Grotesque (After the Gramme)

This was the first album for drummer Paul Hanley (Steve Hanley's younger brother), who joined the Fall earlier in the year aged 15. Kay Carroll, singer Mark E. Smith's then-girlfriend and the band's manager, played kazoo on "New Face in Hell" and added backing vocals.[2] Grotesque was recorded at Cargo Studios in Rochdale and Street Level in London, with production by the band and Grant Showbiz, Geoff Travis and Mayo Thompson.[3]

The album was preceded by two acclaimed singles, "How I Wrote 'Elastic Man'" and "Totally Wired", which were subsequently included on CD reissues of the album. The colour sleeve (the group's first) was drawn by Smith's sister, Suzanne.[4]

According to the Slates & Dates press release, this album was, at one point, to be titled After the Gramme – The Grotesque Peasants.

The Fall's music at the time was described as "Mancabilly", and by Smith himself as "Country 'n' Northern".[2][5] The album opens with "Pay Your Rates", the lyric described as one that "excoriates small-minded conformity".[5] Second track "English Scheme" was seen as Smith "sneering at the middle class liberals".[6] "New Face in Hell" takes its name from the 1968 film P. J. which was retitled New Face in Hell in the UK.[7] It has been described as "a paranoid tale of sinister government agencies 'disappearing' innocent amateur radio hams".[5] "C'n'C–S Mithering" was seen by AllMusic reviewer Ned Raggett as "a brilliant vivisection of California and its record business, and the attendant perception of the Fall themselves", and by Stereogum's Robert Ham as "his sprawling screed at the vapidity of the music industry".[3][8] The song makes reference to the band's meeting with A&M Records co-founder Herb Alpert ("big A&M Herb was there") while seeking an American record deal.[9] Side one closes with "The Container Drivers", which Al Spicer described as "[shattering] the stereotype of the noble trucker, depicting a world of loudmouthed ignorance and bowel-rotting gluttony".[5]

The second side opens with "Impression of J. Temperance", a "stark, mud-stained tale of cloning gone horribly wrong".[5] "In the Park" deals with outdoor sex.[5] "W.M.C. – Blob 59" combines lo-fi tape recordings of rehearsals and conversations.[5] "Gramme Friday" was described as a "hymn to amphetamines".[5] The album's closing track, "The N.W.R.A" ("The North Will Rise Again", not, as some supposed, "The North West Republican Army")[10] was viewed by AllMusic as "Smith's own take on the long-standing "soft south/grim north" dichotomy in English society",[3] while Robert Ham saw it as "a literary vision of political upheaval in Northern England".[8] Rolling Stone merely saw it as Smith shouting out his hometown.[6]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[3]
Christgau's Record Guide	B[11]
Classic Rock	8/10[12]
Encyclopedia of Popular Music	[13]
Mojo	[14]
Record Mirror	[15]
The Rolling Stone Album Guide	[6]
Sounds	[16]
Spin Alternative Record Guide	9/10[17]

Johnny Waller, reviewing Grotesque for Sounds, hailed the album as "rock n' roll with a conscience".[16] Critic Robert Christgau described it simply as "poetry readings with two-chord backing".[11] NME writer Graham Lock was more reserved in his praise, deeming it the Fall's "least flawed album" while suggesting that the band had yet to reach their full potential.[18][19] Chris Westwood of Record Mirror viewed it as a disappointment, finding that the band's cynical outlook had become predictable.[15]

Retrospective assessments were more positive. In his review of Grotesque for AllMusic, Ned Raggett opined that the band "really started hitting its stride" with the album, commenting on its "sharp rockabilly leads and random art rock racket".[3] In The New Rolling Stone Album Guide, Joe Gross cites Grotesque as "the first truly great Fall album".[6] In Stereogum, Robert Ham saw the band "hitting their creative stride as songwriters and players" on the album, stating, "Some of it is still very tattered around the edges, but the majority of it finds that unique static charge that made their '80s work so compelling."[8] Trouser Press viewed the album as "[removing] the Fall even further from the world of easy listening", describing the tracks as "mostly one-or-two-chord jams played too slowly to be hardcore, but structured similarly".[20]

Grotesque was included in Al Spicer's 1999 book Rock: 100 Essential CDs, in which he described it as "among the Fall's most powerful statements, and recorded by the most inventive of the band's constantly evolving line-ups".[5] In a 2018 article for Billboard, Geeta Dayal listed Grotesque as the Fall's fifth best album, noting its "slightly cleaner sound" and citing "The N.W.R.A." and "The Container Drivers" as highlights.[21]

Grotesque was first reissued through Castle Music in 1993.[2] In 1998, Cog Sinister, Mark E. Smith's own imprint, released a poorly mastered edition with significant vinyl noise. However, an improved edition followed almost immediately through Castle, adding four bonus tracks: "How I Wrote 'Elastic Man'", "City Hobgoblins", "Totally Wired" and "Putta Block", the last of these being slightly edited from the original "Totally Wired" single. The final and current edition, again on Castle, was properly remastered, including the four bonus tracks ("Putta Block" still being slightly cut) and a "self-interview" by Smith that had been used for promotional purposes upon the album's original release.

The original ten-track album was reissued on vinyl by the Turning Point label in 2002,[2] with a two-LP edition being issued by Earmark in 2005. The latter edition replicated the definitive track listing of the 2004 CD. It was released again on vinyl in 2016 by Superior Viaduct.

All lyrics are written by Mark E. Smith.

The Fall

• Mark E. Smith – vocals, tape operation, kazoo (track 3), guitar
• Marc Riley – guitar, keyboards
• Craig Scanlon – guitar (credited as 'Craig Scanlan')
• Steve Hanley – bass guitar
• Paul Hanley – drums
• Kay Carroll – additional vocals

Technical

• The Fall – production
• Geoff Travis – production
• Grant Showbiz – production ("Pay Your Rates", "The Container Drivers")
• Mayo Thompson – production
• John Brierley – engineering
• George "Porky" Peckham – mastering

• Grotesque at Discogs (list of releases)