List of Indy Eleven records and statistics

As of May 4, 2019

	Name	Years	Signed from	League	Playoffs	U.S. Open Cup	Total
1	Brad Ring	2014–2018	Portland Timbers	109	2	4	115
2	Don Smart	2014–2017	RVA FC	95	2	4	101
3	Dylan Mares	2014–2016 2018	Indiana Hoosiers Miami FC 2	85	2	5	92
4	Marco Franco	2014 2015–2017	Chicago Fire	82	2	4	88
5	Justin Braun	2016–2018	Sacramento Republic	58	2	4	64
	Nemanja Vuković	2016–2017	Sacramento Republic	59	2	3	64
7	Éamon Zayed	2016–2017	Sabah	59	2	2	63
8	Jon Busch	2016–2017	Chicago Fire	59	2	1	62
9	Colin Falvey	2016–2017	Ottawa Fury FC	52	2	1	55
	Cory Miller	2014–2017	Los Angeles Blues	54	0	1	55

Bold denotes players still playing for the club.

Éamon Zayed scored 27 goals in 63 games during his two years with the club

As of May 4, 2019

	Name	Years	Signed from	League	Playoffs	U.S. Open Cup	Total
1	Éamon Zayed	2016–2017	Sabah	26	0	1	27
2	Justin Braun	2016–2018	Sacramento Republic	18	0	1	19
3	Dylan Mares	2014–2016 2018	Indiana Hoosiers Miami FC 2	12	0	1	13
4	Jack McInerney	2018	LA Galaxy	10	0	0	10
	Don Smart	2014–2017	RVA FC	10	0	0	10
6	Kléberson	2014–2015	Bahia	8	0	0	8
7	Mike Ambersley	2014	Minnesota United	6	0	1	7
	Ben Speas	2017–present	Minnesota United	7	0	0	7
9	Blake Smith	2014	Montreal Impact	2	0	4	6
	Eugene Starikov	2018–present	New York Cosmos	6	0	0	6

Bold denotes players still playing for the club.

As of May 4, 2019

Name	From	To	P	W	D	L	GS	GA	%W	Honors
Juergen Sommer	June 11, 2013	June 2, 2015[1]	38	8	13	17	49	63	021.05
Tim Regan (interim)	June 2, 2015[1]	December 2, 2015[2]	22	7	5	10	26	37	031.82
Tim Hankinson	December 2, 2015[2]	November 28, 2017[3]	69	24	24	21	94	89	034.78	(1) NASL Spring Season
Martin Rennie	January 16, 2018[4]		44	17	12	15	58	54	038.64

• Notes:

P – Total of played matches W – Won matches D – Drawn matches L – Lost matches GS – Goals scored GA – Goals against
%W – Percentage of matches won