In Your House 2

Before the event went live on pay-per-view, Skip, who was accompanied to the ring by his valet Sunny, defeated Aldo Montoya in a dark match.[17]

The pay-per-view started with a Singles match between the Roadie and the 1–2–3 Kid. 1–2–3 Kid surprised the Roadie with an attack outside the ring and had the early advantage, but the Roadie soon took control, performing a clothesline, grounding Kid.[12] At several points during the match, Jeff Jarrett was shown preparing for his performance of "With My Baby Tonight" in his dressing room, ignoring The Roadie's performance.[2][12] At the end of the match, Kid missed a dropkick from the second-rope. The Roadie capitalized with a powerbomb and a piledriver off the top rope, allowing him to pin the Kid.[12]

Razor Ramon, who teamed up with Savio Vega to take on Men on a Mission at In Your House 2

In the second pay-per-view match Men on a Mission (King Mabel and Sir Mo) faced Razor Ramon and Savio Vega. Mabel and Mo had the upper hand throughout most of the match, with Mabel dominating Vega. Vega eventually managed to tag in Ramon, who got control and powerslammed Mabel from the top rope.[12] The advantage for Ramon and Vega was short-lived, as Mabel executed an avalanche on Ramon in the corner, followed by a belly to belly suplex to get the victory.[1][18]

After the second match, WWF Intercontinental Champion Jeff Jarrett made his live singing debut, performing the song "With My Baby Tonight". Notably, Jarrett's personal enforcer, remained unseen during the performance.[1]

Next, Bam Bam Bigelow squared off against Henry O. Godwinn.[2] After several near-falls from both Bigelow and Godwinn, Godwinn missed a knee drop from the second rope. Bigelow capitalized by rolling up Godwinn for the win. That ending was rushed, i.e. not planned, as Godwinn had sustained a legit injury during the missed knee drop.[1]

In the following match, Jeff Jarrett (accompanied by the Roadie) defended his Intercontinental Championship against Shawn Michaels. The match first went back and forth, with both Michaels and Jarrett taking control for certain periods. The first highspot occurred when Jarrett backdropped Michaels over the top rope to the arena floor.[12] Throughout the match, the Roadie distracted the referee, allowing Jarrett to perform illegal tactics to gain an advantage.[1] Michaels managed to escape a sleeper hold minutes later, gaining the upper hand in the process. After several highspot moves by Michaels, The Roadie shook the ring-ropes while Michaels was on the top rope, grounding Michaels in the process.[1][2] Jarrett attempted to regain the advantage by performing the Figure four leglock, but Michaels reversed the hold into a near-fall. Jarrett went for the submission hold again, but Michaels shoved him into the referee, sending the official to the ground. Michaels tried to seize the advantage with a Superkick, but the Roadie grabbed Michaels.[1] Jarrett performed a Crossbody, getting a near-fall in the process. The finish to the match came when the Roadie accidentally tripped Jarrett. Jarrett got back up only to walk into Michaels's Superkick. Michaels pinned him and became Intercontinental Champion.[2][12] It was revealed later in the show that Jarrett and The Roadie were involved in a backstage confrontation with each other, signaling an end to their on-screen friendship.[1][12]

Next, Owen Hart and Yokozuna, accompanied by Jim Cornette and Mr. Fuji, defended their WWF Tag Team Championship against the Allied Powers (Lex Luger and The British Bulldog). The challengers got the advantage early on, with Luger wearing down Yokozuna by smashing Yokozuna's head into the top turnbuckle. Yokozuna accidentally fell onto Hart's foot, sparking a confrontation between the tag team partners.[1][12] After a few minutes, the two settled their differences, the challengers retained the advantage for much of the match. The finish came after the Allied Powers double-teamed on Yokozuna. Following a back suplex, the referee ordered Bulldog, who wasn't the legal man, out of the ring. Hart hit the distracted Luger with a double axe handle from the top rope, allowing Yokozuna to pin Luger with a leg drop.[1][12]

This was followed by the co-main event which was a Casket match between The Undertaker (accompanied by manager Paul Bearer) and Kama (accompanied by Ted DiBiase). Kama attempted to perform The Undertaker's finishing move, the Tombstone Piledriver, but The Undertaker reversed it, chokeslamming Kama. The Undertaker then performed a big boot to Kama, which sent him into the casket, meaning The Undertaker won the match.[12]

Diesel, who defended the WWF World Championship against Sid in a Lumberjack match.

In the main event, Diesel defended the WWF World Championship against Sycho Sid in a Lumberjack match. After back and forth action during the first few minutes, which included each wrestler being attacked by opposing lumberjacks, Diesel performed a suicide dive over the top rope onto all of Sid's lumberjacks.[1] The champion continued to attack Sid's lumberjacks, but King Mabel intervened, tossing Diesel into the steel steps.[2][12] Sid attempted to capitalize by performing his finishing move, the Powerbomb. Instead of pinning his opponent, Sid high fived his lumberjacks on the outside, giving Diesel time to recover and kick out at the two-count.[1][12] After a second attempted Powerbomb by Sid was countered, the match spilled outside of the ring: Sid got into a brawl with Diesel's lumberjacks. Shawn Michaels, one of Diesel's lumberjacks hit Sid with a double axe handle off the top rope.[12] Some of Sid's lumberjacks, including Tatanka and Irwin R. Schyster, attacked Diesel, who fought them off. Diesel performed a big boot, pinning Sid to retain the WWF Championship. Diesel celebrated with his lumberjacks after the match ended.[1][2][12]

There was one more match at the arena after the pay-per-view event went off the air. It was later part of the In Your House 2 video released by Coliseum Video:[2][12] Bret Hart wrestled Jean-Pierre Lafitte. Lafitte held control for most of the match, but Hart gained the advantage near the end as Lafitte missed a diving crossbody. Hart capitalized, pinning Lafitte via a roll-up.[12]