Flat-chested kitten syndrome

Reports of kittens with FCKS by breed 1999-2018

GCCF statistics for numbers of kittens registered 1999-2018

Almost all reporting of FCKS is treated as anecdotal, since it comes from breeders and not from veterinary practitioners. However, in the absence of robust clinical studies breeder-reporting is the only source of information currently available. Reporting about type of FCKS is hampered by the lack of differentiation between one type and another by both breeders and vets. The data informing this article came from three sources:

• Analysis of emails reporting cases of FCKS sent to the owner of a website giving information about the condition and methods of treatment, 1999-2019 [87 of these kittens were examined in person by the author]
• Data gathered by the THINK project 2005-2015 who published an online questionnaire (the project is now defunct)
• Directly solicited reports requested from 27 individual breeders of Abyssinian (4 responded) and 35 breeders of British Shorthair (2 responded) in the UK

The 20-year analysis was compared with the Governing Council of the Cat Fancy in the UK (GCCF) analysis of numbers of kittens registered during the same period. The full report is to be published during 2020.[1]

Only direct reports from owners (362) about their own cats or vets examining kittens (2) were considered. Kittens exhibiting any other condition (including pectus excavatum) were excluded. The overwhelming majority of reports (76%) were of single FCKS cases in a litter, with the remainder whole or part litters. The data comprised 311 reports of litters of kittens in which one or more developed FCKS, for a total of 464 affected kittens (see table).

Reports in which the sex was specified showed breakdown by sex of male 56%/female 44%. 16 breeders reported that whereas they might have expected the smallest kitten in a litter (if any) to develop FCKS, it was the largest and strongest kittens that developed flat chests, and these were often males. The condition does not appear to be sex-linked, but the preponderance of male kittens in this reporting group may be due to the fact that males tend to be larger than females and these are the kittens getting most milk or suckling hardest because they are stronger, in which case the type of FCKS in these litters may have been due to colic caused by overfeeding (see Causes, below).

Reports originated from 21 countries (Australia (15), Austria (11), Belgium (2), Canada (8), Denmark (3), Finland (2), France (24), Germany (13), Hungary (1), Japan (2), Netherlands (14), New Zealand (6), Norway (5), Portugal (1), Singapore (1), Slovakia (1), South Africa (5), Sweden (11), Switzerland (1), UK (100), USA (85)) and covered 39 breeds (including non-pedigree domestic shorthair, non-pedigree domestic longhair, and some ‘unrecognised’ crosses between two pedigree breeds or pedigree breeds x DSH). 10 reports did not specify breed.

High numbers of reports in certain breeds has in the past been taken to imply that some breeds are more prone to the condition than others, but the data is skewed by various factors: a) the numbers of kittens bred; b) cluster-reporting in response to articles in breed club circulars or c) the work of a particular group of breeders (cf Burmese) in attempting to address a problem that they had seen in their own lines d) the culture within an individual breed of information-sharing or reporting problems. Breeders are generally not inclined to discuss health issues because of a culture of blame and gossip, having a dramatic effect on information-sharing. No ‘cluster’ triggers have been identified for the relatively high number of reports in the Maine Coon or Bengal breeds, while the Burmese cat club commissioned a study into the condition in 1997 by Sturgess et al, and the THINK project solicited reports from Burmese breeders specifically. However statistics on the registration of kittens provided by the GCCF show that Bengal, Burmese and Maine Coon are consistently in the top nine breeds by number of kittens registered (see table). The breeds showing highest numbers of kittens registered therefore broadly correlate demographically to reports of FCKS. More significant is perhaps the low number of reported cases in the British Shorthair (especially when compared with the Manx), but this seems to be attributable to the culture of breeders and level of diagnostic awareness in that group.

Mortality: of 195 cases where the outcome was notified, 88 died, or were euthanised due to distress; 107 recovered and survived beyond 3 months of age. Those that recovered fully did not appear to suffer any long-term respiratory effects (Interference of the development of the upper spine while the body was held in an incorrect position by the FCKS led to long-term kyphosis in some, but not all, cases), although reporting is patchy.

Mentions of FCKS in the veterinary literature (usually no more than a single sentence) include no descriptive information and have no evidential basis, in particular the claim in Saperstein, Harris & Leipold (1976) that the condition may be hereditary, which has been repeated in subsequent literature.

FCKS develops usually in kittens around three days of age, and sometimes affects whole litters, sometimes only individuals or part of a litter. Kittens can go flat any time during early maturation, some flattening as late as 10 days of age or (in very rare cases) later. It is possible that the later-developing cases are due to Respiratory tract infection or pneumonia. Until 2010 FCKS was believed to be caused by a spasm in the intercostal muscles, but re-examination of old post-mortem data (i.e. that kittens remain flat even when they are dead and therefore cannot maintain a muscular spasm) and new data has led to the conclusion that flattening is caused by failure of the lungs to inflate normally or, when it occurs in older kittens, by lung collapse. This cause is now cited by the veterinary community (Sturgess 2016) but without any source acknowledgement.

Gross physical symptoms include flattening of the underside of the thorax in moderate cases (a ridge can usually be felt along the sides of the ribcage, running parallel to the spine); complete flattening of the upper body in extreme cases (the kitten looks as if it has been stepped on); moderate to extreme effort and/or gasping during breathing; the gut is drawn upwards during the in-breath. Breathing is not usually rapid (as in pneumonia or pyrexia) but at a normal rate when compared with unaffected kittens. The position of the thorax and activity of the abdomen is not unlike that seen during normal hiccups, but the sudden spasm in hiccups is slowed down or halted in FCKS: where a hiccup releases, returning the body to a normal position, FCKS breathing does not release. There may be involvement with digestive difficulty in FCKS kittens (see Colic, below).

Diagram of normal cat thorax

Diagram of thoracic deformities of flat chested kitten

Banana used to demonstrate FCKS shape

Determining whether a kitten has FCKS or not can be difficult with only text descriptions: a mild case of FCKS causes the thorax to feel similar to the shape of a banana when held curve downward. The ribcage is not fixed in position, and the most noticeable effect in mild cases is the ridge along the side of the ribcage.

The condition causes weight-gain to halt, respiratory distress, inability to feed normally and, in a significant proportion of cases, death. However, since a significant percentage of kittens survive the condition immediate euthanasia is not indicated, and supportive treatments can be employed to increase the likelihood of survival (see Treatment, below).

The condition is often misdiagnosed as Pectus excavatum,[2] with which it has no direct connection, although FCKS kittens may also have PE. Although the condition is believed to be more prevalent in the Burmese breed it is found in every breed of cat, including non-pedigree domestic cats, and the apparent prevalence in the Burmese is most likely due to better communication between breeders and reporting of the condition, as well as the naturally more barrel-shaped chest of this particular genotype.[3] Since early reporting of the condition identified the Burmese as susceptible the Bengal breed, with a similar physiology, has emerged, and shows a similarly large number of FCKS kittens, however this may be due to specific interest in the condition among those working with the breeds. It is reported in all breeds and in domestic non-pedigree cats, both those kept as pets and those living as 'barn cats'. An article in a Swedish cat club newsletter about FCKS led to a spike in reporting of the condition in Ragdolls in Sweden.

Egyptian Mau kitten with FCKS

Rex kitten with FCKS and Kyphosis - note narrowing of thorax around the shoulders

Oriental kitten with moderate to extreme FCKS. Pectus Excavatum is not present. The kitten was wrapped in a 'corset' for about 2 weeks. It is now a healthy adult.

The syndrome is life-threatening in a significant number of cases (possibly around 40%) mainly due to a lack of understanding of the underlying cause of the condition, failure to treat colic (leading to slow starvation) and insufficient sources of information in veterinary literature.

Position of Phrenic nerve in a sleeping kitten. The nerve bifurcates and runs down both sides of the neck.

Treatment is difficult to define given the number of different causes and the wealth of anecdotal information collected by and from cat breeders. Treatments have hitherto been based on the assumption that FCKS is caused by a muscular spasm, and their effectiveness is impossible to assess because some kittens will recover spontaneously without intervention. FCKS cannot be corrected surgically.

Diaphragmatic spasm is easily tested for and treated by short term interruption of the Phrenic nerve. The nerve runs down the outside of the neck where the neck joins to the shoulder, within a bundle of muscles and tendons at this junction. The cluster can be pinched gently and held for a few seconds each time. Kittens with spasmodic FCKS will show almost immediate improvement, but the treatment may need to be repeated several times over a few days as the spasm may have a tendency to recur, particularly after suckling. It is sometimes evident that the spasm only affects one side of the diaphragm, as interruption of the nerve is only necessary or effective on one side.

Continuous positive air pressure (CPAP) is used in human babies with lung collapse, but this is impossible with kittens. It is possible that the success of some breeders in curing kittens by splinting the body, thus putting pressure on the ribcage, was successful as it has created the effect of positive air pressure, thus gradually re-inflating the lungs by pulling them open rather than pushing them open as is the case with CPAP (see below).

It is difficult to determine whether a kitten that goes flat will survive or not. A good indicator is the weight of the kitten: those that continue to gain weight generally have a better chance of survival. Supplement feeding is therefore recommended in all cases, together with vitamin supplements,[7] although many of these kittens will not accept hand feeding. Liquid Paraffin to alleviate colic seems to be significant in assisting normal feeding and weight-gain.

Another indicator to the severity of the case is the use of the stomach when breathing: normal kittens use only the ribcage, a flat-chested kitten may manage to breathe only using the ribcage, or may suck the gut upwards with every breath – if the latter is the case then the likelihood of survival seems to be lower, though still not sufficient to warrant immediate euthanasia. If the condition is stable (i.e. the flatness does not increase over time) or improving, the kitten is more likely to survive. If the condition worsens over several days, survival is less likely.

Kittens with FCKS may die (or have to be euthanised) very soon after onset. There are two points at which breeders report kittens that were otherwise doing well deteriorating and dying: at 10 days of age and at 3 weeks. Generally if the kitten is still flat, but survives the 3-week developmental stage, its prognosis is good. Many will have returned to a normal shape by this time. Those retaining some degree of flatness often grow out of the condition at any point in the ensuing 6 months, and the vast majority of survivors appear to lead normal lives with no side-effects, either physical or immunological.

FCKS kittens that survive but who have not been given any drug treatment or support other than supplementary feeding, generally recover over a period of 4–10 weeks, and are usually normal by 12 weeks of age, though some take as long as 6 months to normalise. In the very small number of kittens reported so far treated with steroids, antibiotics and liquid paraffin (to address colic) recovery is usually seen within a matter of days. Given the number of different types of FCKS these kittens (all with the minor form of the condition) may not be representative of all cases. More data is required for statistical analysis.

A small proportion of severe FCKS kittens are left with long-term respiratory problems, kyphosis, and in some cases cardiac issues caused by the compression of the thorax during the early developmental stages (particularly where the condition has been coupled with Pectus Excavatum). Cardiac issues are generally audible on physical examination; further indications include the kitten becoming breathless after play, less active than siblings, and failure to grow and develop normally.

Crucial in the decision to breed would be the primary cause of FCKS in the litter, which may or may not be genetic (see Heredity above). Some recovered FCKS adults have produced FCKS offspring in their turn, and some queens consistently produce flat kittens, so breeding from those lines is therefore inadvisable. However, repeat matings in which FCKS has appeared does not result in further FCKS kittens any more often than non-repeat matings. Queens and studs who consistently throw complete litters of kittens with the condition are generally neutered, but isolated instances of single flat kittens in an otherwise healthy litter seem to be unlikely to have a genetic component and neutering of parents of such kittens is not usually necessary in pedigree breeding, particularly where doing so may have detrimental effects on the gene pool.

If the cause of flattening is colic related to over-production of milk then this would not be cause for neutering. The only way to determine if the cause is digestive would be if the condition was alleviated by pinching the phrenic nerve and/or use of liquid paraffin to relieve colic, resulting in improvement in the condition.

Line-breeding or inbreeding is highly inadvisable in any situation, and particularly so in lines where FCKS has appeared, given the possibility of inheritance of any underlying condition or breeding factor that may cause kittens to develop FCKS.

Kittens with FCKS sometimes also show bony deformities such as pectus excavatum or kyphosis (characterised in kittens by a dip in the spine just behind the shoulder blades). Although a kitten may be born with these deformities, extreme forms of FCKS may cause kyphosis to develop in an otherwise normal kitten, as the kitten grows with the spine held in an abnormal position due to the flattened ribcage. When there are bony deformities in the upper body, or other problems present, these may contribute to malfunctioning in soft-tissue organs such as the respiratory and digestive systems.

Flat chest occurs in piglets and puppies, may be known in cattle (anecdotal information only), and is also recorded in humans, though possibly in humans this is not the same type of condition and may be a bone deformity.

• Vetstream article on FCKS in journal Felis ISSN 2398-2950
• Flat-Chested Kitten Syndrome
• Marine Minnaert: Étude rétrospective de la cage thoracique plate chez le chat : caractéristiques épidémiologiques et cliniques, pronostic et aspects génétiques, PhD thesis (2014) pdf
• International Cat Care website; based on Sturgess 1997, which is out of date and incorrect in many particulars
• Sturgess C P, Waters L, Gruffydd-Jones T J et al (1997) Investigation of the association between whole blood and tissue taurine levels and the development of thoracic deformities in neonatal Burmese kittens. Vet Rec 141, 566-570
• Feline Medicine and Therapeutics By E. A. Chandler, R. M. Gaskell, C. J. Gaskell describes the condition very briefly and refers to it as 'almost certainly hereditary' without any evidence for doing so. No other information is given as to cause.
• In Arthur's Veterinary Reproduction and Obstetrics E-Book By David E. Noakes FCKS is listed in a table of hereditary defects in cats, again without any supporting citation or information
• Google Books link to article in Feline Medicine and Therapeutics By E. A. Chandler, R. M. Gaskell, C. J. Gaskell
• Sturgess, C. P. (2016) Thoracic wall deformities in kittens: what do you do? Australian and New Zealand College of Veterinary Scientists Science Week, Small Animal Medicine and Feline Chapters

• Blunden, A. S., Hill, C. M., Brown, B. D. and Morley C. J. (1987) Lung surfactant composition in puppies dying of fading puppy complex. Research in Veterinary Science 42: 113–118
• Blunden, T. S. (1998) The neonate: congenital defects and fading puppies. In: Manual of Small Animal Reproduction and Neonatology. Simpson, G., England, G. C. W. & Harvey, M. (eds). British Small Animal Veterinary Association, Cheltenham, UK.
• Chandler, E. A., Gaskell, R. M., Gaskell, C. J. eds. (2004) Feline Medicine and Therapeutics. 3rd edn. Blackwell, Oxford (for BSAVA), 369. [Warning: this source mentions FCKS very briefly and refers to it as 'almost certainly hereditary'. No evidence, sources or further information are given.]
• Charlesworth, T. M., Schwarz, T., Sturgess, C. P. (2015) Pectus excavatum: computed tomography and medium-term surgical outcome in a prospective cohort of 10 kittens. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery Jun 18, 11
• Fossum, T. W., Boudrieau, R. J., Hobson, H. P., Rudy, R. L. (1989). Surgical correction of pectus excavatum using external splintage in two dogs and a cat. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 195: 91–97
• Hosgood, G., Hoskins J. D. (1998) Small Animal Paediatric Medicine and Surgery. Pergamon Veterinary Handbooks. Butterworth-Heinemann
• Malik, R. (2001) Genetic diseases of cats, Proceedings of ESFM Symposium at BSAVA Congress, Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery 3, 109–113
• Noakes, D. E., Parkinson, T. J., England, G. C. W. (2009) Arthur's Veterinary Reproduction and Obstetrics E-Book. 9th edn. Saunders/Elsevier, Edinburgh, 128. FCKS is listed in a table of hereditary defects in cats.
• Robinson (1991) Genetics for Cat Breeders 3rd Revised edition, Butterworth-Heinemann
• Saperstein G., Harris S., Leipold H.W. (1976). Congenital defects in domestic cats. Feline Practice, 6, 18.
• Schultheiss, P. C., Gardner, S. A., Owens, J. M., Wenger, D. A., Thrall, M. A. (2000). Mucopolysaccharidosis VII in a cat. Veterinary Pathology 37, 502–505.
• Soderstrom, M. J., Gilson, S. D., Gulbas, N. (1995) Fatal reexpansion Pulmonary Edema in a Kitten Following Surgical Correction of Pectus Excavatum. Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 31, 133–136
• Sturgess C. P., Waters L., Gruffydd-Jones T. J., Nott H. M. R., Earle, K. E. (1997) Investigation of the association between whole blood and tissue taurine levels and the development of thoracic deformities in neonatal Burmese kittens. Veterinary Record 141, 566–570. [Warning: much information now superseded]
• Vella, C. M., Shelton L. M., McGonagle, J. J., Stanglein, T. W. (1999) Robinson's Genetics for Cat Breeders and Veterinarians, 4th edn, Butterworth-Heinemann