Maxine Feibelman

"Tiny Dancer" is the first track on Elton John's album Madman Across the Water.[11] During the early stages of Taupin's and Feibelman's courtship, Taupin wrote the lyrics of "Tiny Dancer" to celebrate his feelings for her,[12] including literal details about Feibelman: She served as seamstress for the Elton John band,[13] traveling with John's entourage during his first U.S. tour[14] and making repairs when needed to the band's clothing.[15] In 1973, Taupin was asked directly whether the song is about Feibelman, and he answered, "That's true, yes."[6] In 1974, Taupin said, "I've never written a song meaning something more than it says."[16] Later, Taupin observed that the song also captured the spirit of those years with all of the women he got to know when he moved to California.[17][18]

When Taupin's and Feibelman's marriage began to deteriorate prior to 1976, the breakdown of their relationship motivated the creation of the song "I Feel Like a Bullet (in the Gun of Robert Ford)," with music by Elton John and lyrics by Bernie Taupin, which was the fifth track on John's album Rock of the Westies.[19] Taupin's lyrics for "I Feel Like a Bullet (in the Gun of Robert Ford)" may be interpreted as an apologetic message from Taupin to Feibelman. In the song, Taupin takes much of the blame for the situation, comparing himself to the fatal bullet with which outlaw Jesse James was shot in the back, through lyrics such as, "I'm low as a paid assassin is / You know I'm cold as a hired sword / I'm so ashamed / Can't we patch it up?'[12]

"Between Seventeen and Twenty," a song by Elton John with lyrics by Bernie Taupin, is the eleventh track on Elton John's 1976 album Blue Moves.[20] Music historians consider the song to be inspired by how Taupin felt when he discovered that Feibelman was having an affair with the Elton John band's bass player, Kenny Passarelli. The title refers to the age difference between Bernie and Feibelman, because he was 20 years old when he met her, and she was 17.[5] One biographer describes the song as "a thinly veiled rebuke to [Taupin's] estranged wife, Maxine, now sharing the bed of Kenny Passarelli, who was playing on this very track,",[4] particularly in the lyrics, "I wonder who's sleeping in your bed tonight / Whose head rests upon the bed / Could it be a close friend I knew so well / Who seems to be so close to you instead?"[4]

The first track (and second single released from) on the 1974 album Caribou, "The Bitch Is Back," with music by Elton John and lyrics by Bernie Taupin, was certified Gold on 13 September 1995 by the Recording Industry Association of America,[21] despite limited airplay because of reluctance to broadcast the word "bitch."[22] The song's title and repeated refrain was a direct quote of Feibelman, who said "the bitch is back" whenever John was in a bad mood.[5]^(p83)[23][24]^(p169)

"Mellow" is a song by Elton John with lyrics by Bernie Taupin, the second track on his 1972 album Honky Château.[25]"Mellow" has been interpreted as a reflection on Taupin's and Feibelman's happiness with life as a married couple in their mansion in Lincolnshire.[26] Taupin's lyrics appear to speak directly to Feibelman: "I love your Roman nose, the way you curl your toes."

The breakup of Bernie Taupin's marriage to Feibelman was reflected sharply, according to music historians, through the melancholy mood of Elton John's Blue Moves album.[24]^(p35) A biographer writes that Bernie Taupin was at a low point personally by mid-1976, mainly because of marital difficulties, and that Taupin's "almost exclusively downbeat lyrics about doomed relationships, unrequited love, and hurt also suited Elton's own fragile state."[4]

The song "Lovesick," by Elton John with lyrics by Bernie Taupin, appears as a bonus track — the 15th track — on Elton John's 1978 album A Single Man.[27] Despite the liveliness of the melody, the unhappy lyrics by Bernie Taupin were written near Taupin's divorce from Feibelman during the sessions for the album Blue Moves, and along with songs on that album it reflects the Taupin's moods in full marital crisis.

"I Cry at Night," a song by Elton John with lyrics by Bernie Taupin, is the 14th track (a bonus track) on the remastered edition of Elton John's 1978 album A Single Man,[27] and was released as B-side to "Part-time Love." This song was written and recorded during sessions for the Blue Moves album, when Taupin was struggling with the breakdown of his marriage to Feibelman. A noted biographer says that at that time "[e]veryone was coming unglued. Taupin, his wife ... it's there, all the pain in every line. I mean check out even the words to 'I Cry at Night.'"[28]