Benjamin Ogle Tayloe House

Front view

Benjamin Ogle Tayloe married Julia Maria Dickinson on November 8, 1824.[3] Although Tayloe preferred to live at Windsor, his estate in King George County, Virginia, his wife asked that they move into the city, where she was more comfortable.[4] The house was constructed on Lots 10 and 11 in Square 221.[5] At the time of the building's construction in 1828,[6] the expanse of the city from 15th Street NW (one block east of the home) to 17th Street NW from the White House north to H Street NW was a flat field bare of trees and shrubs.[7]

As originally built, the Federal-style[8] house had three stories.[9] The completed house had four or five parlors.[10] It was built of unpainted, cream-colored brick.[11] The entrance was level with the ground, with an oriel window above it on the second floor and a Palladian window on the third floor above that.[12] An oval portico protected visitors arriving at the front doors.[11]

The house was completed in 1828, but not immediately occupied. Tayloe had a strong political disagreement with the newly elected President, Andrew Jackson, and refused to move into the home.[4] Tayloe leased the building to Thomas Swann, Sr., a lawyer (and the father of Thomas Swann, Jr., who became Governor of Maryland in 1866).[13] Swann vacated the home in November 1829, at which time Tayloe and his wife occupied it.[4] The house was an important social gathering place for important Washingtonians in the four decades following its construction.[9][14] In 1829, when Henry Clay left the office of Secretary of State, much of the furniture in his home was acquired by the Tayloes and used to decorate their home.[15] Tayloe House was the last house in Washington visited by President William Henry Harrison before his death in 1841.[16][17]

Benjamin Ogle Tayloe by Thomas Sully

Julia Tayloe died on July 4, 1846.[18] Tayloe married Phoebe Warren on April 17, 1849.[19]

The House was the scene of a murder in 1859. Philip Barton Key II was the son of Francis Scott Key and the nephew of Chief Justice Roger B. Taney.[20] In the spring of 1858, Key began having an affair with Teresa Bagioli Sickles, the wife of his friend Daniel Sickles.[21] On February 26, 1859, Sickles learned of the affair.[22] The following day, he saw Key in Lafayette Square signalling to his wife.[22] Sickles rushed out into the park, drew a single pistol, and shot the unarmed Key three times while the other man pleaded for his life.[22] Key was taken into the nearby Tayloe House and died moments later.[19] Key's spirit, eyewitnesses and authors claim, now haunts Lafayette Square and can be seen on dark nights near the spot where he was shot.[23]

Plaque

The Tayloe house became a noted meeting place for many of the leading political figures of early 19th-century American politics. Tayloe was one of the most influential and active members of the Whig Party in the District of Columbia.[24] Among the many frequent visitors to the house were Chief Justice John Marshall, Senator and Secretary of State Henry Clay, Senator and Secretary of State Daniel Webster, Vice President and Secretary of State John C. Calhoun, Senator Henry Clay, Senator and Secretary of State Lewis Cass, Secretary of State Edward Livingston, Speaker of the House and Senator Robert Charles Winthrop, General Winfield Scott, Senator and Secretary of State Edward Everett, Senator and Secretary of State William H. Seward, Associate Justice Joseph Story, and many others.[25] Presidents John Quincy Adams, Martin Van Buren, William Henry Harrison, Zachary Taylor, and Millard Fillmore also were frequent guests.[26] Anthony Trollope spent much of his free time being entertained by the Tayloes at their home during his visit to Washington, D.C., in the winter of 1862.[24]

Benjamin Ogle Tayloe died on February 28, 1868,[27] and Phoebe Tayloe inherited the house.[28] After she died in 1881, more than 200 marble statues, bronze sculptures, items of fine furniture, and paintings in the house were donated to the Corcoran Gallery of Art.[29] Phoebe Warren Tayloe's niece, Elizabeth H. Price, inherited the house in 1882.[30]

In April 1885, the Cosmos Club considered purchasing the house from the Tayloe family. The influential club already owned most of the block north of the Tayloe House, and was expanding rapidly. It valued the home at $60,000 and the furnishings at an additional $5,000.[31] The Cosmos Club declined to buy the home after an investigation found that the cost of upgrading the Tayloe property for its use would be too costly.[32]

Senator Don Cameron of Pennsylvania purchased the Benjamin Ogle Tayloe House for $60,000 in 1887,[33] and resided there for a time.[28] Cameron expanded the home significantly, almost entirely rebuilding its interior.[34] After the renovation, the front entrance opened onto a square entrance hall.[35] A fireplace adorned the hall.[35] Large rooms on either side of the entrance hall were used as office space.[12] A broad staircase led from the entrance hall up to the second floor, where there were four large rooms.[35] The rooms opened on to one another, permitting the second floor to be opened up into something approaching a single large ballroom.[12] The windows on the second floor reached to the floor.[12] An iron veranda ran around the entire second floor.[33] The home contained a total of 30 rooms after the renovation.[33] Cameron did not, however, renovate the exterior, which remained much the same as it always had.[36] Henry Adams was a frequent guest of the Camerons, playing often with their daughter Martha to alleviate his bouts of depression.[37]

About 1896, the U.S. Senate passed legislation which would have made the building the official residence of the Vice President of the United States, but the House of Representatives failed to act on the bill.[34]

The Tayloe House in 1886, the year before Sen. Don Cameron purchased it

Cameron leased the house to Vice President Garret Hobart from March 1897 until the fall of 1899.[38] No other Vice President had ever lived so close to the White House,[39] and this close proximity helped boost Hobart's access to and influence with the President so much that he was called "Assistant President" and is now considered one of the most powerful Vice Presidents in U.S. history.[40] On several occasions Hobart entertained the entire U.S. Senate at the house, as well as President William McKinley.[41] The International Boundary Commission (which established much of the water and land boundary between the U.S. and Canada) dined in the house at a formal dinner hosted by Hobart, as did Prince Albert of Belgium.[42] The press and public nicknamed the house the "Historic Corner" and the "Cream White House" (a reference to the color of its brickwork) for the large number of politically important visitors and meetings held on the premises during Hobart's tenure there.[43] Hobart's failing health led the family to leave the Tayloe House in the fall of 1899 and return to New Jersey (where Hobart died on November 21).[38]

Cameron then leased the home to Senator Mark Hanna from January 1900 to 1902.[44] Hanna developed his plans for the re-election of President McKinley while resident in the house, plans which gave rise to the first "big money" presidential election in U.S. history.[45] The home was also host to Hanna's famous large breakfasts of corned beef hash and pancakes, over which the most important political decisions of the moment would be made.[46] These meals were so politically important that President Theodore Roosevelt breakfasted with Hanna every Sunday.[46] McKinley and other politically powerful people visited the home so much that it became known as the "Little White House."[14][25][45] It was at just such a breakfast on March 10, 1902, that J. P. Morgan asked Senator Hanna whether the United States government had any intention of filing an antitrust lawsuit against the recently formed Northern Securities Company.[47][48] Hanna said the government would not file suit against the trust.[49] When the government filed suit hours later, Morgan accused Hanna of betraying him, and Hanna accused Roosevelt of betraying him.[47] Hanna died in office on February 15, 1904.

The Congressional Union for Woman Suffrage leased the house in the fall of 1915, and made the building its headquarters for two years.[45] The group rented the house in order to emphasize their importance in the fight for women's suffrage.[25]

The Tayloe House with the Markey National Courts Building to the right and background

The Cosmos Club finally purchased the house on December 1, 1917.[50][51] It used the home as its women's annex, and converted the stables into a meeting hall.[50]

The Cosmos Club vacated the Tayloe House in 1952 to move to new headquarters in the Townsend Mansion at 2121 Massachusetts Avenue NW,[52] at which time the building was purchased by the U.S. government and used for offices.[53][54] From October 1958 until November 1961, the headquarters of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) were in the Tayloe House.[55] T. Keith Glennan, the first Administrator of NASA, also had his office in the structure.[55]

In 1960, the Tayloe House was nearly razed. The impetus for tearing down nearly all the historic structures on Lafayette Square began 60 years before. In 1900, the United States Congress passed a resolution establishing the U.S. Senate Park Commission (also known as the "McMillan Commission" because it was chaired by Michigan's Republican Senator James McMillan).[56] The Park Commission's charge was to reconcile competing visions for the development of Washington, D.C., and in particular the National Mall and adjacent areas.[56] The Park Commission's proposals, which came to be known as the "McMillan Plan," proposed that all the buildings around Lafayette Square be razed and replaced by tall, Neoclassical buildings clad in white marble for use by executive branch agencies.[57] For a time, it appeared that the Cutts-Madison House would not survive. William Wilson Corcoran's Corcoran House at 1615 H Street NW was torn down in 1922 and replaced with the Neoclassical United States Chamber of Commerce headquarters.[58] The Hay-Adams Houses were razed in 1927 by real estate developer Harry Wardman, and the Hay–Adams Hotel built on the site.[59] At nearby 1616 H Street NW, the Brookings Institution purchased the rear garden from the private owners of the Decatur House and built an eight-story Modernist office building there.[60] Several million dollars were spent in the late 1950s on designs to raze all the buildings on the east side of Lafayette Square and replace them with a white, modernist office building which would house judicial offices.[61]

Opposition to the demolition of the Tayloe House and other buildings on Lafayette Square began forming shortly after the plan to raze the structures was announced. Senators James E. Murray and Wayne Morse, several members of the House of Representatives, and citizens of the District of Columbia lobbied to defeat the legislation authorizing the demolition of the buildings.[62] The American Institute of Architects (AIA) devoted the February 1961 issue of its journal to a "Lament for Lafayette Square."[63] The AIA established a committee to develop plans to save the buildings and adapt the new structures so that they incorporated the style and feel of the older homes.[64]

The newly elected Kennedy administration indicated on February 16, 1961, that it was anxious to retain the existing historic homes on Lafayette Square.[65] In November, the Committee of 100 on the Federal City (an influential group of city leaders) asked President Kennedy to save and restore all the remaining buildings on Lafayette Square.[66] In February 1962, First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy lobbied General Services Administration (GSA) director Bernard L. Boutin to stop the demolition and adopt a different design plan.[67] "The wreckers haven't started yet, and until they do it can be saved," she wrote.[68] Mrs. Kennedy enlisted architect John Carl Warnecke, a friend of her husband's who happened to be in town that weekend,[69] to create a design which would incorporate the new buildings with the old.[70] Warnecke conceived the basic design over that weekend,[70] and worked closely with Mrs. Kennedy over the next few months to formalize the design proposal.[71] The design was presented to the public and the Commission of Fine Arts (which had approval over any plan) in October 1962, and with Mrs. Kennedy's backing the Commission adopted the revised Warnecke design proposal.[72]

Warnecke's design for the square was based on the architectural theory of contextualism.[73] Not only did Warnecke's design build the first modern buildings on Lafayette Square, but they were the first buildings in the city to utilize contextualism as a design philosophy.[73] Warnecke's design for the Markey National Courts Building was to create tall, flat structures in red brick which would serve as relatively unobtrusive backgrounds to the lighter-colored residential homes like the Cutts-Madison House.[73] The Cutts-Madison House, Cosmos Club building, and Benjamin Ogle Tayloe House were joined, and a courtyard built between them and the National Courts Building.[73]

The Tayloe House has remained part of the National Courts building complex ever since.

• Mount Airy, Richmond County, Virginia, the country estate house built in 1762 by Col. John Tayloe II