2017–18 Birmingham City F.C. season

Birmingham City opened their 2017–18 EFL Championship season away to Ipswich Town, without injured striker Lukas Jutkiewicz, unsettled centre-back Ryan Shotton, and club captain Paul Robinson, who was serving the final instalment of a three-match ban.[26][27] The team lined up in a 4–4–2 formation with David Stockdale in goal, Emilio Nsue and Jonathan Grounds at full back, Michael Morrison (captain) and Marc Roberts at centre back, Cheikh Ndoye alongside Craig Gardner in central midfield, David Davis and Jacques Maghoma as wide midfielders, and Che Adams and Clayton Donaldson in the forward line.[28] Birmingham had the better of the first half, but early in the second, Ipswich were "perhaps fortunate" that Jordan Spence was not sent off for a professional foul on Donaldson and promptly broke forward for Joe Garner to score the only goal of the match.[29] Without centre-back Aden Flint, a transfer target for Birmingham,[30] Bristol City took the lead in the second minute of their visit to St Andrew's; Gardner equalised after half an hour. Davis, who was suffering from a virus, and the injured Grounds were replaced at half-time by Maikel Kieftenbeld and Robinson; 15 minutes later, Adams' hamstring injury gave winger David Cotterill a first league appearance for Birmingham since January.[31][32][33] Maghoma "displayed a brilliant piece of individual finishing",[34] and despite Kieftenbeld's sending off for a mistimed tackle – which was rescinded on appeal[35] – the ten men held on for the win.[31]

A goalless draw with Bolton Wanderers at St Andrew's was marked by the inclusion of Ryan Shotton, despite a reportedly imminent transfer to Middlesbrough, first in the matchday squad and then on the field after Morrison suffered a facial injury, and a "quiet" debut for former Luton Town striker Isaac Vassell. Redknapp said afterwards that he couldn't claim to have enjoyed the match, that "it was almost the same team which struggled to stay up last season and that is a big worry", and if the club failed to sign some quality players it would be "another tough season".[36] Wearing a mask to protect his broken nose and damaged cheekbone, Morrison started the televised visit to Burton Albion and Shotton, whose wife had recently given birth, was left out entirely.[37] Donaldson's cross was knocked down by Jutkiewicz for Maghoma to tap in against his former club, but after the break, Birmingham conceded two well-worked goals to lose to Burton for the third time in three attempts.[38] Redknapp was vitriolic afterwards, accusing the players of having "ruined Zola last year", of failing to "win any battles", criticising "four or five of them" for disappearing, and stating that what he needs "is to change a lot of them because that's not good enough."[39] Before the next fixture, three loanees arrived from Premier League clubs: inexperienced full-back Cohen Bramall and England international defender Carl Jenkinson, both from Arsenal, and Southampton striker Sam Gallagher.[40] All three started at home to Reading. Jenkinson dislocated his shoulder after half an hour, and a 2–0 defeat left Birmingham 20th in the table going into the international break.[41]

Six more players joined before the transfer window closed: centre-back Harlee Dean, full-back Maxime Colin and – for a club record fee – Spanish winger Jota, all from Brentford, free-agent midfielder Jason Lowe, late of Blackburn Rovers, and two young loanee midfielders, Everton's Liam Walsh[42] and Jérémie Boga, who made his Premier League debut for Chelsea early in the season.[43] An attempt to sign former Arsenal midfielder Alex Song from Rubin Kazan fell through.[44] Robert Tesche and Cheick Keita left the club on season-long loans.[42] In permanent departures, Shotton completed his move to Middlesbrough,[45] Donaldson joined Sheffield United,[42] and, after bids for midfield partner Davis were rejected,[46] Kieftenbeld was reported to have signed for Derby County.[42] However, the league refused to ratify the transfer because of problems with the documentation.[47] After the window closed, the club issued a statement talking up the financial contribution made by the owners to support the manager: "Blues have undergone a major transformation, with the owners showing the ambition and providing resources to help create an exciting, new-look side under Redknapp".[46]

September began with three more hamstring injuries, to Adams, Jota and Lowe,[48] and three successive defeats – away to Norwich City with six debutants in the starting eleven,[49] away to Leeds United, a result that took the hosts top of the table,[50] and at home to Preston North End, which left Birmingham 23rd in the table.[51] Just hours after the match, the board issued a statement:

Unfortunately due to the poor start to the campaign which sees the club second from bottom of the Championship, we are left with no choice but to terminate the contract of the manager with immediate effect.[52]

Redknapp said that, despite the frustrations of the amount of injuries and by the failure to sign some of his primary transfer targets, he was enjoying his work, believed he would have brought success to the club, and was disappointed that he was given no more than a week with the new players to prove it.[52][53][54]

Under the caretaker management of development coach and former Birmingham midfielder Lee Carsley, and despite a wrist injury to Stockdale that was expected to keep him out for some weeks, the losing streak ended after a 1–1 draw with Gary Rowett's Derby County; they took a second-half lead via Jutkiewicz's first touch, but could not hold on to the lead.[55][56] At home to Sheffield Wednesday, Vassell's first goal for Birmingham gave them their second win of the season.[57] On 29 September, Steve Cotterill, who worked with Redknapp in the final three games of the 2016–17 season, signed a two-and-a-half-year contract as Birmingham's fourth permanent manager in ten months.[58] He watched Carsley oversee Hull City end a five-match winless run by beating Birmingham 6–1 – Gallagher's stoppage-time goal was his first for the club[59] – before formally taking charge on 2 October.[58]

Cotterill began his tenure with a home fixture against top-of-the-table Cardiff City. Ahead of the match, he commented that the large size of the squad made it "awkward" to omit players whose training performances would normally justify their inclusion on matchday.[60] He made several changes to the team, recalling Kieftenbeld – for the first time since his transfer to Derby fell through – Grounds, Roberts and Adams, and naming Vassell as a lone striker in a 4–2–3–1 formation with Ndoye in the middle of the three.[61] After Adams gave the team a 19th-minute lead "with a low, right-foot shot after a superb mazy run", they had chances to extend their advantage against a Cardiff team that had no shots on target.[62] In contrast, what Cotterill described as a tentative start to the televised visit to Millwall allowed the hosts to gain and keep the advantage in a 2–0 win.[63] The final October fixture was the Second City derby at home to Aston Villa. In a misguided attempt to boost the atmosphere inside the stadium, the club distributed cardboard "clappers" in the home fans' areas; unsurprisingly, they were thrown onto the pitch during the match. The resulting controversy, which included Daily Mail columnist Martin Samuel advocating closure of the ground,[64][65] overshadowed an entertaining but goalless draw in which both teams had chances – Jota shot over the bar when clean through with only the goalkeeper to beat[66] – and both sets of fans united in applause in support of the victims of the 1974 Birmingham pub bombings.[65] The month ended with confirmation that Isaac Vassell had ruptured a cruciate ligament during the Villa match and was unlikely to be back before the end of the season.[67]

Four points from a possible fifteen during November established Birmingham in and around 21st place in the table. They scored only twice. Adams' early goal and "a succession of fine saves" by Kuszczak gave Birmingham a home win against Nottingham Forest,[68] and away to Sheffield United, a corner was cleared to Boga who took a couple of steps forward before "thumping a curling effort" past the goalkeeper from outside the penalty area;[69] the hosts equalised in the second half to restrict Birmingham to just their second away point of the season.[70] Three 2–0 defeats completed the league return: at home to Brentford and away to Barnsley and Middlesbrough.

Three defeats by the odd goal, in the second of which, in front of more than 4000 travelling supporters at Fulham, Boga hit a 75th-minute penalty well over the bar, left Birmingham bottom of the table.[71][72] Cotterill received a vote of confidence from the directors before the visit to Sunderland, in which Gallagher opened the scoring and was then sent off for two yellow cards, and Birmingham's determined defending with ten men earned them a draw.[73] The point left them still bottom, three points adrift of safety; as the Birmingham Mail pointed out, for the past eight seasons, the team bottom of the Championship at Christmas had been relegated.[74] With only Jutkiewicz of the senior strikers available for the visit of Norwich City, Birmingham conceded in each half and failed to score.[75] In the final fixture of 2017, at home to fifth-placed Leeds United, Maghoma's late goal gave Birmingham their first win in eight matches. With relegation rivals Bolton and Sunderland both winning and Burton Albion drawing, Birmingham remained at the foot of the table going into the transfer window.[76]

The new year began with another win, away to Reading. Maghoma opened the scoring, continuing a run of form that the local paper was to describe as "the best football of his Blues career",[77] and Gallagher's fourth goal for the club gave Birmingham a 2–0 win. Cotterill thought his team were improving: "We are learning, we are fitter, we are more organised and we are settled now."[78] Two opponents were booked for bad fouls on Maghoma and Grounds hit the post twice at home to Derby County, but the visitors won 3–0.[79] Maghoma's assist for Gallagher allowed Birmingham to earn a draw at Preston North End,[80] and another assist, this time for Boga's header, contributed to a 3–1 victory at home to relegation rivals Sunderland before an injury forced his substitution; the third goal was Gallagher's fifth in seven league matches.[81] January's results earned Cotterill a nomination for the EFL Championship Manager of the Month award: according to the rationale, "never has his ebullience and self-confidence been more fiercely tested. Seven points from four games to move out of the bottom three say that he is winning the battle."[82]

Cotterill said that Birmingham's approach to the January transfer window would be "strategic": they would not be paying over the odds, and would be interested in loans.[83] He went into the transfer window "close to landing two new additions",[84] but three weeks later, after releasing David Cotterill and selling Nsue to APOEL FC, he was discussing more outgoings and the implications of Financial Fair Play.[85] By the time the window closed, Stephen Gleeson had left for Ipswich, Che Adams had not left, Kieftenbeld and Grounds had signed contract extensions – Maghoma would do the same a few days later – but there were no additions.[86]

Despite Maghoma's absence, the winning run continued at Sheffield Wednesday – who had two men sent off – via Davis's second goal in consecutive matches and Jota's first goals for the club.[87] Jonathan Grounds, the team's only senior left back, suffered a badly torn medial knee ligament during the match and was expected to be out for the rest of the season.[88] Going into the visit to Aston Villa, the mood was positive, but the hosts extended their winning streak to seven league matches with a 2–0 result.[89][90] Cotterill's "hope that this was a one-off"[90] proved unfounded. With a midfield weakened by the absence of Kieftenbeld, serving a two-match ban for accumulated yellow cards, and Davis injured, Birmingham lost the next three matches, conceding eight goals and scoring none. The results included a 5–0 defeat at Brentford,[91] and a 2–0 loss at home to Barnsley, during which Cotterill was given a police escort off the field and objects including a plastic bottle were thrown at him. He spoke of the players "look[ing] frightened to play at home".[92]

During the following week, the parent company released their accounts for the six months ending December 2017: they showed a loss of £17.8 million loss – more than in the previous twelve months.[93] Holding company chairman Zhao Wenqing flew to England for talks. Cotterill outlined the past two months from his viewpoint, and described Zhao as "incredibly supportive".[93] A fifth successive defeat, by 2–1 at Nottingham Forest on 3 March, preceded the dismissal that same day of not only Cotterill, but also the coaching staff and senior sports science staff inherited from previous incumbents, as well as director of football Jeff Vetere. The board's statement expressed "great regret and sadness" at the decision, and commended Cotterill's professionalism, work ethic and honesty.[94]

The Daily Telegraph reported that "Birmingham's transfer activity was allegedly disrupted by an ongoing row between two key figures in the boardroom, leaving Cotterill unable to make any additions", that chief executive Xuandong Ren's position was in doubt, and that agent Darren Dein, who held a consultancy role with the owners, had been "marginalised".[95] Channel 5's Football on 5 pundit Chris Iwelumo commented on the adverse effects of lack of communication between the club's ownership and its other stakeholders, and felt that a new manager might face the same problems as his predecessors if the infrastructure remained unchanged.[96] The Birmingham Mail's Brian Dick recognised that "Cotterill had a little more than half a season to effect the positive change Blues are so desperate to see but unfortunately for him it proved too difficult", but noted that "many of the problems and strategic issues that have blighted three previous managers remain. One can only wonder if Harry Houdini could succeed where Harry Redknapp – and now Steve Cotterill have come up short."[97]

The next evening, Birmingham appointed former Swansea City, Leeds United and Middlesbrough manager Garry Monk on a three-and-a-half-year contract as their fifth permanent manager in fifteen months. He was accompanied by members of the backroom staff that had worked with him at some or all of his previous clubs: Pep Clotet as assistant manager, James Beattie (first-team coach), Darryl Flahavan (goalkeeping coach), Sean Rush (head of performance) and Ryan Needs (head of analysis).[98][99]

Monk's first fixture was at home to Middlesbrough, the club from which he was sacked in December. He made two team changes, restoring Jota to the starting eleven after a month out of it and giving Jutkiewicz a first league start of 2018.[100] Although they lost 1–0, the victory putting Middlesbrough back in the playoff positions, Monk's post-match interview highlighted the positives: "I thought we limited their threats very well, so from a defensive point of [view] we were very, very good. When the goal went in I was very pleased with the commitment, the attitude and the passion the players showed today along with a passionate crowd."[101] Away to Cardiff City, Birmingham were 3–0 down by half-time. Monk brought Roberts on for Jenkinson, and the team brought the score back to 3–2, but still finished with their eighth consecutive defeat. [102] In the last match before the international break, played in a snowstorm, Birmingham finally broke the losing streak by beating Hull City 3–0. Monk gave academy product Wes Harding a league debut at right back, chosen ahead of more experienced players because his pace and tenacity would better counteract the threat from Hull's wingers.[103]

Birmingham beat Ipswich Town 1–0 courtesy of Jota's penalty. BBC Sport remarked that "The most noticeable difference since Monk's appointment has been the greater influence of Spanish forward Jota, who struggled for goals following his club-record move from Brentford in August, but has been pivotal in Blues' successive wins either side of the international break."[104] Nearly 5,000 fans travelled to Bolton Wanderers on a Tuesday night to see Jutkiewicz's first league goal in six months give Birmingham another 1–0 win.[105] He also scored in the next two matches but the team gained only one point, through his late equaliser at home to Burton Albion,[106][107] and a 2–0 defeat away to already-promoted Wolverhampton Wanderers in which Dean was sent off, left them two points above the relegation places with three matches remaining.[108]

Sheffield United's Mark Duffy approached the visit to his former club with the intention of scoring and proving some of its fans wrong.[109] He duly scored after just seven minutes, but his extravagant celebration antagonised the home supporters and disappointed his manager;[110] Birmingham went on to win 2–1.[111] A defeat at Queens Park Rangers, after which Monk said the pressure of avoiding relegation had affected the players so that they showed fear, meant that for the second successive season their fate would be decided on the last day of the season.[112] At home to Fulham, who were on a 23-match unbeaten run and needed to win to have a chance of automatic promotion, Birmingham's performance belied their standing as the division's lowest scorers as they completed a 3–1 win. According to Monk, they produced "what the fans want to see. They want to see commitment and fight and then, on top of that, they want to see some quality, and we had that."[113] They finished in 19th place, the same as in 2016–17, but with seven points fewer.[114]

General source:[115] Match content not verifiable from these sources is referenced individually.

Date	Player	Club	Fee	Ref
1 July 2017	Craig Gardner	West Bromwich Albion	Undisclosed	[13]
1 July 2017	Marc Roberts	Barnsley	Undisclosed	[12]
1 July 2017	David Stockdale	(Brighton & Hove Albion)	Free	[10]
13 July 2017	Cheikh Ndoye	(Angers)	Free	[143]
14 August 2017	Isaac Vassell	Luton Town	Undisclosed	[144]
30 August 2017	Harlee Dean	Brentford	Undisclosed	[145]
31 August 2017	Maxime Colin	Brentford	Undisclosed	[42]
31 August 2017	Jota	Brentford	Undisclosed[lower-alpha 1]	[42]
31 August 2017	Jason Lowe	(Blackburn Rovers)	Free	[42]

Brackets round a club's name indicate the player's contract with that club had expired before he joined Birmingham.

Date	Player	Club	Fee	Ref
21 July 2017	Kerim Frei	İstanbul Başakşehir	Undisclosed	[14]
8 August 2017	Adam Legzdins	Burnley	Undisclosed	[146]
30 August 2017	Ryan Shotton	Middlesbrough	Undisclosed	[45]
31 August 2017	Clayton Donaldson	Sheffield United	Undisclosed	[42]
19 December 2017	David Cotterill	(ATK)	Mutual consent	[147]
8 January 2018	Emilio Nsue	APOEL	Undisclosed	[148]
8 January 2018	David Popa	UTA Arad	Mutual consent	[149]
19 January 2018	Stephen Gleeson	Ipswich Town	Free	[150]
19 January 2018	Dan Cleary	(Dundalk)	Mutual consent	[151]
1 June 2018	Andrew Shinnie	Luton Town	Free	[152]
8 June 2018	Jason Lowe	Bolton Wanderers	Free	[153]
30 June 2018	Tai-Reece Chisholm	(Barnsley)	Released	[154][155]
30 June 2018	Jordan Clarke		Released	[154]
30 June 2018	Tyrell Hamilton	(AFC Bournemouth)	Released	[156]
30 June 2018	Wes McDonald	(Yeovil Town)	Released	[157][158]
30 June 2018	Olly Mulders		Released	[157]
30 June 2018	Paul Robinson		Retired	[159]
30 June 2018	Jack Storer	(Partick Thistle)	Released	[157][160]
30 June 2018	Matthew Timms		Released	[157]
1 July 2018	Robert Tesche	(VfL Bochum)	Released	[161]

Brackets round a club's name denote the player joined that club after his Birmingham City contract expired.