List of state applications for an Article V Convention
This is a list of known applications made to the United States Congress by the state legislatures for a national convention to propose amendments to the United States Constitution under Article V of the Constitution which provides in pertinent part:
The Congress, ..., on the Application of the Legislatures of two thirds of the several States, shall call a Convention for proposing Amendments ... which, ..., shall be valid to all Intents and Purposes, as Part of this Constitution, when ratified by the Legislatures of three fourths thereof, or by Conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other Mode of Ratification may be proposed by the Congress.
This article is part of a series on the |
Constitution of the United States |
---|
Preamble and Articles |
Amendments to the Constitution |
Unratified Amendments: |
History |
Full text |
|
A discussion on the history of this process can be found at Convention to propose amendments to the United States Constitution. In particular, theories as to the validity of rescission of applications may also be found there as well as in List of rescissions of Article V Convention applications. All known applications are listed here, noting if and when such an application was known to have been subsequently rescinded.
On January 6, 2015 the United States House of Representatives began the process of cataloging applications submitted to the House by the state legislatures with the adoption of a new provision in the House's parliamentary rules of procedure. Previously, all documents related to Article V Convention applications were administratively processed as memorials and only summarized in the House's portion of the Congressional Record and then referred to the House's Judiciary Committee. The Clerk of the House, on that office's webpage, has since listed some—but not all—applications and rescissions received by Congress' lower chamber since 1960.[1] As this list may so easily be subsequently removed by a mere change in House rules, references to the actual Congressional Record are preferred. In its portion of the Congressional Record, the United States Senate, by contrast, typically publishes the entire verbatim text of a state legislature's application for an Article V Convention rather than to merely summarize the application's content. Once published verbatim in the Record, the Senate refers such memorials to its own Judiciary Committee.
The Congressional Record prior to 1876 is available through the Library of Congress,[2] and online since 1995.[3] In 1990, Judge Bruce Van Sickle and attorney Lynn M. Boughey compiled a list from the Congressional Record of state applications for an Article V Convention in the Hamline Law Review. Photocopies of the relevant sections of the Congressional Record have are available through Friends of the Article V Convention (FOAVC) for the gap in the electronically available Congressional Record.
Van Sickle-Boughey classification
In "A Lawful and Peaceful Revolution",[4] Van Sickle and Boughey define five classifications of applications:
- Class I: A call for a general convention, with no motivating issue listed
- Class II: A call for a general convention, with a separate statement of proposed amendment or explicit statement that the convention may consider other amendments proposed by states
- Class III: A call for a general convention tied to a proposed amendment
- Class IV: A call for a convention, with language aimed to limit the convention to the issue presented
- Class V: A call for a convention, with language to rescind the application from consideration for a convention if any other topic is to be covered
The following is added to this list, where the original text was not recorded in the Congressional Record:
- Class ??: A note of an application without the actual text
Van Sickle and Boughey indicate which applications have been rescinded by their state by encasing these in parentheses, and make no note of which applications have led to amendments proposed by Congress.
In the table below, the classification of rescinded applications are stricken, with the year of rescission given in parentheses and a link to the record of the rescission. Those applications which lead to amendments proposed by Congress are listed in parentheses.
List of state applications for an Article V convention
Although all columns are sortable, applications are initially arranged by date approved by the state legislature or by date of entry into the Congressional Record. Application classes are encased in parentheses if Congress presented an amendment on the topic given and stricken if the state legislature has subsequently rescinded its application. All descriptions with six or more states have identical amendment text, unless specified. As of October 2020, only the Hawaii State Legislature has never approved an Article V convention application through both its upper chamber and its lower chamber during the same legislative session.
State | Issue/Subject | Date of State's Approval | Receipt by Congress | Class (or Year of Rescission) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Virginia | Bill of Rights | November 14, 1788 | AC V.1 258-259 | |
New York | Bill of Rights | February 5, 1789 | AC V.1 282Text | (II) |
Georgia | Clarify Amendment X | December 12, 1832 | J HR V22.2 270-271 | |
South Carolina | Clarify Amendment X | December 19, 1832 | J HR V22.2 219-220 | |
Alabama | Limitation on Tariffs | January 12, 1833 | J HR V22.2 361-362 | II |
Indiana | General and Unlimited Article V Convention | March 13, 1861? | CG V.37.S 1465-6 | I |
Ohio | General and Unlimited Article V Convention | March 20, 1861 | 1861 Ohio Laws 181 | I |
New Jersey | Final Resolution for Slavery | February 1, 1861 | CG V. 36.2 p. 681 | (II) |
Kentucky | Final Resolution for Slavery | February 5, 1861 | CG V.36.2 p. 773 | (II) |
Illinois | Final Resolution for Slavery | February 28, 1861 | CG V.36.2 p. 1270 | (??) |
Nebraska | Direct Election of Senators, Other | April 14, 1893 | 1893 Neb. Laws 466-7 | III |
Texas | General and Unlimited Article V Convention | June 5, 1899? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 33, p. 219 ("Concurrent resolution, S.C.R. No. 4") | I |
Minnesota | Direct Election of Senators, Other | February 13, 1901? | CR V.34 p.2561 | (III) |
Pennsylvania | Direct Election of Senators, II | February 13, 1901? | CR V.45 p.7118 | (III) |
Idaho | Direct Election of President, Vice-President and Senators | February 14, 1901? | CR V.45 p.7114 | |
Montana | Direct Election of Senators, II Direct Election of Senators, II |
February 21, 1901? January 31, 1905? |
CR V.35 p.208 CR V.39 p.2447 |
|
Oregon | Direct Election of Senators, Other Direct Election of Senators, I Direct Election of Senators, Other |
February 23, 1901? March 10, 1903? January 26, 1909? |
CR V.35 p.117 CR V.45 p.7118 CR V.43 p.2025 |
|
Tennessee | Direct Election of Senators, II Direct Election of Senators, Other |
March 27, 1901? March 14, 1905? |
CR V.35 p.2344 CR V.45 p.7119 |
|
Colorado | Direct Election of Senators, I | April 1, 1901? | CR V.45 p.7113 | (II) |
Michigan | Direct Election of Senators, Other | April 9, 1901? | CR V.35 p.117 | (III) |
Texas | Direct Election of Senators, I | April 17, 1901? | CR V.45 p.7119 | (II) |
Arkansas | Direct Election of Senators, Other | April 25, 1901? | CR V.45 p.7113 | (III) |
Kentucky | Direct Election of Senators, II | February 10, 1902? | CR V.45 p.7115 | (III) |
Illinois | Direct Election of Senators, I Direct Election of Senators, Other |
February 10, 1903? May 23, 1907? |
CR V.45 p.7114 CR V.42 p.164 |
(III) | (II)
Nevada | Direct Election of Senators, II | February 25, 1903? | CR V.37 p.24 | (III) |
Utah | Direct Election of Senators, I | March 12, 1903? | CR V.45 p.7119 | |
Washington | Direct Election of Senators, Other | March 12, 1903? | CR V.45 p.7119 | (II) |
Nebraska | Direct Election of Senators, I | March 25, 1903? | CR V.45 p.7116-7 | (III) |
Iowa | Direct Election of Senators, I | March 24, 1904? | CR V.38 p.4959 | (III) |
Missouri | Direct Election of Senators, II | March 18, 1905? | CR V.40 p.1905 | (III) |
South Dakota | Direct Election of Senators, Other Direct Election of Senators, I |
February 2, 1907? February 9, 1909? |
CR V.41 p.1907 CR V.43 p.2667-2668 |
(III) | (III)
Delaware | Anti-Polygamy | February 11, 1907? | CR V.41 p.3011 | |
Missouri | General and Unlimited Article V Convention | March 6, 1907? | CR V.45 p.7116 | I |
Indiana | Direct Election of Senators, Other | March 11, 1907? | CR V.45 p.7114 | (II) |
Iowa | Direct Election of Senators, Other | March 12, 1907? | CR V.45 p.7114-5 | (II) |
Nevada | Direct Election of Senators, I | March 23, 1907? | CR V.42 p.163 | (II) |
New Jersey | Direct Election of Senators, I | May 28, 1907? | CR V.42 p.164 | (III) |
Louisiana | Direct Election of Senators, Other | November 25, 1907? | CR V.42 p.5906 | |
Oklahoma | Direct Election of Senators, Other | January 20, 1908? | CR V.45 p.7117-8 | |
South Dakota | Anti-Polygamy | February 6, 1909? | CR V.43 p.2670 | III |
Kansas | Direct Election of Senators, I | March 6, 1909? | CR V.45 p.7115 | (II) |
Wisconsin | Direct Election of Senators, I | May 31, 1910? | CR V.45 p.7119-20 | (III) |
Washington | Anti-Polygamy | September 1, 1910? | CR V.46 p.651 | III |
Montana | Direct Election of Senators, Other | January 20, 1911? | CR V.46 p.2411 | |
Maine | Direct Election of Senators, Other | February 22, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 46, p. 4280 ("Joint resolution") | (III) |
Tennessee | Anti-Polygamy | February 17, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 47, p. 187 ("Senate joint resolution 43") | |
Montana | Anti-Polygamy | March 1, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 47, pp. 98-99 ("House joint memorial 7") remainder of text p. 99 | |
Nebraska | Anti-Polygamy | March 14, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 47, p. 99 ("Joint resolution by House and Senate of Nebraska Legislature") | III |
Ohio | Anti-Polygamy | March 15, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 47, pp. 660-661 ("House joint resolution 13") remainder of text p. 661 | III |
Illinois | Prevent and Suppress Monopolies | May 11, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 47, p. 1298 ("House joint resolution 9") | III |
Wisconsin | General and Unlimited Article V Convention | June 12, 1911? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 47, p. 1873 ("Joint resolution (J. Res. 15, S.)") | I |
California | Direct Election of Senators, I | June 13, 1911? | CR V.47 p.2000 | (??) |
Vermont | Anti-Polygamy | December 18, 1912? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 49, p. 1433 ("Joint resolution") | III |
Illinois | Anti-Polygamy | March 12, 1913? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 50, pp. 120-121 (Senate joint resolution 12") remainder of text p. 121 | III |
Oregon | Anti-Polygamy | January 20, 1913? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 49, p. 2463 ("Senate joint resolution 2") | |
Wisconsin | Anti-Polygamy | March 26, 1913? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 50, pp. 42-43 (No number, or resolution type, is given for this resolution) remainder of text p. 43 See, also, Cong. Rec. Vol. 50, p. 116 | III |
Missouri | Supreme Court Jurisdiction | April 15, 1913? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 50, p. 2428 ("House joint and concurrent resolution 23") | III |
Michigan | Anti-Polygamy | July 2, 1913? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 50, p. 2290 ("House resolution No. 120") | III |
South Carolina | Anti-Polygamy | February 15, 1915? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 53, p. 2442 ("Concurrent resolution") | |
Louisiana | Mode of Amendment, Other | January 12, 1920? | CR V.60 p.31 | |
Nevada | Anti-Prohibition | December 7, 1925? | CR V.67 p.458 | (??) |
Wisconsin | Direct Election of President and VP | December 7, 1925? | CR V.67 p.458 | (??) |
Wisconsin | General and Unlimited Article V Convention | June 10, 1929 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 71, p. 2590 ("Senate Joint Resolution 65") | (??) |
Wisconsin | Article V Requirements Already Met for Convention Call | September 4, 1929? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 71, p. 3369 ("Senate Joint Resolution 83") | (??) |
Wisconsin | Article V Requirements Already Met for Convention Call | September 23, 1929? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 71, p. 3856 ("Joint Resolution No. 83, S.") | (??) |
Massachusetts | Anti-Prohibition | March 13, 1931? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 75, p. 45 ("Resolutions") | (III) |
New York | Anti-Prohibition | December 8, 1931? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 75, p. 48 ("Assembly 4") | (IV) |
Wisconsin | Anti-Prohibition | December 8, 1931? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 75, p. 57 ("Joint resolution") | (III) |
New Jersey | Anti-Prohibition | February 1, 1932? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 75, p. 3299 ("Joint Resolution 1") | (III) |
California | Tax on Government Securities | July 9, 1935? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 79, p. 10814 ("Senate joint resolution") | III |
California | Federal Labor Laws | July 9, 1935? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 79, p. 10814 ("Senate Joint Resolution 23") | III |
Oregon | General Welfare Act of 1937 ("Townsend National Recovery Plan") | February 1, 1939? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 84, p. 985 ("House Joint Memorial 1") | |
Wyoming | Income Tax, Limit II | March 8, 1939? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 84, pp. 2509-2510 ("House Joint Memorial 4") remainder of text p. 2510 | |
Maryland | Income Tax, Limit II | March 27, 1939? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 84, p. 3320 ("House resolution") appearing to have been approved only by the Maryland House of Delegates—and NOT at all by the Maryland Senate | III |
Rhode Island | Income Tax, Limit I | March 26, 1940? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 86, p. 3407 ("Resolution") | III |
Iowa | Income Tax, Limit II | April 18, 1941? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 87, p. 3172 ("House Concurrent Resolution 15") | III |
Maine | Income Tax, Limit I | April 17, 1941? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 87, pp. 3370-3371 ("Resolution") remainder of text p. 3371 | |
Massachusetts | Income Tax, Limit I | April 29, 1941? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 87, pp. 3812-3813 ("Resolutions") remainder of text p. 3813 | |
Michigan | Income Tax, Limit I | May 16, 1941? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 87, p. 4537 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution 20") | III |
Iowa | Presidential Term Limits | March 26, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, p. 2516 ("House Concurrent Resolution 26") | (III) |
Illinois | Presidential Term Limits | March 26, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, pp. 2516-2517 ("Senate Joint Resolution 8") remainder of text p. 2517 | (III) |
Michigan | Presidential Term Limits | April 6, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, p. 2944 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution 24") | (III) |
New Hampshire | Income Tax, II | April 29, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, pp. 3761-3762 ("A concurrent resolution") remainder of text p. 3762 | |
Delaware | Income Tax, Limit I | May 3, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, p. 4017 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution 6") | |
Illinois | Income Tax, Limit II | May 26, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, pp. 742-743 (HJR 32) remainder of text p. 743 | |
Pennsylvania | Limited Funding Mandates, Various | May 27, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, p. 8220 ("Joint resolution") | III |
Pennsylvania | Income Tax, Limit II | May 27, 1943? | CR V.89 pp.8220-8221 ("[House Concurrent resolution [No. 50]"] | III |
Alabama | Income Tax, Limit I | July 8, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, pp. 7523-7524 ("House Joint Resolution 66") remainder of text p. 7524 | III |
Wisconsin | Income Tax, Limit I | September 14, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, p. 7524 ("Assembly Joint Resolution 55") | III |
Wisconsin | Presidential Term Limits | September 14, 1943? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 89, p. 7525 ("Joint Resolution No. 38, A") | (III) |
Kentucky | Income Tax, Limit I | March 20, 1944? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 90, pp. 4040-4041 ("House Resolution 79") remainder of text p. 4041 | |
New Jersey | Income Tax, Limit I | February 25, 1944? | CR V.90 p.6141 | |
California | World Federation | April 14, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, pp. 4568-4569 ("Assembly Joint Resolution 26") remainder of text p. 4569 | IV |
New Jersey | World Federation | April 14, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, p. 4571 ("Assembly Concurrent Resolution 17") | IV |
North Carolina | World Federation | April 20, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, pp. 6587-6588 ("Resolution 37") remainder of text p. 6588 | IV |
Michigan | Revenue Sharing, II | May 5, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, pp. 5628-5629 (HCR 26) remainder of text p. 5629 | IV |
Florida | World Federation | May 16, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, p. 7000 ("Senate Memorial 282") | |
Nebraska | Revenue Sharing, II | May 25, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, pp. 7893-7894 ("Legislative Resolution 32") remainder of text p. 7894 | |
Connecticut | World Federation | June 1, 1949? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 95, p. 7689 ("Joint Resolution") | IV |
Kansas | Income Tax, Limit I | March 28, 1951? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 97, p. 2936 (SCR 4) | III |
Iowa | Revenue Sharing, II | April 17, 1951? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 97, pp. 3939-3940 (SCR 11) remainder of text p. 3940 | IV |
Florida | Income Tax, Limit I | May 10, 1951? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 97, pp. 5155-5156 (SCR 206) remainder of text p. 5156 | |
Maine | Revenue Sharing, II | June 4, 1951? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 97, pp. 6033-6034 ("Joint Resolution") remainder of text p. 6034 | IV |
New Hampshire | Revenue Sharing, II | August 28, 1951? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 97, pp. 10716-10717 ("Concurrent Resolution") remainder of text p. 10717 | |
Arkansas | Income Tax, Limit II | February 4, 1952? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, p. 742 (SCR 10) | III |
Utah | Income Tax, Limit I | February 11, 1952? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, p. 947 ("Joint Resolution") | |
New Mexico | Revenue Sharing, II | February 11, 1952? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, pp. 947-948 (HJR 12) p. 948 | IV |
Georgia | Limited Treaty Powers, Various | January 29, 1952? | CR V.98 p.1057 | |
Georgia | Income Tax, Limit I | February 6, 1952? | CR V.98 p.1057 | |
Indiana | Income Tax, Limit II Income Tax, Limit II |
February 18, 1952? March 12, 1957? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, pp. 1056-1057 (HCR 10) remainder of text p. 1057 Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, pp. 6474-6475 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution 8") remainder of text p. 6475 |
III III |
Virginia | Income Tax, Limit I | February 21, 1952? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, p. 1496 (HJR 32) | |
California | Motor Vehicle Tax Distribution | April 16, 1952? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 98, pp. 4003-4004 (AJR 8) remainder of text p. 4004 | III |
Louisiana | Income Tax, Limit I | January 13, 1953? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 99, p. 320 ("Concurrent resolution") remainder of text p. 321 | |
South Dakota | Mode of Amendment, Other Mode of Amendment, by 12 States Mode of Amendment, Identical Text |
March 5, 1953? February 15, 1955? March 2, 1963? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 99, pp. 9180-9181 (SJR 4) remainder of text p. 9181 Cong. Rec. Vol. 101, pp. 2861-2862 (SJR 5) remainder of text p. 2862 Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 14638-14639 (SJR 1) remainder of text p. 14639 |
|
Illinois | Mode of Amendment, Other Mode of Amendment, Identical Text |
June 25, 1953? March 5, 1963? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 99, p. 9864 (HJR 37) Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 3788 (SJR 4) |
III | IV
Georgia | School Management, States' Right School Management, States' Right School Management, States' Right |
January 31, 1955? February 5, 1959? March 4, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 101, p. 1532 ("Resolution") Cong. Rec. Vol. 105, p. 1834 (HR 99) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 5817 (HR 128-212) |
|
Texas | Mode of Amendment, by 12 States Mode of Amendment, Identical Text |
March 14, 1955? April 4, 1963? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 101, pp. 2770-2771 (SCR 15) remainder of text p. 2771 Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 11852 (HCR 21) |
III | IV
Oklahoma | Income Tax, Limit Other | May 23, 1955? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 101, pp. 8397-8398 (SJR 15) remainder of text p. 8398 (referred to the Committee on Finance rather than to the Committee on the Judiciary) | |
Michigan | Mode of Amendment, by 12 States | April 4, 1956? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 102, pp. 7240-7241 (HCR 8) remainder of text p. 7241 | IV |
Idaho | Mode of Amendment, by 12 States | April 1, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103 pp. 4831-4832 (HCR 6) remainder of text p. 4832 | |
Indiana | Mode of Amendment, by 12 States | March 12, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, pp. 6471-6472 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution 2") remainder of text p. 6472 | IV |
Indiana | Limited Treaty Powers, Various | March 12, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, pp. 6472-6473 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution 4") remainder of text p. 6473 | III |
Indiana | Proportional Electoral College, Other | March 12, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, pp. 6473-6474 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution 7") remainder of text p. 6474 | III |
Indiana | Repeal of Constitution's 16th Amendment | March 12, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, pp. 6474-6475 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution 8") remainder of text p. 6475 | III |
Indiana | Balanced Budget, Other Balanced Budget, Other |
March 12, 1957? January 26, 1976? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, pp. 6475-6476 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution 9") remainder of text p. 6476 Cong. Rec. Vol. 122, p. 931 ("Concurrent Resolution") |
III III |
Florida | Supreme Court Review, Other | June 5, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, p. 12787 (SCR 116) | |
Alabama | Judicial Term Limits | June 25, 1957? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 103, p. 10863 (SJR 47) | III |
Connecticut | Prohibit Interstate Income Tax | May 6, 1958? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 104, pp. 8085-8086 (SJR 9) remainder of text p. 8086 | III |
Alabama | Limited Federal Preemption | January 1, 1959? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 105, p. 3083 (SJR 2) | III |
Wyoming | Limit Federal Powers | February 26, 1959? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 105, pp. 3085-3086 ("Enrolled Joint Resolution 2") remainder of text p. 3086 | |
Arkansas | Validity of 14th Amendment | March 18, 1959? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 105, p. 4398 (HCR 24) | III |
Nevada | Limit Federal Powers | March 11, 1960? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 106, p. 10749 (SJR 7) | III |
Louisiana | Limit Federal Powers | June 11, 1960? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 106, p. 14401 (HCR 22) | |
Arkansas | Supreme Court Review, Other | February 2, 1961? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 107, p. 2154 (HCR 14) | III |
Wyoming | Balanced Budget, Other Balanced Budget, Emergency |
February 21, 1961? February 8, 1979? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 107, p. 2759 ("Enrolled Joint Resolution 4") CR V.125 p.2116 |
|
Georgia | Supreme Court Review, Other | March 9, 1961? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 107, p. 4715 (SR 39) | |
South Carolina | Limit Federal Powers | March 11, 1962? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 108, p. 5051 ("Concurrent Resolution") | |
Oklahoma | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | January 21, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 1172 ("Enrolled Senate Concurrent Resolution 2") | |
Oklahoma | Apportionment of Legislature, I | January 21, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 1172-1173 ("Enrolled Senate Concurrent Resolution 3") remainder of text p. 1173 | |
Kansas | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | January 31, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2769 (SCR 3) | |
Kansas | Apportionment of Legislature, I | January 31, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2769 (SCR 4) | |
Florida | Supreme Court Review, Court of the Union | February 5, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 2071-2072 ("Senate Memorial 12-X(63)" remainder of text p. 2072 | |
Florida | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | February 5, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2072 ("Senate Memorial 13-X(63)" | |
Idaho | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
February 14, 1963? January 26, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2281 (SJM 4) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 1229 (SJM 1) |
|
Arkansas | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | February 21, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2768 (HJR 2) | III |
Arkansas | Supreme Court Review, Court of the Union | February 21, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 2768-2769 (HJR 3) remainder of text p. 2769 | III |
Arkansas | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
February 21, 1963? April 5, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2769 (HJR 4) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 6917-6918 (SJR 1) remainder of text p. 6918 |
III III |
Arkansas | Proportional Electoral College, Other | February 21, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 2769 (HJR 12) | III |
South Dakota | Proportional Electoral College, Other | March 11, 1963? | CR V.109 p.3982 | ?? |
Montana | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
March 11, 1963? February 17, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 3854 (SJR 15) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 2777 ("A Joint Resolution") |
|
Idaho | Balanced Budget, Other | March 11, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 3855 ("SJM 9") | |
Montana | Proportional Electoral College, I | March 25, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 4469 ("HJR 13") | |
Wyoming | Supreme Court Review, Court of the Union | February 14, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109 pp. 4778-4779 ("Enrolled Joint Resolution 2") remainder of text p. 4779 | |
Wyoming | Apportionment of Legislature, I | February 9, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 4779 ("Enrolled Joint Memorial 14") | |
Wyoming | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | February 15, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 4779 ("Enrolled Joint Memorial 15") | |
Alabama | Supreme Court Review, Court of the Union | March 13, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 5250 (HJR 13) | III |
Washington | Apportionment of Legislature, I | March 30, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 5867 (HJM 1) | III |
Missouri | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
April 8, 1963? February 22, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 5868 (HCR 4) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 3304 (HCR 2) |
III III |
Missouri | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | April 8, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 5868 (HCR 5) | III |
Utah | Proportional Electoral College, I | April 8, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 5947 (HCR 1) | |
Colorado | Proportional Electoral College, I | April 11, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 6659 (HJM 4) | III |
Colorado | Income Tax, Limit Other | April 25, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 7060 (SJM 9) | III |
Nevada | Apportionment of Legislature, I | February 12, 1963? February 17, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 9942 (SJR 2) | III |
South Carolina | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
June 10, 1963? February 18, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 10441 ("House Concurrent Resolution") Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 3304 ("Concurrent Resolution") |
|
South Carolina | Apportionment of Legislature, I | June 10, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 10442 (SCR 149) | |
South Carolina | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | June 10, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 10441 ("House Concurrent Resolution") | |
South Carolina | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | June 10, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 10442 (SCR 148) | |
South Carolina | Supreme Court Review, Court of the Union | June 10, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 10441-10442 ("House Concurrent Resolution") remainder of text p. 10442 | |
South Carolina | Supreme Court Review, Court of the Union | June 10, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 10442-10443 (SCR 147) remainder of text p. 10443 | |
Texas | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
April 4, 1963? July 26, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 11852 (HCR 22) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 18171 (SCR 24) |
III III |
Texas | Proportional Electoral College, I | May 22, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, pp. 11852-11853 (HCR 29) remainder of text p. 11853 | III |
South Dakota | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
March 2, 1963? March 1, 1965? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 14639 (SJR 2) Cong. Rec. Vol.111, pp.3722-3723 ("Joint resolution") remainder of text p. 3723 |
|
Wisconsin | Proportional Electoral College, I | March 2, 1963? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 109, p. 14808 (Resolution Number Not Provided) | III |
Virginia | Apportionment of Legislature, I Apportionment of Legislature, II |
March 15, 1964? December 3, 1964? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 110, p. 5659 (HJR 90) Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 880-881 (HJR 6) remainder of text p. 881 |
|
Massachusetts | School Management, Other | March 18, 1964? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 110, p. 7616 (Unnumbered resolution) appearing to have been approved only by the Massachusetts House of Representatives—and NOT at all by the Massachusetts Senate | III |
Massachusetts | Senior Pensions | April 23, 1964? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 110, p. 9875 (Unnumbered resolution) | III |
Virginia | Mode of Amendment, Identical Text | December 3, 1964? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 880 (HJR 5) | |
Louisiana | School Management, States' Right | January 6, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 164-165 (SCR 3) remainder of text p. 165 | |
Arizona | Apportionment of Legislature, II | February 18, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 3061 (HCM 1) | |
Kansas | Apportionment of Legislature, II | January 27, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 3061-3062 (SCR 1) remainder of text p. 3062 | |
South Carolina | School Management, States' Right | February 18, 1965? | CR V.111 p.3304 | |
Utah | Apportionment of Legislature, II | March 8, 1965? | CR V.111 p.4320 | |
Maryland | Apportionment of Legislature, II | March 25, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 5820 (SJR 1) | III |
North Carolina | Apportionment of Legislature, II | May 17, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 10673 ("Resolution 60") | |
Minnesota | Apportionment of Legislature, II | May 17, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 10673 ("Resolution 5") | III |
Oklahoma | Proportional Electoral College, I | May 12, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 11488 (SCR 35) also found at Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 11802-11803 ("Enrolled Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 35") remainder of text p. 11803 | |
Louisiana | Apportionment of Legislature, II | June 1, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 12110 (SCR 25) | |
New Hampshire | Apportionment of Legislature, II | June 8, 1965? | CR V.111 p.12853 | |
Illinois | Revenue Sharing, Other | June 9, 1965? | CR V.111 p.14144 | III |
Florida | Apportionment of Legislature, II | June 22, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 14308 (HM 2433) | |
Mississippi | Apportionment of Legislature, II | July 7, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 15769 ("S. Con. Res. 101") | III |
Mississippi | School Management, States' Right | July 7, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 15769-15770 ("S. Con. Res. 102") remainder of text p. 15770 | III |
Mississippi | Anti-Subversion | July 7, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 15770 ("H. Con. Res. 14") | III |
Illinois | Apportionment of Legislature, II Apportionment of Legislature, Other |
June 22, 1965 March 13, 1967 |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 19379 ("Senate Resolution No. 52" and unicameral--not likewise approved by Illinois House of Representatives) Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 8004 (HJR 32) |
III |
Nebraska | Proportional Electoral College, I | August 10, 1965? | CR V.111 p.19775 | III |
Nebraska | Apportionment of Legislature, I | September 22, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 24723 ("Legislative Resolution") | III |
Ohio | Revenue Sharing, Other | September 28, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, p. 25237 (SJR 16) | III |
Kentucky | Apportionment of Legislature, II | October 6, 1965? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 111, pp. 26073-26074 ("Senate" Concurrent "Resolution 8") remainder of text p. 26074 | III |
Alabama | Apportionment of Legislature, II | January 14, 1966? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 112, pp. 200-201 (SJR 3) remainder of text p. 201 | III |
New Mexico | Apportionment of Legislature, II | January 14, 1966? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 112, p. 199 (SJR 2) | III |
Tennessee | Apportionment of Legislature, II | January 14, 1966? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 112, p. 199-200 (HJR 34) remainder of text p. 200 | |
Illinois | Apportionment of Legislature, Other | March 13, 1967 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 8004 (HJR 32) | III |
Indiana | Apportionment of Legislature, II | March 13, 1967? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 6384 ("House Enrolled Concurrent Resolution No. 58") | III |
Alabama | Revenue Sharing, Other | April 19, 1967? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, pp. 10117-10118 ("Resolution No. 11") remainder of text p. 10118 | III |
North Dakota | Apportionment of Legislature, Other | April 28, 1967? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 11175 (HCR I-1) | |
Georgia | Revenue Sharing, Other | May 4, 1967? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, pp. 11743-11744 ("Resolution 96") remainder of text p. 11744 | |
Texas | Revenue Sharing, Other | June 28, 1967? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 17634 (SCR 12) | III |
Illinois | Revenue Sharing, Other | June 28, 1967? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 17634-17635 (SJR 63) remainder of text p. 17635 | |
Iowa | Apportionment of Legislature, Other | May 13, 1969? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 115, p. 12249 (SCR 13) | III |
Florida | Revenue Sharing, Other | September 3, 1969? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 115, p. 24116 (SM 397) | |
New Hampshire | Revenue Sharing, I | December 1, 1969? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 115, p. 36153-36154 ("Concurrent resolution..." remainder of text p. 36154 | |
Mississippi | School Management, Other School Management, No Assignment |
March 5, 1970? March 15, 1973? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 113, p. 6097 (SCR 514) Cong. Rec. Vol. 119, p. 8089 (HCR 55) |
III IV |
Louisiana | Anti-Subversion | June 22, 1970? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 116, pp. 20672-20673 (HCR 4-A) remainder of text p. 20673 | |
Louisiana | Income Tax, Limit Other | July 7, 1970? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 116, p. 22906 (SCR 25) | |
Louisiana | Revenue Sharing, Other | July 10, 1970? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 116, p. 23765 (HCR 270) | |
New Jersey | Revenue Sharing, I | December 16, 1970? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 116, p. 41879 (SCR 77) | IV |
West Virginia | Revenue Sharing, I | January 26, 1971? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, pp. 541-542 (HCR 9) remainder of text p. 542 | IV |
Massachusetts | Revenue Sharing, I | March 4, 1971? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, p. 5020 (Unnumbered resolution) | IV |
South Dakota | Revenue Sharing, I | March 8, 1971? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, p. 5303 (HJR 503) | IV |
North Dakota | Revenue Sharing, I | April 26, 1971? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, p. 11841 (SCR 4013) | |
Louisiana | Revenue Sharing, I | June 15, 1971? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, pp. 19801-19802 (SCR 138) remainder of text p. 19802 | |
Ohio | Revenue Sharing, I | June 28, 1971? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, p. 22280 ("Joint Resolution") | IV |
Delaware | Revenue Sharing, I | February 18, 1971? | CR V.117 p.3175 | |
Oregon | Revenue Sharing, I | May 24, 1971? | CR V.117 p.16574 | ?? |
Massachusetts | School Management, Other School Management, Other |
September 8, 1971? March 28, 1973? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 117, p. 30905 (Unnumbered resolution) CR Vol. 119, pp. 12408-12409 (Unnumbered resolution) remainder of text p. 12409 |
IV IV |
Michigan | School Management, No Assignment | November 16, 1971? | CR V.117 pp.41598-41599 (SCR 172) Printed in "Extensions of Remarks" portion of Congressional Record remainder of text p. 41599 | IV |
Iowa | Revenue Sharing, I | March 2, 1972? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 118, pp. 6501-6502 (HJR 1) remainder of text p. 6502 | IV |
Florida | Senate Control of Presiding Officer | April 4, 1972? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 118, p. 11444 (SM 227) | |
Arizona | School Management, Prayer | April 4, 1972? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 118, p. 11445 (HCR 2009) | |
Tennessee | School management, No Assignment | May 8, 1972? | CR V.118 p.16214 | |
New York | School Management, Other | October 2, 1972? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 118, pp. 33047-33048 ("Joint Resolution No. 7) remainder of text p. 33048 | IV |
Virginia | Balanced Federal Budget | March 15, 1973? March 10, 1975? March 29, 1976? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 119, p. 8091 (HJR 75) CR Vol. 121, p. 5793 (SJR 107) CR Vol. 122, pp. 8335-8336 (SJR 36) remainder of text p. 8336 |
|
Mississippi | Prayer in Public Buildings | March 20, 1973? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 119, p. 8689 (HCR 14) | IV |
Virginia | School management, No Assignment | April 3, 1973? | CR V.119 p.10675 | |
New Jersey | School Management, Other | April 9, 1973? | CR V.119 p.11446 | ?? |
Texas | School Management, No Assignment | April 10, 1973? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 119, p. 11515 ("House Concurrent Resolution") | IV |
Oklahoma | School Management, No Assignment | April 25, 1973? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 119, p. 14428 (HCR 1026) | |
Maryland | School Management, Other | May 7, 1973? | CR V.119 p.14421 | ?? |
Nevada | School Management, No Assignment | May 29, 1973? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 119, pp. 17022-17023 (SJR 7) remainder of text p. 17023 | IV |
New Hampshire | School Management, Other | June 5, 1973? | CR V.119 p.18190 | |
Arkansas | Balanced Federal Budget | March 10, 1975? March 8, 1979? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, p. 5793 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution") CR Vol. 125, p. 4372, POM-78 (HJR 1) |
III IV |
Mississippi | Balanced Federal Budget | April 29, 1975? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, pp. 12175-12176 (HCR 51) remainder of text p. 12176 | III |
Missouri | Right to Life, Various | May 5, 1975? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, p. 12867 (SCR 7) | III |
Nevada | Limited Funding Mandates, Various | June 26, 1975? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, p. 21065 (AJR 47) | III |
Louisiana | Balanced Federal Budget | July 28, 1975? February 8, 1979? July 19, 1979? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, p. 25312 (SCR 109) CR V.125 p.2110-1 Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, pp. 19470-19471, POM-394 (SCR 4) remainder of text p. 19471 |
|
Kentucky | School Management, No Assignment | September 8, 1975? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, p. 27821 ("House" Joint "Resolution No. 29") | III |
Alabama | Balanced Federal Budget | September 10, 1975? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 121, p. 28347 (HJR 105) | |
Georgia | Balanced Federal Budget | February 6, 1976? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 122, p. 2740 (HR 469-1267) | |
Delaware | Balanced Federal Budget | February 25, 1976? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 122, p. 4329 (HCR 36) | |
South Carolina | Balanced Federal Budget | February 25, 1976? February 8, 1979? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 122, p. 4329 (Numerically Undesignated Resolution) CR V.125 p.2114 |
|
Massachusetts | School Management, No Assignment | April 7, 1976? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 122, p. 9735, (Unnumbered resolution) | III |
Oklahoma | Limited Funding Mandates, Various | June 7, 1976? | CR V.122 p.16814 | III |
Louisiana | Right to Life, Various | July 22, 1976? | CR V.122 p.23550 | |
Maryland | Balanced Federal Budget | January 28, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, pp. 2545-2546, POM-59 (SJR 4) remainder of text p. 2546 | IV |
Virginia | Line Item Veto, Various | March 28, 1977? | CR V.123 p.9289 (1977 House Joint Resolution No. 168) | |
New Jersey | Right to Life, Various | April 5, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, p. 10481, POM-124 ("Senate No. 1271") | IV |
South Dakota | Right to Life, Unborn Right to Life, Sacred Life |
April 18, 1977? April 18, 1980? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, p. 11048, POM-135 (HJR 503) | |
Utah | Right to Life, Various | May 2, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, pp. 13057-13058, POM-151 (HJR 28) remainder of text p.13058 | |
Arkansas | Right to Life, Various | May 20, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, pp. 15808-15809, POM-189 (HJR 2) remainder of text p. 15809 | IV |
Rhode Island | Right to Life, Various | May 20, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, p. 15809, POM-190 ("Resolution") | IV |
Texas | Balanced Federal Budget | May 30, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, pp. 5223-5224, POM-95 (HCR 31) remainder of text p. 5224 | IV |
Arizona | Balanced Federal Budget | June 14, 1977? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 123, pp. 18873-18874, POM-231 (HCM 2003) remainder of text p. 18874 | |
Massachusetts | Right to Life, Various | June 23, 1977? | CR V.123 p.20659 | ?? |
Indiana | Right to Life, Various | July 22, 1977? | CR V.123 p.4797 | ?? |
Colorado | Balanced Federal Budget | April 5, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 8778, POM-579 (Senate Joint Memorial No. 1) | V |
Nebraska | Right to Life, Various | April 21, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 12694, POM-637 (Legislative Resolution No. 152) | IV |
Tennessee | Judicial Term Limits | April 25, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 11437, POM-612 (HJR 21) | |
Tennessee | Balanced Federal Budget | April 25, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, pp. 11437-11438, POM-613 (HJR 22) remainder of text p. 11438 | |
Pennsylvania | Right to Life, Various | April 25, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 11438, POM-614 (House Bill No. 71--described as a "Joint Resolution") | IV |
Oklahoma | Balanced Federal Budget | May 3, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 12397 (POM-629) (HJR 1049) | |
Kansas | Balanced Federal Budget | May 19, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 14584, POM-657 (SCR 1661) | IV |
Delaware | Right to Life, Various | June 9, 1978? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 124, p. 17055, POM-687 (HCR 9) | |
North Dakota | Balanced Federal Budget | February 8, 1979? | CR V.125 p.2113 | |
North Carolina | Balanced Federal Budget | February 22, 1979? | CR V.125 p.2113-4 | ?? |
Mississippi | Right to Life, Various | February 26, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 3196, POM-49 (HCR 3) | IV |
Florida | Balanced Federal Budget | March 1, 1979? June 21, 1988? |
Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 3655, POM-59 ("Senate Memorial" No. 234) Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, pp. 3655-3656, POM-60 (HM 2801) remainder of text p. 3656 Cong. Rec. Vol. 134, p. 15363, POM-549 (SM 302) |
|
Idaho | Balanced Federal Budget | March 1, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 3657, POM-64 (HCR 7) | |
New Mexico | Balanced Federal Budget | March 1, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, pp. 3656-3657, POM-62 (SJR 1) remainder of text p. 3657 | IV |
South Dakota | Balanced Federal Budget | March 1, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 3656, POM-61 (SJR 1) | |
Nebraska | Balanced Federal Budget | March 7, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 4152, POM-67 (Legislative Resolution No. 106) | IV |
Georgia | Right to Life, Various | March 8, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 4372, POM-79 (House Resolution No. 254) | |
Utah | Balanced Federal Budget | March 8, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, pp. 4372-4373, POM-80 (HJR 12) | |
Pennsylvania | Balanced Federal Budget | March 12, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 4627-4628, POM-85 (House Concurrent "Resolution No. 236") | IV |
Oregon | Balanced Federal Budget | March 22, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 5953, POM-104 (SJM 2) | |
Indiana | Balanced Federal Budget | May 1, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 9188, POM-192 ("Senate Enrolled Joint Resolution No. 8") | IV |
New Hampshire | Balanced Federal Budget | May 16, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125 p. 11584, POM-223 (HCR 8) | |
Iowa | Balanced Federal Budget | June 18, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 15227, POM-301 (SJR 1) | IV |
Nevada | Right to Life, Various | June 25, 1979? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 125, p. 16350, POM-312 (SJR 27) | V |
Nevada | Balanced Federal Budget | January 29, 1980? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 126, pp. 1104-1105, POM-535 (SJR 8) remainder of text p. 1105 | III |
Idaho | Right to Life, Various | March 21, 1980? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 126, p. 6172, POM-602 (SCR 132) | |
Oklahoma | Right to Life, Various | April 24, 1980? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 126, p. 8972, POM-701 (HJR 1053) | |
Tennessee | Right to Life, Various | May 2, 1980? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 126, p. 9765, POM-712 (SJR 23) | |
Alabama | Right to Life, Various | May 8, 1980? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 126, p. 10650, POM-717 (SJR 9) | IV |
Arizona | Limited Funding Mandates, Various | May 15, 1980? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 126, p. 11389, POM-730, (HCR 2001) | |
North Dakota | Right to Life, Various | April 27, 1981? | CR V.127 p.10650 | ?? |
Alaska | Balanced Federal Budget | February 3, 1982? | CR V.128 p.798 | ?? |
Missouri | Balanced Federal Budget | July 21, 1983? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 129, p. 20352, POM-323 (SCR 3) | V |
Arizona | Line Item Veto, Various | June 5, 1984? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 130, p. 15611, POM-684 (SCR 1008) | |
South Dakota | Line Item Veto, Various | March 12, 1986? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 132, pp. 4473-4474, POM-599, ("A Joint Resolution") remainder of text p. 4474 | |
Utah | Income Tax, Limit Other | March 30, 1987? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 133, p. 9736, POM-94 (SJR 8) | |
South Dakota | Term Limits on Members of Congress | April 4, 1989? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 135, pp. 5395-5396, POM-42 (HJR 1001) remainder of text p. 5396 | |
Idaho | Income Tax, Limit Other | April 10, 1989? | CR V.135 p.5895 | |
Georgia | Flag Desecration | April 16, 1991? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 137, pp. 8085-8086, POM-26 (House "Resolution No. 105") remainder of text p. 8086 | |
Colorado | Limited Funded Mandates, Various | June 26, 1992? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 138, p. 16552, POM-428 (SJM 92-3) | V |
South Dakota | Limited Funded Mandates, Various | March 22, 1993? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 139, p. 5905, POM-50 (SJR 3) | |
Missouri | No Judicial Taxing Power | June 29, 1993? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 139, p. 14565, POM-175 (SCR 9) | V |
Delaware | Income Tax, Limit Other | June 28, 1994? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 140, p. 14718, POM-554 (HCR 56) | |
Missouri | Limited Funding Mandates, Various | June 29, 1994? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 140, pp. 15072-15073, POM-575 (SCR 21) remainder of text p. 15073 | V |
Arizona | No Judicial Taxing Power | March 27, 1996? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 142, pp. S3012-S3013, POM-523 (SCR 1014) remainder of text p. S3013 | |
South Dakota | No Judicial Taxing Power | March 27, 1996? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 142, p. S3013, POM-526 (HCR 1010) | III |
Nevada | Term Limits on Members of Congress | June 29, 1996? | Nevada Constitution | III |
North Dakota | No Judicial Taxing Power | April 6, 2001? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 147, pp. S3704-S3705, POM-7 ("House Concurrent Resolution No. 3031") remainder of text p. S3705 | III |
Louisiana | Posse Comitatus | April 29, 2008? | Cong. Rec. Vol. 154, p. S3504, POM-329 ("House Concurrent Resolution No. 38") | IV |
Florida | Balanced Federal Budget | April 19, 2010 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, pp. S5563-S5564, POM-323 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution 10") remainder of text p. S5564 | V |
Nebraska | Balanced Federal Budget (Reaffirmation of 1976 Legislative Resolution No. 106) | April 13, 2010 | Legislative Resolution No. 538 | V |
North Dakota | Mode of Amendment, Other | April 14, 2011 | HCR 3048 | V |
North Dakota | Increase in federal debt to require approval by majority of state legislatures | April 11, 2011 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 158, p. S1459, POM-66 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 4007") | IV |
Alabama | Balanced Federal Budget | June 1, 2011 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, pp. S3666-S3667, POM-251 ("Senate Joint Resolution No. 100") remainder of text p. S3667 | V |
Louisiana | Increase in federal debt to require approval by majority of state legislatures | June 21, 2011 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 158, p. S2241, POM-69 ("House Concurrent Resolution No. 87") | IV |
New Hampshire | Balanced Federal Budget | May 16, 2012 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, p. S5153, POM-197 ("House Concurrent Resolution 40") | V |
Ohio | Balanced Federal Budget | November 20, 2013 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S1174, POM-197 ((Senate) "Joint Resolution No. 5") | V |
Georgia | Balanced Federal Budget | February 20, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, pp. S3667-S3668, POM-254 ("Senate Resolution 371") remainder of text p. S3668 | V |
Georgia | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | March 6, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S4332, POM-285 ("Senate Resolution No. 736") | V |
Michigan | Balanced Federal Budget | March 26, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, p. S2098, POM-14 ("Enrolled Senate Joint Resolution V") | V |
Tennessee | Balanced Federal Budget | April 9, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 165, p. S5406, POM-128 ("House Joint Resolution No. 548") | V |
Alaska | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | April 19, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S6021, POM-345 ("House Joint Resolution 22", also referred to as "Legislative Resolve No. 68") | V |
Florida | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | April 21, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S4332, POM-286 ("Senate Memorial 476") | V |
Florida | Balanced Federal Budget | April 21, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S4333, POM-288 ("Senate Memorial 658") | V |
Florida | Legislation in Congress to contain only one subject and that one subject must be clearly expressed in the measure's title | April 23, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S4333, POM-289 ("House Memorial 261") | V |
Vermont | Regulation of election campaign donations and expenditures; end legal concept of "corporate personhood"; overturn 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission | May 2, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S4331, POM-284 ("Joint Senate Resolution No. 27") | V |
Louisiana | Balanced Federal Budget | May 15, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S5563, POM-322 ("House Concurrent Resolution No. 70") | V |
California | Regulation of election campaign donations and expenditures; end legal concept of "corporate personhood"; overturn 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission | June 23, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 160, p. S5507, POM-320 ("Assembly Joint Resolution No. 1") | V |
Illinois | Regulation of election campaign donations and expenditures; end legal concept of "corporate personhood"; overturn 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission | December 3, 2014 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, p. S71, POM-126 ("Senate Joint Resolution No. 42") | V |
South Dakota | Balanced Federal Budget | February 17, 2015 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, p. S6550, POM-255 ("House Joint Resolution No. 1001") | V |
New Jersey | Regulation of election campaign donations and expenditures; end legal concept of "corporate personhood"; overturn 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission | February 23, 2015 | SCR 132 | V |
Utah | Balanced Federal Budget | March 6, 2015 | HJR 7 | V |
North Dakota | Balanced Federal Budget | March 24, 2015 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 161, pp. S2399-S2400, POM-17 ("House Concurrent Resolution 3015") remainder of text p. S2400 | V |
Alabama | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | May 21, 2015 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 161 pp. S8601-S8602, POM-124 ("House Joint Resolution 112") remainder of text p. S8602 | V |
Tennessee | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | February 4, 2016 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, p. S6534, POM-117 ("Senate Joint Resolution No. 67") | V |
Florida | Term limits on Members of Congress | February 10, 2016 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, p. S112, POM-6 ("House Memorial 417") | V |
Indiana | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | February 29, 2016 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, p. S6663, POM-256 ("Senate Enrolled Joint Resolution No. 14") | V |
West Virginia | Balanced Federal Budget | March 12, 2016 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, p. S5277, POM-201 and POM-202 ("House Concurrent Resolution 36") | V |
Alaska | Countermand Amendment, which would allow states to propose initiatives that could repeal any federal statute, executive order, judicial decision, or regulatory decision if three-fifths of state legislatures approved. | April 16, 2016 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 164, p. S703, POM-164 (HJR 14, also referred to as "Legislative Resolve No. 49") | V |
Oklahoma | Combination of: (1) Balanced Federal Budget; and (2) Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | April 18, 2016 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, pp. S6354-6355, POM-213 ("Senate Joint Resolution No. 4") remainder of text p. S6355 | V |
Louisiana | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | May 25, 2016 | SCR 52 | V |
Rhode Island | Regulation of election campaign donations and expenditures; end legal concept of "corporate personhood"; overturn 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (Rhode Island lawmakers chose to approve two separate unicameral resolutions, rather than to adopt a single bicameral resolution. The validity of this approach is subject to question). | June 16, 2016 (R.I. House version) and June 17, 2016 (R.I. Senate version) | Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, p. S5276, POM-198 (R 326—H 7670) and Cong. Rec. Vol. 162, pp. S5276-S5277, POM-199 (R 327—S 2589) remainder of text p. S5277 | V |
Wyoming | Balanced Federal Budget | February 27, 2017 | "House Enrolled Joint Resolution No. 2" | V |
Arizona | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | March 13, 2017 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, pp. S6534-S6535, POM-118 and POM-120 ("House Concurrent Resolution 2010") remainder of text p. S6535 | V |
North Dakota | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | March 24, 2017 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, p. S2527, POM-16 ("House Concurrent Resolution No. 3006") | V |
Arizona | Balanced Federal Budget | March 27, 2017 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, p. S6535, POM-119 and POM-121 ("House Concurrent Resolution 2013") | V |
Texas | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | May 10, 2017 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, p. S4056, POM-65 ("Senate Joint Resolution No. 2") | V |
Missouri | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | May 12, 2017 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 163, pp. S3361-S3362, POM-40 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 4") | V |
Wisconsin | Balanced Federal Budget | November 7, 2017 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 164, pp. S109-S110, POM-154 ("Assembly Joint Resolution No. 21") remainder of text p. S110 | V |
Alabama | Term Limits on Members of Congress | January 25, 2018 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 164, pp. S3759-S3760, POM-243 ("House Joint Resolution No. 23") | V |
Missouri | Term Limits on Members of Congress | May 17, 2018 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 164, p. S5422, POM-278 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 40") | V |
Arkansas | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | February 14, 2019 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 165, pp. S5601-S5602, POM-138 and POM-139 ("Senate Joint Resolution No. 3") | V |
Utah | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress | March 5, 2019 | Senate Joint Resolution No. 9 | V |
Mississippi | Fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials—but specifically excluding the imposition of term limits upon members of Congress | March 27, 2019 | Cong. Rec. Vol. 165, p. S5447, POM-133 ("Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 596") | V |
Counts by states
In 1929 Wisconsin presented a list of states having made applications for a convention exceeding the two-thirds requirement that was referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, with no further action. In 2013 states began listing existing state applications when joining them.
Wisconsin 1929
In 1929 Wisconsin applied to Congress to perform their constitutional duty to call a convention, listing Alabama, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Delaware, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin as states having made an application for a convention. There were 48 states in 1929, so 32 applications would be required to call a convention. 35 states were named.
Links to the text of applications by all states except California and North Carolina are provided in the table above. A reference to an application by California has been found in the Congressional Record and the text of an application by South Carolina is given in the table above. It may be that North Carolina was mistakenly included for South Carolina.
Three states, Missouri, Texas, and Wisconsin, had applied for a general convention. Eleven states listed had applied for a convention to prohibit polygamy (Delaware, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, Ohio, Oregon, South Dakota, Vermont, and Washington), plus South Carolina. Idaho had included the direct election of the President and Vice President with their request for direct election of Senators. Thus, 16 states clearly had outstanding applications.
Alabama and Georgia had outstanding issues from 1832 and 1833, making a less certain 18. Colorado, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Nevada, and Oklahoma would be added if we include class II requests for Direct Elections of Senators, for a total of 25.
The only known records for an application New York and Virginia are their ratification documents, before the Bill of Rights. New Jersey and Kentucky applied for a convention to prevent the Civil War, and class III applications for the Direct Election of Senators. Arkansas, Maine, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, and Utah only had documented class III applications for the Direct Election of Senators. California is most likely in this group. These ten states have applications that may have been mooted by amendments proposed by Congress.
Balanced Budget
The balanced budget application of Ohio in 2013 through that of Arizona in 2017—except North Dakota—include a list of previous state applications for a balanced budget. Wisconsin's 2017 application also does not contain such a list. These lists mostly extend the previous lists, except possibly omitting state applications from the same legislative session.
Arizona has the most complete list, including Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah and West Virginia. This represents 29 states.
Applications for all of the states mentioned above can be found in the list. Additionally, rescinded applications can be found for Delaware, Idaho, Oregon and Virginia. In particular, Delaware is included in lists prior to their rescission in 2016, but not after.
Wyoming and Wisconsin have made recent applications not included by Arizona, while Maryland, Nevada and New Mexico have recently rescinded their applications. This suggests a current total of 28 states, six short of the required 34.
Convention of States Resolution
The Convention of States Resolution includes fiscal restraints on the federal government, limiting the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, and limiting the terms of office of federal officials, including members of Congress. Oklahoma in 2016 and Texas in 2019 included counts of previous applications.
Texas has the most complete list, including the following 13 states: Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Louisiana, Missouri, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Tennessee and Texas.
All of these applications are included in the list, and Utah and Mississippi have recent applications not included by Texas, for a total of 15 states.
Wolf Pac Resolution
The Wolf Pac Resolution calls for regulation of election campaign donations and expenditures; end legal concept of "corporate personhood"; overturn 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in case of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission. Rhode Island included a count of the states in their 2016 application.
Rhode Island has the most complete list, including the following five states: California, Illinois, New Jersey, Rhode Island and Vermont. All of these applications are included in the list, with no recent additions.
Paulsen style application counts
Michael Stokes Paulsen holds that the applications for a convention alone should govern the convention.[5] Thus, this section contains counts of applications based on groupings not excluded by the applications themselves.
Counts including class IV, V, or VI applications would be limited to those with the same description, and can be found by sorting the list by topic.
Class I and II Applications
Indiana, Missouri, Ohio, Texas, and Wisconsin have outstanding applications for a convention to propose amendments, with no accompanying issue.
Alabama has a request for a convention limiting tariffs, and South Carolina one for clarification on Amendment X, each implying that other amendments may be considered.
Class I, II, and III Applications
24 more states have outstanding class III applications. These are Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington.
This gives a total of 31 states with known class I, II, or III applications. Three more applications would meet the 2/3rds requirement to call a convention.
Brennan style application counts
Thomas E. Brennan holds that, in 1982, it was necessary, desirable, and feasible to hold a convention.[6] He lists the following counts in the introduction to his claim:
- 450 applications through 1980, plus 25 more since 1980, gives 475 total applications.
- Applications from every state in the union (Hawaii's expired and did not call for a convention, 8 states have rescinded all applications, leaving 41).
- 36 states with more than six or more separate applications (Ten of those have since rescinded all or most of their applications, and five are not identified in the table above, but several states have five applications listed here).
See also
References
- http://clerk.house.gov/legislative/memorials.aspx
- http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/amlaw/lwdebt.html
- https://www.congress.gov/
- Judge Bruce Van Sickle and attorney Lynn Boughey M. (Fall 1990). "A Lawful and Peaceful Revolution: Article V and Congress' Present Duty to Call a Convention for Proposing Amendments". Hamline Law Review, Volume 14, p. 1.
- Paulson, Michael "A General Theory of Article V: The Constitutional Lessons of the Twenty-Seventh Amendment". Yale Law Journal 103: 677.
- Brennan, Thomas E., "Return to Philadelphia: A Case for Calling of an Amendatory Convention Under Article 5 of the Federal Constitution,'"1 Cooley Law Review 1 (1982).