Loughinisland massacre

The Loughinisland massacre[1][2][3][4] took place on 18 June 1994 in the small village of Loughinisland, County Down, Northern Ireland. Members of the Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF), a loyalist paramilitary group, burst into a pub with assault rifles and fired on the customers,[5] killing six civilians and wounding five. The pub was targeted because it was frequented mainly by Catholics,[6] and was crowded with people watching the Republic of Ireland play against Italy in the 1994 FIFA World Cup.[6] It is thus sometimes called the "World Cup massacre".[7][8][9] The UVF claimed the attack was retaliation for the killing of three UVF members by the Irish National Liberation Army (INLA).

Loughinisland massacre
Part of the Troubles
O'Toole's Pub (white building) in 2006
LocationO'Toole's Pub, Loughinisland, County Down, Northern Ireland
Coordinates54°20′17″N 5°49′30″W
DateJune 18, 1994 (1994-06-18)
10:10 p.m. (GMT)
Attack type
Mass shooting
WeaponsVz. 58 assault rifles
Deaths6 civilians
Injured5 civilians
PerpetratorUlster Volunteer Force

There have been allegations that police (Royal Ulster Constabulary) double agents or informers in the UVF were linked to the massacre and that police protected those informers by destroying evidence and failing to carry out a proper investigation.[10] At the request of the victims' families, the Police Ombudsman investigated the police. In 2011 the Ombudsman concluded that there were major failings in the police investigation, but no evidence that police colluded with the UVF. The Ombudsman did not investigate the role of informers and the report was branded a whitewash. The Ombudsman's own investigators demanded to be disassociated from it. The report was quashed, the Ombudsman replaced and a new inquiry ordered.[11]

In 2016, a new Ombudsman report concluded that there had been collusion between the police and the UVF, and that the investigation was undermined by the wish to protect informers, but found no evidence police had foreknowledge of the attack.[12] A documentary film about the massacre, No Stone Unturned, was released in 2017. It named the main suspects, one of whom was a British soldier, and claimed that one of the killers was an informer.

Background

The UVF emerged in the late 1960s, at the beginning of the thirty-year conflict known as the Troubles. The UVF's claimed goal was to fight Irish republicanism – particularly the Irish Republican Army (IRA) – and maintain Northern Ireland's status as part of the United Kingdom.[13] Most of its victims were innocent Catholic civilians, who were often killed at random.[14] Whenever it claimed responsibility for attacks, the UVF usually claimed that those targeted were IRA members or were helping the IRA.[15] Other times, attacks on Catholic civilians were claimed as "retaliation" for IRA actions, since the IRA drew almost all of its support from the Catholic population.[16]

Since the 1970s, the UVF had carried out many gun and bomb attacks on Catholic-owned pubs and there had been many incidents of collusion between the UVF and members of the state security forces. During the early 1990s, loyalists drastically increased their attacks on Catholics and Irish nationalists and – for the first time since the conflict began – were responsible for more deaths than republicans or the security forces.[17][18]

On 16 June 1994, the Irish National Liberation Army (INLA) killed three UVF members – Trevor King, Colin Craig and David Hamilton – in a drive-by shooting on the Shankill Road in Belfast.[19] Senior UVF members had been meeting in a building nearby. According to one senior member, after this attack the UVF called on its members to retaliate, for there to be "blood on the streets" and to "kill any Catholic" they could.[20] The following day, the UVF launched two 'retaliatory' attacks. In the first, UVF members shot dead a Catholic civilian taxi driver in Carrickfergus.[19] In the second, they shot dead two Protestant civilians in Newtownabbey, whom they believed were Catholics.[19] The Loughinisland shootings, a day later, are believed to have been further retaliation.[1]

Pub attack
The pub in 2009

On the evening of 18 June 1994, about 24 people[6][21] were gathered in The Heights Bar (also known as O'Toole's Pub) watching the Republic of Ireland vs Italy in the FIFA World Cup.[5]

At 10:10 p.m., two UVF members wearing boiler suits and balaclavas walked into the bar. One shouted "Fenian bastards!" and opened fire on the crowd with a vz. 58 assault rifle,[22] spraying the small room with more than sixty bullets.[23] Six men were killed outright,[5][19] and five other people were wounded. Witnesses said the gunmen then ran to a getaway car, "laughing".[5][23] One described "bodies … lying piled on top of each other on the floor".[23] The dead were Adrian Rogan (34), Malcolm Jenkinson (52), Barney Green (87), Daniel McCreanor (59), Patrick O'Hare (35) and Eamon Byrne (39), all Catholic civilians.[19] O'Hare was the brother-in-law of Eamon Byrne and Green was one of the oldest people to be killed during the Troubles.[5][24]

The UVF claimed responsibility within hours of the attack. It claimed that an Irish republican meeting was being held in the pub and that the shooting was retaliation for the INLA attack.[25] Police said there is no evidence the pub had links to republican paramilitary activity,[25] and said the attack was purely sectarian.[26] Journalist Peter Taylor wrote in his book Loyalists that the attack may not have been sanctioned by the UVF leadership.[27] Police intelligence indicates that the order to retaliate came from the UVF leadership and that its 'Military Commander' had supplied the rifle used.[28] Police believe the attack was carried out by a local UVF unit under the command of a senior member who reported to the leadership in Belfast.[26]

The attack received international media coverage and was widely condemned. Among those who sent messages of sympathy were Pope John Paul II, Queen Elizabeth II and US President Bill Clinton. Local Protestant families visited their wounded neighbours in hospital, expressing their shock and disgust.[23]

Aftermath

The massacre ultimately led to a temporary return to tit-for-tat violence.[29] The following month, the IRA shot dead three high-ranking members of the Ulster Defence Association (UDA), the other main loyalist paramilitary group alongside the UVF. It is claimed this was retaliation for the Loughinisland massacre.[30][31][32] The IRA stated that the men were directing the UDA's campaign of violence against Catholics.[33]

On 11 July the IRA shot dead Ray Smallwoods, a member of the UDA's Inner Council and spokesman for its political wing, the Ulster Democratic Party. Six days later, UDA gunmen tried to repeat the Loughinisland massacre when they attacked the Hawthorn Inn at nearby Annaclone. About 40 people were inside watching the football World Cup final. The pub's thick doors had been locked and so the gunmen instead fired through the windows, wounding seven people.[34] On 31 July, the IRA shot dead UDA commander Joe Bratty and his right-hand man Raymond Elder.[35]

Investigation and campaign by victims' families

The morning after the attack, the getaway car—a red Triumph Acclaim—was found abandoned in a field near Crossgar.[36] On 4 August, the assault rifle used in the attack was found hidden at a bridge near Saintfield along with a holdall containing boiler suits, balaclavas, gloves, three handguns and ammunition.[37]

The first arrests were made on 18 July 1994, a month after the attack, when six men were arrested as suspects under the terrorism laws. Two of them were re-arrested on 22 August, along with a further suspect. All were released without charge for lack of evidence.[38]

In 2006, following claims that "an RUC agent" had supplied the getaway car to the gunmen, the victims' families lodged an official complaint about the investigation with the Police Ombudsman.[39] The complaint included allegations "that the investigation had not been efficiently or properly carried out; no earnest effort was made to identify those responsible; and there were suspicions of state collusion in the murders". It was alleged that police agents or informers within the UVF were linked to the attack, and that the police's investigation was hindered by its desire to protect those informers. The victims' families also alleged that the police had failed to keep in contact with them about the investigation, even about significant developments.[40]

It was revealed that the police had destroyed key evidence and documents. The car had been disposed of in April 1995, ten months into the investigation.[41] In 1998, police documents related to the investigation were destroyed at Gough Barracks RUC station, allegedly because of fears they were contaminated by asbestos. It is believed they included the original notes, made during interviews of suspects in 1994 and 1995.[42] A hair follicle had been recovered from the car but nobody had yet been charged, while the other items (balaclavas, gloves, etc.) had not been subjected to new tests made possible by advances in forensic science.[43] It was alleged that the rifle used in the attack had been part of a shipment smuggled into Northern Ireland for loyalists by British agent Brian Nelson.[44]

A key eyewitness claimed she gave police a description of the getaway driver within hours of the massacre, but that police failed to record important information she gave them and never asked her to identify suspects. A serving policeman later gave the woman's personal details to a relative of the suspected getaway driver. Police then visited her and advised her to increase her security for fear she could be shot.[45]

The Office of the Police Ombudsman, which investigated the police over the massacre

In 2008 it was revealed that, since the shootings, up to 20 people had been arrested for questioning but none had ever been charged.[46] In January 2010 a reserve Police Service of Northern Ireland officer (formerly an RUC officer) was arrested by detectives from the Police Ombudsman's Office and questioned over "perverting the course of justice" and "aiding the killers' escape".[47][48] Later that year, the Public Prosecution Service (PPS) concluded there wasn't enough evidence to prosecute. In reply, the Ombudsman's Office said it would consider disciplinary action against the officer.[48]

First Police Ombudsman's report

In September 2009 it was revealed that a Police Ombudsman's report on the killings was to be published on 15 September.[10] At the same time, some details of the report were made known. Police sources said the report would expose the role of four RUC informers in "ordering or organising" the attack.[10] The report was also said to highlight a series of major failings in the police investigation – including that not enough effort was made to identify those responsible, that police failed to speak to people of interest, that key evidence was destroyed and that there was poor record management.[43] Shortly after these revelations, the Ombudsman postponed publication of the report as "new evidence" had emerged.[10]

The Ombudsman's report was finally published on 24 June 2011.[49] It said that the police investigation had lacked "diligence, focus and leadership"; that there were failings in record management; that significant lines of enquiry were not identified; and that police failed to communicate effectively with the victims' families. It said that there was "insufficient evidence of collusion" and "no evidence that police could have prevented the attack". The report was harshly criticised for not investigating the role of RUC informers inside the UVF.[50] Social Democratic and Labour Party leader Margaret Ritchie said the findings were flawed and contrary "to a mountain of evidence of collusion". She added: "It completely lets down the victims' families and the wider community. [The Ombudsman] paints a picture of an incompetent keystone cops type of police force when the reality was that the RUC and Special Branch were rotten to the core".[51] Niall Murphy, the solicitor for the victims' relatives, described the report's findings as "timid, mild and meek". He added: "The ombudsman has performed factual gymnastics to ensure there was no evidence of collusion in his conclusion". The relatives stated that they believe the report proves police colluded with those involved and made "no real attempt to catch the killers".[52]

After the report's publication, there were calls for the Ombudsman, Al Hutchinson, to resign, and the victims' families began a High Court challenge to have the report's findings quashed.[53] In September 2011, the Criminal Justice Inspectorate (CJI) criticized Hutchinson and recommended that the Ombudsman's Office be suspended from investigating historic murders because its independence had been compromised. CJI inspectors found "major inconsistencies" in the Ombudsman's report. Ombudsman investigators had demanded to be disassociated from the report because their original findings "were dramatically altered without reason". Ombudsman investigators also believed that key intelligence had been deliberately withheld from them.[54] In 2012, the Belfast High Court quashed the report's findings and Hutchinson was replaced by Michael Maguire, who ordered a new inquiry into the massacre.[11]

Second Police Ombudsman's report

A second Police Ombudsman's report was published in June 2016. The Ombudsman, Michael Maguire, stated: "I have no hesitation in unambiguously determining that collusion is a significant feature of the Loughinisland murders".[55] Among the Ombudsman's findings and conclusions were that:

  • The rifle used in the attack came from a shipment of weapons smuggled into Northern Ireland by loyalists in 1988. Police were aware of the smuggling operation, as informers were involved in it. Much of the weaponry was seized, but "a significant proportion" was not,[56] "despite a number of indicators as to where those weapons could be found".[57]
  • RUC Special Branch identified five suspects to the investigation team the day after the attack. Suspects did not begin to be arrested until one month later. The Ombudsman said these "unexplained delays" meant that "evidential opportunities were probably lost".[58]
  • One of the suspects was an informer,[59] and Special Branch did not pass on all relevant intelligence to those investigating the massacre, in order to "protect" its informers within the UVF. The Ombudsman concluded that the wish to protect informers influenced policing activity and undermined the investigation.[60]
  • The security forces in the area had been "compromised" by having associations with, and sympathies for, loyalist paramilitaries. UVF members had close relatives who worked at local police stations and within the police force itself.[61] A police officer allegedly warned chief suspects on 21 August 1994 that they would be arrested the next morning.[59] The Ombudsman said it was "inexcusable" that police had not investigated this.[62]

The Republic of Ireland's Foreign Minister called the Ombudsman's findings "deeply disturbing".[63]

Documentary

In August 2016, it was reported that Oscar-winning film-maker Alex Gibney was making a documentary film about the massacre, called No Stone Unturned.[64] The film's name comes from Claire Rogan's (widow of Aidan Rogan[7]) statement that police had assured the families they would leave "no stone unturned" in the investigation.[64] Their daughter Emma Rogan—later a Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) for South Down[65]—said the film would be "a permanent memory to the victims and the injustice done".[64] Gibney had earlier directed a shorter documentary about the massacre, named "Ceasefire Massacre", broadcast on 29 April 2014 by ESPN, as part of their 30 for 30 series.[66] No Stone Unturned was released in November 2017.

The film named the main suspects in the massacre, one of whom had been a soldier in the British Army at the time. It claims that in 1995 the wife of a main suspect anonymously told police he was the gunman, and named the others involved.[67] These anonymous messages were noted in the Police Ombudsman's report.[68] Police allegedly recognized her voice because she had worked in a local police station. She and her husband had been arrested and she admitted making the claims, but they had been released without charge.[69]

The film also claims that one of the killers was an informer,[70] and an ex-police officer told the film-makers that Special Branch may have had foreknowledge of the attack. According to the officer, Special Branch told him there was an arrest operation ready to catch the UVF unit, after receiving intelligence from an informer. The informer told Special Branch hours before the attack that it had been called off because of problems with the getaway car. The arrest operation was cancelled, but the attack went ahead.[71]

On 31 August 2018 the Police Service of Northern Ireland arrested Trevor Birney and Barry McCaffrey, two journalists who researched the event, in connection with the theft of material relating to the Ombudsman's investigation, handling stolen goods, and possible breaches of the Official Secrets Act and data protection laws.[72]

In 2020, the High Court in Belfast found the Police Service of Northern Ireland had wrongfully raided the homes of Birney and McCaffrey.[73]

Commemoration

On the 18th anniversary of the attack, the Republic of Ireland football team again played Italy – this time in Euro 2012 at Poznań, Poland. The Irish team wore black armbands during the match, to commemorate those killed while watching the same teams playing 18 years before. The idea was proposed by the Football Association of Ireland (FAI) and backed by UEFA. Some prominent loyalists berated the move. South Belfast UDA brigadier Jackie McDonald said that it was "bringing politics into sport" and would lead to "dire repercussions" for football. Another leading loyalist, Winston Churchill Rea, also raised concerns about the tribute.[74] The victims' families supported the gesture.[74]

See also

References
  1. O'Brien, Brendan. The Long War: The IRA and Sinn Féin. Syracuse University Press, 1999. Page 314.
  2. Elliott, Sydney. Conflict in Northern Ireland: an encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO, 1999. Page 350.
  3. Sluka, Jeffrey. Death Squad: The Anthropology of State Terror. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2000. Page 141.
  4. Cusack, Jim. UVF. Poolbeg, 1997. Page 317.
  5. "The UVF's catalogue of atrocities". BBC News. 18 June 2009.
  6. The Economist newspaper. 25 June 1994. Pages 25–26. "For the 24 fans gathered in Heights Bar in the quiet village of Loughinisland in County Down, the cheering was followed by carnage. Two men walked into the pub and sprayed the room with bullets, killing six and wounding five, and then fled laughing. The Ulster Volunteer Force, a Protestant terrorist group, later claimed it had carried out the attack. It chose the pub only because it knew that those gathered to support Ireland's team would be Catholic".
  7. Duggan, Keith (14 June 2014). "Six men dead: the World Cup massacre". Irish Times. Archived from the original on 15 June 2014. Retrieved 17 July 2017.
  8. "Six shot dead in Ulster World Cup massacre". The Independent. 19 June 1994.
  9. "1994 World Cup massacre of Irish fans by Loyalists will be major ESPN movie". IrishCentral. 12 January 2014.
  10. "RUC informers 'knew about Loughinisland shootings'". The Observer. 13 September 2009.
  11. "Loughinisland massacre: Court quashes Police Ombudsman report". BBC News, 20 December 2012. Retrieved 18 June 2013.
  12. "Loughinisland: Ombudsman confirms collusion between police and loyalist killers". BBC News, 9 June 2016. Retrieved 15 June 2016.
  13. Country Reports on Terrorism: 2004. State Department, Office of the Coordinator for Conterterrorism. p.128
  14. David McKittrick (12 March 2009). "Will loyalists seek bloody revenge?". The Independent. Retrieved 21 June 2011.
  15. Kentucky New Era, 14 April 1992
  16. Mitchell, Thomas G. (2000). "Chapter 7 subsection: The Loyalist terrorists of Ulster, 1969–94". Native vs. Settler. Greenwood Press. pp. 154–165.
  17. "Johnny Adair: Feared Loyalist Leader", BBC News, 6 July 2000. Retrieved on 27 February 2007.
  18. Clayton, Pamela (1996). Enemies and Passing Friends: Settler ideologies in twentieth-century Ulster. Pluto Press. p. 156. More recently, the resurgence in loyalist violence that led to their carrying out more killings than Republicans from the beginning of 1992 until their ceasefire (a fact widely reported in Northern Ireland) was still described as following 'the IRA's well-tested tactic of trying to usurp the political process by violence'…
  19. "Sutton Index of Deaths, 1994". Conflict Archive on the Internet (CAIN). Retrieved 19 February 2010.
  20. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.81
  21. "Loughinisland suspect is detained in England". Belfast Newsletter. 1 July 2008. Retrieved 23 January 2010.
  22. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.8
  23. McKittrick, David. Lost Lives: The Stories of the Men, Women and Children who Died as a Result of the Northern Ireland Troubles. Random House, 2001. p.1367
  24. "Pair held over murders released". BBC News. 6 June 2006. Retrieved 23 January 2010.
  25. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. p.11
  26. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.2
  27. Taylor, Peter (1999). Loyalists. London: Bloomsbury Publishing Plc. p.230
  28. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.82
  29. McDonald and Cusack, pp. 259–70
  30. H. McDonald & J. Cusack (2004) UDA –Inside the Heart of Loyalist Terror, Dublin, Penguin Ireland, p. 269
  31. Brian Feeney,Sinn Féin: A Hundred Turbulent Years, Dublin: O'Brien Press, 2002, pp. 406–407
  32. Biblio Country Reports, Issue 3. Commission of the European Communities. Library (Brussels, Belgium), p. 44
  33. McDonald & Cusack, p. 313
  34. "Publican averted Ulster massacre". The Independent. 19 July 1994.
  35. "CAIN: Chronology of the Conflict 1994". cain.ulster.ac.uk.
  36. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. p.3
  37. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. p.20
  38. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. pp. 119–121
  39. "`Police ignored my evidence' says Loughinisland eyewitness". The Detail. Retrieved 30 August 2017.
  40. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. pp.4–5
  41. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. p.17
  42. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. p.28
  43. "Police Ombudsman postpones Loughinisland murders report". The Irish Times. 11 September 2009. Retrieved 23 January 2010.
  44. 1st Police Ombudsman's report. 24 June 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013. p.21
  45. "'Police ignored my evidence' says Loughinisland eyewitness". The Detail. 28 March 2011. Retrieved 18 June 2013.
  46. "Loughinisland investigation sees questioned man freed". Down Democrat. 9 July 2008. Archived from the original on 29 June 2011. Retrieved 23 January 2010.
  47. "Officer arrested over Loughinisland misconduct probe". BBC News. 23 January 2010. Retrieved 23 January 2010.
  48. "Loughinisland officer could face disciplinary action". BBC News. 24 November 2010. Retrieved 8 December 2010.
  49. Cobain, Ian (15 October 2012). "Northern Ireland loyalist shootings: one night of carnage, 18 years of silence". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 30 August 2017.
  50. "Where was Special Branch in Loughinisland massacre?". The Detail. 24 June 2011.
  51. "Margaret Ritchie wants ombudsman Hutchinson resignation". BBC News. 24 June 2011.
  52. "Loughinisland report: families devastated by findings". BBC News. 24 June 2011.
  53. "Legal move in Loughinisland court case". BBC News. 20 February 2012.
  54. "Police Ombudsman opening new investigation into Loughinisland". The Detail. 19 December 2012. Retrieved 18 June 2013.
  55. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.146
  56. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.134
  57. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.61
  58. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. pp. 118–119, 127
  59. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.117
  60. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. pp.135, 137
  61. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. pp. 77–78
  62. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.136
  63. NI Police colluded with Loyalist killers of six Catholics watching World Cup Irish Central, 11 June 2016
  64. Short, Evan (19 August 2016). "New massacre movie to be seen across the world". Belfast Media Group. Archived from the original on 20 August 2016. Retrieved 17 July 2017.
  65. Simpson, Claire (16 June 2017). "Emma Rogan co-opted to replace Chris Hazzard as South Down Sinn Féin assembly member". Irish News. Archived from the original on 17 July 2017. Retrieved 17 July 2017.
  66. "Ceasefire Massacre - ESPN Films: 30 for 30". www.espn.com.
  67. "Wife of Loughinisland suspect told councillor he was killer, documentary claims". Belfast Telegraph. 2 November 2017.
  68. 2nd Police Ombudsman's report. 9 June 2016. p.126
  69. "Wife of suspected Loughinisland gunman gave his name to police". The Irish News. 2 November 2017.
  70. "Ulster pub massacre families sue amid claims killer was informer". The Sunday Times. 12 November 2017.
  71. "Loughinisland documentary suggests Special Branch had prior knowledge of massacre". The Irish News. 2 November 2017.
  72. "No Stone Unturned". National Union of Journalists.
  73. "Police wrongly obtained warrants to search Loughinisland journalists' homes and offices, High Court rules". Irish News.
  74. "Ireland's Euro 2012 armband match tribute to UVF massacre victims slammed". Belfast Telegraph. Brian Rowan. 14 June 2012 Retrieved 19 June 2012

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.