Web shell

Web shells are used in attacks mostly because they are multi-purpose and difficult to detect.[6]

Web shells are commonly used for:

• Data theft[6]
• Infecting website visitors (watering hole attacks)[7]
• Website defacement by modifying files with a malicious intent
• Launch distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks[3]
• To relay commands inside the network which is inaccessible over the Internet[3]
• To use as command and control base, for example as a bot in a botnet system or in way to compromise the security of additional external networks.[3]

Web shells are installed through vulnerabilities in web application or weak server security configuration including the following:[3][6]

• SQL injection;
• Vulnerabilities in applications and services (e.g. web server software such as NGINX or content management system applications such as WordPress);[8][9]
• File processing and uploading vulnerabilities, which can be mitigated by e.g. limiting the file types that can be uploaded;[9]
• Remote file inclusion (RFI) and local file inclusion (LFI) vulnerabilities;
• Remote code execution;
• Exposed administration interfaces;[3]

An attacker may also modify (spoof) the Content-Type header to be sent by the attacker in a file upload to bypass improper file validation (validation using MIME type sent by the client), which will result in a successful upload of the attacker's shell.

A b374k shell running on a Windows 7 Ultimate Edition server.

An example of what a fake error page might look like in a WSO web shell.

• b374k – A web shell written in PHP with abilities such as monitoring processes & command execution. The latest version of the b374k shell is 3.2.3.[3][10][11][12]
• C99 – A web shell capable of showing the web server's security standards and has a self-destruction option.[3][13] The original version of C99Shell does not work with PHP 7 due to the usage of removed functions.
• China Chopper – A web shell which is only 4 kilobytes in size, which was first discovered in 2012. This web shell is commonly used by malicious Chinese actors, including advanced persistent threat (APT) groups, to remotely access web servers. This web shell has two parts, the client interface (an executable file) and the receiver host file on the compromised web server. Has many commands and control features such as a password brute-force attack option.[14][15][16]
• R57 – The R57 web shell has tools to scan the infected web server for other web shell installations, with the option to remove or overwrite them.[17]
• WSO (web shell by oRb) – Has the ability to be password protected with a login form, some variants can disguise as a fake HTTP error page.[3][18][19]

Web shells can be as short as just one line of code. The following example PHP script is 15 bytes in size:

<?=`$_GET[x]`?>

If an attacker inserts this line of code into a malicious file with a PHP filename extension (such as .php) on a web server that is running PHP, the attacker can issue commands, for example reading the /etc/passwd file, through a web browser using the following Uniform Resource Locator if the web shell was located at uploads/webshell.php:

http://example.com/uploads/webshell.php?x=cat%20%2Fetc%2Fpasswd

The above request will take the value of the x URL parameter, decode the URL and send the following shell command:

cat /etc/passwd

If the permissions of the /etc/passwd file allow viewing the file, the web server will send the contents of /etc/passwd to the web browser and the browser will then display the contents of the /etc/passwd file or any other file the attacker wishes to view.

This attack could have been prevented if the file permissions did not allow viewing the file or if the shell functions of PHP were disabled so that arbitrary shell commands cannot be executed from PHP.

Other malicious actions are able to be executed by attackers with that web shell, such as replacing the contents of a file on the web server. For example, consider the following command:

echo x > index.php

The above command could be used to replace the contents of the index.php file with the text "x", which is one way a web page could be defaced, or create the index.php file with the contents if the file does not exist. Attackers can also use the Bash command rm to delete files on the web server and mv to move files.

A web shell is usually installed by taking advantage of vulnerabilities present in the web server's software. That is why removal of these vulnerabilities are important to avoid the potential risk of a compromised web server.

The following are security measures for preventing the installation of a web shell:[3][4]

• Regularly update the applications and the host server's operating system to ensure immunity from known bugs
• Deploying a demilitarized zone (DMZ) between the web facing servers and the internal networks
• Secure configuration of the web server[3]
• Closing or blocking ports and services which are not used[3]
• Using user input data validation to limit local and remote file inclusion vulnerabilities[3]
• Use a reverse proxy service to restrict the administrative URL's to known legitimate ones [3]
• Frequent vulnerability scan to detect areas of risk and conduct regular scans using web security software (this does not prevent zero day attacks[3])
• Deploy a firewall[3]
• Disable directory browsing
• Not using default passwords[3]

Web shells can be easily modified, so it's not easy to detect web shells and antivirus software are often not able to detect web shells.[3][20]

The following are common indicators that a web shell is present on a web server:[3][4]

• Abnormal high web server usage (due to heavy downloading and uploading by the attacker);[3][20]
• Files with an abnormal timestamp (e.g. newer than the last modification date);[20]
• Unknown files in a web server;
• Files having dubious references, for example, cmd.exe or eval;
• Unknown connections in the logs of web server

For example, a file generating suspicious traffic (e.g. a PNG file requesting with POST parameters);[3][21][22][23] Dubious logins from DMZ servers to internal sub-nets and vice versa.[3]

Web shells may also contain a login form, which is often disguised as an error page.[3][24][25][26]

Using web shells, adversaries can modify the .htaccess file (on servers running the Apache HTTP Server software) on web servers to redirect search engine requests to the web page with malware or spam. Often web shells detect the user-agent and the content presented to the search engine spider is different from that presented to the user's browser. To find a web shell a user-agent change of the crawler bot is usually required. Once the web shell is identified, it can be deleted easily.[3]

Analyzing the web server's log could specify the exact location of the web shell. Legitimate users/visitor usually have different user-agents and referers (referrers), on the other hand, a web shell is usually only visited by the attacker, therefore have very few variants of user-agent strings.[3]

• Backdoor (computing)
• Cyberwarfare
• Internet security
• Network security
• China Chopper