Billy Geen

Geen was selected to play for Oxford against Cambridge in four consecutive years from 1910 to 1913.[1] In the first of these, on 13 December 1910, a 9,000-strong crowd turned up at Queen's, mostly to watch Ronnie Poulton, playing for Oxford. Cambridge started strong but a try by Bryn Lewis was disallowed in the opening minutes after a touch judge signalled that Geen had put his foot into touch in the preceding Oxford move. Moments later, Poulton ran through the Cambridge defence, drew the fullback and passed to Geen to dive in at the corner for a try. With Turner's conversion, Oxford led 5–0. A similar passage of play again saw Poulton put Geen through for a try, but he dropped the ball after crossing the line while trying to get closer to the posts.[5]

Geen got his second try after another break from Poulton. Cambridge meanwhile scored two tries and at half-time were leading 15–13. Fifteen minutes into the second half, a second try for Cambridge put them five points ahead. An injury to one of Cambridge's scoring wings reduced the team to fourteen players; a forward moved to cover the wing, giving Oxford an advantage in the forwards. Poulton capitalised on it: he scored from a dummy pass to Geen; and ran in a solo try after receiving a pass from flyhalf Freddie Knott. The end score was 23–18 to Oxford.[6][7]

A couple of days before the Varsity Match, talk in the press had been of Geen's likely selection for England for the forthcoming Home Nations Championship.[8] Geen and Poulton, who together were considered the scoring force of the Oxford team, were both selected to play for England in the second trial match against The North in Leeds. Although Geen scored a try in the game, his form was lacking and he was outshone by Poulton.[9] So for the third and final trial, England versus The Rest on 7 January 1911, Geen was not selected.[10]

In the run up to the 1911 Varsity Match, the Poulton–Geen partnership was a constant threat to opposition teams. Ten days before the Varsity Match, Oxford beat London Scottish 39–3.[11] Twice Poulton put Geen in the clear, with the latter ending the day with four tries in total.[12] On 12 December, Cambridge were favourites to win but Poulton captained Oxford to victory, in front of a crowd of 10,000.[13] Geen's form coming into the game was suspect but he proved his worth.[14] However, Poulton suffered a hamstring injury early on and his replacement Eric Thomas, a forward, lacked the speed and skills to combine effectively with Geen. Nevertheless, he came close to scoring, but, as he had done in the previous year's match, he dropped the ball over the tryline. He was to repeat the error the following year.[15]

The Newport team that defeated South Africa in 1912. Billy Geen is the first player on the left of the back row.

Geen played for Newport Rugby Club before going to Oxford and returned to Newport during the holiday periods, providing "dazzling entertainment".[16][17] He was described by Tommy Vile's biographer Philip J Grant as looking "the promising player in Wales"; and scored 10 tries and a dropped goal in 14 games for the Monmouthshire club.[18] On 24 October 1912, he was part of the team that played and beat the touring South Africans 9–3. He was not first choice for the game, but when George Hirst failed to recover from an injury sustained at Leicester the week before, Geen was his replacement.[19]

South Africa was as yet undefeated on the tour, with wins over Somerset, Devon, Cornwall, Monmouthshire, Glamorgan and Llanelli. Whereas Newport, according to "Dromio" (W J Townsend Collins) writing in the Argus, had been poor in attack in their previous three encounters and weak in defence in the last two.[20] Townsend Collins later recollected that the South Africans were taller, heavier, stronger and faster. The Newport victory was the result of "superior tactics and superlative captaincy".[21]

Just before half time, a try by Newport's Jack Wetter was disallowed for a forward pass. The ball was then worked back to Fred Birt, standing within range in front of the posts, and he kicked a drop-goal, putting the home side 4–0 ahead at the break. In the second half, the Springboks repeatedly attacked but the Newport defence kept them from crossing the line, although a break from Dick Luyt, the South African centre, left Douglas Morkel to score under the posts. Luyt failed to convert and Newport remained a point ahead. Newport scored again through a cross-kick from Wetter, which Birt jumped on over the line for a try, which he then converted.[21]

Newport was one of only three teams to beat the Springboks on the tour and Geen played his part, bringing down Johan Stegmann when he was within sight of the try line.[22] He was praised after the match for his play.[23] The Times the following day reported: "Newport deserved the victory, if only for their remarkably sound and highly intelligent defence... In spite, however, of the good play of the Newport forwards ... the South African backs would have scored at least three tries but for the fine tackling of Geen and Reg Plummer, the Newport wings, who saved one certain try by just stopping Otto Van Der Hoff on the line."[24]

Geen was then selected and played three times for Wales in the 1912–1913 season.[25] He earned his first cap against the same touring South Africans on 14 December.[26] His next international appearance, under the captaincy of his Newport teammate Tommy Vile, was on 18 January 1913 against England.[21] Wales were beaten in Cardiff 0–12.[27] After the game, and disappointed by the performance of most of the team, the selectors made nine changes for the upcoming match against Scotland. Only two backs were to be retained, Bobby Williams, the fullback, and Billy Geen, deemed the outstanding threequarter against England, moving from wing to centre.[28] However, on the Wednesday preceding the encounter in Edinburgh, Geen withdrew after a training session due to an ongoing shoulder injury, and his place on the team was taken by Willie Watts.[29]

His final game for Wales was on 8 March 1913 against Ireland, when he showed "brilliance and judgment" (according to Townsend Collins) helping to create two tries towards a Welsh 16–13 victory.[16][30] Geen was selected to play centre for the first match of the 1914 Home Nations against England at Twickenham but was forced to withdraw due to injury.[31] He was replaced, once again, by Willie Watts,[32] and probably missed out on four more caps for Wales.[33]

In 1911, Geen was approached by Barbarian F.C., an invitational touring rugby team based in England, to join them on their 1911 Easter tour.[34] Geen played in two matches of the tour, the first a 15–8 loss against Cardiff RFC where he was captained by Ireland's Tommy Smyth.[35] Despite missing the Swansea game two days later, Geen returned to the Barbarians squad to face Cheltenham, which ended in an 8–3 victory for the tourists.[34][36] Later that year Geen was again invited to play for the Barbarians, another contest against Cardiff in their traditional Boxing Day encounter.[34] In 1912 Geen played in his first Barbarians match outside Wales, facing the Leicester Tigers. His captain on that day was England international Edgar Mobbs, and although finishing on the losing side, Geen scored his first and only try for the Barbarians.[34][37]

With the outbreak of the First World War in 1914, competitive rugby union matches were suspended. Despite this, Edgar Mobbs organised two Barbarians matches against Leicester in early 1915 to aid recruiting and to raise charity funds.[38] Mobbs then arranged one final Barbarians match against the Royal Army Medical Corps (RAMC), leading a team made up of military personnel, including Geen in his last Barbarians appearance, to a 10–3 victory. Of Geen's teammates on that day, Mobbs and another England international Arthur James Dingle, would also die in action during the war.[39][40]

• Billot, John (1974). Springboks in Wales. Ferndale, Glamorgan: Ron Jones Publications. OCLC 86022999.
• Corsan, James (2009). For Poulton and England: The Life and Times of an Edwardian Rugby Hero. Leicester: Matador. ISBN 978-1848762107.
• Grant, Philip J (2010). Tommy Vile: A Giant of a Man. Llandysul: Gomer Press. ISBN 978-0-9567271-0-7.
• McCrery, Nigel (2014). Into Touch: Rugby Internationals Killed in the Great War. Pen and Sword. ISBN 978-1473833210.
• Sewell, Edward Humphrey Dalrymple (1919). The Rugby Football Internationals Roll of Honour. London, Edinburgh: T. C. & E. C. Jack. OCLC 503803942.
• Starmer-Smith, Nigel (1977). The Barbarians. Macdonald & Jane's Publishers. ISBN 0-8600-7552-4.
• Townsend Collins, W J (1948). Rugby Recollections. Newport: R. H. Johns. OCLC 60698254.