My Gift

Underwood first announced the album in June 2020.[1] The tracklist was announced on August 27, 2020.[2] Underwood had been wanting to make a full-length Christmas album for a long time, and decided it would be her next musical project after promoting her previous album, Cry Pretty. The album was produced and arranged by Greg Wells.[3]

The album features eight traditional tracks and three originals, two of those co-written by Underwood. One of the traditional tracks, "The Little Drummer Boy", Underwood was going to record alone but kept thinking about her oldest son Isaiah and asked him if he would want to sing with her on it, which he said "yes." John Legend is featured on "Hallelujah" which he co-wrote with Toby Gad. The two recorded it separately via emails and Zoom.[4] During an interview with Today's Country with Kelleigh Bannen, Underwood stated that the song came in late into the album process and she knew she had to make room for it. It was also her idea to make the song a duet.[5]

In September, Underwood told MusicRow, "I went through like every single song and I went on my iTunes and just started listening to so many versions, and marked down notes to give him [Wells] an idea of what I was looking for. Celine Dion's version of "O Holy Night" is so beautiful and big and classic. That was one I referenced. On the flip side, I didn't think I would find a version I liked of "Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Thee," because so many are so march-y. I was like, "How can we get away from that?" And he had the idea of me singing a cappella. I tried it and it ended up being so unique and it had a certain feeling about it that made me really happy and that's why we put it first on the album."[6]

Underwood appeared on the Today Show on September 24, 2020, to promote the album.[7] As cross-promotion for the album, Underwood starred in and executive produced an original HBO Max holiday special, airing on December 3, 2020,[8][9] entitled My Gift: A Christmas Special from Carrie Underwood. In November, Underwood released a bonus track to the album, "Favorite Time of Year", in partnership with Amazon Music.[10] It reached number one on the Billboard Hot Christian Songs chart, becoming Underwood's second number one hit on that chart and also reached number 62 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart.[11]

The official music video for "Hallelujah" was released on November 19.[12] Underwood appeared in a Ring commercial, as cross-promotion for her song "Favorite Time of Year."[13] On November 26, Underwood and Josh Groban were the featured artists for iHeartRadio's Holiday special.[14] Underwood performed "Mary, Did You Know?", "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas", and "O Holy Night." On December 3, Underwood performed "O Holy Night" on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon.[15] On December 8, Underwood performed songs from the album for a Pandora Live event, hosted by Storme Warren.[16] On December 18, Underwood performed "Mary, Did You Know?" on The Kelly Clarkson Show.

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[19]
The Observer	3.5/5[20]

My Gift received mostly positive reviews from critics. Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic called the album a "stately, somber affair" partly due to the production from Greg Wells, writing that the album "proceeds at a steady pace, adorned with very few bells and whistles, and a sparse choice that helps highlight how Underwood chooses to sing primarily religious-themed material."[21] Tom Cramer of The Eastern Echo gave a positive review, writing that it "will bring the listener the gift of contemplation: to contemplate what the true meaning of Christmas is, what’s really necessary to celebrate Christmas during a pandemic, and to contemplate what is going on in the world today", also praising the duet with John Legend, saying it "would be spectacular if they ever get to perform this song together."[22] Emily Simpson of Vinyl Chapters gave a positive review, calling the duet between Underwood and Legend a stand-out track, and writing, "In a decidedly non-traditional year, Carrie Underwood has kept one musical tradition going with this album. My Gift offers us moments of joy and unity, a little dose of Christmas cheer that everyone needs to hear."[23]

Chuck Campbell of Knoxville News Sentinel gave a positive review of the album, awarding it 4 out of 5, calling it "reverential, poignant and heavily religious – calming music suitable for reflection and introspection", but was less favorable toward the duets with John Legend and Underwood's son, calling the former "disjointed and ultimately overcooked" and speculating that the latter will "sound adorable to many, but cloying to others."[24] The Observer gave a positive review of the album, awarding it 3.5 out of 5, but highlighted the promotional single, "Let There Be Peace," calling it "the most soulful" of the album.[20]

In the United States, My Gift sold approximately 43,000 copies in its debut week, tabulated by Billboard.[25] Of that figure, 41,000 were from pure album sales, giving it a debut at No. 8 on the Billboard 200 and number one on the Top Country Albums respectively. The album also debuted at number one on Billboard's Holiday Albums and Top Christian Albums charts, Underwood's first album to do so.[26] The achievement made Underwood the first artist to place eight consecutive number one albums on the Top Country Albums chart, according to Billboard.[27] It reached a new peak of number five on the Billboard 200 after moving 53,000 units on the week ending December 19, 2020.[28] The album experienced its best sales on the week ending December 24, when it sold 57,000 copies.[29] Having sold over 271,000 copies, it finished as the top-selling Christmas album of the year.[30]

The album contains two number one hits, "Favorite Time of Year" and "Hallelujah", both of which topped Billboard's Hot Christian Songs chart.[31] The achievement earned Underwood her second and third number one hits on the Hot Christian Songs, following 2014's "Something in the Water."

All the tracks from "My Gift", including the Amazon Music exclusive "Favorite Time of Year", appeared on the Billboard Hot Christian Songs chart. "Favorite Time of Year" spent two weeks at number one before being replaced by "Hallelujah" at the number one spot, making Underwood the first female artist and only the second artist to replace themselves at the top spot in the chart's 17 year history. Additionally with "Silent Night" at number three, Underwood became the first artist to command the top three positions of the chart for multiple weeks (four consecutive weeks).[32]

Three of the songs from the album appeared on the Billboard Hot 100 chart, led by "Hallelujah" at number 54, "Favorite Time of Year" at number 62 and "Silent Night" at number 94. The first two songs also peaked high on the Hot Country Songs chart, at numbers three and five respectively, for the week ending January 2, 2021.

Vocals

• Isaiah Fisher – featured vocals (track 4)
• Brett James – background vocals
• John Legend – featured vocals (track 6)
• Carrie Underwood – lead vocals
• Nina Woodford – background vocals

Musicians

• Steven Becknell – French horn
• David Campbell – arranger
• Heather Clark – flute
• Andrew Duckles – viola
• Donald Foster – clarinet
• David Garcia – acoustic guitar
• Steven Holtman – contrabass trombone
• David Kalmusky – electric guitar
• Rong Huey Liu – oboe
• Mac McAnally – acoustic guitar
• Carolyn Riley – viola
• David Stone – bass
• David Washburn – trumpet
• Greg Wells – acoustic guitar, arranger, bass, drums, electric guitar, percussion

Production

• Serban Ghenea – mastering
• Joseph Lianes – photography
• Randy Merrill – mixing
• Greg Wells – producer, engineer, programming