Is This the Life We Really Want?

Is This the Life We Really Want? was recorded in Los Angeles and London.[2] It was produced by Radiohead producer Nigel Godrich, who met Waters when he produced the 2015 live album Roger Waters: The Wall.[2] Though Waters had not heard Godrich's work with Radiohead, they got on well and discussed working together.[2] Godrich, a fan of Waters' work with Pink Floyd, was frank with Waters, telling him he found some of his solo work "unlistenable". However, he was reassured that Waters "really still had it" after hearing his demo of "Déjà Vu".[3]

Godrich wanted to create a pared-back album to showcase Waters "the poet".[3] He felt Waters' creativity had been invigorated by the Wall Live tour, and that his role as producer was "to push him a little bit".[3] He encouraged Waters to make a concise record, reminding him that Pink Floyd's 1973 album The Dark Side of the Moon is only 43 minutes long.[2] Unlike most of Waters' work, Waters did not co-produce the record; he said: "[Godrich] did a brilliant job ... I sat on my hands with lips zipped. You've rented this dog, let it work."[4] Godrich used tape loops and found sounds extensively to make the album's segues. He is also credited for arrangement, sound collages, keyboards, guitar, and mixing.[5]

Is This the Life We Really Want, a concept album,[6] was conceived as a radio play about a man and his granddaughter investigating why children are being killed in other parts of the world.[6] Waters described the play as "part magic carpet ride, part political rant, part anguish", and featured about a dozen songs.[2] Godrich persuaded Waters to abandon the theatrical elements and create a "far less linear" work.[6] Waters said he planned to produce the original idea in the future.[6]

Waters said of the album's themes:[6]

The concerns I have with that central question – "Why are we killing the children?" – are still there. I'm still deeply concerned that we're killing children all over the world with hardly a second thought because we've become so insensitive to the idea of every time the curtain falls on some forgotten life, it is because we stood by silent and indifferent – it's normal. I'm quoting from the record now. And unfortunately, it has become normal; we have normalized the death of the innocent.

Waters also said the album had been influenced by having fallen in love:[2]

The record is really about love – which is what all of my records have been about, in fact ... It's also the question of how do we take these moments of love – if we are granted any in our lives – and allow that love to shine on the rest of existence, on others.

Is This the Life We Really Want? was released on 2 June 2017 by Columbia Records.[7] It was Waters' first solo album since Amused to Death (1992).[8] The album peaked at number 3 in the United Kingdom and number 11 in the United States before falling off the US charts in four weeks. It produced four singles: "Smell the Roses" released on 20 April, "Déjà Vu" released on 8 May, "The Last Refugee" released on 19 May and "Wait for Her" released on 19 July in 2017. The album was blocked from release in Italy after the artist Emilio Isgrò alleged that the cover art plagiarised his work.[9]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	72/100[10]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[11]
Consequence of Sound	B[12]
Drowned in Sound	8/10[13]
Exclaim!	7/10[14]
The Independent	[15]
The Observer	[16]
Pitchfork	6.9/10[17]
Rolling Stone	[18]
Sputnikmusic	4.1/5[19]

At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from critics, the album received an average score of 72, based on 16 reviews, indicating "generally favorable reviews".[10] Rolling Stone said: "The music is quintessential post-Dark Side Of The Moon Floyd, but channeled by offspring: producer Nigel Godrich brings prog-rock grandeur, multi-instrumentalist Jonathan Wilson microdose psychedelia, Lucius alt-R&B backing vocals."[18] Drowned in Sound said the album is "a long, sprawling epic that stretches out for its slightly-padded running time, but one so full of ideas and intricacies that it's an easy album to get sucked into."[13] Consequence of Sound said the album "is easily the most accessible of Waters' solo work—a distillation in many regards of the anti-fascist, anti-imperialist, anti-greed messages he's been broadcasting since Pink Floyd."[12] Pitchfork said the "myriad sonic references to his work with Pink Floyd suggest that Waters is comfortable with his past. The more you accept how much his past reflects in his present, the more receptive you'll be to this album's charms."[17]

All tracks are written by Roger Waters, except "Wait for Her", written by Waters & Mahmoud Darwish.

• Roger Waters – vocals, acoustic guitar, bass guitar
• Nigel Godrich – keyboards, guitar, sound collages, arrangements
• Gus Seyffert – guitar, keyboards, bass guitar
• Jonathan Wilson – guitar, keyboards
• Roger Joseph Manning, Jr. – keyboards
• Lee Pardini – keyboards
• Joey Waronker – drums
• Jessica Wolfe – vocals
• Holly Laessig – vocals
• David Campbell – string arrangements

• Is This the Life We Really Want? at AllMusic
• Is This the Life We Really Want? at Discogs (list of releases)
• Is This the Life We Really Want? at Metacritic
• Roger Waters new album – "Is This The Life We Really Want?" on YouTube