed at the show surrounds financial issues that some of the families have had after receiving the home makeover, which following the onset of the 2007 Financial Crisis was covered extensively by the media. As of 2020, a total of nine of the original show's recipient families have given up their homes due to financial issues, which included two foreclosures. [13][14] While most cases were reported as resulting from instances such as unemployment, accumulations of medical bills or tax rate increases, the most widely publicized cases featured families who had defaulted on home loans they had extracted on their EM:HE homes since receiving them, one of which resulted in a foreclosure. In a 2018 interview with The Wrap, Pennington explained the nature of these cases. “There’s a couple of stories that families lost their home. We left them with a financial adviser. However, if the family chooses to triple-mortgage their house to start a business that they’ve never done before just to see if they can get into it, that’s their own demise. That’s how you lose your home, is you’re like, ‘Oh, let’s use it as a lottery ticket and see what we can get out of it. And then you lose it because you can’t make the payment. But that’s what press does. They were like, ‘This is too good to be true, what is really happening?’ But with ‘Extreme’ it really was that good.”[15]

The five children of the Higgins family, aged 14–21, filed a lawsuit against ABC after they were evicted by a family that had taken them in before the show came to renovate the family's house. The five kids "say that the producers took advantage of the family's hard-luck story and promised them new cars and other prizes to persuade them to participate in the program", according to the LA Times.[16] On July 17, 2007, Judge Paul Gutman ruled against the siblings, stating that the plaintiffs failed to prove their case.[17] The decision of the trial court was affirmed on appeal.[18]

Questions arose when Theresa "Momi" Akana was picked for the Extreme Makeover program for Hawaii. The Honolulu Advertiser investigated their tax records and found out that she and her husband each made over $100,000 in salary. Denise Cramsey, the executive producer of the show, responded with "I think Momi certainly fits the bill." She defended the pick by stating that they look beyond the family's finances and consider other factors, including family plight and contributions to the community.[19]

This list includes both officially licensed versions and so-called copies of this show, mostly inspired by that, but not licensed by Endemol Shine Group, the current owner of format.

Country	Title	Broadcaster	Host	Original run	Source(s)
Albania	Nga e Para	Vizion Plus	Anila Çela	April 16, 2019
Argentina	Extreme Makeover: Home Edition Argentina	Telefe	Andy Kusnetzoff	November 11, 2013
Brazil	Extreme Makeover Social	RecordTV	Cristiana Arcangeli	September 25, 2010 – December 15, 2012	[20]
	Extreme Makeover Brasil: Casa dos Sonhos	GNT	Otaviano Costa	March 10, 2020 –	[21]
Bulgaria	Бригада нов дом	bTV	Maria Silvester	2015-
Czech Republic	Jak se staví sen	TV Prima	Pavel Cejnar	September 12, 2007
	Mise nový domov	TV Nova	Tereza Pergnerová	October 16, 2016
Italy	Extreme Makeover: Home Edition Italia	Canale 5	Alessia Marcuzzi	January 23, 2013 – 2014
Israel	Extreme Makeover Israel	Channel 10	Amos Tamam	June 12, 2013 - 2014	[22]
Philippines	Extreme Makeover: Home Edition Philippines	TV5	Paolo Bediones
Poland	Nasz Nowy Dom	Polsat	Katarzyna Dowbor	September 29, 2013	[23]
Romania	Visuri la cheie	Pro TV	Dragoș Bucur	October 29, 2014	[24]
Serbia	Radna akcija	Prva TV	Tamara Grujić	December 11, 2010 — July 15, 2016	[25]
	S Tamarom u akciji	RTS 1	Tamara Grujić	March 11, 2016 – still airing	[26]
	Kuća od srca	B92, RTV Pink	Žarko Lazić, Jelena Matijašević	September 22, 2014 – still airing	[27]
Spain	Esta casa era una ruina	Antena 3	Jorge Fernández	2008-2009

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Extreme Makeover: Home Edition.

• Official website
• Former website
• Extreme Makeover: Home Edition at IMDb
• Extreme Makeover: Home Edition at TV.com
• Extreme Makeover: Home Edition at TV Guide