Save the World, Lose the Girl

Midtown was formed in 1998 by vocalist/bassist Gabe Saporta, guitarist/vocalist Tyler Rann, guitarist/vocalist Heath Saraceno and drummer Rob Hitt, three of whom attended Rutgers University together.[1] They released The Sacrifice of Life EP through independent label Pinball Records in April 1999. That same month, the band revealed they would be recording an album for independent label Drive-Thru Records later in the year.[2] The band did pre-production with Heath Miller at Excess DB Studios in Bergen Country, New Jersey; he was assisted by Stuart Karmatz and Tom Petta.[3]

The EP was supported with an east coast tour in June with One Cool Guy.[2] Following its conclusion, they traveled to California in July to record with producer Mark Trombino.[2] Sessions were held at Doug Messenger Studios in North Hollywood.[3] For their first week, they rehearsed material and altered the arrangements. Though recording was initially planned to finish in mid-July, it continued until the end of the month.[2] Trombino mixed the recordings with the assistance of Annette Cisneros at Eldorado in Burbank, California. They were then mixed by Brad Vance at DNA Mastering in Studio City, California.[3]

Musically, Save the World, Lose the Girl has been described as pop punk, with elements of emo,[4][5] drawing comparison to MxPx,[5] Jawbreaker and the Ataris.[6] All of the music was credited to the band, while Saporta wrote almost all of the lyrics with the exception: "Direction" (co-written with Rann), "Come On" (co-written with Hitt) and "Such a Person" (portion of lyrics from Russ Ballard). Saporta, Rann and Saraceno all took on lead vocal roles over the course of the album.[7]

The opening track "Just Rock and Roll" was reminiscent of the Offspring,[8] and was about Sporta leaving his previous band.[7] It is followed by rock number "Direction".[7] "Another Boy" is a punk rock track.[7] The pop ballad "No Place Feels Like Home" discusses the feeling of being homesick.[7] "Such a Person" contains an interpolation of "God Gave Rock 'n' Roll to You" by Argent, written by Ballard.[3] The closing track "Frayed Ends" is a ballad that features acoustic guitar.[7]

Following the end of the recording sessions, the members finished their final semester of school in preparation for future touring. They finished the year playing two shows, one in November and the other in December.[2] Preceding the album, the band went on tour in January 2000 with Fenix TX.[9] Save the World, Lose the Girl was released on Drive-Thru Records on February 15, 2000,[10] which was promoted with a February–March tour with New Found Glory and Rx Bandits. They continued touring until June, when they took the month off. During the month, the music video for "Just Rock and Roll" was posted online, directed by Richard and Stephanie Reines. Following this, the band appeared at the July 8–12 dates of the 2000 Warped Tour, before going on a cross-country stint with the Stereo.[9]

Midtown performing live in 2000.

In September, the group embarked on a Japanese tour with All. Around this time, the band signed to Burning Heart Records in Europe, who licensed the band's album from Drive-Thru for release in territory.[9] Preceded by two shows in Hawaii,[11] the band embarked on a full US tour between mid September and late October, with main support from Weston. Hot Rod Circuit, the Juliana Theory, Luckie Strike and Catch 22 appeared on select dates.[12] In November, the band toured with Reel Big Fish and Catch 22;[13] partway through the trek, the band were in a van accident, which resulted in their friend being seriously injured.[9] They had a supporting slot for New Found Glory on their headlining tour in November and December.[14] For this stint, they borrowed a van from their friends and were lent equipment from New Found Glory.[9]

In early January 2001, the band performed three benefit shows for their friend that was injured.[9] Between January and March, the band went on a European tour with the Donots.[15] They returned to the US and went on a cross-country trek with Hot Rod Circuit in April and May. They were supported on select dates by River City High, Thursday, the Rocking Horse Winner and Thrice.[16] In May, the group went on tour with H2O and Autopilot Off.[17] That same month, the band released a split EP with Millencolin, which featured "Let Go" alongside two new songs, "Get It Together" and "You Should Know".[18] The group performed on the 2001 Warped Tour in July, before supporting Blink-182 in July and August.[19]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[4]
CMJ New Music Report	Favorable[20]
Daily Skiff	Favorable[7]
Ox-Fanzine	Favorable[6]
Rock Hard	7.5/10[8]

Rock Sound included the album at number 44 on their list of the most essential pop punk releases.[21]

Save the World, Lose the Girl received positive reviews from music critics. AllMusic reviewer Heather Phares said the "deft harmonies and shared lead vocals" offered the tracks "extra appeal."[4] She viewed the release as a "strong debut ... reveal[ing] Midtown as an accomplished and surprisingly complex punk band."[4] Daily Skiff staff writer Victor Drabicky wrote that the album was a "wonderful mix of intelligently written lyrics and beautifully performed music".[7] Disregarding musical definition, it was "a masterpiece filled with superb writing and even better performance."[7] He praised the "exceptional" vocals and "the uniqueness with which each line is delivered."[7]

Randy Flame of Ox-Fanzine liked the interplay between the guitars, aiding Saporta's vocals with "a warm, full sound [and] is particularly successful."[6] CMJ New Music Report's Bill Konig saw it as an "unpretentious collection of emotionally-charged melodies" that were "fueled by tempestuous beats and dueling guitars."[20] He complimented the "beautiful vocal harmonies", alongside "heartfelt" lyricism.[20] Rock Hard said in spite of the "beautiful" harmonies, the release provided "a few pleasant corners, edges and melancholy tones" that make it "not necessarily risk-taking, but [a] thoroughly sympathetic album."[8]

All music by Midtown, all lyrics by Gabe Saporta, except where noted.[3]

1. "Just Rock and Roll" – 3:08
2. "Direction" (Saporta, Tyler Rann) – 2:29
3. "Recluse" – 3:22
4. "Another Boy" – 0:44
5. "Let Go" – 2:55
6. "No Place Feels Like Home" – 4:27
7. "Such a Person" (Saporta, Russ Ballard) – 2:29
8. "We Bring Us Down" – 0:59
9. "Knew It All Along" – 2:36
10. "Come On" (Saporta, Rob Hitt) – 5:12
11. "Resting Sound" – 3:59
12. "Frayed Ends" (contains hidden track) – 6:27

Personnel per booklet.[3]

Citations

Sources