China–South Africa relations

People's Republic of China – South Africa relations refer to the current and historical relationship between the People's Republic of China (PRC) and the Republic of South Africa.

Sino-South Africa relations

China
South Africa
For the article on Taiwanese–South African relations, see South Africa–Taiwan relations.

In 2010, China was South Africa's largest trading partner.[1] Since 2007 Sino-South African relations have become increasingly close with increasing trade, policy and political ties.[2][3] In the 2010 Beijing Declaration, South Africa was upgraded to the diplomatic status of Strategic Comprehensive Partner by the Chinese government.[4]

History
South African Air Force 2 Squadron Mustang fighters during the Korean War.

Prior to the fall of apartheid in South Africa relations between the two countries were officially non-existent and unofficially antagonistic.

In the Korean War, the South African Air Force fought on the side of the United Nations against the Chinese Peoples Liberation Army, while Pretoria later enjoyed a strong relationship with the Republic of China (ROC) in Taiwan.

The PRC supported and was closely allied with the anti-apartheid group the Pan African Congress (PAC) while the African National Congress (ANC) was supported by the PRC's communist rival, the Soviet Union.[5]:178

On October, 1st 1996, the National Day of the People's Republic of China, Nelson Mandela sent a congratulation message to Jiang Zemin, President of the PRC.[6] November 27, he said that it supported a Greater China, including PRC and ROC.[7] The administration of South African president Jacob Zuma saw a significant warming of relations between 2009 and 2018 that coincided with a cooling of South Africa–United States relations.[8] During this period South Africa placed much of its diplomatic focus on supporting the BRICS partnership in which China plays an important role.

Recognition
Embassy of South Africa in China

Official relations between the PRC and South Africa were established in January 1998. The dismantling of the apartheid regime in South Africa and the fall of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s opened up the possibility of official relations being established between the PRC and South Africa. Before the 1990s South Africa had a close official relationship with the government in Taiwan for strategic and economic reasons.

Prior to the establishment of full diplomatic relations, South Africa and the People's Republic of China established "cultural centres" in Beijing and Pretoria, known as the South African Centre for Chinese Studies and the Chinese Centre for South African Studies respectively.[9] Although the Centres, each headed by a Director, did not use diplomatic titles, national flags, or coats of arms, their staff used diplomatic passports and were issued with diplomatic identity documents, while their vehicles had diplomatic number plates.[10] They also performed visa and consular services.[11]

The handover of Hong Kong to the PRC in 1997 was a factor in the switch in official recognition, as South Africa had strong trade links with the territory, then under British administration. Pretoria was concerned that after the handover, Beijing might downgrade its consulate and the country would no longer be allowed to use Hong Kong as a transit route for air traffic and trade.[12] In addition, key South African politicians and government officials in the post-apartheid government, most notably the Communist Party of South Africa, lobbied strongly in support of shifting recognition to the PRC.[13]

However, Taiwan lobbied hard for continued South African recognition and initiated an expensive public relations drive to convince members of the anti-apartheid government. Then President Nelson Mandela argued in favour of a 'Two Chinas' policy that was incompatible with the Beijing's One China policy.

After many years of strong lobbying and engagement with Mandela in November 1996 the South African government announced that it would switch recognition from Taiwan to the PRC in January 1998.[14] A visit by Taipei's Foreign Minister John Chiang to meet with Alfred Nzo and attempt to salvage the situation produced no results, and so Taipei's ambassador to Pretoria Gene Loh was recalled on 6 December 1996.[15][16]

Economics
Countries which signed cooperation documents related to the Belt and Road Initiative

In 1992, trade between China and South Africa amounted to US$14 million, but by the time the two countries had established relations in 1998, this had swelled to US$1.4 billion.[5]:182 By 2010 trade between the two countries had increased to US$25.6 billion with imports from South Africa reaching US$14.8 billion. Cross country investment had grown to US$7 billion in the same year. Most South African exports to China in 2010 were primary products.[17] Two-way trade between China and South Africa reached US$60.3 billion by 2014.[18]

In December 2010, South Africa was invited to join China in BRICS group of emerging economies.[19] With the invitation, it was expected that South Africa would expand its trade relations with other BRIC countries, including China. Some see the BRICS relationship as potentially competing with South Africa's relations with the IBSA Dialogue Forum.[20] In July 2010, the South African publication Business Day reported that 45% of SABMiller's growth would come from its China operations by 2014. The anomalous growth of South African media company Naspers in 2009 was largely owed to its stake in the Chinese company Tencent.[21]

In December 2015 the two countries signed twenty-five agreements worth a combined value of US$16.5 billion at an event at the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC) Business Forum held in South Africa and attended by about 400 business people from both countries. At the same event, the two countries discussed economic priority such as the "alignment of industries to accelerate South Africa's industrialisation process; enhancement of cooperation in Special Economic Zones (SEZs); marine cooperation; infrastructure development, human resources cooperation; and financial cooperation."[18]

As of 2015/16 there were over 140 medium-sized or large Chinese companies in South Africa with a combined investment of US$13 billion, employing around 30,000 South Africans. Significant investments by Chinese firms in South Africa include the China First Automotive assembly plant in Coega Industrial Park, a Hisense Group white goods factory, and a Hebei Jidong Development Group cement plant.[22]

Increasingly the South African government, inspired by China's success in reducing poverty and promoting economic growth, is looking to China for policy ideas and inspiration in its efforts at promoting growth.[21]

Loans

In 2020 South Africa was estimated to owe the equivalent of 4% of its annual GDP to Chinese lenders.[23]

In July 2018, China announced to invest $15 billion in South Africa's economy which included loans for power utilities and infrastructure. Chinese loans to South African power utility Eskom have proven controversial amidst accusations that it was an example of debt-trap diplomacy by China.[24] In 2018 an additional R370 billion (US$25.8 billion) loan from the China Development Bank was issued to the South African government as part of an economic stimulus package. The size of loan and the lack of public information about it was controversial[25][26] and criticized by opposition parties as a possibly pushing South Africa into a "debt trap".[27]

Chinese development finance to South Africa

From 2000 to 2011, there are approximately 37 Chinese official development finance projects identified in South Africa through various media reports.[28] These projects range from a financial cooperation agreement worth of $2.5 US billion between the Development Bank of South Africa and the China Development Bank,[29] to an investment of $877 million by China's state-owned miner Jinchuan and China Development Bank in South Africa's platinum industry,[30] and an investment of US$250 million by China's Huaqiang Holdings in a theme park in Johannesburg.[31]

Visits
South African former Deputy President Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka giving a speech at Tsinghua University's School of Public Policy and Management on Sino-South African relations in 2007.

In the early nineties, before South Africa officially recognised the PRC, Chinese Foreign Minister and politburo member Qian Qichen (钱其琛) paid an unofficial and very quiet visit to South Africa to meet senior government ministers and inspect possible future embassy sites. Then South African Minister for Foreign Relations, Pik Botha, interrupted his participation in the CODESA talks to have the first high-level meeting between South Africa and the PRC.[5]:177 In October 1991 a South African delegation including Pik Botha went to Beijing to meet Qian Qichen.[5]:168–169

In September 2007 then South African Deputy President Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka visited Beijing and met with Chinese President Hu Jintao (胡锦涛).[32] After which she gave a speech at Tsinghua University on building Sino-South African relations.[33]

Sino-South African relations expanded significantly in 2010 following a number of high-level official visits and exchanges by officials from both countries. In late March 2010 CPPCC Chairman Jia Qinglin (贾庆林) visited South Africa and met with South Africa's President Jacob Zuma and signed contracts worth more than US$300 million.[34]

In August 2010 President Jacob Zuma led a South African delegation of 17 cabinet members and 300 businesspeople to China[1][35] where they signed the Beijing Declaration on the Establishment of a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership Between the People's Republic of China and the Republic of South Africa. This was followed by a visit to China by speaker of the National Assembly of South Africa Max Sisulu in October 2010. In November 2010 Chinese Vice President Xi Jinping (习近平) travelled to South Africa to meet with South African Vice President Motlanthe and signed bilateral cooperation agreements in energy, trade statistics, banking regulation and other areas.[34] His visit was followed by an official goodwill visit to South Africa by China's top legislator Wu Bangguo (吴邦国) in May 2011 as part of his Africa-Asia tour which included Namibia and Angola.[36]

In late September 2011 South African Vice President Motlanthe lead a trade delegation to Beijing at the invitation of Chinese Vice President Xi. During the visit the China Development Bank and the Development Bank of South Africa signed a US$2.5 billion agreement. The two countries also signed a Memorandum of Understanding on geological exploration and mineral resources.[37]

On the 17 July 2012 President Zuma led a South African delegation that included International Relations Minister Maite Nkoana-Mashabane, Minister in the Presidency Collins Chabane and Trade and Industry Minister Rob Davies to attend the fifth Forum on China-Africa Co-operation (FOCAC) in Beijing.[38]

The emergence of China as a power among others gives or offers an opportunity to African countries to be able to free themselves from the shackles that are really colonially designed - Jacob Zuma, speaking at Tsinghua University, 2014[39]

In December 2014 President Zuma led another delegation of South African government ministers and a 100 representatives of South African business to China[39] representing a further consolidation of warm South African-Sino relations.[40] From the South African side trade imbalances, China's impact on South African industry, and concerns over China's influence over South Africa's domestic and international affairs remain issues of concern for bilateral relations.[41] In July 2015 South Africa's deputy president, Cyril Ramaphosa, led a trade and economic delegation to China.[42]

In September 2015 President Zuma attended the Chinese 70th anniversary celebrations since the end of World War 2.[43] This was closely followed by a visit from, now President, Xi Jinping to Pretoria, South Africa on the 2nd December 2015 where agreements to finalise the China-South Africa 5-10 Year Framework on Cooperation were signed.[44]

The administration of Cyril Ramaphosa saw an expansion of Sino-South African warm relations with implementation of joint naval exercises with Chinese and Russian navel vessels off the coast of Cape Town in November 2019.[8]

Politics

Since 2007 Political relations between the South African government and the Chinese government has been growing closer.

It has been alleged that South Africa's ruling political party, the African National Congress, has received funding for election campaigns from foreign countries particularity for the 2009 national elections. Amongst the foreign countries accused of giving money to the ANC is the Communist Party of China. Other countries and the ruling political parties and figures accused of giving money to the ANC include the Congress Party of India, the Gaddafi administration of Libya and Equatorial Guinea.[45][46]

In 2014 it was announced that the Chinese Communist Party will support and construct a political training school for South Africa's ruling political party the ANC in Venterskroon.[47] An increasing number of South African government functionaries are being sent to Chinese government schools in Beijing. South Africa plans to send increasing numbers of executives from South African Parastatals to study China's relationship with its State Owned Enterprises.[3][48][49] A number of annalists such as Patrick Heller,[47] have argued that South Africa's ruling ANC sees the Chinese Communist Party as a model for maintaining control over the country as a de facto One-party state and/or as an aspect of anti-Western feeling by South African government elites.[2][3]

Dalai Lama & Tibet

The Dalai Lama visited South Africa in 1996, (meeting then president Nelson Mandela).[50] In March 2009 the Dalai Lama was refused entry to South Africa, officially to keep Tibetan politics from overshadowing the 2010 FIFA World Cup.[51][52] The refusal to allow the Dalai Lama to visit South Africa sparked a political debate within South Africa about the country's political and business interests with China, with some accusing the government of "selling out" sovereignty, and others pointing out the negative consequences to Sino-French business relations after French president Nicolas Sarkozy met with the Dalai Lama.[53]

In 2011 the Dalai Lama was invited to attend and give a lecture at the 80th birthday of Desmond Tutu in October. The Dalai Lama's staff accused the South African government of delaying consideration of his visa application because of Chinese pressure, but the government denied such pressure and counteraccused the Dalai Lama of not submitting any visa applications.[50][54] Three days before Tutu's birthday the Dalai Lama announced that he would not attend the event as he did not expect to be granted a visa. Tutu responded by calling the ANC government "worse than the apartheid government" and suggested that the government should be toppled in the style of the Arab Spring.[55] The Dalai Lama joined Tutu on his birthday by videoconferencing, calling China a country "built on lies" and "run by hypocrites", and implored Tutu to continue inviting him to South Africa to "test [South Africa's] government".[56] Opposition and COSATU politicians again accused the ANC government of "betraying South Africa's sovereignty and Constitution."[57] Others in South Africa argued that the Dalai Lama's physical nonattendance was ultimately in South Africa's interests, reasoning that "it's easier to Skype in the Dalai Lama than [to find] billions in alternative investments."[58]

Dalai Lama was again unable to enter South Africa when he was invited to attend the Nobel Peace Laureates world summit in October 2014. It is alleged by the mayor of Cape Town that he was asked by national government to withdraw his application for a visa to visit SA for reasons “in the national interest” so as to avoid embarrassment by his visa being officially rejected.[59]

The 2018 visit to South Africa of President in exile of Tibet, Lobsang Sangay, strained relations as the South African government refused Chinese demands to expel Sangay despite threats that the visit might impact Chinese investment into South Africa.[60]

Chinese South Africans
Main article: Chinese South Africans

Chinese South Africans are an ethnic group of Chinese diaspora in South Africa. They and their ancestors immigrated to South Africa beginning during the Dutch colonial era in the Cape Colony. Since 2000 an estimated 350,000 Chinese immigrations, most of whom came from mainland China, have settled in South Africa.[61]

Other events

Illegal fishing

In May 2016, the South African Department of Fisheries stated that a total of nine Chinese owned vessels were spotted in South African waters allegedly engaged in illegal fishing. The vessels initially agreed to be escorted into port for inspection but on the way broke up and evaded the escorting South African patrol vessel.[62] The nine vessels were part of a fleet of 28 Chinese trawlers that were accused by local anglers of illegal fishing within 3 kilometers of South African waters allegedly fishing the annual sardine run.[63][64]

Irregular tenders to Gupta Family
Main article: Gupta family

In June 2016 the state owned Chinese locomotive manufacturer, CSR Corporation Limited, was implicated in a 2012 R51 billion (US$6 billion) tender to deliver 600 locomotives to the state owned Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa.[65][66] It was later reported that the future South African Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane was allegedly implicated in the deal when she worked as Counselor Immigration and Civic Services in South Africa's embassy in China.[67][68] By 2020 it was reported that funds allocated to pay for an adjusted contract to deliver the locomotives produced by CSR Corporation, now reformed and renamed CRRC, had been frozen by the South African Revenue Service due to possible instances of corruption paid to associates of the Gupta family to secure the contract.[69]

Bibliography
  • Cardenal, Juan Pablo; Araújo, Heriberto (2011). La silenciosa conquista china (in Spanish). Barcelona: Crítica. pp. 51–54, 91, 115, 137. ISBN 9788498922578.

References
  1. South Africa-China trade ties: President Zuma bids to shore up 'Gateway to China' status The Christian Science Monitor, 25 August 2010
  2. "South Africa's inexplicable love affair with China". The China Africa Project. 5 September 2015. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  3. Allison, Simon (20 August 2015). "ANC's future foreign policy: All roads lead to China". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  4. Anthony, Ross (11 January 2016). "South Africa and China: Behind the smoke and mirrors". Mail and Guardian. Retrieved 17 January 2016.
  5. Wolvaardt, Pieter; Wheeler, Tom; Scholtz, Tom (2010). From Verwoerd to Mandela: South African Diplomats Remember. Vol 2. South Africa: Crink. ISBN 978-0-620-45459-9.
  6. Message by President Nelson Mandela to China on celebrating National Day on mandela.gov.za
  7. Statement by President Nelson Mandela on South Africa's relations with the Greater China region on mandela.gov.za
  8. Ol, Eric; er. "With Chinese and Russian Warships Heading to South Africa, Pretoria Sends a Powerful Message to the U.S." The China Africa Project. Retrieved 2019-11-15.
  9. Interpreting Chinese Foreign Policy: The Micro-macro Linkage Approach, Quansheng Zhao Oxford University Press, 1996, page 68
  10. Establishing the SA Mission in the PRC, Embassy of the People's Republic of China, 31 March 2008
  11. Colour, Confusion and Concessions: The History of the Chinese in South Africa, Hong Kong University Press, 1996, page 424
  12. Statement on Future South Africa/Hong Kong Relations by the Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mr Aziz Pahad, June 12, 1997
  13. South Africa and Taiwan: Pariahs, International Redemption and Global Change, Peter Vale in Taiwan's Expanding Role in the International Arena, Maysing H. Yang, M.E. Sharpe, 1997, page 104
  14. China / South Africa -- a Chopsticks Relationship, P J Botha, Embassy of the People's Republic of China in the Republic of South Africa, 4 July 2008
  15. Chu, Monique (2002-04-18). "Veteran diplomat tells it like it was". Taipei Times. Retrieved 2012-10-27.
  16. McNeil, Donald G. (1996-12-06). "Taiwan, Snubbed by South Africa, Ends Aid and Recalls Envoy". The New York Times. Retrieved 2012-10-17.
  17. "China becomes South Africa's biggest export destination: ambassador". Xinhua. August 21, 2011. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
  18. "Africa, China Business Leaders Sign Billions in Investments". SABC News. 5 December 2015. Retrieved 17 January 2016.
  19. Joining BRIC not a game changer Moneyweb.co.za15
  20. David Brewster. India's Ocean: the Story of India's Bid for Regional Leadership. Retrieved 13 August 2014.
  21. Faeeza Ballim (July 20, 2012). "South Africa and China in awkward embrace". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved July 21, 2012.
  22. Rong, Yansong - Chinese Embassy in South Africa (9 March 2016). "Economic transformation: China, SA should co-operate". Cape Times: Business Report. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  23. Merwe, Greg Mills and Emily van Der (2020-04-29). "Op-Ed: Will we see a post-Covid China-Africa reset?". Brenthurst Foundation. Daily Maverick. Retrieved 2020-06-11.
  24. Maqhina, Mayibongwe (29 October 2018). "Eskom urged to divulge R33bn loan terms with China bank | IOL News". www.iol.co.za. Retrieved 2019-01-02.
  25. Anthony, Ross (2018-09-14). "China gifts SA with R370bn". The Mail & Guardian. Retrieved 2020-06-08.
  26. "DA wants Ramaphosa, Nene to provide details on China's R370bn 'gift'". www.iol.co.za. Retrieved 2020-06-08.
  27. "DA demands details of R370bn Chinese loan, warns of debt trap". Fin24. Archived from the original on 2018-10-15. Retrieved 2018-09-16.
  28. Austin Strange, Bradley C. Parks, Michael J. Tierney, Andreas Fuchs, Axel Dreher, and Vijaya Ramachandran. 2013. China’s Development Finance to Africa: A Media-Based Approach to Data Collection. CGD Working Paper 323. Washington DC: Center for Global Development.http://china.aiddata.org%5B%5D
  29. Strange, Parks, Tierney, Fuchs, Dreher, and Ramachandran, China’s Development Finance to Africa: A Media-Based Approach to Data Collection.http://aiddatachina.org/projects/28153
  30. Strange, Parks, Tierney, Fuchs, Dreher, and Ramachandran, China’s Development Finance to Africa: A Media-Based Approach to Data Collection.http://aiddatachina.org/projects/2479
  31. Strange, Parks, Tierney, Fuchs, Dreher, and Ramachandran, China’s Development Finance to Africa: A Media-Based Approach to Data Collection.http://aiddatachina.org/projects/16779
  32. "Hu Jintao Meets with South African Deputy President". Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs. September 25, 2007. Archived from the original on March 31, 2012. Retrieved November 5, 2011.
  33. Li Han (September 28, 2007). "Deputy President of the Republic of South Africa Delivers Speech". School of Public Policy and Management: Tsinghua University. Retrieved November 5, 2011.
  34. "Bilateral Relations ( Last Update: 2011/08/22)". Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 2011-08-22. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
  35. South Africa President Zuma in China. TV2Africa. 24 Aug 2010.
  36. "Top Chinese legislator starts visit to South Africa". Xinhua. May 24, 2011. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
  37. "China Looking to Enhance Ties with South Africa". 2 Point 6 Billion. October 3, 2011. Retrieved October 4, 2011.
  38. SAPA (July 18, 2012). "Zuma jets off to China for partnership talks". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved July 21, 2012.
  39. Sapa-AFP (5 December 2014). "Zuma call China anti-colonial force". IOL News. Retrieved 8 December 2014.
  40. "Zuma, ministers and business to visit China". Business Day. 1 December 2014. Retrieved 8 December 2014.
  41. Everett, Cath (5 December 2014). "Chinese business deals trump Nelson Mandela commemoration for South Africa's President Jacob Zuma". International Business Times. Retrieved 8 December 2014.
  42. Naledi Shange (13 July 2015). "Ramaphosa on state visit to China". News24. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  43. "Zuma concludes China visit". Business Day. 4 September 2015. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  44. "South Africa: President Zuma to Host President Xi for State Visit". SABC. 2 December 2015. Retrieved 17 January 2016.
  45. Rossouw, Mandy (March 21, 2009). "ANC's dodgy funders". Mail and Guardian. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
  46. Myburgh, James (24 March 2009). "Is the ANC selling out our sovereignty?". Politics Web. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
  47. Stephanie Findlay (24 November 2014). "South Africa's Ruling ANC Looks to Learn from Chinese Communist Party". Time. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  48. Mataboge, Mmanaledi (21 August 2015). "My Chinese dream: ANC brass put ideas to work". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  49. de Wet, Phillip (21 August 2015). "SA and China: A love founded on state control". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved 19 September 2015.
  50. "Dalai Lama visit to SA hangs in the balance". Mail & Guardian. September 28, 2011. Retrieved September 28, 2011.
  51. Baldauf, Scott (March 26, 2009). "South Africa turns away Dalai Lama, political firestorm follows". Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved September 28, 2011.
  52. "South African minister: Refusing visa to Dalai Lama "a matter between states"". Xinhua. Retrieved September 28, 2011.
  53. Berger, Sebastien (March 23, 2009). "South Africa accused of "selling out" after Dalai Lama barred from peace conference". The Telegraph. Retrieved September 28, 2011.
  54. Gerardy, Justine (October 2, 2011). "South Africa's moral beacon Desmond Tutu turns 80 on Friday with celebrations overshadowed by his government's dithering on whether to allow his close friend the Dalai Lama to visit". Mail and Guardian. Retrieved October 2, 2011.
  55. "Dalai Lama calls off South Africa visit over visa". Washington Post. Associated Press. October 4, 2011. Retrieved October 4, 2011.
  56. Tassiem, Shafiek (2011-10-08). "Dalai Lama: China is built on lies, run by hypocrites". Cape Town. Reuters. Retrieved 2011-10-09.
  57. South Africa Press Association (October 4, 2011). "That's that, then: Dalai Lama cancels South Africa trip". Mail & Guardian. Retrieved October 4, 2011.
  58. Ndlovu, Zama (2011-10-07). "A South African visa for the Dalai Lama? Not as simple as it sounds". The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved 2011-10-09.
  59. Murray Williams (7 October 2014). "Dalai Lama was 'asked to withdraw'". Cape Argus. Retrieved 8 October 2014.
  60. Fabricius, Peter. "DIPLOMATIC MANOEUVRES IN THE DARK: Sudden recall of China's ambassador to SA raises questions, offers few answers". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 2020-03-19.
  61. Park, Yoon Jung (2009). Recent Chinese Migrations to South Africa - New Intersections of Race, Class and Ethnicity (PDF). Representation, Expression and Identity. Interdisciplinary Perspectives. ISBN 978-1-904710-81-3. Archived from the original (PDF) on December 28, 2010. Retrieved September 20, 2010.
  62. Loewe, Jerome Cornelius And Mike. "Seized Chinese trawler escorted to Cape Town in illegal fishing rumpus". Sunday Times. Retrieved 2016-05-17.
  63. "Navy probes fleet of Chinese trawlers off Wild Coast". Business Day Live. Retrieved 2016-05-17.
  64. "Buzz over mystery Chinese vessels - HeraldLIVE". HeraldLIVE. 2016-05-13. Archived from the original on 2016-05-14. Retrieved 2016-05-17.
  65. "amaBhungane - Guptas' R51bn train grab". amabhungane.co.za. Retrieved 2016-07-16.
  66. SOLE, STEFAANS BRÜMMER and SAM. "The Guptas' R51bn train grab". Sunday Times. Retrieved 2016-07-16.
  67. Cameron, Jackie (2019-07-31). "HSBC joins dots from Gupta-friendly public protector to Chinese rail company kickbacks". BizNews.com. Retrieved 2019-08-01.
  68. "$5,000 payment to Mkhwebane flagged by HSBC bank: report". TimesLIVE. Retrieved 2019-08-01.
  69. Brümmer, Stefaans (2020-12-04). "amaBhungane: At a minute to midnight SARS tries to secure R4bn State Capture loot". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 2020-12-08.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.