1923–24 Southampton F.C. season

Southampton manager Jimmy McIntyre bought and sold several players before the start of the 1923–24 season. One of the first departures during the summer was inside-forward John Cooper, who returned to his former club Darlaston after having made just five league appearances with the Saints during two seasons.[1] Also leaving was outside-left Joe Clark, who was sold to Third Division North side Rochdale after losing his place in the first team to Len Andrews late the previous season.[2] Two players were brought in to take Clark's place – Elias MacDonald from Burton All Saints in May,[3] and Jimmy Carr from Reading in June.[4] Also arriving in the summer were George Harkus, a half-back who joined from First Division side Aston Villa for £250,[5] and Harold Pearson, a forward who was transferred from Brierley Hill Alliance in the Birmingham & District League.[6] Half-back Alex Christie also left for Norwich City after just one season at the club,[2] while Jack Elkes was sold to Tottenham Hotspur for a club record fee of £1,050.[7][8]

Several more players were added to the squad during the season. Inside-forward Jock Salter joined as an amateur in September 1923, signing professional terms the following month.[9] The club signed another amateur player in November, bringing in outside-forward Stan Cribb from local side Gosport Athletic, although he would not turn professional until the following season.[10] The same month, winger Bill Henderson was signed for a fee of £500 from Luton Town after Sammy Meston – one of the club's two regular outside-rights – broke his leg during a match against Bristol City on 6 October.[11] Before the end of the calendar year, inside-left Cliff Price was transferred from Third Division North club Halifax Town.[12] The club sold two more players in the new year. In January, Herbert Lock left for Bournemouth and Boscombe Athletic, having last played in May.[13] The next month, Henry Johnson also left The Dell to join top-flight side Queens Park Rangers, after scoring three goals in eleven appearances during the season so far.[14]

Players transferred in

Name	Nationality	Pos.	Club	Date	Ref.
George Harkus	England	HB	Aston Villa	May 1923	[5]
Elias MacDonald	England	FW	Burton All Saints	May 1923	[3]
Harold Pearson	England	FW	Brierley Hill Alliance	May 1923	[6]
Jimmy Carr	Scotland	FW	Reading	June 1923	[4]
Jock Salter	England	FW	Bitterne Sports	September 1923	[9]
Stan Cribb	England	FW	Gosport Athletic	November 1923	[10]
Bill Henderson	England	FW	Luton Town	November 1923	[11]
Cliff Price	England	FW	Halifax Town	December 1923	[12]

Players transferred out

Name	Nationality	Pos.	Club	Date	Ref.
Robert Blyth	England	FW	none (temporarily retired)	May 1923	[15]
John Cooper	England	FW	Darlaston	May 1923	[1]
Joe Clark	England	FW	Rochdale	June 1923	[2]
Alex Christie	Scotland	HB	Norwich City	July 1923	[2]
Jack Elkes	England	FW	Tottenham Hotspur	August 1923	[7]
Herbert Lock	England	GK	Boscombe	January 1924	[13]
Henry Johnson	England	FW	Queens Park Rangers	February 1924	[14]

Southampton's second season in the Second Division of the Football League started poorly, as the club immediately found themselves at the bottom of the league table following two 1–0 losses away to Bury and Manchester United, both of whom finished in the top six of the division the previous year.[16] The team's form quickly improved, however, as they beat Bury in the return fixture 3–0 and went on a seven-game unbeaten run to move up to the top five in the league table.[16][17] Despite this run of form, which also included a 3–0 win at home to The Wednesday, Southampton's main goal threat Bill Rawlings did not score until October, when he picked up the only goal in a 1–0 win over recently promoted Bristol City; during this period, recent signing Harold Pearson – who had replaced Rawlings in the side after the first six games of the campaign – was the club's top scorer with three goals.[16] By the end of the year, Southampton were firmly placed in the First Division promotion race as they sat in sixth place in the Second Division table.[18]

The club picked up their biggest win of the season on 19 January 1924, when they beat Barnsley (who had finished two places above them the previous season) 6–0 at The Dell. Bill Rawlings picked up half of the goals, with Henry Johnson (twice) and Arthur Dominy also registering on the scoresheet.[16] The result saw the Saints move up to fifth in the league table for the first time since September.[19] However, during February and March the team's results began to deteriorate, including two losses at the hands of league leaders Leeds United; club historians attributed this dip to the number of replays required in the team's FA Cup run, which also had an effect on the number of injuries in the side.[20] With ten games remaining, Southampton had dropped to 13th in the table, two places lower than they had finished in 1922–23.[21] Following their elimination from the FA Cup, the team's performances began to improve drastically. Starting from 22 March 1924, they went on an unbeaten run until the end of season, which included six wins.[16]

The club moved back up to the top ten with a 1–0 win over fellow mid-table side Leicester City, the only goal scored by right-back Tom Parker, and moved up to seventh two weeks later when they beat Clapton Orient 5–0 thanks to goals from Rawlings (who scored his second hat-trick of the season), Dominy and Parker.[16] Despite taking three points each from the games against Stockport County and Crystal Palace, the Saints were unable to move above seventh place in the table, as the sides above them continued to pick up wins.[16] Finally they did so in the last two games of the season against Oldham Athletic, both of which they won 3–2. Rawlings scored all three in the first game – at Boundary Park – to bring his hat-trick tally to three for the season, and scored a final goal in the return game at The Dell to bring his league total for the year to 19; Dominy and Cliff Price scored the other two.[16] Southampton finished the season in fifth place with 17 wins, 14 draws and 11 losses, three points away from the second promotion place.[20]

List of match results

Bury v Southampton

25 August 1923 1	Bury	1–0	Southampton	Bury
				Stadium: Gigg Lane Attendance: 14,000

Manchester United v Southampton

27 August 1923 2	Manchester United	1–0	Southampton	Manchester
				Stadium: Old Trafford Attendance: 35,000

Southampton v Bury

1 September 1923 3	Southampton	3–0	Bury	Southampton
	Meston Carr			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 15,000

Southampton v Manchester United

3 September 1923 4	Southampton	0–0	Manchester United	Southampton
				Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 20,000

The Wednesday v Southampton

8 September 1923 5	The Wednesday	1–1	Southampton	Sheffield
			Own goal	Stadium: Hillsborough Stadium Attendance: 20,000

Nelson v Southampton

11 September 1923 6	Nelson	0–0	Southampton	Nelson
				Stadium: Seedhill Attendance: 8,000

Southampton v The Wednesday

15 September 1923 7	Southampton	3–0	The Wednesday	Southampton
	Pearson Dominy			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 10,000

Coventry City v Southampton

22 September 1923 8	Coventry City	0–0	Southampton	Coventry
				Stadium: Highfield Road Attendance: 10,000

Stoke v Southampton

24 September 1923 9	Stoke	1–1	Southampton	Stoke-on-Trent
			Pearson	Stadium: Victoria Ground Attendance: 11,000

Southampton v Coventry City

29 September 1923 10	Southampton	1–3	Coventry City	Southampton
	Carr			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 12,000

Southampton v Bristol City

6 October 1923 11	Southampton	1–0	Bristol City	Southampton
	Rawlings			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 12,000

Bristol City v Southampton

13 October 1923 12	Bristol City	1–1	Southampton	Bristol
			Rawlings	Stadium: Ashton Gate Stadium Attendance: 12,000

Southampton v Stoke

15 October 1923 13	Southampton	0–1	Stoke	Southampton
				Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 10,000

Southampton v Derby County

20 October 1923 14	Southampton	0–0	Derby County	Southampton
				Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 11,000

Derby County v Southampton

27 October 1923 15	Derby County	1–0	Southampton	Derby
				Stadium: Baseball Ground Attendance: 13,000

Southampton v Fulham

3 November 1923 16	Southampton	1–0	Fulham	Southampton
	Own goal			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 10,000

Fulham v Southampton

10 November 1923 17	Fulham	3–2	Southampton	London
			Rawlings	Stadium: Craven Cottage Attendance: 15,000

Southampton v Blackpool

17 November 1923 18	Southampton	3–2	Blackpool	Southampton
	Dominy Rawlings Carr			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 9,000

Blackpool v Southampton

24 November 1923 19	Blackpool	2–0	Southampton	Blackpool
				Stadium: Bloomfield Road Attendance: 8,000

Southampton v Nelson

8 December 1923 20	Southampton	3–0	Nelson	Southampton
	Dominy Rawlings Pearson			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 11,000

Southampton v South Shields

15 December 1923 21	Southampton	0–0	South Shields	Southampton
				Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 11,000

South Shields v Southampton

22 December 1923 22	South Shields	1–2	Southampton	South Shields
			Dominy Rawlings	Stadium: Horsley Hill Attendance: 4,000

Southampton v Hull City

29 December 1923 23	Southampton	2–0	Hull City	Southampton
	Dominy Carr			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 11,000

Hull City v Southampton

5 January 1924 24	Hull City	0–0	Southampton	Kingston upon Hull
				Stadium: Anlaby Road Attendance: 9,000

Southampton v Barnsley

19 January 1924 25	Southampton	6–0	Barnsley	Southampton
	Rawlings Johnson Dominy			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 7,000

Barnsley v Southampton

26 January 1924 26	Barnsley	1–1	Southampton	Barnsley
			Johnson	Stadium: Oakwell Attendance: 7,000

Bradford City v Southampton

9 February 1924 27	Bradford City	2–1	Southampton	Bradford
			Price	Stadium: Valley Parade Attendance: 10,000

Southampton v Bradford City

11 February 1924 28	Southampton	2-0	Bradford City	Southampton
	Henderson Price			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 8,000

Southampton v Port Vale

16 February 1924 29	Southampton	1–1	Port Vale	Southampton
	Dominy			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 9,000

Southampton v Leeds United

1 March 1924 30	Southampton	0–1	Leeds United	Southampton
				Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 8,000

Leeds United v Southampton

8 March 1924 31	Leeds United	3–0	Southampton	Leeds
				Stadium: Elland Road Attendance: 18,000

Leicester City v Southampton

15 March 1924 32	Leicester City	0–1	Southampton	Leicester
			Dominy	Stadium: Filbert Street Attendance: 20,000

Port Vale v Southampton

17 March 1924 33	Port Vale	1–0	Southampton	Hanley
				Stadium: Old Recreation Ground Attendance: 9,000

Southampton v Leicester City

22 March 1924 34	Southampton	1–0	Leicester City	Southampton
	Parker			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 9,000

Clapton Orient v Southampton

29 March 1924 35	Clapton Orient	0–0	Southampton	London
				Stadium: Clapton Stadium Attendance: 18,000

Southampton v Clapton Orient

5 April 1924 36	Southampton	5–0	Clapton Orient	Southampton
	Rawlings Dominy Parker			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 7,000

Stockport County v Southampton

12 April 1924 37	Stockport County	2–3	Southampton	Stockport
			Shelley Dominy Rawlings	Stadium: Edgeley Park Attendance: 11,000

Crystal Palace v Southampton

18 April 1924 38	Crystal Palace	0–0	Southampton	London
				Stadium: The Nest Attendance: 8,000

Southampton v Stockport County

19 April 1924 39	Southampton	0–0	Stockport County	Southampton
				Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 10,000

Southampton v Crystal Palace

21 April 1924 40	Southampton	1–0	Crystal Palace	Southampton
	Rawlings			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 10,000

Oldham Athletic v Southampton

26 April 1924 41	Oldham Athletic	1–3	Southampton	Oldham
			Rawlings	Stadium: Boundary Park Attendance: 6,000

Southampton v Oldham Athletic

3 May 1924 42	Southampton	3–1	Oldham Athletic	Southampton
	Dominy Rawlings Price			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 8,000

Southampton entered the 1923–24 FA Cup in the first round against First Division club Chelsea, who they had knocked out in the second round of the previous year's tournament.[23] The hosts initially led at Stamford Bridge thanks to a "brilliant individual goal" from Andrew Wilson, who had joined the London club from Middlesbrough for a British transfer record fee of £6,000 at the beginning of the season, but a goal from Arthur Dominy forced a replay at The Dell four days later.[20] The Saints won the replay 2–0, with Dominy scoring from a Bill Turner free-kick and Bill Rawlings converting after a setup by Bill Henderson.[20] In the second round, Southampton beat fellow Second Division side Blackpool 3–1 at The Dell, with a goal each from Rawlings, Dominy and Cliff Price sending them through to the third round.[20]

The third round of the tournament on 23 February 1924 saw Southampton hosting reigning First Division league champions Liverpool, who had eliminated the previous season's cup winners Bolton Wanderers in the second round. The game ended in a goalless draw, forcing a replay at Liverpool's home Anfield four days later.[20] Southampton played much of the game with ten players, after left-back Fred Titmuss suffered a "freak injury" in which a blood vessel in his eyeball was burst by a loose shoelace, and was forced to be taken off amid fear of permanent eye damage.[20] The hosts opened the scoring shortly after half-time courtesy of Harry Chambers, but the ten men of Southampton prevented conceding more until six minutes from the end, when Dick Forshaw doubled his side's lead and secured the result.[20]

Chelsea v Southampton

12 January 1924 Round 1	Chelsea	1–1	Southampton	London
	Wilson		Dominy	Stadium: Stamford Bridge Attendance: 34,586

Southampton v Chelsea

16 January 1924 Round 1 Replay	Southampton	2–0	Chelsea	Southampton
	Dominy Rawlings			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 17,000

Southampton v Blackpool

2 February 1924 Round 2	Southampton	3–1	Blackpool	Southampton
	Rawlings Dominy Price			Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 18,000

Liverpool v Southampton

27 February 1924 Round 3 Replay	Liverpool	2–0	Southampton	Liverpool
	Chambers Forshaw  83'			Stadium: Anfield Attendance: 49,569

Outside of the league and the FA Cup, Southampton played five additional first-team matches during the 1923–24 season. The first was a friendly match against local rivals Portsmouth at The Dell on 24 November 1923. A benefit for former player Bert Lee, who was now a trainer at the club, the match ended in a 2–0 win for Pompey thanks to two goals by Willie Haines – one in the first half as the result of "some good combined work by the Pompey front line", and one in the second after the centre-forward "got right through on his own".[24] A writer for the Football Mail reporting on the game observed that Portsmouth's work as a team featured "always more method" than that of Southampton.[24] Two more friendlies also ended in losses – both against amateur club Corinthian in December.[25][26]

Southampton ended their season with two more fixtures against Portsmouth. The first took place on 5 May 1924 and was for the second Rowland Hospital Cup. Portsmouth, having just won their first Third Division South championship, travelled to The Dell "anxious to demonstrate that they [were] capable of beating a Second Division side", according to a reporter for the Football Echo.[24] The visitors took an advantage, as Stephen Dearn and Willie Haines put Pompey 2–1 up, with Bill Rawlings scoring in between the goals for the hosts.[27] After losing Sammy Meston and Tom Parker, the Saints went 3–1 down thanks to a second goal from Haines, before Rawlings scored a second as well.[27] Pompey made it three wins out of three against Southampton two days later, when they also beat them at Fratton Park to win the Hampshire Benevolent Cup. William Beedie scored early to give the advantage to the hosts, who dominated the remainder of the game and scored a second through Haines on 60 minutes.[27]

Southampton v Portsmouth

24 November 1923 Friendly	Southampton	0–2	Portsmouth	Southampton
			Haines	Stadium: The Dell Referee: V. G. Primmer

Corinthian v Southampton

1 December 1923 Friendly	Corinthian	1–0	Southampton	London
	Nicholas			Stadium: The Crystal Palace Attendance: 3,000

Southampton v Corinthian

26 December 1923 Friendly	Southampton	1–2	Corinthian	Southampton
	Price		Ashton	Stadium: The Dell Attendance: 7,000

Southampton v Portsmouth

5 May 1924 Rowland Hospital Cup	Southampton	2–3	Portsmouth	Southampton
	Rawlings		Dearn Haines	Stadium: The Dell Referee: Albert Prince-Cox

Portsmouth v Southampton

7 May 1924 Hampshire BC	Portsmouth	2–0	Southampton	Portsmouth
	Beedie  3' Haines  60'			Stadium: Fratton Park Attendance: 7,496 Referee: F. C. Winton

Southampton manager Jimmy McIntyre used 24 different players during the 1923–24 season, ten of whom scored during the campaign. The team played in a 2–3–5 formation throughout the campaign, with two full-backs, three half-backs, two outside forwards, two inside forwards and a centre-forward.[16] Goalkeeper Tommy Allen and right-half Bert Shelley appeared in all 47 league and FA Cup matches. Right-back Tom Parker missed only one league fixture, while inside-right Arthur Dominy played in all but three.[16] Centre-forward Bill Rawlings finished as the club's top scorer for the season, with 19 goals in the Second Division and four in the cups. Dominy scored 11 in the league and three in the FA Cup. Shelley was the club's only scoring half-back of the season, while Parker was their only scoring full-back of the season, scoring twice in the league.[16]

Squad statistics

Name	Pos.	Nat.	League		FA Cup		Other[lower-alpha 1]		Total
			Apps.	Gls.	Apps.	Gls.	Apps.	Gls.	Apps.	Gls.
Tommy Allen	GK		42	0	5	0	2	0	49	0
Len Andrews	FW		7	0	0	0	0	0	7	0
Arthur Bradford	HB		2	0	0	0	0	0	2	0
Charlie Brown	FW		12	0	1	0	0	0	13	0
Les Bruton	FW		5	0	0	0	0	0	5	0
Alec Campbell	HB		29	0	5	0	2	0	36	0
Jimmy Carr	FW		24	4	5	0	0	0	29	4
Arthur Dominy	FW		39	11	5	3	2	0	46	14
George Harkus	HB		14	0	0	0	2	0	16	0
Bill Henderson	FW		23	1	4	0	2	0	29	1
Harry Hooper	FB		4	0	0	0	0	0	4	0
Ted Hough	FB		4	0	0	0	0	0	4	0
Michael Keeping	FB		0	0	0	0	1	0	1	0
Elias MacDonald	FW		18	0	0	0	0	0	18	0
Sammy Meston	FW		7	2	0	0	1	0	8	2
Tom Parker	FB		41	2	5	0	1	0	47	2
Harold Pearson	FW		8	4	0	0	0	0	8	4
Cliff Price	FW		19	3	5	1	2	0	26	4
Bill Rawlings	FW		36	19	5	2	2	2	43	23
Jock Salter	FW		1	0	0	0	0	0	1	0
Bert Shelley	HB		42	1	5	0	2	0	49	1
Fred Titmuss	FB		37	0	5	0	2	0	44	0
Bill Turner	HB		37	0	5	0	0	0	42	0
Players with appearances who left before the end of the season
Henry Johnson	FW		11	3	0	0	0	0	11	3

Notes

1. Includes the Rowland Hospital Cup and Hampshire Benevolent Cup matches.

• Cavallini, Rob (2007), Play Up Corinth: A History of the Corinthian Football Club, Stroud: Stadia, ISBN 978-0752444796
• Chalk, Gary; Holley, Duncan (10 August 1987), A Complete Record of Southampton Football Club: 1885–1987, Derby, England: Breedon Books, ISBN 978-0907969228
• Chalk, Gary; Holley, Duncan; Bull, David (28 November 2013), All the Saints: A Complete Who's Who of Southampton FC, Bristol, England: Hagiology Publishing, ISBN 978-0992686406
• Juson, Dave; Aldworth, Clay; Bendel, Barry; Bull, David; Chalk, Gary (10 November 2004), Saints v Pompey: A History of Unrelenting Rivalry, Bristol, England: Hagiology Publishing, ISBN 978-0953447459

• Southampton F.C. official website