Me and My Imagination

The song received general acclaim from music critics. K. Ross Hoffman of AllMusic called it "an immaculate disco glide,"[1] while Nick Levine of Digital Spy named it "a sun-dappled disco."[5] Stuart McCaighy of DIY magazine wrote a very positive review, stating "It's an immediate and irresistible slice of pop. The song's pace and melody make the most of Sophie's deadpan delivery. This is modern pop with old time appeal - it sticks in the head and refuses to budge."[6] Emily MacKay of Yahoo! Music commented: "It's an old-school Sophie handbag house with a soft icy melody and a simple, smart lyrical concept."[4] Caroline Sullivan of The Guardian commented: "She excels herself on the delicious single Me and My Imagination, her disengaged presence helping (along with a walloping melody and frantic violins) to push the song to ecstatic heights."[7] However, Kitt Empire of The Observer wrote that the song "tries to recreate the Ibizan bliss of her debut album Read My Lips, but ends up more fake tan than sunkissed glow."[8] Talia Kraine of BBC Music perceived that the song "recalled days of Read My Lips."[9]

Andrew Bain of musicOMH wrote a favorable review, commenting "On first listen, most of the song is pretty forgettable, but with some persistence it manages, as all good pop songs do, to burrow neatly into the listener's brain and lodge itself there. However, unlike most other pop songs it achieves this goal with a more understated sound, achieving memorability through a chorus so gentle that you barely realise it's there. In other words, Sophie achieves a good pop single with the class that she is known for, never stooping to the unbearably repetitive nature of most pop. It makes for a much more pleasurable listen, even for those whose tastes usually lie outside the genre. As a whole it is a perfectly listenable and amiable song. If you liked Sophie's previous stuff, especially the last single (and not so much Murder on the Dancefloor), then this single is for you."[10] Pitchfork ranked "Me and My Imagination" at number 87 on its list of the 100 Greatest Tracks of 2007.[3] David Raposa wrote:

"Some things Sophie Ellis-Bextor can't do without: the three-minute song, disco strings, pop glitter, and men that play hard-to-get. This standout track from her third solo album is more of the same from a UK pop factory that produces pop hooks most Americans adore only when in the mouths of teenage babes or Gwen Stefani. Radio programmers, please note: Pure sugar like this will go a long way toward making the usual Top 40 placebos easier to swallow."[3]

The single peaked at number 23 on the UK Singles Chart and it sold 10,000 copies in the United Kingdom.[11] "Me and My Imagination" later appeared on the Abercrombie & Fitch playlist in America.[12] On the Russian Top Hit 100, the song debuted at number 96 on the issue dated 21 May 2007.[13] On the issue dated 28 May 2007, the song climbed from 96 to 53.[14] On the issue dated 4 June 2007, the song moved to number 35.[15] The song peaked at number 16 on the chart issue dated 16 July 2007.[16]

The single's digital release caused controversy when iTunes failed to add the song until a week after it was supposed to be released, appearing on 14 May 2007 instead of 7 May 2007. Ellis-Bextor believed she would have scored a top 10 hit if the problem had not occurred.[17] She described the error as "a nightmare", and believed it placed her chart position in jeopardy.[17]