I Wish I Could Have Loved You More

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
Allmusic	[1]
The Times	[2]

Tracks 4 and 8 feature backing vocals by Payne's brother Sean Payne, his fiancee Abi Harding and Russell Pritchard, all of The Zutons.[3]

All songs written by Candie Payne and Simon Dine

1. "I Wish I Could Have Loved You More" – 3:33
2. "Why Should I Settle for You" – 4:01
3. "Take Me" – 2:27
4. "In the Morning" – 3:06
5. "All I Need to Hear" – 2:45
6. "A Different You" – 3:52
7. "By Tomorrow" – 3:31
8. "One More Chance" – 2:46
9. "Hey Goodbye" – 3:16
10. "Seasons Change" – 1:50
11. "Turn Back Now" – 3:10

• Candie Payne – vocals[4]

Production[4]

• Simon Dine – producer
• Jessica Corcoran – engineer
• Ion Metsovitis – engineer
• Matthew Edge – vocal engineer
• Serge Krebs – assistant engineer
• Mike Hedges – mixing
• Craig Silvey – mixing
• Richard Wilkinson – mixing
• John Brough – vocal mixing
• John Davis – mastering

Additional musicians[4]

• Abi Harding – backing vocals
• Sean Payne – backing vocals
• Russell Pritchard – backing vocals

Emma Bunton covered "I Wish I Could Have Loved You More" on her 2019 album My Happy Place.