Prisoner of Love (Russ Columbo song)

Written in 1931, Leo Robin has related how publisher Con Conrad walked into his hotel room with Russ Columbo, and asked him to write words within the hour for a tune he had. Robin, who was on vacation, at first refused but Conrad explained that he wanted Columbo to demonstrate it to Flo Ziegfeld who needed a song for Helen Morgan in one of his shows. Robin then wrote the lyric, which he afterwards said he disliked, and the song was duly performed for Ziegfeld but he did not accept it.[1] Russ Columbo, however, sang it on his radio show and recorded it on October 9, 1931 for Victor Records[2] and it was very popular in 1932.[3] Columbo also sang it in the 1933 short film That Goes Double.[4] In 1946 the song became a major hit for Billy Eckstine, Perry Como and the Ink Spots.[5]

African-American crooner Billy Eckstine recorded his version with Duke Ellington on piano and Art Blakey on drums September 4, 1945. The record became a million seller and a No. 10 hit.[6]

Como's first recording was made on December 18, 1945 and released by RCA Victor as catalog number 20-1814-B. It first reached the Billboard magazine charts on March 30, 1946 and lasted 21 weeks on the chart, peaking at No. 1.[7] The flip side was "All Through the Day".[8] This recording was re-released in 1949, by RCA Victor, as a 78rpm single (catalog number 20-3298-A) and a 45rpm single (catalog number 47-2886), with the flip side "Temptation." Billboard ranked it as the No. 1 song of the year for 1946.[9]

Como made two further recordings of the song: one in February 1946 for a V-Disc, number CS-656-B, and another in July 1970 in a live performance in Las Vegas, issued as a long-playing album (titled Perry Como in Person at the International Hotel, Las Vegas in its United States and United Kingdom releases, Perry Como in Person in its Japanese release, and Perry Como in Concert in its Dutch release).

The Como version was used on the soundtrack of the 1980 film Raging Bull.[10]

This was recorded on March 18, 1946 for Decca Records (catalogue No. 18864)[11] and it spent 11 weeks in the USA charts, peaking at No. 9.[12]

James Brown revived "Prisoner of Love" in 1963. It charted No. 6 R&B and No. 18 Pop. The studio recording was arranged by Sammy Lowe.[13] Brown performed the song live with his vocal group, The Famous Flames, in the concert film T.A.M.I. Show and on a mid-1960s telecast of The Ed Sullivan Show. It also appears on many of his live albums.

• 1932 Roy Fox and His Band - vocal by Al Bowlly.(Al Bowlly Discography).
• 1939 Mildred Bailey recorded for Vocalion Records (catalogue No. 5268) on March 16, 1939.[14]
• 1941 Teddy Wilson - Lena Horne (vocal) NYC, September 16, 1941.[15]
• 1956 Bing Crosby recorded the song for his album Songs I Wish I Had Sung the First Time Around.
• 1957 Les Paul and Mary Ford - for their album Time to Dream.[16]
• 1957 Coleman Hawkins and Ben Webster, with Oscar Peterson - (instrumental) for their album Coleman Hawkins Encounters Ben Webster
• 1958 Jerry Vale - for the album I Remember Russ .
• 1958 Matt Monro issued as a single for Fontana Records.[17]
• 1960 The Platters on their EP Pick Of The Platters No.6.[18]
• 1960 Connie Francis - included in her album One for the Boys.
• 1962 Frank Sinatra - recorded for his album Sinatra and Strings.
• 1962 Keely Smith - for her album Because You're Mine.[19]
• 1962 Pat Boone - recorded for his album I'll See You in My Dreams.[20]
• 1973 The Vogues - Single
• 1981 Flo & Eddie from their album Rock Steady with Flo & Eddie

• AllMusic review of the James Brown recording