Challenge Cup

The first ever Challenge Cup Final, 1897: Batley vs. St Helens

The clubs that formed the Northern Union had long been playing in local knock-out cup competitions under the auspices of the Rugby Football Union. However, the rugby union authorities refused to sanction a nationwide tournament, fearing that this would inevitably lead to professionalism. After the schism of 1895, the northern clubs were free to go-ahead, and they instigated the Northern Rugby Football Union Challenge Cup. In 1896 Fattorini's of Bradford were commissioned to manufacture the Challenge Cup at a cost of just £60. Fattorini's also supplied three-guineas winners' medals then valued at thirty shillings (£1.50).

The first competition was held during the 1896–97 season (the second season of the new game), and 52 clubs entered to compete for the trophy. The first final was held at Headingley in Leeds, on 24 April 1897. Batley defeated St. Helens 10–3[3] in front of a crowd of 13,492 (see picture). The St Helens side did not play in a standardised team jersey.

The competition was later interrupted by the Great War, although it was held in 1915, when the season that had begun before the war was completed. It was then suspended until the end of hostilities. Initially, the final tie was held at one of the larger club grounds in the north, however, noting the excitement in Huddersfield that the town’s football team were playing at Wembley in the FA Cup Final and the increasing difficulty for any of the rugby league grounds to satisfy spectator demand to see the final tie, the rugby league authorities voted 13–10 to move to the recently built Wembley Stadium in London, aiming to emulate the FA Cup's success and to put the game on the national stage.[4]

The first final held at Wembley was in 1929 when Wigan beat Dewsbury 13–2 in front of a crowd of 41,500. At the start of the Second World War, rugby league suspended its season immediately, but the Challenge Cup took a single year’s break before restarting, on a limited basis and with the support of the authorities, as part of keeping up morale. The Challenge Cup finals, which took place in the game’s Northern heartland, got big crowds as the game raised money for prisoners of war and for Lord Beaverbrook’s armaments programme.

In 1946, the Lance Todd Trophy was introduced and awarded to the man of the match. The first winner was Billy Stott of Wakefield Trinity while the first winner of the trophy on the losing team was Frank Whitcombe of Bradford Northern in 1948. In itself, it is a prestigious trophy presented only at the Challenge Cup Final. The winner is selected by the members of the Rugby League Writers' Association present at the game and the trophy was presented at a celebratory dinner at the Willows, the home of Salford.

1954 saw the Challenge Cup final drawn and the replay set the record for a rugby league match attendance. The match was on 5 May and 102,569 was the official attendance at Odsal Stadium, although it is believed that up to 120,000 spectators were present to see Warrington defeat Halifax 8–4.

The first final that was played under limited tackle rules (Originally 4, later changed to 6) Was the 1967 final between Barrow and Featherstone Rovers.

Wigan became well known for their successes in the Challenge Cup competition, winning every Challenge Cup Final from 1988 to 1995.

Until the 1993–94 season there were very few amateur clubs included in the cup, typically two. For part of the 1980s, and the 1992–93 season the cup was solely for professional clubs. The competition was then opened up to large numbers of amateur clubs as part of a deal between the Rugby Football League and British Amateur Rugby League Association over bridging the gap between the professional and amateur leagues.

In 1997, a Challenge Cup Plate took place for teams knocked out in the early rounds of the competition. The final took place at Wembley and was won by Hull Kingston Rovers who beat Hunslet 60–14.

The first final that featured use of the Video Referee, for try decisions, was the 1999 final between Leeds Rhinos and London Broncos, which saw the Broncos beaten by a record margin of 52–16 in a Challenge Cup Final.[2]

The 1999 Challenge Cup Final was also the last to be played at the old Wembley Stadium before the construction of the new Wembley Stadium began in 2003. During this time a variety of venues were used to hold the Final including Twickenham, Murrayfield and the Millennium Stadium. The Challenge Cup Final moved back into the new Wembley Stadium for the 2007 Final.

There was a belief that the Challenge Cup final taking place early in the season had led to a decline in the prestige of the cup,[5] so the timing of the competition was altered in 2005

Wembley Stadium before the 2011 Challenge Cup Final

On 26 August 2006 St. Helens scrum-half Sean Long became the first player in the history of the Challenge Cup to collect a third Lance Todd trophy following his man-of-the-match performance in the final against Huddersfield. His other Lance Todd trophy wins came in the 2001 and 2004 Challenge Cup Finals.

On 25 August 2018, Catalans Dragons became the first non-English team to win the Challenge Cup as they defeated Warrington Wolves 20-14 at Wembley.

The modern Challenge Cup has eight rounds prior to the final. Teams are seeded, entering at different stages. The precise format has altered slightly from year to year, however the current format is as follows:

• First round: Amateur teams from around the United Kingdom are invited to participate. Most of the teams are English and affiliated to BARLA. Also included are, or have been, the national champions of the Irish, Welsh and Scottish rugby leagues; teams representing the three armed forces, the police, and student rugby league teams. Occasionally other teams have been invited such as the inclusion for 2019 of Serbian side Red Star Belgrade.[6]
• Second round: The first round winners play again.
• Third round: The League 1 clubs enter the draw with the winners from the second round.
• Fourth round: The Championship teams enter the draw with the third round winners.
• Fifth round: The bottom four Super League teams enter the draw with the fourth round winners.
• Sixth round: The top eight Super League teams enter the draw with the eight fifth round winners.
• Quarter finals: Last eight.
• Semi finals: Played at neutral venue(s).
• Final: Played at Wembley Stadium, on the Saturday of the August bank holiday weekend until 2019; will be played in July from 2020 onwards.[7]

Since 2007 the final has been held at Wembley Stadium

During the first round right through to the quarter finals the cup is hosted at the stadium of the team who has been drawn at home. The semi finals are hosted at neutral venues so there is no advantage for the home team. In the event of a draw in the final a replay will be played at a neutral venue somewhere else. The final is played at Wembley traditionally and was first played there in 1928–29 season. Before, the final had been held in different neutral venues, including Leeds, Huddersfield, Manchester, Wigan, Salford and Rochdale. The first Challenge Cup final was held at Headingley, Leeds between Batley and St. Helens in front of a crowd of 13,492.

NRFU Challenge Cup first presented 1896–97

The Challenge Cup trophy was designed by silversmiths Fattorini & Sons of Bradford in 1897.[4] The trophy stood 36 inches high manufactured of solid silver and stood on a black ebony base approximately 8 inches deep.

Tony Collins, the Rugby Football League's archivist, stated in 2007 that, "Fattorini's weren't given any particular commission, just told to come up with something prestigious".[4] The trophy cost £60.[4] The average wage in 1897 was around £2 per week which suggests an equivalent 2007 price of £16,000, although Collins says, "if you wanted something made of silver and with that level of craftsmanship these days, it would be far more expensive. In terms of its subsequent value, the RFL got a bargain."[4]

The trophy currently presented to the winners after the final is not the original which had to be withdrawn due to its delicate condition.[4] As well as the silver wearing thin, it had lost its fluted top and the players on each of the handles had been damaged.[4] The original Fattorini trophy was last presented at the 2001 Challenge Cup Final to St Helens captain Chris Joynt after his team had beaten Bradford.[8] The original trophy is now stored at the RFL's headquarters at Red Hall and only used for promotional appearances.[4]

The trophy used today was created by Jack Spencer (goldsmith) of Sheffield in 800 man-hours and is an almost exact replica of the Fattorini piece.[4][8] One improvement made with the new version is that the small shields displaying each winning team and captain are now the same size, whereas they had been getting smaller as space ran out on the original.[4] The new trophy's neck has been strengthened.[8] The second trophy was first presented to Wigan, winners of the 2002 Challenge Cup Final.[8]

The winners of the cup in looking after the trophy must "follow a certain code of practice," says Collins.[4] When not in a secure cabinet, the trophy must always be in the presence of someone.[4] When the trophy is taken out overnight, somebody must sleep in the same room and if taken in a car there must be two people in attendance.[4] Collins reveals that, "When it went down to France for some Catalans publicity photos, it even had its own seat on the plane."[4]

The Lance Todd Trophy, named in memory of Lance Todd, is awarded to the man-of-the-match in the Challenge Cup Final.[9] The winner is decided each year by those members of the Rugby League Writers' Association present at the match.[9]

The Trophy was first presented in 1946 to William "Billy" Stott of Wakefield Trinity.[9][10]

The Challenge Cup has been sponsored since 1980, with the sponsor being able to determine the cup's sponsorship name. There have been eight sponsors with Betfred being the current sponsors.[11]

The official rugby ball supplier is Steeden.[12]

The most tries scored in a final was 5 scored by Tom Briscoe (Leeds Rhinos v Hull KR in 2015), who also holds the record for most tries in total from one player (7 for Leeds, 2014 - 1, 2015 - 5, 2020 - 1) one ahead of Kevin Iro (6 for Wigan, 1988 – 2, 1989 – 2, 1990 – 2).

The first hat trick of tries in a final was scored by Robbie Paul for Bradford Bulls v St Helens in 1996. Three years later, Leroy Rivett scored 4 for Leeds Rhinos against London Broncos in 1999. Some players previously missed out on becoming the first to score a hat trick due to tries being disallowed, such as Martin Offiah (Wigan v Castleford in 1992), Tony Iro (Wigan v Halifax in 1988) & Kevin Iro (Wigan v Warrington in 1990).

Graham Rees scored the quickest Challenge Cup Final try after just 35 seconds for St Helens against Leeds in 1972.

The most famous final was the 1968 'Watersplash' game between Leeds and Wakefield Trinity. Due to a heavy thunderstorm both before and during the match, the pitch became totally waterlogged. In the final minute, with Leeds 11 - 7 in front, Wakefield winger Ken Hurst scored under the posts, and Don Fox (Who had already won the Lance Todd Trophy that day) had a match winning conversion to take in injury time. But due to the saturated pitch, he miskicked the ball, sending it wide of the posts. Despite a successful career for both club and country, Fox has always been remembered for that one infamous moment.

The first player to be sent off in a final was Syd Hynes, for Leeds against Leigh in 1971, for headbutting Alex Murphy. Hynes has always protested his innocence over the incident. Richard Eyers of Widnes was shown a red card for an off the ball elbow on Martin Offiah of Wigan in the 1993 final, and was banned for 6 games as a result.[13] Steve Hampson was the first player to be sin binned for 10 minutes, during the 1991 final for Wigan against St Helens.

In total, 26 different clubs have won the Challenge Cup and 30 different teams have appeared in the final. Wigan Warriors hold the record for most wins with 19 and have appeared in 30 finals. In 2007, Catalans Dragons became the first non English team to reach the final but lost to St. Helens.

Year	Winners	Score	Runner–up
1896–97	Batley	10–3	St. Helens
1897–98	Batley	7–0	Bradford F.C.
1898–99	Oldham	19–9	Hunslet
1899–1900	Swinton	16–8	Salford
1900–01	Batley	6–0	Warrington
1901–02	Broughton Rangers	25–0	Salford
1902–03	Halifax	7–0	Salford
1903–04	Halifax	8–3	Warrington
1904–05	Warrington	6–0	Hull Kingston Rovers
1905–06	Bradford F.C.	5–0	Salford
1906–07	Warrington	17–3	Oldham
1907–08	Hunslet	14–0	Hull F.C.
1908–09	Wakefield Trinity	17–0	Hull F.C.
1909–10	Leeds	7–7	Hull F.C.
Replay	Leeds	26–12	Hull F.C.
1910–11	Broughton Rangers	4–0	Wigan
1911–12	Dewsbury	8–5	Oldham
1912–13	Huddersfield	9–5	Warrington
1913–14	Hull F.C.	6–0	Wakefield Trinity
1914–15	Huddersfield	37–3	St. Helens
1919–20	Huddersfield	21–10	Wigan
1920–21	Leigh	13–0	Halifax
1921–22	Rochdale Hornets	10–9	Hull F.C.
1922–23	Leeds	28–3	Hull F.C.
1923–24	Wigan	21–4	Oldham
1924–25	Oldham	16–3	Hull Kingston Rovers
1925–26	Swinton	9–3	Oldham
1926–27	Oldham	26–7	Swinton
1927–28	Swinton	5–3	Warrington
1928–29	Wigan	13–2	Dewsbury
1929–30	Widnes	10–3	St. Helens
1930–31	Halifax	22–8	York
1931–32	Leeds	11–8	Swinton
1932–33	Huddersfield	21–17	Warrington
1933–34	Hunslet	11–5	Widnes
1934–35	Castleford	11–8	Huddersfield
1935–36	Leeds	18–2	Warrington
1936–37	Widnes	18–5	Keighley
1937–38	Salford	7–4	Barrow
1938–39	Halifax	20–3	Salford
1940–41	Leeds	19–2	Halifax
1941–42	Leeds	15–10	Halifax
1942–43	Dewsbury	16–15	Leeds
1943–44	Bradford Northern	8–3	Wigan
1944–45	Huddersfield	13–9	Bradford Northern
1945–46	Wakefield Trinity	13–12	Wigan
1946–47	Bradford Northern	8–4	Leeds
1947–48	Wigan	8–3	Bradford Northern
1948–49	Bradford Northern	12–0	Halifax
1949–50	Warrington	19–0	Widnes
1950–51	Wigan	10–0	Barrow
1951–52	Workington Town	18–10	Featherstone Rovers
1952–53	Huddersfield	15–10	St. Helens
1953–54	Warrington	4–4	Halifax
Replay	Warrington	8–4	Halifax
1954–55	Barrow	21–12	Workington Town
1955–56	St. Helens	13–2	Halifax
1956–57	Leeds	9–7	Barrow
1957–58	Wigan	13–9	Workington Town
1958–59	Wigan	30–13	Hull F.C.
1959–60	Wakefield Trinity	38–5	Hull F.C.
1960–61	St. Helens	12–6	Wigan
1961–62	Wakefield Trinity	12–6	Huddersfield
1962–63	Wakefield Trinity	25–10	Wigan
1963–64	Widnes	13–5	Hull Kingston Rovers
1964–65	Wigan	20–16	Hunslet
1965–66	St. Helens	21–2	Wigan
1966–67	Featherstone Rovers	17–12	Barrow
1967–68	Leeds	11–10	Wakefield Trinity
1968–69	Castleford	11–6	Salford
1969–70	Castleford	7–2	Wigan
1970–71	Leigh	24–7	Leeds
1971–72	St. Helens	16–13	Leeds
1972–73	Featherstone Rovers	33–14	Bradford Northern
1973–74	Warrington	24 –9	Featherstone Rovers
1974–75	Widnes	14–7	Warrington
1975–76	St. Helens	20–5	Widnes
1976–77	Leeds	16–7	Widnes
1977–78	Leeds	14–12	St. Helens
1978–79	Widnes	12–3	Wakefield Trinity
1979–80	Hull Kingston Rovers	10–5	Hull F.C.
1980–81	Widnes	18–9	Hull Kingston Rovers
1981–82	Hull F.C.	14–14	Widnes
Replay	Hull F.C.	18–9	Widnes
1982–83	Featherstone Rovers	14–12	Hull F.C.
1983–84	Widnes	19–6	Wigan
1984–85	Wigan	28–24	Hull F.C.
1985–86	Castleford	15–14	Hull Kingston Rovers
1986–87	Halifax	19–18	St. Helens
1987–88	Wigan	32–12	Halifax
1988–89	Wigan	27–0	St. Helens
1989–90	Wigan	36–14	Warrington
1990–91	Wigan	13–8	St. Helens
1991–92	Wigan	28–12	Castleford
1992–93	Wigan	20–14	Widnes
1993–94	Wigan	26–16	Leeds
1994–95	Wigan	30–10	Leeds
1996	St. Helens	40–32	Bradford
1997	St. Helens	32–22	Bradford
1998	Sheffield Eagles	17–8	Wigan
1999	Leeds	52– 16	London Broncos
2000	Bradford	24–18	Leeds
2001	St. Helens	13–6	Bradford
2002	Wigan	21–12	St. Helens
2003	Bradford	22–20	Leeds
2004	St. Helens	32–16	Wigan
2005	Hull F.C.	25–24	Leeds
2006	St. Helens	42–12	Huddersfield
2007	St. Helens	30–8	Catalans Dragons
2008	St. Helens	28–16	Hull F.C.
2009	Warrington	25–16	Huddersfield
2010	Warrington	30–6	Leeds
2011	Wigan	28–18	Leeds
2012	Warrington	35–18	Leeds
2013	Wigan	16–0	Hull F.C.
2014	Leeds	23–10	Castleford
2015	Leeds	50–0	Hull Kingston Rovers
2016	Hull F.C.	12–10	Warrington
2017	Hull F.C.	18–14	Wigan
2018	Catalans Dragons	20–14	Warrington
2019	Warrington	18–4	St. Helens
2020	Leeds	17–16	Salford

Winners

Clubs ordered by number of wins, then by number of runners-up appearances, then by how recently they last won a final, then finally by how recently they last made a runners-up appearance. Only the aggregate winner/loser for the years during the Second World War has been counted.

	Club	Wins	Last win	Runners-up	Last final lost	Total finals
1	Wigan	19	2013	13	2017	32
2	Leeds	14	2020	12	2012	26
3	St. Helens	12	2008	10	2019	22
4	Warrington	9	2019	10	2018	19
5	Widnes	7	1984	6	1993	13
6	Huddersfield	6	1953	4	2009	10
7	Hull	5	2017	12	2013	17
8	Halifax	5	1987	7	1988	12
9	Bradford	5	2003	6	2001	11
10	Wakefield	5	1963	3	1979	8
11	Castleford	4	1986	2	2014	6
12	Oldham	3	1927	4	1926	7
13	Featherstone Rovers	3	1983	2	1974	5
13	Swinton	3	1928	2	1932	5
15	Batley	3	1901	0	–	3
16	Hunslet §	2	1934	2	1965	4
17	Dewsbury	2	1943	1	1929	3
18	Leigh	2	1971	0	–	2
18	Broughton Rangers	2	1911	0	–	2
20	Salford	1	1938	7	2020	8
21	Hull Kingston Rovers	1	1980	6	2015	7
22	Barrow	1	1955	4	1967	5
23	Workington Town	1	1952	2	1958	3
24	Catalans Dragons	1	2018	1	2007	2
24	Bradford F.C. §	1	1906	1	1898	2
26	Sheffield Eagles	1	1998	0	–	1
26	Rochdale Hornets	1	1922	0	–	1
28	London Broncos	0	–	1	1999	1
28	Keighley	0	–	1	1937	1
28	York §	0	–	1	1931	1

• GOLD Denotes current holders
• § Denotes club now defunct

The Double

Main article: The Double (rugby league)

In Rugby League, the term 'the Double' is referring to the achievement of a club that wins the Super League (Rugby Football League Championship First Division before 1996) and Challenge Cup in the same season. To date, this has been achieved by ten different clubs.

	Club	Wins	Winning Years
1	Wigan	7	1989–90, 1990–91, 1991–92, 1992–93, 1993–94, 1994–95, 2013
2	St. Helens	3	1965–66, 1996, 2006
3	Huddersfield	2	1912–13, 1914–15
4	Broughton Rangers	1	1901–02
5	Halifax	1	1902–03
6	Hunslet	1	1907–08
7	Swinton	1	1927–28
8	Warrington	1	1953–54
9	Bradford	1	2003
10	Leeds	1	2015

The Treble

Main article: The Treble (rugby league)

The Treble refers to the team who wins all three domestic honours on offer during the season; Grand Final, League Leaders' Shield and Challenge Cup. To date seven teams have won the treble, only Bradford, St. Helens and Leeds have won the treble in the Super League era.

	Club	Wins	Winning years
1	Wigan	3	1991–92, 1993–94, 1994–95
2	Huddersfield	2	1912–13, 1914–15
3	St. Helens	2	1965–66, 2006
4	Hunslet	1	1907–08
5	Swinton	1	1927–28
6	Bradford	1	2003
7	Leeds	1	2015

All Four Cups

Main article: All Four Cups

Winning all Four Cups currently refers to winning the Super League (or RFL First Division Championship prior to 1996–97 season), League Leaders' Shield, Challenge Cup and World Club Challenge in one season. Not all of these cups were available in the past but have replaced other cups that could be won.

	Club	Wins	Winning years
1	Hunslet	1	1907–08
2	Huddersfield	1	1914–15
3	Swinton	1	1927–28
4	Wigan	1	1994–95
5	Bradford	1	2003–04
6	St. Helens	1	2006–07

The BBC first covered the final of this competition when Wigan beat Bradford Northern in 1948. At that time though the only TV transmitter was in London, so fans up North never got to see it. It was another four years before another final was covered when Workington Town beat Featherstone Rovers in 1952. The cup final was not broadcast on TV again until the 1958 final between Wigan and Workington Town since when it has been shown every year. The inception of Grandstand also saw coverage of earlier rounds start to be shown during the 1960s with ITV "World of Sport" even showing games as well for a short period.

The BBC has been the predominant broadcaster, showing every final live since 1958 (except the 1982 Final Replay shown as highlights). Eddie Waring was the first commentator for BBC coverage. When he retired, commentary was covered by Ray French and he continues to work for the BBC albeit in semi-retirement, with his last Challenge Cup Final in 2008. From 2009, the present day main commentator is Dave Woods. He usually commentates with Brian Noble, Jonathan Davies, Iestyn Harris or Ian Millward. Nowadays, the BBC continue to broadcast the tournament with Clare Balding hosting from 2006 to 2012 until her move to Channel 4 Racing. Mark Chapman was secondary host in 2012 when Balding was unavailable for the cup and international matches, and previous hosts for the BBC are John Inverdale and Steve Rider. The current main hosts (2018) are Mark Chapman and Super League Show presenter Tanya Arnold.

Sky Sports currently have the rights for the early rounds with one match each round and two quarter finals; whilst BBC Sport show two sixth round matches, two quarter finals, both semi-finals and the final.

International

Country/ Region	Broadcaster
France	beIn Sports
New Zealand	Sky Sport
	Māori Television
United States	Fox Soccer Plus
Brazil	BandSports
Russia	NTV+
Balkans	Sportklub
Australia	Fox League
Canada	Game TV and CBC Sports

• Amco Cup
• British rugby league system
• List of sports attendance figures
• Super League

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Challenge Cup.

• The Challenge Cup at therfl.co.uk