Lost in the Fifties Tonight

1. "Lost in the Fifties Tonight (In the Still of the Night)" (Mike Reid, Troy Seals)
2. "In Love" (Reid, Bruce Dees)
3. "Old Fashioned Girl Like You" (Reid, Naomi Martin)
4. "I Heard It Through the Grapevine" (Norman Whitfield, Barrett Strong)
5. "Don't Take It Tonight" (Reid, Seals)
6. "How Do I Turn You On" (Reid, Byrne)
7. "Happy, Happy Birthday Baby" (M. Sylvia, G. Lopez)
8. "Nashville Moon" (Roger Murrah, John Schweers)
9. "I Only Remember the Good Times" (Reid, Martin)
10. "Money (That's What I Want)" (Janice Bradford, Berry Gordy)

As listed in liner notes.[2]

• Brandon Barnes – synthesizer
• Robert Byrne – background vocals
• Larry Byrom – electric guitar
• Jimmy Capps – acoustic guitar
• Bruce Dees – electric guitar, background vocals
• Sonny Garrish – steel guitar
• Jon Goin – electric guitar, acoustic guitar
• Jim Horn – saxophone
• Mitch Humphries – keyboards
• Shane Keister – keyboards, synthesizer, drum programming
• Mike Lawler – synthesizer
• Larrie Londin – drums
• Ronnie Milsap – lead vocals, background vocals, keyboards
• Farrell Morris – percussion
• Lisa Silver – background vocals
• Jay Spell – keyboards
• Suzy Storm – background vocals
• Diane Tidwell – background vocals
• Marie Tomlinson – background vocals
• Bergen White – background vocals
• Dennis Wilson – background vocals
• Bob Wray – bass guitar
• Barbara Wyrick – background vocals
• Roy Yeager – drums
• Strings performed by the Nashville String Machine, arranged by Bergen White and conducted by Carlos Gorodetzky.