Regional state
A regional state or a regionalised unitary state, is a term used to denote a type of state that is formally unitary but where a high degree of political power has been highly decentralised to regional governments. This contrasts with a state organized on principles of federalism (either a federal republic such as the United States, Brazil, or India or a federal monarchy such as Belgium or Malaysia) where the powers of the regions are enshrined in constitutional law. In many cases, the regions are based on long standing cultural or regional divisions.
Europe
Many regional states exist in Europe because many European states are very old and their constitutional structures evolved from absolute monarchy and hold that power emanates from the central government. This means that any regional autonomy is theoretically only existent at the sufferance of the central government. However, in practice, there would be enormous popular and political resistance if the central government tried to revoke the autonomy of a region. This can be seen in the opposition to the Spanish government's application of direct rule in Catalonia during and immediately after the Catalan crisis. Catalonia's autonomy has since been restored.
Spain
One example of a regional state is Spain which is divided into autonomous communities which are highly autonomous government bodies that exercise a large degree of lawmaking and in some cases tax-setting authority but are officially creations of the central government. They are designed to ensure limited autonomy for the nationalities and regions of Spain such as the Catalans and the Galicians, among others. Many political parties in Spain, especially those expressing one of the various regional nationalisms, have called for the creation of a full federal system in the country, as opposed to the current system, which is often described as "federalism in all but name" or "federation without federalism".
Italy
Italy is another European regional state since it is divided into 20 regions that exercise significant authority. Five of the regions (Sicily, Sardinia, Friuli Venezia Giulia, Trentino-Alto Adige/Südtirol, and the Val d'Aosta) are more autonomous than the others. As in Spain, some politicians and political parties in the country, especially those that express regionalist ideology, favor the establishment of a federal system in Italy.
Others
Europe is the continent with the most regional states. Though Spain and Italy are the most well known for their regional structures, Greece, Ukraine, France and the United Kingdom are all also regionalised, being respectively divided into Decentralized administrations of Greece,Oblasts of Ukraine, Regions of France, and Countries of the United Kingdom (The UK also has a number of other types of devolved government, notably the Crown Dependencies and British Overseas Territories). There are also several federations in Europe, notably Germany, Austria, and Belgium but also Bosnia and Herzegovina, Russia, Switzerland and debatably the Kingdom of the Netherlands (not to be confused with The Netherlands which forms one of its constituent countries, though overwhelmingly the most important one)
Americas
There is only one regional state in the Americas, Bolivia. The reason for this is that the American states are, on average, much more recently created than those in Europe. Thus, federal structures are much more common and are found in the United States, Canada, Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, Venezuela, and formerly in the West Indies Federation. Other countries such as Saint Kitts and Nevis and Antigua and Barbuda have devolved power to certain regions but they are not regionalized because the regional system does not expend across the whole nation.
European territories
Several European countries (namely the Netherlands, France and the UK) all have overseas territories in the Caribbean that have devolved governments of their own.
Asia
China
China might be considered a regional state since significant levels of power are exercised by the provinces and autonomous regions as well as the special administrative regions. Provinces exercise such a degree of independent authority that some analysts claim that there exists a de facto federation in China because of striking differences in the nature of state policy between provinces, as exemplified by the competing Chongqing model and Guangdong model. Taiwan, which may or may not be considered part of China also devolves significant authority to its various administrative divisions.
Indonesia
Indonesia is a regionalised unitary state. Though it was formerly a federal country for a brief period following its independence under the name United States of Indonesia, this system was replaced by a unitary one in 1950. However, the country is divided into provinces, which exercise significant authority over local issues because of the large size of the country. Additionally, some regions such as Western New Guinea and Aceh have more autonomy because of their unique and often fractious relationship with the national government. Yogyakarta Sultanate is also a region of Indonesia that has a special relationship with the central government, being a monarchy where the Sultan of Yogyakarta serves in a position similar to a governor.
Philippines
The Philippines is divided into provinces and the Bangsamoro autonomous region. The Provinces exercise significant degree of authority in local matters. Many people in the Philippines propose the creation of a federation.
Africa
There are several regional states in Africa. Federal structures are common here because the countries in Africa, with the exceptions of Liberia and Ethiopia, all came into existence in the 20th or 21st centuries and thus were not constrained by old constitutional structures in setting up their governments.
South Africa
South Africa is a regional state divided into a number of provinces. All the provinces have their own elected provincial legislature and Premier and exercise significant degrees of authority. Some people and political parties, most notably the Inkatha Freedom Party, advocate the establishment of a federal system where the provinces would be the federal units.
Tanzania
Tanzania is divided into 21 regions as well as Zanzibar. The regions exercise a large degree of political power. However, Zanzibar is more autonomous than the others with its own leader, the President of Zanzibar, and the Zanzibar House of Representatives as its legislature.
References
- Glassner, Martin Ira. Political Geography, 2nd Edition. New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc., 1995.