I Can Feel You Forgetting Me

The band released the lead single, "Used to Like" on November 13, 2019.[2] The song peaked at number four on the US Alternative Airplay chart[3] and number 17 on the US Rock Songs chart.[4] The second single, "New Best Friend" was released on May 20, 2020. The song peaked at number 33 on the US Alternative Airplay chart.[3] On July 10, 2020, the band released the third single called "Mess Me Up".[5] The fourth and final single, "Nights", was released on July 22, 2020.[6]

Singer Tyler Glenn stated that they started making the album in 2018. The band wrote around 40 songs for the album then narrowed it down to ten songs.[1] Glenn also stated that the album "sounds like one full night of reflection, alone at the bar, walking past the places you’d go with them, texting them when you shouldn’t, and ultimately embracing the idea that no one else can complete you."[7]

Luke Wells of Soundigest called the album a departure from the band's "poppy tone" that made them famous in the early 2010s. He wrote that the production is glossy and that it has 1980s vibes. He wrote that the track, "Nights", "lays out the recurring theme of extensive reflection and struggles faced in transitioning your life out of a long-term relationship". He called "Everything Is Killing Me", "the strongest song on the album" because it is about the struggles from the use of substances that are faced during a breakup.[8]

• Mike Green – producer (tracks 1, 2, 6, 7, 9), composer (tracks 1, 6, 7, 9), writer (track 2)
• Nico Stadi – producer (tracks 1, 2, 6, 7, 9)
• Niko Hartikainen – composer (tracks 1, 6, 7, 9), writer (track 2)
• Tyler Glenn – composer (tracks 1, 3-9), writer (tracks 2, 10)
• Chris Gehringer – masterer (track 2)
• Neal Avron – mixer (track 2)
• Dave Bassett – producer (track 3), composer (track 3)
• Micah Gordon – producer (tracks 4, 5, 8), composer (tracks 4, 6, 8)
• Cameron Hale – producer (tracks 5, 8), composer (tracks 5, 8)
• Joe Janiak – producer (track 10), writer (track 10)