Highly Questionable

A series of viewer submitted questions begin the proceedings. Papi reads each of them from an Apple iPad in front of him. When Papi doesn't, the producer asks the question, and Le Batard and Jones each take turns addressing the audience with their takes, while Papi chimes in with a random non sequitur. Occasionally, Dan and Papi find questions humorous or ignorant enough in nature that they are not worth answering, and just simply laugh, instead.[15][21] Once in a while, Papi will say something completely ridiculous and potentially damaging; when he does this, a technical difficulty bumper will play for several seconds, and Le Batard will prompt Papi to apologize.

On certain Mondays, particularly during the National Football League regular season, the "Questions" segment will continue into the second segment.

During the second segment, a pretaped interview with a guest airs. The questions are usually related to a current issue or event in sports, and Dan and Bomani often ask about the guest's life outside of sports. Papi asks the final question, usually about topics unrelated to sports.[15]

On days when no guest is available, one of several things will happen. One of "Papi's famous interview medleys", with highlights from past interviews shown, might play or a second set of questions might be asked. "Do You Question" (see below) may also serve as the second segment, and more and more frequently does serve that purpose.

The third segment is essentially a repeat of the first segment, and is introduced by Jones by saying, "you give us topics and events, we question 'em." The only difference is that they begin with "Do you question..." and often feature humorous video clips that do not necessarily have anything to do with sports.[15]

The final segment of the show relates to television programming. The three hosts are given the name of a program airing that evening and offer their opinions on whether or not they are intrigued. Each responds with "Sí" or "No" while holding up a placard with his response. Most of the programs are sports related but at least one is a general interest program such as a documentary or reality program[15] such as The Bachelor, which Le Batard hates and leaves the set whenever it is featured. Papi has the on-show reputation for responding "Sí, sí, I'm very intrigued!" to just about everything and often comes up with odd reasons for doing so, such as a team with a "Latino player" (sometimes an actual Latino player, but other times one with a Spanish-sounding name or even one he completely makes up, like "Miguel Verde" or "Bernardo Bishopo") who is going to have a "helluva game" or who will be a "name you'll never forget" (which he promptly forgets), or humorous misunderstandings of the shows in question.

One of the show's most frequently used running gags is the Banana Phone, where Papi imitates a ringing telephone and picks up the banana out of the plastic fruit bowl to (pretend to) speak to someone on the other end. To further the gag a cord is attached to the banana.

Usually, Papi calls his bookie "Juanito" and tells him to "put everything" on the team he thinks will win. Juanito takes bets on virtually any sporting event known to man, from the America's Cup to middle school basketball. Papi is also known to thank Juanito for a tip he allegedly gave him or implying that he had a role in a certain event's outcome, including horses crashing at the finish line of a race, or other bloopers.

In more recent episodes the gag has expanded to having Papi pretend to speak to other people besides Juanito. During the 2017 NBA playoffs, Papi frequently received "calls" from Fred Hoiberg, the head coach of the Chicago Bulls who complained frequently about traveling calls not being made against Isaiah Thomas of the Boston Celtics; to this effect, Hoiberg always "phones in" when he believes a traveling call anywhere was missed.

The number to call Papi from the Banana Phone is 1-800-BANANA.

After "Sí o No", the show comes to an end with Papi or Dan thanking the viewers for watching. Le Batard follows with his own goodbye, reminding the viewers when to catch the show again and occasionally promoting either his or his co-hosts other tv/radio shows or podcasts. Le Batard's co-host has the last word, saying "Gracias, see ya mañana" or "see ya el lunes" depending on the day of the week (lunes being Spanish for Monday; this is usually said to close the Friday show). After this, there is a brief interlude where something from a previous segment, or from earlier in the show is revisited humorously before the show cuts out.

Occasionally during the commercial interlude, a special guest would appear on the set. During the use of the kitchen-themed set, the guest could be seen utilizing the kitchen, supposedly without Dan or Gonzalo noticing. On the Clevelander set, the guests have appeared in studio, sometimes joining the panel for the "¿Sí o No?" segment.[22] Special guests have included Lil Wayne,[22] Pat Riley, Jason Taylor, Kimbo Slice, Sebastian the Ibis, NBA Hall of Famer Isiah Thomas, Ron Magill, Steven Bauer, Pedro Martínez, Micky Arison, Mike Lowell, Lil Dicky, Robert Smith, and Pat Sajak among others.

Since 2014, Highly Questionable presents the "Papi Awards", an end of the year special which consists of a series of awards based on video clips that were usually visited in Do You Question. Papi dresses in a tuxedo while Le Batard and Jones served as his co-hosts, and each category has a winner and at least two runners-up. Each "winner" receives the "Golden Banana", a trophy made for the occasion. A constant running gag for the awards is that the winners are not able to receive the award in person for various reasons, so the trophy is held over for each subsequent award.[23] There was no Papi Awards special in 2019, due to Papi's sabbatical from the program. The segment returned for the final time on January 4, 2021, the Le Batards' final episode.