Plastic Hearts

Feeling distant from the mainstream urban culture she explored on Bangerz (2013) and the musical experimentalism of Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz (2015), Cyrus decided to go for "rootsy" country music elements while making her sixth studio album Younger Now (2017).[7] The album was released on September 29, 2017 to lukewarm critical and commercial performance. It received an average score of 58 out of 100 on Metacritic,[8] and charted at number five on the US Billboard 200 with first-week sales of 33,000 copies and 45,000 overall album-equivalent units.[9] Its lead single "Malibu" became her ninth top-ten single on the US Billboard Hot 100, while the title track peaked at number 79.[10] Cyrus confirmed there would be no further singles only one month after the album was released and that she would not be touring for it.[11]

Two weeks prior to Younger Now being released, Cyrus claimed that she was "over [the album]" and was "already two songs deep on the next one";[12] however, she later said that she began working on the album in early 2018.[13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21] In December 2019, Cyrus acknowledged that the musical direction of Younger Now "wasn't exactly the home for [her]" and credited Ronson with "[helping her] carve out [her] sound, where [she] could do everything that [she wanted], which is more modern."[6] Cyrus later cited Britney Spears and Metallica as musical influences on the album.[22]

In November, Cyrus announced she was collaborating with Ronson, and continued work on her forthcoming record.[24] Cyrus and Ronson told Matt Wilkinson of Beats 1 that they were "80% done" with their albums, and tentatively planned for Cyrus' project to be released in June 2019.[25]

Cyrus held a private listening session of the album for iHeartRadio executives upon announcing its completion in May.[26] On May 9, Cyrus announced on social media that she would be releasing new music on May 30,[27] and later stated that the rollout of her new music would be "unconventional".[28] On May 31, Cyrus tweeted that the album would be titled She Is Miley Cyrus, and that it would be preceded by three six-track extended plays: She Is Coming on May 31, She Is Here in the summer, and She Is Everything in the fall.[29][30] Cyrus described the three EPs as "different [chapters] to a trilogy" that together would form the full-length album.[31] Their track listings were to be "seasonal" in nature; she related She Is Coming to "[wanting to feel] light and feel the warmth" of early summer, and She Is Here and She Is Everything to being "colder and a little darker" as the release cycle was to extend into the fall.[13] She Is Here was inspired by "the present of where [Cyrus is] at", while She Is Everything was to be comparatively more ballad-driven.[13] She later explained that the "she" pronoun in the album title described the "most confident version of herself".[23]

Cyrus continued work on the record following her split from then-husband Liam Hemsworth in August.[32] The following month, it was reported that Cyrus was undecided between updating the existing album that was completed before her divorce or scrapping that version of the record altogether.[33] On October 20, it was speculated from Cyrus' Instagram Live video that the release date for the full-length album was scheduled for her birthday on November 23, 2019.[34] On November 3, Ronson stated that Cyrus' collaborations with him were tentatively planned to be released before the end of that year.[35] On November 9, however, it was reported that Cyrus' new music would be delayed until early 2020 due to her vocal cord surgery earlier that month.[36]

On New Year's Day 2020, Cyrus uploaded a highlight video of the past decade and announced that "[the] new era starts now".[37] She stated that "[she was] getting super close [and was] feeling the urgency" during an interview with DJ Smallzy on March 4.[38] She tweeted a clip of the music video for her 2007 song "Start All Over" with the hashtags "#sheiscoming" and "#butforrealthistime" on August 4.[39] With the release of the single "Midnight Sky" on August 14, Cyrus confirmed the cancellation of the She Is Here and She Is Everything EPs, citing that "this year has been extremely unexpected [and] I guess I was feeling like it didn't make sense for me to continue the next two projects."[40] She stated that she did not have plans to release the full-length album in the near future because "when you write a record, a lot of the time, you're writing your experiences, and then by the time the record comes out, you've evolved past that experience" whereas releasing standalone singles "allows you to talk to your fans in real time". She later stated that she would wait until she could tour again to release the record,[41] however the album was later reported to be released in November.[42] On October 23, Cyrus announced that the album would now be titled Plastic Hearts and would be released on November 27; it became available for preorder that day.[43]

Plastic Hearts' opening track "WTF Do I Know" was described by British Vogue as "a galloping rock stomper that recalls the stop-start rhythm of The Strokes with a tinge of glam rock",[44] with People describing its lyrics as "Cyrus singing about the uncertainty of life and is a clear nod to Hemsworth, 30, who she split from last year." Cyrus stated that the song is "not that it's how I feel every second of the day, it's how I felt for a moment".[45] The title track "Plastic Hearts" "opts for a more jam-orientated rock flavour, slowly blooming out of a piano and percussion intro".[44] "Angels like You", the album's third track, was compared by British Vogue to Cyrus' 2013 single "Wrecking Ball", where "Cyrus glides between fragile heartbreak ("Won't call me by name, only baby") in the verses, to a full-throated roar of defiance on the sky-scraping chorus ("I know that you're wrong for me, gonna wish we never met on the day I leave"), with Cosmopolitan referring to Cyrus' 2019 relationship with Kaitlynn Carter as the song's lyrical inspiration.[46]

Second single "Prisoner" was described by NME as a "heartache anthem" and "is a glam declaration of independence".[47] The theme of independence is shared with "Midnight Sky", in which Cyrus is said to be "tak[ing] back her narrative" and being confident in herself.[48][49]

Eighth track "High", co-produced by Mark Ronson, "channels the rustic, singsong around the campfire varnished hurt of the A Star Is Born soundtrack", while "Never Be Me" was compared to a ballad from the 1980s and "over a bubbling synth pulse, Cyrus lays out what she will and won't do vis-à-vis new relationships. So, "If you're looking for faithful, that'll never be me" later morphs into the climactic, heart-bursting, "If you think that I'm someone to give up and leave, that'll never be me.""[44] Closing track "Golden G String", according to Cyrus, is "reflective of Donald Trump as president and the men hold all the cards -- and they ain't playing gin, and they determine your fate."[50]

The album artwork for Plastic Hearts was photographed by Mick Rock, who is widely known for his work with artists including Joan Jett and Debbie Harry.[51] The standard cover applies a pink filter to Cyrus' image, while limited edition copies from Cyrus' website feature black-and-white and full color variants.[52] Cyrus is pictured on the cover with a blonde mullet, wearing a Jean Paul Gaultier sleeveless black-and-white shirt with the word "censored" printed on it,[53] and accessorized with gold jewelry.[54]

Plastic Hearts was made available for pre-order on October 24, 2020, with three songs available to download. These were lead single "Midnight Sky", live covers of "Heart of Glass" (originally released September 29, 2020) and "Zombie".[43] "Edge of Midnight (Midnight Sky Remix)", a mash-up of "Midnight Sky" with Stevie Nicks' song "Edge of Seventeen" was released as the fourth pre-release download on November 6, 2020, and released to radio in Italy on November 9.[55][56]

"Prisoner", featuring Dua Lipa, was released as the album's second single on November 19, 2020.[57] The music video was released the same day.[58]

Cyrus was interviewed by Zane Lowe for Apple Music 1, which was released on November 23, 2020.[59] Cyrus previewed the album for video-sharing service TikTok's "Watermarked" series on November 26,[60] and featured on Dua Lipa's Studio 2054 livestream concert on November 27.[61] She performed on the first episode of the Amazon Music Holiday Plays digital concert series on December 1.[62] On 13 December, she gave an interview on Fantástico.[63]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
AnyDecentMusic?	7.1/10[64]
Metacritic	75/100[65]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[66]
Clash	8/10[67]
Exclaim!	7/10[68]
The Guardian	[69]
The Independent	[1]
The Line of Best Fit	8/10[70]
musicOMH	[71]
NME	[72]
Pitchfork	6.4/10[73]
Rolling Stone	[74]

At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album has an average score of 75 based on 22 reviews, indicating "generally favorable reviews"; it is the highest Metascore for any of Cyrus' albums.[65]

Katie Tymochenko of Exclaim! described Plastic Hearts as "Cyrus' gateway into the world of rock", but stated that "although she's proven herself to be a musical chameleon throughout all aspects of her career, Cyrus still caters to her pop following that's been with her since day one".[68] El Hunt of NME said that Cyrus was reflecting her Black Mirror character Ashley O in her transition from teen pop star to rock star, and complimented the "glam-rock tendencies" of "Prisoner" and "industrial undercurrent" of "Gimme What I Want".[72] Elly Watson of DIY praised her new musical direction saying "Overall, Miley's seventh era seems to be the one that suits her best".[75] Bella Fleming of The Line of Best Fit also praised Cyrus' new found independence and passion, saying "with Plastic Hearts, comes a wonderful album about life as a fiercely independent woman. Cyrus has found the perfect balance of pushing her own musical boundaries whilst proving she's one of the strongest and bravest names in the constant celebrity whirlwind."

Reviewing the album for AllMusic, Heather Phares claimed the album to be both "Passionate and self-aware" and that it is "easily the finest incarnation of Cyrus' music yet."[66]

In the United States, physical copies of Plastic Hearts were unavailable on the release date due to major retailers' stock limitations of physical music in anticipation of Black Friday, on which the release date fell. Cyrus stated that she and her team were not informed of these expected distribution disruptions upon selecting "the suggested [November 27] date" and was "equally/if not more frustrated" than her fans.[86] Nevertheless, the album debuted at number two on the US Billboard 200 with 60,000 album-equivalent units, making it her ninth release to chart within the top five and her highest-charting release since Bangerz (2013).[87] During its second week of release, Plastic Hearts dropped to number 12 with sales of 37,500 copies, and dropped to number 19 in its third week after moving 31,000 units. Additionally, the album became Cyrus' first entry and chart-topper on the Billboard Top Rock Albums chart, with seven of its songs entering the Hot Rock & Alternative Songs chart.[88]

Plastic Hearts debuted at number four on the UK Albums Chart, with sales of 15,318 units.[89] In Canada, the album debuted atop the Canadian Albums Chart, making it her third number-one and ninth top-ten album on the chart.

Notes

• ^{^[a]} indicates an additional producer
• "Prisoner" contains an interpolation of Olivia Newton-John's "Physical".[90]

Credits adapted from Tidal.[91]

Musicians

Technical