Mad Man Pondo

Canady began his professional wrestling career in 1989 at the age of 20.[4] Initially performing as a traditional professional wrestler, Canady realized that he would not become a nationally recognized talent.[4][5] He noticed that his friends were in awe while watching wrestling tapes of death matches, and soon adopted the same hardcore style himself.[4][5] He created his ring name Mad Man Pondo as a play on Abdullah the Butcher's nickname the "Mad Man from Sudan" and the character Pondo Sinatra from The Party Animal.[4] He and fellow wrestlers Corporal Robinson and 2 Tuff Tony began traveling throughout the country together early in their careers.[6] Video distribution company Smart Mark Video helped the trio gain national exposure.[6]

Canady began working for Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South (IWA-MS) in 1997. In 1999, he volunteered to get into a rivalry with 2 Tuff Tony to help introduce him to the hardcore wrestling style of the company.[7] Pondo acquainted him to the proper techniques of hardcore wrestling, and Tony later recalled that Pondo "took good care of me" in their matches.[7] On April 15, Canady became the first IWA Mid-South Hardcore Champion.[8] He lost the title to Tony two weeks later before winning it back the following month.[8] Canady lost the championship to Tony the next day, but won the IWA Mid-South Heavyweight Championship that September.[8][9]

In 2003, he participated in the King of the Deathmatch Tournament. Canady defeated Nate Webb, Axl Rotten, then Nick Gage to make it to the finals.[10] In the final match, he defeated J.C. Bailey to be crowned the 2003 King of the Deathmatch.[10] On March 18, 2006, Canady and Ian Rotten defeated Iron Saints to become the IWA Mid-South Tag Team Championship.[11] The duo lost the championship five months later.[11] That November, Canady and 2 Tuff Tony took part in the first Double Death Tag Team Tournament, though they weren't told which team would win the tournament.[7] They defeated Children of Pain then Dysfunction and Corporal Robinson to make it to the finals. In the finals, he and Tony defeated Tough Crazy Bastards to be crowned the first Double Death Tag Team Tournament champions.[7]

He later went on and lost in the second round of the 2008 King of the Deathmatch Tournament.[12]

In 1997, Canady wrestled for Insane Clown Posse at the event ICP's Strangle-Mania Live.[13] Two years later, he, 2 Tuff Tony, and Corporal Robinson wrestled at the Dan Curtis Memorial, an independent wrestling booker who had recently worked for Insane Clown Posse.[6][14] Several days after the event, Tony, Robinson, and Canady were booked to wrestle for Insane Clown Posse's first Juggalo Championship Wrestling show.[6] Canady teamed with Pete Madden to defeat Ian Rotten and Corporal Robinson in an Exploding Barbwire match.

The following year, Canady participated in the "Strangle-Mania Live Tour". His Hardcore match with Fat Fuck Barrel Boy was put on JCW, Vol. 2.[15] Canady began appearing every year at the annual Gathering of the Juggalos and quickly became a staple in the company. In 2003, he and Necro Butcher fought in a deathmatch which was released on JCW, Vol. 3.[16] Soon after, the two men began teaming together. At the 2005 Gathering of the Juggalos, Canaday defeated champion Terry Funk to become JCW Heavyweight Champion. He held the title for over a year before losing it to Corporal Robinson at the Hallowicked After Party 2006.

The following year, Canady went on tour with JCW to film the internet wrestling show SlamTV!. On the first episode, Insane Clown Posse announced that the JCW Tag Team Championship had been vacated, which caused several tag teams to emerge.[17] Canady aligned himself with Necro Butcher, and the team dominated competition for several weeks.[17] However, animosity grew between the two as miscommunication cost both members multiple matches. The following weeks saw the duo break out into fist fights, which led to a series of matches between them.[17] The team reunited at "East Side Wars", though, and eventually established themselves as top contenders for the vacant tag team title.[18] At Bloodymania, the duo won an 8 Team Tag-Team Elimination match to become the new JCW Tag Team Champions.[18] The reign was short lived, however, as Necro Butcher signed a contract with Ring of Honor, forcing Canady to team with several partners. At a live event in Cleveland, Ohio on January 26, 2008, Canady and his partner Breyer Wellington lost the title to 2 Tuff Tony and Violent J.[19]

Canady also wrestled at both Bloodymania II and Bloodymania III in singles matches.[20][21] At Big Ballas X-Mas Party 2009, Canady and Necro teamed up again to face the Thomaselli Brothers.[22] On May 21, 2010, while touring with JCW on Insane Clown Posse's "Happy Daze Tour," Pondo defeated Corporal Robinson to become a two-time JCW Heavyweight Champion.[23] In a rematch ten days later, Pondo lost the championship to Robinson in a Four Corners of Pain match.[24] At Bloodymania IV, Canady and Necro Butcher lost to the team of Balls Mahoney and Hollywood Chuck Hogan.[25]

On March 9, 2011, at Hardcore Hell, the team of Pondo and Necro Butcher defeated The Haters in a hardcore Barbed Wire, Thumbtacks, and Ladders match for their second JCW Tag Team Championship.[26] The duo lost their championship to Ring Rydas the following month.[27]

At Bloodbath 2000, Canady and Ian Rotten wrestled to a draw in his debut match in Combat Zone Wrestling. He continued wrestling for the company, while also participating in their talent exchange with the Japanese company Big Japan Pro Wrestling.[7] Canady won the CZW Iron Man Championship on June 9, but lost it the following September.[28] During his time with the company, Canady was made an honorary member of the stable the H8 Club.

Canady begin wrestling in Big Japan Pro Wrestling in 2000 as a part of the talent exchange between the company and Combat Zone Wrestling.[4][7] He wrestled singles matches under the name Original Foolish Foreigner before changing his name back to Mad Man Pondo. The talent exchange between the companies stopped in 2001 when Combat Zone Wrestling demanded more money.[7] Big Japan Pro Wrestling refused, so CZW pulled all of their talent from Japan.[7] Canady, however, refused to leave because the fans and the company treated him well.[7]

He was later named the American booker for Big Japan Pro Wrestling and brought in talent from the states, including 2 Tuff Tony. He and Tony soon formed the tag team Baka Gaijin, Japanese for Stupid Foreigners.[7] The team was well received by both the Japanese crowd and the Japanese wrestlers.[7] They continued to wrestle multiple tours together from 2001 to 2006, while Canady continued singles tours until 2008.[4][7]