Severus of Antioch

Severus was born in the city of Sozopolis in Pisidia in c. 459,[3] or c. 465,[4] into an affluent Christian family, however, later monophysite sources would assert that his parents were pagan.[5] His father was a senator in the city,[6] and his paternal grandfather,[3] also named Severus,[7] was the Bishop of Sozopolis and had attended the Council of Ephesus in 431.[6] According to Severus' hagiography, he was named after his paternal grandfather as he had received a vision in which he was told, "the child who is for your son will strengthen Orthodoxy, and his name will be after your name".[7]

After his father's death,[6] in 485, Severus travelled to Alexandria in Egypt to study grammar, rhetoric,[8] and philosophy,[5] in both Greek and Latin.[9] At Alexandria, he met Zacharias of Mytilene, a fellow student and friend, who persuaded him to read the works of Gregory of Nazianzus, and Basil of Caesarea, in particular his correspondence with Libanius. According to Zacharias, whilst students at Alexandria, he and Severus discovered and destroyed a hoard of pagan idols at the neighbouring city of Menouthis.[6]

In the autumn of 486,[6] Severus travelled to Berytus in Phoenicia and studied law and philosophy at the law school,[9] where he was later joined by Zacharias in 487.[6] At Berytus, Severus and Zacharias led the expulsion of necromancers and enchanters from the city, and Severus began to dedicate his free time to studying the works of the Fathers of the Church. At this time, he joined a group of students led by a certain Evagrius who prayed together at the Church of the Resurrection every evening. Severus was convinced to be baptised, as he had not yet undergone baptism due to Pisidian custom in which men could not be baptised until they had grown a beard.[6] In 488,[5] he was baptised at the Church of Saint Leontius at Tripolis with Evagrius as his sponsor.[6]

Severus subsequently adopted an ascetic life whereby he rejected bathing and adopted fasting. He initially intended to return to Pisidia and practise law, however, after a pilgrimage to the Church of Saint Leontius in Tripolis, the head of John the Baptist at Emesa, and Jerusalem, he resolved to join Evagrius and become a monk.[6] Severus entered the monastery of Peter the Iberian near Maiuma in Palestine, a prominent centre of non-Chalcedonianism, and remained there for several years.[10] He later joined a monastic brotherhood in the desert near Eleutheropolis under the archimandrite Mamas.[11] Severus practised asceticism in the desert until c. 500,[10] at which time he became ill and was convinced to recover at the Monastery of Saint Romanus in Maiuma,[12] where he was ordained a priest by Epiphanius, Bishop of Magydus.[10] At Maiuma, Severus received his inheritance from his parents; he shared the property with his brothers, donated most of his share to the poor,[12] and constructed a monastery.[9]

On a walk outside the city, Severus came upon a hermit who left his cave to call out, "welcome to you Severus, teacher of Orthodoxy, and Patriarch of Antioch", despite never meeting Severus, the hermit thus prophesied Severus' ascension to the patriarchal throne.[7] He remained at his monastery until 507/508, at which time Nephalius, a Chalcedonian monk, arrived at Maiuma and preached against Severus and other non-Chalcedonians.[6] In 508, Nephalius wrote an apologia of the Council of Chalcedon,[13] to which Severus replied in his two Orationes ad Nephalium.[10] In the same year, Patriarch Elias of Jerusalem commissioned Nephalius to expel non-Chalcedonian monks from their monasteries in Palestine, and Severus was sent to Constantinople to complain to Emperor Anastasius.[14]

Severus travelled to Constantinople alongside 200 non-Chalcedonian monks,[9] and gained favour with the emperor soon after his arrival.[13] Patriarch Macedonius II of Constantinople attempted to sway Anastasius to support the Council of Chalcedon and presented the emperor with a collection of edited excerpts from the works of Cyril of Alexandria, an important Father of the Church who had died prior to the council.[13] Severus, however, wrote Philalethes, and refuted Macedonius as the work of Cyril presented to the emperor was shown to be taken out of context.[13] At Constantinople, Severus became friends with Julian, Bishop of Halicarnassus.[15] Under Severus' influence, in 510, Anastasius allowed non-Chalcedonians to retake their monasteries, and, in 510/511, the emperor issued a typos (edict) that adopted the non-Chalcedonian interpretation of the Henotikon as law.[16] After Macedonius' deposition and his succession by Timothy I, a non-Chalcedonian, in August 511, Severus returned to his monastery in Palestine.[6]

In 512, Flavian II, Patriarch of Antioch, was deposed by Anastasius,[16] and a synod was held at Laodicea in Syria to elect a successor.[5] Severus was elected on 6 November and consecrated at the Great Church of Antioch on 16 November.[17] The consecration ceremony was attended by the bishops Dionysius of Tarsus, Nicias of Laodicea, Philoxenus of Hierapolis, Peter of Beroea, Simeon of Chalcis, Marion of Sura, Eusebius of Gabbula, Silvanus of Urima, Sergius of Cyrrhus, John of Europus, Philoxenus of Doliche, and Iulianus of Salamias.[18] During the consecration ceremony, he affirmed the councils of Nicaea, Constantinople, and Ephesus, and the Henotikon.[19] Despite orders from Anastasius to not act or speak against the Council of Chalcedon,[20] Severus condemned the council, as well as Pope Leo's Tome, Nestorius, Eutyches, Diodorus of Tarsus, Theodore of Mopsuestia, Ibas of Edessa, Barsauma, and Cyrus and John of Aigai.[19] However, Severus could not be heard due to shouting and commotion, and he signed a declaration of faith at the ceremony's conclusion.[17]

Upon his consecration, Severus had the baths at the patriarchal palace destroyed and the cooks sent away, in keeping with his abstinence from bathing and eating.[19] He was accepted as Patriarch of Antioch by Patriarch Timothy I of Constantinople and Pope John of Alexandria, but Patriarch Elias of Jerusalem and other bishops refused to acknowledge him.[6] Couriers taking synodical letters from Severus to Jerusalem were expelled from the city by Sabbas and a crowd congregated at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre and chanted, "anathema to Severus and his fellow communicants".[21] Within Syria, Severus was popular amongst the population of the province of Syria Prima, which had largely adopted non-Chalcedonianism, whereas the province of Syria Secunda, which was home to a large Greek population who favoured Chalcedonianism, was hostile towards Severus.[21]

A synod was held at Tyre in Phoenicia in c. 514, at which the Council of Chalcedon and Leo's Tome was denounced, and Severus declared that the Henotikon had annulled the acts of the Council of Chalcedon.[19] Severus began to exchange letters with Sergius the Grammarian at this time as Sergius had written to Antoninus, Bishop of Aleppo, who had asked Severus to respond.[22] Sergius argued that the Synod of Tyre had made serious concessions to Chalcedonians,[22] to which Severus responded with a treatise against Sergius.[9] As patriarch, Severus and Peter, Archbishop of Apamea, were alleged to have hired Jewish mercenaries to kill 250 Chalcedonian pilgrims and leave their bodies unburied by the roadside.[23] Chalcedonians also claimed that the monasteries that the pilgrims had fled to were set alight and the monks that had protected them were also killed.[23] Between 514 and 518,[24] John of Caesarea wrote an apologia of the Council of Chalcedon in response to Severus' Philalethes.[22] Severus wrote a treatise in defence of Philalethes, and began work on a reply to John of Caesarea.[9]

Following Anastasius' death and his succession by Emperor Justin I in July 518, the bishops of Syria Secunda travelled to Constantinople and clamoured for Severus' deposition.[25] Justin demanded Severus affirmed the Council of Chalcedon, to which he refused,[7] and the emperor subsequently ordered Irenaeus, Count of the East, to arrest Severus and cut out his tongue.[23] Theodora, wife of Justinian, Justin's nephew and heir, discovered Justin's orders and warned Severus.[7] On 25 September 518,[9] Severus fled Antioch by boat to Alexandria, where he was well received by Pope Timothy III of Alexandria and the city's inhabitants.[23] Severus' arrival in Egypt is celebrated by the Coptic Orthodox Church on 12 October.[26] Despite his deposition, Severus did not cease to be seen as the legitimate Patriarch of Antioch by non-Chalcedonians.[27]

During his exile in Egypt, Severus resided at the monastery of the Ennaton with Pope Timothy,[15] and is known to have performed a number of miracles.[7] He completed his three volume book,[9] liber contra impium grammaticum, against John of Caesarea in c. 519.[19] In his exile, Julian of Halicarnassus also took up residence at the monastery of the Ennaton and exchanged letters with Severus on the topic of the body of Christ.[6] Whereas Julian had adopted aphthartodocetism, which argued that the body of Christ was incorruptible, Severus argued that the body of Christ was corruptible until the resurrection.[6] He wrote five treatises against Julian,[15] who responded in peri aphtharsias and an apologia.[28] The non-Chalcedonian community was quickly divided between "Severians", followers of Severus, and aphthartodocetae,[6] and divisions remained unresolved until 527.[22] The Severians were also known as the Pthartolatrae.[29]

Emperor Justinian, who succeeded his uncle Justin in 527, held a three-day synod at the Palace of Hormisdas in the spring of 532 at Constantinople to restore unity to the church through dialogue between five Chalcedonians and five or more non-Chalcedonians.[30] The emperor invited Severus and promised immunity,[19] however, he chose not to attend on the grounds of age and as he was accused of corruption and bribery, which he vehemently denied.[31] In c. 534, the non-Chalcedonian community faced further division with the separation of the Themistians from the Severians after their leader, Themistius, a deacon at Alexandria, advocated a more extreme belief of Christ's corruptibility.[32] At the invitation of Justinian, in the winter of 534/535,[33] Severus travelled to Constantinople alongside Peter of Apamea and the monk Zooras.[34] At this time, Anthimus, Archbishop of Trebizond, was consecrated Patriarch of Constantinople and refused to affirm the Council of Chalcedon.[35] Severus successfully convinced Anthimus to adopt a position in line with himself and Pope Theodosius I of Alexandria.[30]

Severus' fortunes were quickly overturned as Pope Agapetus I of Rome arrived at Constantinople in March 536.[30] Agapetus swayed Justinian to adopt a firm Chalcedonian position and Anthimus was replaced by Menas.[35] Menas held a synod from 2 May to 4 June,[34] at the conclusion of which Severus, Anthimus, Peter of Apamea, and Zooras were excommunicated.[36] On 6 August 536, Justinian issued an edict that charged Severus, Anthimus, Peter, and Zooras with Nestorianism and Eutychianism, banned Severus' books,[35] and banished them from the capital and all major cities.[34] Severus fled Constantinople with the aid of Empress Theodora and returned to Egypt.[35] He resided at the residence of Dorotheus in the city of Sakha until his death on 5 February 538.[37][38] Dorotheus had Severus' body moved to the Zogag Monastery, and the relocation of the his body is celebrated on 19 December.[38]