The Doughnut

The construction of the Doughnut in 2003 consolidated the operations previously spread across two sites into a single location, replacing more than 50 buildings in the process.[3] The last staff from the nearby GCHQ site at Oakley were transferred to the Doughnut in late 2011.[9]

The design of the Doughnut reflects GCHQ's intended new mode of work after the end of the Cold War, with its design facilitating talking among staff, and between them and the Director of GCHQ and his subordinates.[3] It was estimated that anyone in the building could reach any other worker within five minutes.[3] The director of GCHQ has no office; in 2014 director Iain Lobban described his desk as being located "within the shouting distance of lawyers".[5]

The Doughnut from Leckhampton Hill, 2010

At a cost of £330m, the construction of the Doughnut was funded by a private finance initiative (PFI) put forward by a collective that included the British facilities management and construction company Carillion (now defunct), the Danish security company Group 4/Falck (now G4S), and the British telecommunications company BT Group.[3] The consortium are scheduled to be paid £800m to maintain the Doughnut for 30 years. The creation of the Doughnut was the largest PFI project to date for the British government.[3] The building was designed by the British architect Chris Johnson for the American architectural firm Gensler, and constructed and built by Carillion.[10]

In 2004 the chairman of the Commons Public Accounts Committee, Edward Leigh, criticised the increasing cost of GCHQ's move to the Doughnut.[11] Leigh said that "It was astonishing GCHQ did not realise the extent of what would be involved much sooner".[11] Leigh had said in 2003 that GCHQ's original estimate for the cost of the move was "staggeringly inaccurate".[12]

For security reasons, GCHQ moved its own computers and technical infrastructure to the Doughnut, which caused the cost of its move to increase from £41m to £450m over two years.[11] The moves of MI5 and the SIS to new buildings had also cost more than three times their original estimates due to issues with transferring computers.[13] HM Treasury paid £216m toward a newly agreed budget of £308m, having initially refused to finance the original high figure.[11] The final cost of GCHQ's move to their new headquarters was more than seven times the original estimate.[12]

The complexity of the computer network at GCHQ was responsible for the increase in costs. Issues with the network were found while preparing computers for the "Millennium bug". Simply shutting down each computer individually before restarting them in the Doughnut would have left GCHQ unable to complete key intelligence work for two years, while moving their electronics according to the original schedule without "unacceptable damage" to intelligence gathering would cost £450m.[12] In a review of GCHQ's move in 2003, the National Audit Office said government ministers might never have approved the consolidation of facilities had the final cost been known.[12]

The Doughnut is divided into three separate four-story structures, identical in design and connected at the top and bottom.[3][14] With a total floor area of 140,000 square metres (1,500,000 sq ft), the building contains two circular blocks, internally divided by a "street" covered in glass.[3][14] Construction materials were primarily steel, aluminium, and stone, particularly granite and local limestone from the Cotswolds; designers incorporated recycled materials in the steelwork and the construction of desks.[3] The design of the Doughnut was subsequently nominated for an award to "highlight improvements to the built and landscaped environment" given by Cheltenham's Civic Society.[15]

A circular walkway named "The Street" runs throughout the building.[16] An open-air garden courtyard lies in the middle of the Doughnut; this garden is large enough to contain the Royal Albert Hall.[1] The courtyard has a memorial to GCHQ staff who have been killed on active service; some five staff died in the War in Afghanistan.[5] Below the garden are banks of supercomputers.[3] The Doughnut is 21 metres (70 ft) high and 180 metres (600 ft) in diameter.[1] Individual spaces in the Doughnut include the 24/7/365 area where people working in "small 12-hour shifts monitor GCHQ systems and news bulletins."[5] The 'Action On' programme enables the 24/7/365 staff to act "quickly and freely" to supply information to British armed forces to help their operations.[5] The Doughnut's Internet Ops Centre (INOC), is where "the best technical capabilities [are matched] with the most urgent operational requirements" according to Charles Moore who visited the Doughnut in 2014 for The Daily Telegraph.[5]

The structure of the Doughnut is designed to minimise any potential effect of a fire or a terrorist attack on the building; it also includes independent power generators which can supply power to the facilities in an emergency.[3] About 3,000 kilometres (1,850 mi) of fibre optics were installed in the Doughnut by British Telecom, and about 10,000 km (6,000 mi) of electrical wiring were used in the building.[3]

The Doughnut is surrounded by car and bicycle parking in concentric rings, guarded by a two-metre metal fence and half a dozen vehicle checkpoints.[1][4] The Doughnut is served by an underground road.[1]

Facilities available to staff at the Doughnut include a 600-seat restaurant, shops, a gym, and a prayer or quiet room.[3] Exhibits from the history of GCHQ are displayed throughout the building, including the radios used by the Portland Spy Ring.[16]

The Doughnut was officially opened in 2004 by Queen Elizabeth II and the Duke of Edinburgh.[17] In 2008, the then Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, Gordon Brown, visited the Doughnut and praised the staff working there in a speech.[18] The Doughnut has twice been visited by Charles, Prince of Wales, since its opening.[19] Charles was accompanied by Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall in 2011, on his second visit to the Doughnut.[19]

The Doughnut was already too small for the number of GCHQ staff at its completion, as a vast expansion in the number of employees had occurred as a consequence of the September 11 attacks in 2001.[7] The staff numbered almost 6,500 by 2008.[7] The addition of a two-storey office block and a three-storey car park to the Doughnut was proposed in 2008, but eventually suspended in 2011.[20] The new buildings were intended to facilitate the arrival of 800 staff from GCHQ's former site at Oakley.[20] Though it was initially felt that the Doughnut would be adequate for the new staff, 600 contractors working on technical projects for GCHQ were eventually relocated in a secret undisclosed building in the 'Gloucestershire area'.[20] The parking of cars by GCHQ staff on residential roads has caused 'annoyance' among local residents in Benhall.[20] It was believed that the arrival of new staff may have further affected local parking but GCHQ stated the presence of the new employees would have been offset by redundancies.[20]

On 1 June 2007 the building and its grounds were designated as a protected site for the purposes of Section 128 of the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act 2005. The effect of the act was to make it a specific criminal offence for a person to trespass into the site.[21]

Access to the Doughnut is rarely granted to representatives from the media, but it was visited for the March 2010 BBC Radio 4 documentary GCHQ: Cracking the Code,[16] by Charles Moore for an interview with GCHQ director Iain Lobban for The Daily Telegraph in October 2014,[5] and by historian and writer Ben Macintyre who visited the Doughnut for a series of articles for The Times in October 2015 in anticipation of the draft Investigatory Powers Bill.[22]

The three other headquarters of British intelligence agencies;

• The SIS Building – Headquarters of the Secret Intelligence Service (known as MI6)
• Thames House – Headquarters of the Security Service (known as MI5)
• Northwood Headquarters and Ministry of Defence Main Building - Headquarters of Defence Intelligence (DI)

Bibliography

• Aldrich, Robert J. (2011). GCHQ. London: Harper Press. ISBN 978-0-00-731266-5.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)

• Gloucestershire Echo - Pictures of the construction of the Doughnut and the demolition of GCHQ's old buildings in Cheltenham