List of Are You Afraid of the Dark? episodes

Two brothers who often fight with each other get lost in the woods, and come across a mysterious cab driver named Flynn. He leads the two boys to an unusual man named Dr. Vink to help them find their way out. The catch is that Vink will not help any of his guests until they solve one of his riddles. Failure to do so results in undesired consequences.

• Storyteller : Frank
• Guest star : Aron Tager as Dr. Vink

Josh decides to prove that an amusement park fun house isn't haunted by stealing the nose from a prop of Zeebo the clown. Zeebo was a corrupt circus clown who died in a funhouse fire while escaping from the police after stealing money. Josh soon learns that the story is indeed true when Zeebo's ghost visits him demanding his nose back.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Guest star : Christian Tessier as Josh
• Notable cast : Aron Tager as Zeebo & the Circus Carney

Amanda is stuck spending time at her aunt's house, and desperately wants to be friends with her snotty cousin Beth. She agrees to spend the night in the haunted house next door to become part of her group of friends. She soon finds out that the story regarding the "haunted" house may actually be true with a living connection close by.

• Storyteller : David
• Guest star : Laura Bertram as Amanda
• Notable cast : Pauline Little as Aunt Dottie

In a twist on the classic story "The Monkey's Paw", two boys play a mean trick on an old lady the night before Halloween. The next night the boys return for trick or treating "disguised" in costumes, but rather than candy she gives them a wooden vulture's claw. She tells the boys that this "gift" grants wishes warning them to "be careful what they wish for". The two boys start making wishes with unintended terrifying consequences.

• Storyteller : David

Amy and Pam discover their late aunt's old horse-riding jacket in an old trunk. When Pam puts on the jacket, she becomes possessed by the aunt's spirit, who must feed her hungry dogs in order to rest in peace.

• Storyteller : Kristen
• Guest star : Mia Kirshner as Pam

A prankster named Weeds buys a pair of novelty glasses from Sardo that allow the wearer to see into another dimension. This alternate universe is populated by figures in black, that are looking to merge with the known universe unless Sardo can close the door between the two dimensions.

• Storyteller : Gary
• Guest stars : Eugene Byrd as Weeds and Richard Dumont as Sardo

Danielle and her parents rent a lakeside room for the summer where they befriend the young property owner Peter. Strangely the residence is full of mirrors which the owner cites as a "hobby", and even stranger the parents start feeling weaker by the day. Danielle soon discovers the owner’s trying to take away her parents' youth to keep himself young using a device connected to the mirror and has to stop him before it's too late.

• Storyteller : Kiki
• Notable cast : Ethan Tobman as Peter Kirlan III and Barbara Eve Harris as Sally Sellman

A new family moves into Emma's neighborhood. They are originally from Rovno, Ukraine, wear black, collect blood and are only active at night.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann

Dean is a high school outcast who gets a chance to have some power from awakening an ancient secret hidden in the school. In doing so, he briefly forgets the person who cares for him most without realizing it.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann

Jake Joysen (Benjamin Plener) is an aspiring, young actor who is excited to be part of a play titled Will o' the Wisp, but Jake himself soon learns in due time that there is much more to the play than meets the eye.

• Storyteller : Eric

Andy moves into a new neighborhood where things do not start out well until he figures out that there is something hidden inside his basement that only seems to appear whenever music is played.

• Storyteller : Eric

Three kids attempt to find the truth behind an urban legend of a young girl who died while waiting for her boyfriend to pick her up for the prom. This story is loosely based on Resurrection Mary.

• Storyteller : Kristen

Despite being warned by his boss against playing the pinball machine and finish cleaning up before going home, Ross plays a pinball game that comes to life when he is left in the mall after closing time.

• Storyteller : Gary

Jill is a 13 year old who is reluctant to give up her childhood fairytales, which results in her school friends and family mocking her. She makes a wish one night saying she just wants everyone to leave her alone. The Sandman grants her wish by placing her inside her own nightmarish fairytale.

• Storyteller : Kristen
• Guest star : Bobcat Goldthwait as The Sandman

Dr. Vink helps a struggling movie theater gain more patrons with a copy of the classic vampire film, Nosferatu, but when Dr. Vink gets cheated out of his money in saving the theater, he curses the famous movie monster to step out of the movie and haunt the theater, and it's up to two teenaged ushers to break the curse.

• Storyteller : Frank
• Guest star : Aron Tager as Dr. Vink

A new student from France is assigned a locker that once belonged to a hippie girl named Candy Warren who died in a chemistry lab explosion in 1968...and the new student soon discovers that Candy's spirit wants her to go back in time to prevent her death. The girl succeeds with the help of her friend who makes the teacher, Mr. Shaffner, realize the dangers of using a broken equipment that could've caused a tragedy. Returning to the present, they're shocked to see that Candy is their vice principal and Shaffner has since retired from teaching.

• Storyteller : Kristen
• Guest star : Jennifer Irwin as Candy Warren

Siblings Billy and his adopted sister Karen like to spend their free time playing hockey on the 13th floor of their apartment building, but this stops when a strange toy company rents out the thirteenth floor to store their new products and has picked Karen to test them out.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann

An aspiring writer finds a typewriter that makes whatever is written come true. Things seem harmless enough until he writes a pair of stories that end up putting his best friend and the girl he likes in danger.

• Storyteller : Kiki (told by Gary due to Kiki's laryngitis)

A teenage boy with a debilitating leg injury from a car accident buys a potion from Sardo's Magic Shop in order to cure his injury and get his confidence back. However, the more the boy uses the potion, the more his inner demons turn him into a monster.

• Storyteller : David (for Gary's birthday, borrowing Sardo)
• Guest star : Richard Dumont as Sardo

After a day in the park, babysitter Louise and two pre-teenagers get lost in the highway and stop at a mansion where things are not what they seem.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann

A rich kid and his grumpy babysitter head off to his poor aunt's house in the country, where a little boy who can only utter, "I'm cold" haunts the woods.

• Storyteller : Kristen
• Guest star : Melissa Joan Hart as Daphne

An aspiring pet detective suspects his mother's new boyfriend might be a werewolf.

• Storyteller : Frank

Mike hasn't been the same since his friend Ricky died in an accident while riding his shiny, red bicycle. Things get worse when Mike begins seeing Ricky's ghost and the red bicycle and discovers that his younger brother will die just like Ricky did unless he does something to change his brother's fate.

• Storyteller : David

Todd becomes the new assistant to an elderly stage magician named Shandu, who teaches him everything he needs to know about magic with his three magical rules. But when Todd steals Shandu's magic wand, he unleashes an evil spirit and must rely on Shandu's rules to trap the spirit.

• Storyteller : Gary

Siblings Jazz and Augie enroll at a boarding school run by a strange couple who need slaves to care for their alien eggs.

• Storyteller : David

Two boys from a tough city move into a new neighborhood where a group of kids invite them to play hide and seek in a cemetery, rumored to be haunted by a ghost known as Old Man Corcoran.

• Storyteller : Kiki
• Note : This is Nathaniel Moreau and Rachel Blanchard's final episode. In "The Tale of the Midnight Ride," Gary mentions that they moved away.

In a modern retelling of Sleepy Hollow, Ian Matthews moves to the legendary town. He soon meets a girl (Katie) who becomes his new girlfriend, but a local bully who also has eyes on her are jealous of the two. He challenges Ian to go-to the bridge of souls of which the headless horseman can never cross and stick a knife in a pumpkin proving he was there. The following night after being chased by the bully in disguise he meets the ghost of Ichabod Crane who has lost his way. After pointing him in the direction away from the bridge, Ian is soon chased by the real headless horseman. Ian manages to make it across the bridge of souls destroying the horseman, and then runs into Crane again who remarks that he meant to go "that way" referring to the bridge.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Guest star : Arthur Holden as Ichabod Crane's Ghost
• Notable cast : Rachel Wilson as Katie
• Note : Introduces Tucker to the cast.

After Stacey moves into a new apartment with her mom, she befriends an elderly woman living next door by coming by for visits. The old woman tells Stacey to visit her on a special day of importance in particular to which Stacey promises to do so.

• Storyteller : Kiki
• Note : The campfire was not extinguished.

After Sarah and Kelly get lost in the woods, they discover the terrifying truth behind the legend of "Watcher's Woods".

• Storyteller : Sam
• Guest star : Jewel Staite as Kelly
• Notable cast : Tom Rack as The watcher
• Notes : The campfire was not extinguished. Introduces Sam to the cast.

Jake loves to make prank calls, but is caught one night by his sister who warns him to stop or the phone police will get involved. Scoffing at sister, Jake decides to look up Billy Baxter who was mentioned in his sister's story. When he calls the number provided Billy pleads for help and keeps calling Jake relentlessly afterwards.

• Storyteller : Tucker

Melissa comes to the country to visit her aunt and uncle, and is excited to see her friend Susan. They tell Melissa though that she moved back to the city a few months ago. Melissa decides to explore her friend's now vacant home and discovers a dollhouse in the attic along with a mysterious door.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Notable cast : Amanda Walsh as Susan

Twelve year old Ricky is obsessed with TV and video games and is not happy when his mom hired a babysitter named Belinda to look after him one night. Belinda makes a deal with him that if he reads a book for five minutes he can watch TV the rest of the night. Ricky is excited and starts to read but cannot do it as he finds the books too boring, opting for video games in his room. Things take an unexpected turn when the characters from one of the books come alive in the real world forcing Ricky to finish his own story about how it ends with Belinda's help.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Notable cast : Natalie Radford as Belinda the babysitter

Alison just moved into a new town and is struggling to make new friends. She stops by Sardo's shop where he sells her a "friendship stone" that unknown to the shop owner grants the wearer the ability to time travel. Alison is soon pursued by a powerful sorcerer named Brother Septimus who is after his stone, but is able to escape to the 1890s through her mirror. In this different time period she makes friends with the former occupant (Tom Bradshaw) of the house in which she now lives.

• Storyteller : Gary
• Guest stars : Frank Gorshin as Brother Septimus and Richard Dumont as Sardo.
• Notable cast : John White as Tom Bradshaw

Josh and Cleo's family vacation is canceled yet again when Dr. Capel-Smith stops their father on his way out of the museum and finds a mummy buried there. There is a legend of a curse for anyone who digs it up, but only Josh believes it.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Guest star : Danny Cooksey as Josh Dugan
• Notable cast : Vanessa King as Cleo Dugan

When a bullied kid named Matt visits a photographer about his school picture, he ends up with the photographer's mysterious camera, which predicts doom for anything -- and anyone -- it photographs.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Guest star : Eddie Kaye Thomas as Matt
• Notable cast : Christian Tessier as Kullback

A teenage janitor named Johnny falls for a girl named Donna, but a string of bizarre events lead Johnny to believe that his dream girl may be a nightmare.

• Storyteller : Sam
• Notable cast : Fab Filippo as Johnny Angelli

Two brothers move into the same house where a girl died trying to get rid of a demon spirit known as The Quicksilver and discover that history might be repeating itself.

• Storyteller : Kiki
• Guest star : Tatyana Ali as Laura/Connie
• Notable cast : Stuart Stone as Doug Johnston

Sam is described as a mean "rotten" kid who despises his brother Mike. Their mother's birthday is coming up and Mike finds the perfect gift, but Sam winds up stealing the money his brother had saved up buying a video game instead. Mike finds out what his brother did, and having no money to buy the gift points to a clown doll in the shop saying that if Sam does not stop being nasty the "Crimson Clown" would get him. Sam scoffs at his brother's story despite the clown disappearing from the shop when they leave, but he doesn't realize that the "Crimson Clown" may indeed be out to get him just like Mike says.

• Storyteller : Gary
• Notable cast : Michael Barry as Sam

Reed Hanson is a young guy who appears to fear nothing. He applies for a job at The Wild Boar restaurant where he meets a waitress names Nonnie, and the head chef named Dr. Vink who makes a hugely popular dish at the restaurant called "The Dangerous Soup". One evening after hours the two hear screaming coming from a waitress trapped in the freezer. Vink is confronted by Reed and Nonnie where he is forced to reveal the secret ingredient of the soup after releasing the dazed waitress.

• Storyteller : Frank
• Guest stars : Neve Campbell as Nonnie and Aron Tager as Dr. Vink
• Notable cast : Martin Watier as Paul

A boy who enjoys playing pranks goes too far one day and is punished by being trapped in a virtual reality game infected with a living computer virus bent on scrambling the most advanced computer system out there: the human brain.

• Storyteller : Gary

A boy is transported back to the Revolutionary War, where he must help a soldier return to his girlfriend before she marries another man.

• Storyteller : Sam
• Guest star : Will Friedle as Jimmy Armstrong

Two cousins deliver food to an old sea captain who lives in fear of underwater zombies who haunt him the minute he falls asleep.

• Storyteller : Tucker

Part one of two. When a teenager finds a spyglass locked in a treasure chest at Sardo's magic shop, the ghost of an evil pirate is released.

• Storytellers : Gary and Frank
• Guest stars : Charles S. Dutton as Captain Jonas Cutter, Richard Dumont as Sardo, and Aron Tager as Dr. Vink
• Note : This was both Dumont's and Tager's fourth appearance in the series.

Conclusion. Rush must find a way to save Max with the help of Dr. Vink and Sardo.

• Storytellers : Gary and Frank
• Guest stars : Charles S. Dutton as Captain Jonas Cutter, Richard Dumont as Sardo, and Aron Tager as Dr. Vink
• Notes : This was both Dumont's and Tager's fifth appearance in the series. It was also Tager's final appearance as Dr. Vink in the series. This was the only time that Dr. Vink was an ally to the protagonist.

A forgotten book forces two bitter rivals to work together to avoid the clutches of a former librarian's spirit who insists that "silence is golden" -- and traps those who don't follow this rule.

• Storyteller : Kiki

Cousins Anne and Jared bring a scarecrow to life with a magic spell and use it to do their chores at their uncle's farm. At first it goes well, until one of them accidentally orders it to commit murder.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Guest star : Tyler Labine as Mark

A teenage girl stays with her grandfather, who takes in a ghost looking to possess the girl's grandfather so he can find his lost love.

• Storyteller : Sam

A young comic book artist, beset by rejection and lazy parents who don't support his dreams, buys an unfinished copy of a rare comic book -- and accidentally unleashes its villain who turns his victims into drooling, giggling zombies.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann

While celebrating their dad's birthday at the firehouse, Jimmy and Roxanne are left alone when the firemen go on call. They soon find that there is an incendiary ghost who's seeking revenge against firemen.

• Storyteller : Tucker

A deaf girl and her bully get lost in a strange building, which turns out to be an alien planet's intergalactic zoo which houses kids from all over the world as the main exhibit.

• Storyteller : Kiki

Cody, an aspiring young artist, apprentices under an art gallery owner who insists all of her students use her paintbrushes, which may be the reason why a lot of young artists are going missing.

• Storyteller : Gary
• Guest star : Jewel Staite as Cody

A young boy, obsessed with trains and railroads thanks to his deceased conductor father, starts playing with a toy train set that transports him inside -- and takes him on a deadly ride.

• Storyteller : Frank
• Guest star : Gregory Smith as Tim
• Note : This was the last appearance of Frank. In "The Tale of the Dead Man's Float", Gary mentions he moved away.

A boy named Zeke and his friend Clorice reopen an abandoned swimming pool, only to discover what lies there might be best left buried and forgotten.

• Storyteller : Stig
• Guest star : Jay Baruchel as Joe
• Notes : This was Baruchel's first and last appearance in the original series. Introduces Stig to the cast.

Chris, who is fascinated with death and dying, discovers a radio station that guides the recently deceased into the afterlife -- and is mistaken for a dead man by a shrill-voiced DJ named Roy.

• Storyteller : Stig
• Guest stars : Ryan Gosling as Jamie, Gilbert Gottfried as DJ Roy, and Jason Marsden as Edde

Cindy gets a job at a boutique run by a former beauty queen who transforms her customers and employees into dogs so she can harvest their beauty for an occult ritual.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Guest star : Laura Bertram as Laurel

Janice gets bitten by an unusual species of chameleon that has the power to take over someone's life after it bites its victim twice and sprays it with water.

• Storyteller : Betty Ann
• Guest stars : Tia and Tamera Mowry as Janice/The Chameleon

Two stepbrothers help an old prisoner ghost reunite with his daughter after the two accidentally bring the spirit home from a field trip.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Guest star : Christopher Castile as Jason

A family moves into a house by the lake where an ancient jukebox revives the memory of a fallen soldier.

• Storyteller : Sam
• Note : This was the last episode to be directed by David Winning.

A blithe boy name Jonah enlists in a camping expedition with a group of misfits where an ancient legend has awoken in the woods and is out to feast.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Guest star : Michael Greyeyes as The Shaman

Two teenage boys accidentally contact aliens through the sound equipment on one of their father's computer.

• Storyteller : Kiki

Catherine stumbles upon an open-air market run by a woman in a burqa, who will give Catherine everything she wants for a price. As Catherine begins enjoying having the best of everything, she soon discovers that the burqa-clad shopkeep wants more than cash for her services -- and that Catherine's sister may be the next victim.

• Storyteller : Kiki

Sardo sells a magic door to a teenage boy which, once he opens, reveals the future -- and the boy must use the magic to save his crush from a house fire.

• Storyteller : Gary
• Note : This was Dumont's sixth and final appearance as Sardo in the original series.

A night shift hospital volunteer named Amanda soon discovers that a vampire is lurking the halls and feeding off the patients.

• Storyteller : Sam
• Guest star : Emmanuelle Chriqui as Amanda and Jorgito Vargas Jr. as Felix

Spending her summer break at her aunt's retirement home was not Claudia's first choice, but it turns out to be more interesting than she expected when a ghostly boy begins stalking her and a strange symbol appears on the side of a mountain.

• Storyteller : Kiki
• Guest star : Hillary Hawkins as Kate

An insecure girl named Gwen, convinced that she has no special talent in her family, discovers from her Irish grandmother that she has been chosen to carry on the magic her Irish side of the family has had for generations -- and puts her skills to the test when her brother is abducted by an evil leprechaun named Badge.

• Storyteller : Gary

A teen boy finds himself trapped, along with his best friend and his sister, as pawns in a life or death board game.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Villain : Nathaniel and the Burden Beast
• Guest star : Kyle Downes as Nathaniel

Tommy and David suspect that their overly-cheery new neighbors who are into cooking are the reason why the people in town have gone missing.

• Storyteller : Megan
• Villain : None
• Guest star : Kathleen Fee as Dotty
• Notes : This was Kathleen Fee's second appearance in the series overall (Her first was in Season 5, Episode 13 - The Tale of the Night Shift, as Nurse Hantin).

Alex and his friends go to a new arcade owned by a man named Mr. Click, who has a strange way of dealing with anyone who loses at his games.

• Storyteller : Vange
• Villain : Mr. Click
• Guest star : Jay Baruchel as Alex
• Note : This was Baruchel's first appearance in the revived series and second appearance overall.

David, a struggling comic book artist slaving away at his parents' failing Chinese restaurant, takes his grandfather's golden fortune cookies and wishes that his life would be better, which sends him into an alternate reality where David is famous for his comic books and the restaurant is a success. But the wish goes awry when his parents in this alternate reality are too busy with the restaurant's success to care about being a family, his sister (now a punk who lives with her delinquent boyfriend) plots on selling the golden fortune cookies to start a new life away from her family, and a black-clad Chinese warrior is after David.

• Storyteller : Andy
• Villain : The Bad Side
• Guest star : Adam MacDonald as Eddy West

A struggling ice hockey player named Wiley finds a former hockey great's stick and uses it to ace the try-outs, but discovers that the stick has cursed him into becoming a snake.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Villain : Jake "The Snake" Desmond

The late 1990s fad of virtual pets get skewered in this tale of a computer-illiterate girl whose choice in not getting into the latest toy fad (Diggers) becomes the key in stopping them when it is found that the Diggers are aliens who feed on information and brainwash humans.

• Storyteller : Vange
• Villain : The Diggers

After finding a strange necklace and having a nightmare, Diana, a hunter's daughter out to bag a legendary wolf known as "The Blaze", wakes up in the body of a wolf and must learn what life is like to be hunted like an animal.

• Storyteller : Andy
• Villain : The Hunters

A rich kid named Allan befriends a kid named Jimmy after accidentally stealing a computer game called "The Wisdom Glass". When the two play the game at home, they discover an invitation to a party that turns out to be a trial from another dimension over stealing "wisdom".

• Storyteller : Quinn
• Villain : The people in the Cyberworld

Ross gets more than a bad case of stage fright when he lands a part in an adaptation of Macbeth (known as "The Scottish Play" due to the popular theater tradition of not saying the actual name of the play) and discovers that the original actors all died before they could finish it.

• Storyteller : Megan
• Villain : Adrian
• Guest star : Jay Baruchel as Ross Doyle
• Note : This was Baruchel's second appearance in the revived series and third appearance overall.

A boy named Max buys a pencil that can make whatever is drawn turn real and an eraser that banishes whatever is drawn to a dimension called "Oblivion", where all that is forgotten is forced to stay -- including a bloodthirsty Viking warrior who wants out of Oblivion and into the real world.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Villain : Kronos the Conqueror
• Guest star : Richard Dumont as Sardo
• Note : This was Dumont's first appearance as Sardo in the revived series and seventh appearance overall.

Adder, a self-proclaimed teenage vampire hunter, gets more than he bargained for when he travels to the town of Wisteria, where the locals think he is a vampire and start to hunt him.

• Storyteller : Quinn
• Villain : Dreyfus the Vampire and Stanley
• Guest star : Kyle Downes as Adder
• Note : Downes had previously appeared in the episode "The Tale of the Forever Game" as a different character. This was his last appearance in the series.

Shy Meggie is thrilled when she discovers she has a secret admirer, but her excitement turns to fear when she realizes her admirer was her mother's jilted high school lover who died in a metal shop explosion and plans on repeating history if he does not get what he wants.

• Storyteller : Megan
• Villain : Teddy

In search of their missing friend, Gina, Danielle and Kirk venture into a mountain area haunted by a ghost who captures its prey in the darkness.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Villain : The Aumbra
• Guest star : Hayden Christensen as Kirk

Gary, the President of The Midnight Society from the original episodes, is back and needs the help of his brother Tucker and his friends to help track down the members of the First Midnight Society from 1937. Together, they must solve an ancient mystery and prevent an evil force from being unleashed on the world. This episode focuses on Tucker and Gary's search for "The General" and his clue to the puzzle.

• Storyteller : None
• Villain : The evil spirit
• Special guest star : Ross Hull as Gary
• Guest star : Ryan Cooley as Waif Kid

The Midnight Society splits up and goes in search of the original members who each hold a clue to the mystery. This episode focuses on Quinn's search for "The Homecoming Queen" and Megan's search for "The Tycoon".

• Storyteller : None
• Villain : The evil spirit
• Special guest star : Ross Hull as Gary
• Guest star : Ryan Cooley as Waif Kid

The Midnight Society continues to go in search of the original members who each hold a clue to the mystery. The final episode focuses on Vange and Andy's search for "The Riddle Man".

• Storyteller : Gary and Tucker's grandfather, Gene
• Villain : The evil spirit
• Special guest star : Ross Hull as Gary
• Guest star : Ryan Cooley as Waif Kid

Jake gets a new girlfriend named Ellen who is literally out of this world when she gives him a ring that will make him the harbinger of an alien invasion.

• Storyteller : Megan
• Villain : The unborn alien babies
• Guest star : Figure skater Tara Lipinski as Ellen and Aaron Ashmore as Jake

In this loose parody of the Greek story Pygmalion, a teenage girl named Julie breaks up with her boyfriend, Kevin, out of fear that her family will not like him -- and things get strange when a statue in the park suddenly has a mate around the same time that Kevin goes missing.

• Storyteller : Megan
• Villain : The maiden statue
• Guest star : Kathleen Fee as the sculptor Vivian White
• Notes : This was Kathleen Fee's third appearance in the series overall (Her first in Season 5, Episode 13 - The Tale of the Night Shift, as Nurse Hantin. Her second was in Season 6, Episode 6 - The Tale of the Gruesome Gourmets, as Dotty.).

Best friends Craig and Justin buy and renovate a 1969 muscle car (a Pontiac GTO) that belonged to two friends who died when they challenged a truck to a game of chicken on an abandoned highway.

• Storyteller : Quinn
• Villain : None
• Guest stars : Benjamin Plener as Justin and Adam MacDonald as Bulldog
• Notes : This was Plener's second appearance in the series overall (his first in Season 1, Episode 10 - The Tale of Jake and the Leprechaun, as Jake). This was also MacDonald's second appearance in the series overall (his first in Season 6, Episode 5 - The Tale of the Misfortune Cookie, as Eddy West).

In this loose homage to the 1985 comedy horror film, Re-Animator, a girl named Julie (not the same one from "The Tale of the Stone Maiden") works for a plant store owner who just created an elixir that can bring dead plants back to life -- and an accident soon proves that the elixir's powers of re-animation also applies to dead humans.

• Storyteller : Quinn
• Villain : Reanimated zombie

A shy boy named Jason buys a Persian victory box to become a better person -- and ends up with more than he bargained for when a tastelessly-dressed genie named Belle grants his every wish with dire consequences and traps Sardo in the box when he foolishly wishes for more wishes.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Villain : Belle the genie
• Guest stars : Jay Baruchel as Jason and Richard Dumont as Sardo
• Notes : This was Baruchel's third appearance in the revived series and fourth (and final) appearance overall. This was also Dumont's second appearance as Sardo in the revived series and eighth (and final) appearance overall.

Prep school students Chandler and Alex try out for a position with The Lions Society, and the friendship is strained when Chandler is chosen over Alex, since Chandler is a legacy student while Alex has a scholarship. Things get worse when Chandler's initiation calls for him to steal the headmaster's portrait, which contains the photo of Jasper Davis, a former student who fell off the clubhouse roof to escape being bullied and is not going to let death get in the way of revenge.

• Storyteller : Andy
• Villain : Jasper Davis

In this loose homage to Gaston Leroux's The Phantom of the Opera, Tara is a violinist who wishes someone would appreciate her talents, as her boyfriend does not, and gets her wish from a strange mutant figure who lives inside the school.

• Storyteller : Andy
• Villain : None

Athletic, overly-competitive twins Ashley and Kara compete in a strange version of laser tag that turns out to be a plot to kidnap and clone Earth's most competitive kids to fight in a distant planet's war.

• Storyteller : Tucker
• Villain : Drake

A struggling teenage model named Emma finds employment with a stage actress who uses a magic book to steal young women's faces and use them as her own.

• Storyteller : Vange
• Villain : Madame Visage

When Nicki and AJ move into their grandparents' house, they see images of a young girl celebrating her birthday and learn that she was a relative who died when her live-in nurse allegedly injected her with poison, and that the nurse has mistaken AJ for her murder victim.

• Storyteller : Vange
• Villain : The nurse (unintentionally)
• Note : This is the series finale for the revived series.

As the new girl in school, Rachel feels out of place until The Midnight Society invites her to join the group. All she has to do is tell a terrifying story.

• Storyteller : Rachel
• Villain : Mr. Tophat

After a disappearance links to Rachel’s story, The Midnight Society decides to go to the Carnival of Doom.

• Storyteller : None
• Villain : Mr. Tophat

Rachel decides to take charge and end Mr. Tophat's reign of horror.

• Storyteller : None
• Villain : Mr. Tophat