British Rail Class 17

The British Rail Class 17 (also known as the Clayton Type 1) was a class of 117 Bo-Bo diesel-electric locomotives built 1962–1965 by Clayton Equipment Company and their sub-contractor Beyer, Peacock & Co., on behalf of British Railways (BR).

Clayton Type 1
British Railways Class 17
D8524 in August 1968.
Type and origin
Power typeDiesel-electric
BuilderClayton Equipment Company & Beyer, Peacock & Co.
Build date1962–1965
Total produced117
Specifications
Configuration:
  UICBo'Bo'
  CommonwealthBo-Bo
Gauge4 ft 8 12 in (1,435 mm) standard gauge
Wheel diameter3 ft 3 12 in (1,003 mm)[1]
Minimum curve230 feet (3.5 chains; 70 m)[1]
Wheelbase36 ft 6 in (11,130 mm)[1]
Length50 ft 7 12 in (15,430 mm)[1]
Width8 ft 9 12 in (2,680 mm)[1]
Height12 ft 8 in (3,860 mm)[1]
Loco weight68 long tons (69 t; 76 short tons)[1]
Fuel capacity500 imp gal (2,300 L; 600 US gal)[1]
Prime moverPaxman 6ZHXL, (2 of)
except D8586–8587: Rolls Royce 'D' type V8, (2 of)
DisplacementPaxman:
2× 29.4 L (1,790 cu in) = 58.8 L (3,590 cu in)
GeneratorD8500–D8587: GEC WT800, GEC WT auxiliary
D8588–D8616: Crompton Parkinson main and auxiliary
Traction motorsGEC WT421, nose-suspended, with single-reduction gear (4 of)
Cylinder sizePaxman:
7 in (178 mm) diameter
7 34 in (197 mm) stroke
TransmissionDiesel electric
MU workingD8500–D8587 Red Diamond
D8588–D8616 Blue Star
Train heatingNone; through steam pipe
Train brakesVacuum
Performance figures
Maximum speed60 mph (97 km/h)
Power outputEngines: 450 hp (336 kW) @ 1500 rpm × 2
Tractive effortMaximum: 40,000 lbf (178 kN)[1]
Continuous: 18,000 lbf (80.1 kN) @ 13 mph (21 km/h)[1]
Brakeforce35 long tons-force (350 kN)
Career
OperatorsBritish Railways
NumbersD8500–D8616
Axle load classRoute availability 4
Retired1968–1971
PreservedD8568
Scrapped1968-71, 1975
Current ownerChinnor and Princes Risborough Railway
DispositionOne preserved, remainder scrapped.

During the 1950s and 1960s, BR procured a wide range of Type 1 diesel locomotives, many of which under the Pilot Scheme. However, several officials felt that the single-cabbed arranged used by the majority of Type 1s presented visibility difficulties to drivers in the 'less convenient' direction. Thus, BR approached several manufacturers, seeking a new locomotives that had a centre cab and low bonnets to maximise visibility. Clayton were selected to produce their proposed locomotive as the Class 17. Its low engine covers required the use of a pair of Paxman 6ZHXL six-cylinder horizontal engines, which had been intended for powering railcars; it was a somewhat unorthodox arrangement for the era.

Production of the Class 17 was undertaken between 1962 and 1965, with those produced being assigned to the north of Britain and the Scottish region. Early on, it was determined that the locomotive was not suited to heavy freight trains, and quickly acquired a reputation for unreliability largely due to its engines, which continued to deliver poor performance even after extensive modifications. The Class 17 proved to be one of the least successful of the Type 1s. Withdrawals took place from the late 1960s to 1971, some locomotives having a working life of less than five years. Several were sold to industrial users, only one example has been preserved.

Background

The Type 1 was the lowest power classification for BR mainline diesels. Under BR's 'Pilot Scheme', three different designs of Type 1 locomotive had been produced. Two of these (Classes 15 and 16 under the TOPS classification system) had a layout based on the 10800 prototype, with a single off-centre cab and full-height engine covers, from which forward visibility for the crew was poor in both directions of travel, while the third (Class 20) had its cab at one end, giving good visibility in that direction only.

Having gained experience with these types, although Class 20 was widely considered to be a technical success, BR decided that it would be desirable to have a single-cab Type 1 locomotive that provided good forward visibility in both directions. The organisation thus approached various locomotive manufacturers with its request for proposals to meet its requirement.[1] Amongst those companies that chose to respond was the British manufacturing interest Clayton Equipment Company, which had already acquiring considerable experience in the design and production of various mechanical elements of existing Type 1 locomotives, and was keen to pursue its own design. Following a review of submissions, BR opted to select Clayton's submission, ordering 117 locomotives off the drawing board, and announced to the railway press that these locos were to be the new Type 1 standard.[2]:59

Between September 1962 and February 1965, production of locomotives D8500-D8587 was performed in house by Clayton, while subcontractor Beyer, Peacock and Company of Manchester delivered D8588-D8616 between March 1964 and April 1965.[1]

Design

The Class 17 locomotive incorporated several features that were relatively novel amongst its contemporaries; to achieve the desired visibility from a single cab, it was decided to place it in a central position and use relatively low engine bays.[1] This arrangement heavily contributed to a key design choice; despite the widespread availability of engines capable of generating sufficient power on their own, the propulsion arrangement opted for was a pair of relatively small six-cylinder horizontal engines, each being placed on either side of the cab. According to the manufacturer, the increased maintenance costs of two engines over a single unit was a worthwhile tradeoff for the improved visibility enabled by such an arrangement.[1]

The majority of Class 17s were powered by a pair of Paxman 6ZHXL engines of 450 hp (340 kW) each,[3] an engine originally intended for diesel railcars, but not adopted.[4] The last two of the Clayton-built batch, D8586-D8587, each had a pair of Rolls Royce Type D 450 hp (340 kW) engines. These units also suffered several crankcase failures, leading to two of the four being replaced by Paxman units.[5] The propulsion arrangement also featured an electric transmission, rather than a hydraulic counterpart; this was a somewhat unusual design choice for the era as the vast majority of contemporary twin-engined locomotives had opted for hydraulic tranmissions.[1]

Fuel was supplied from a single tank mounted in a central position.[1] To prevent overfilling of the tank, an auto-cutoff system was integrated; several other warning systems, such as the fluid level of the radiator header tank, were also present. A total of four GEC WT421 traction motors, each rated for 157 hp of continuous power at 480 rpm, delivered power to the wheels via a 15/66 reduction gear.[1] All four motors could be driven by a single engine, if desired by the driver. The motor armatures were highly balanced to reduce vibration levels; further features included for operational convenience and safety were a relay-based automatic wheelslip detection system, which reduced power without driver intervention, and an automated fire-suppression system that discharged bottled carbon dioxide into the applicable engine bay if excessive temperatures were detected.[1]

The cab features two identically-configured driving positions, one facing in either direction.[1] Large armor plate windows cover the majority of the forward and rear cab walls; in combination with sliding side-facing windows, these provide a high level of exterior visibility to the driver. The cab itself with largely built out of steel, with the space between the interior and exterior surfaces was lined with fibreglass and other materials for both soundproofing and heating purposes.[1] While not included in BR's requirement, the manufacturer opted to include provisions for a steam boiler to be installed in the cab area; this was to enable the Class 17 to potentially haul passenger services, which would require heating to be generated by the locomotive. In addition to steam heating, electrically-heated carriages could also be handled by the type.[1] The Clayton-built Class 17s had 'red diamond' control equipment, while the Beyer Peacock batch had the standard 'blue star' type. A maximum of three Class 17s could work in multiple with one another, as well as other types.[1]

The superstructure is divided into three distinct sections, the cab and the two equipment casings.[1] This is borne upon an underframe, which is entirely composes of welded steel and featuring full-length deep-section longitudinal beams, having been designed to withstand buffeting forces of up to 200 tons. Jacking and lifting brackets were incorporated as to better facilitate maintenance and static transportation of the locomotive alike.[1] Several pieces of equipment, such as the lead acid batteries, were accommodated beneath the underframe Provisions were also made for the installation of a standard BR snow plough.[1]

Operations

Introduction and early service

Distribution of locomotives,
August/October 1967[6]
12A
52A
64B
66A
CodeNameQuantity
12AKingmoor7
52AGateshead18
64BHaymarket39
66APolmadie53
Total: 117

The Clayton examples were delivered to the Scottish Region depots at Polmadie and Haymarket, although some later migrated to Kingmoor on the London Midland Region. The Beyer Peacock locomotives were new to the North Eastern Region at Thornaby (4) and Gateshead (12) and to the Eastern Region at Tinsley (12) and Barrow Hill (1). In September 1963 numbers D8501 and D8536 moved to the Tyne Dock area where they were tested in multiple on Consett iron ore trains. They proved far too underpowered for this work, and so were moved to Ardsley shed a few months later where they undertook a variety of freight work both individually and in multiple.[4] Subsequently all of the locomotives allocated to the Eastern Region were transferred to Haymarket where they were employed on freight traffic in southern Scotland and northern England.

Problems

This design was arguably the least successful diesel locomotive ever employed on British Railways, even more so than the ill-fated Metrovick Co-Bo. The twin Paxman engines were unreliable, being prone to camshaft and cylinder head problems amongst others;[2]:58 overall availability was around 60%, even after extensive modifications. Forward visibility, which had dictated the whole design of the type, was not as good as had been hoped, the long noses meaning that the crew could not see the area immediately in front of the locomotive.

Although the Rolls Royce and Crompton Parkinson engined examples had better reliability, no further examples were ordered and BR decided to dispose of the type, replacing them with an order for 100 of the already proven Class 20 locomotives.[2]:58

Withdrawal

D8574 at Crewe awaiting scrapping in 1971

Withdrawals began in July 1968 and the final locomotives were withdrawn in December 1971. The Class 17s had by far the shortest lives of any significant BR diesel-electric locomotive design, with many examples having a working life of less than five years. Most had been scrapped by the end of 1975, but at this time the possibility of converting 9 of the remaining locos to battery operation was suggested.[4] This came to nothing, and although D8512, D8521 and D8598 enjoyed a brief reprieve by being sent to Derby Research Centre all were later withdrawn and subsequently scrapped.

Preservation

D8568 arriving from Kidderminster

After withdrawal in 1971, D8568 went on to see industrial use at Hemelite, Hemel Hempstead and at Ribblesdale Cement, Clitheroe, and was then secured for preservation.[7] It is now (2018) at the Chinnor and Princes Risborough Railway, Oxfordshire.[8]

In fiction

In the Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends TV Series, a character based on this class appears by the name of Derek, with the problems inherent to the class incorporated into the character and his sole episode.[9]

Models

Danish manufacturer Heljan launched a 00 gauge ready-to-run model of the Class 17 at the 2006 Warley National Model Railway Exhibition which went on sale after some production delays in early 2009. Aside from small runs by TechCad, and in kit form by DC Kits and others, this was the first time the class had been produced as a ready-to-run model.

In November 2018, Heljan announced production of an O gauge version for release in late 2019.

In August 2020, Bachmann announced the imminent release of an N gauge model under their new "EFE Models" brand; to be available in various liveries: BR green with small yellow panels, BR green with full yellow ends, BR blue with full yellow ends, and Ribble Cement green and white livery.

References

  1. "Standard Type 1 Diesel-Electric Locomotive for British Transport Commission" (PDF). The Clayton Equipment Company. November 1962. p. 3. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  2. Green-Hughes, Evan (March 2014). "Reshaping the Railways". Railways Illustrated. Vol. 12 no. 3. Key Publishing. ISSN 1479-2230.
  3. Carr, Richard (13 August 2010). "ZH Traction Applications". Paxman and Diesel Rail Traction. Paxman History Pages. Archived from the original on 2 April 2011.
  4. "The Class 17 Claytons - BR's Standard Type 1?". Rail Blue. Archived from the original on 2 April 2011. Retrieved 1 December 2010.
  5. Clough (2009), pp. 20–21.
  6. British Rail Locoshed Book. Shepperton: Ian Allan. February 1968. p. 32. ISBN 0-7110-0004-2.
  7. Clough (2009), p. 21.
  8. Milner, Chris, ed. (August 2016). "Chinnor takes big stride into Princes Risborough". The Railway Magazine. p. 11.
  9. "Derek - Character Profile". Thomas & Friends. HIT Entertainment. 2013. Retrieved 21 January 2014.

Sources

  • Clough, David N. (2009). "Class 17". British Rail Standard Diesels of the 1960s. Ian Allan. pp. 14–21. ISBN 978-0-7110-3373-3.
  • Stevens-Stratten, S.W.; Carter, R.S. (1978). British Rail Main-Line Diesels. Shepperton: Ian Allan Ltd. ISBN 0-7110-0617-2.
  • Sugden, S.A. Diesel & Electric Loco Register (3rd edn). Sheffield: Platform 5. ISBN 1-872524-55-9.
  • Grindlay, Jim. British Railways Locomotive Allocations 1948-1968 (Part 6 - Diesel & Electric Locomotives). Troon: Modelmaster Publications. ISBN 978-0-9544264-6-0.


Further reading

This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.