Fethullah Gülen

Muhammed Fethullah Gülen (born 27 April 1941) is a Turkish Islamic scholar, preacher, and a one-time opinion leader (as de facto leader of the Gülen movement: an international, faith-based civil society organization once aligned with Turkey's government, but since then outlawed as an alleged "armed terrorist group").[13][14] Gülen is designated an influential Ottomanist,[15] Anatolian panethnicist,[16][17] Islamic poet, writer,[18] social critic, and activist–dissident developing a Nursian theological perspective[19] that embraces democratic modernity,[17] as a citizen of Turkey (until his denaturalization by the government in 2017)[20] he was a local state imam from 1959 to 1981.[21][22] Over the years, Gülen became a centrist political figure in Turkey prior his there being as a fugitive. Since 1999, Gülen has lived in self-exile in the United States near Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania.[23][24][25]

Fethullah Gülen
Born
Muhammed Fethullah Gülen

(1941-04-27) 27 April 1941
Pasinler, Erzurum, Turkey
NationalityTurkish
OccupationScholar, author, preacher
Known forGülen movement
Writing career
SubjectModerate Islam
Turkish politics
Anti-communism
Nuanced Turkish nationalism
Universal education
Interfaith dialogue among people of the Book (Ahl al-kitab) and by extension all peoples[1]
Literary movementNurcu
Notable awards2015 Gandhi King Ikeda Award for Peace[2][3]
Philosophy career
SchoolHanafi[4][5]
Main interests
Islamic thought
moderate, Anatolian Sufism[6]
Websitefgulen.com
"These core values are not about a style of dressing or the use of religious slogans. They include respect for the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary, accountability for the rulers and the preservation of inalienable rights and freedoms of every citizen. The recent setback in the Turkish democratic experience is not because of adherence to these Islamic values, but rather because of their betrayal."

 — «L’échec de l’expérience démocratique turque n’est pas dû à l’adhésion aux valeurs islamiques mais à leur trahison», Fethullah Gülen, Le Monde, 25 February 2019[8][9][10][11][12]

Gülen says his social criticisms are focused upon individuals' faith and morality and a lesser extent toward political ends[26] and self describes as rejecting an Islamist political philosophy, his advocating instead for full participation within professions, society, and political life by religious and secular individuals who profess high moral or ethical principles and who wholly support secular rule, within Muslim-majority countries and elsewhere.[27] Gülen founded the Gülen movement (known as the hizmet, meaning service in Turkish), which is a 3-to-6 million strong, volunteer-based movement in Turkey and around the world. (All Hizmet's schools, foundations and other entities in Turkey have been closed by the Turkish government following the 2016 Turkish coup d'état attempt.[28][29]) Along with the movement's participant's (Gülenists') individual piety and/or ethical conduct, they promote education, civil society, and religious tolerance initiatives and establish social networks. These networks self-describe as originating spontaneously, their constituent local entities functioning independently from each other, existing, in the aggregate, as leaderless activist entities. "I really don’t know 0.1% of the people in this movement", Gülen has said. "I haven’t done much. I have just spoken out on what I believe. Because it [Gülen's teachings] made sense, people grasped it themselves." "I opened one school to see if people liked it. So they created more schools."[30] Inasmuch as the movement includes individuals with advanced theological training serving as "imams" and spiritual counselors on the macro level, with these individuals' identities remaining confidential (reflecting such positions' technical illegality in Turkey, under the formerly Kemalist laws there outlawing religious orders), some observers argue that the movement thus includes a clandestine aspect.[31][32][33]

Sharing Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's ambition to empower religious individuals in civil life previously disenfranchised in secular Turkey, in 2003 a number of Gülen movement participants pivoted from the Turkish political center to become the junior partner with the newly ruling Erdoğan-led and center-right Justice and Development Party (AKP), providing the party political and sorely-needed administrative support.[34][35][36] This political alliance worked together to weaken left-of-center Kemalist factions in the judiciary, military, and police (see Ergenekon trials). It internally fractured in 2011, which became common knowledge by the time of the corruption investigations of highly placed members of Turkey's ruling party in 2013.[35][37][38][39][40][41] Turkish prosecutors accuse Gülen of attempts to overthrow the government by allegedly directing politically motivated corruption investigations by Gülen-linked investigators then in the judiciary,[42][43] who illegally wiretapped the executive office of the Turkish president,[14] and, with assistance perhaps from unnamed individuals in the American intelligence community, Gülen's alleged instigations or fomentations toward the 2016 coup attempt by factions within Turkish armed forces indeed including Gülenists.[44][11] Gülen says he did not personally influence past prosecutions of Justice and Development Party members by judiciary prosecutors from assorted political factions[45] and has said he has "stood against all coups."[46] A Turkish criminal court has issued an arrest warrant for Gülen.[47][48] Turkey is demanding the extradition of Gülen from the United States.[38][49][50] U.S. government officials do not believe he is associated with any terrorist activity, and have requested evidence to be provided by the Turkish Government to substantiate the allegations in the warrant requesting extradition, frequently rejecting Turkish calls for his extradition.[51][52][53]

In a February 2019 opinion piece, Gülen said, "[I]n Turkey, a vast arrest campaign based on guilt by association is ongoing. The number of victims of this campaign of persecution keeps increasing [...]. Erdogan is draining the reputation that the Turkish Republic has gained in the international arena, pushing Turkey into the league of nations known for suffocating freedoms and jailing democratic dissenters. The ruling clique is exploiting diplomatic relations, mobilizing government personnel and resources to harass, haunt and abduct Hizmet movement volunteers all around the world."[54] Gülen is actively involved in the societal debate concerning the future of the Turkish state, and Islam in the modern world. He has been described in the English-language media as an imam "who promotes a tolerant Islam which emphasises altruism, hard work and education" and as "one of the world's most important Muslim figures."[55][56] Gülen is wanted as a terrorist leader in Turkey[57] and Pakistan[58] as well as by the governments of OIC[59][60] and GCC.[61]

Biography
The young Gülen

Muhammed Fethullah Gülen[62] was born in the village of Korucuk, near Erzurum,[63][64] to Ramiz and Refia Gülen,[65] There is some confusion over his birth date. Some accounts, usually older ones, give it as 10 November 1938, while others give 27 April 1941.[63][66] Some commentators point to the 10 November 1938 date coinciding with the death of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, who founded modern Turkey, and suggests that it was deliberately chosen for its political significance.[63][67] An alternative explanation for the discrepancy offered by one of Gülen's close students, and biographer, was that his parents waited 3 years to register his birth.[68] State documents support the 1941 date,[63][66] and Gülen's English website now uses that;[63] it is now the accepted date.[63][66]

His father was an imam.[69] His mother taught the Qur'an in their village, despite such informal religious instruction being banned by the Kemalist government.[70] Gülen's secular formal education ended when his family moved to another village.[69][71] He took part in Islamic education in some Erzurum madrasas[72] and he gave his first sermon as a licensed state preacher in 1958, when he was in his teens.[73] Gülen was influenced by the ideas of Kurdish scholar Said Nursî.[74]

Gülen was in the Turkish civil service from his appointment as an assistant imam at Üç Şerefeli Mosque in Edirne, 6 August 1959,[75] until he retired from formal preaching duties in 1981.

While Gülen was teaching at the Kestanepazari Qur'anic School in Izmir, the coup of 12 March 1971, occurred. During its aftermath, Gülen was arrested for organizing a clandestine religious group based on his teachings and was imprisoned for seven months.[76]

From 1988 to 1991 he gave a series of sermons in popular mosques of major cities. In 1994, he participated in the founding of "Journalists and Writers Foundation"[77] and was given the title "Honorary President" by the foundation.[78] He did not make any comment regarding the closures of the Welfare Party in 1998[79] or the Virtue Party in 2001.[80] He has met some politicians like Tansu Çiller and Bülent Ecevit, but he avoids meeting with the leaders of Islamic political parties.[80]

In 1999, Gülen relocated to the United States for medical treatment.[81] According to the Kemalist Turkish law of the time, intending to ensure modernity and secularism, non-state sanctioned religious endeavors were outlawed and Gülen could have anticipated being tried especially over remarks (aired after he immigrated to U.S.) which seemed to favor an Islamic state.[82][83] In June 1999, after Gülen had left Turkey, videotapes were sent to some Turkish television stations with recordings of Gülen saying,

The existing system is still in power. Our friends who have positions in legislative and administrative bodies should learn its details and be vigilant all the time so that they can transform it and be more fruitful on behalf of Islam in order to carry out a nationwide restoration. However, they should wait until the conditions become more favorable. In other words, they should not come out too early.[84]

Gülen said his remarks were taken out of context,[85] and his supporters raised questions about the authenticity of the tape,[86] which he said had been "manipulated." Gülen was tried in absentia in 2000, and acquitted in 2008 under the new Justice and Development Party (AKP) government of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.[81][87]

Gülen applied for a green card in 2002.[88] After 11 September 2001, the U.S. increased its scrutiny of its domestic Islamic religious groups. Objecting to Gulen's residency application were the FBI, the State Department, and the Department of Homeland Security. Gülen first based his claim to residency on his being as an alien of extraordinary ability as an education activist; the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services rejected it. Lawyers representing the Secretary of Homeland Security argued in that Gülen has no degree or training in the field of education and questioned laudatory opinions about Gülen, cited by his lawyers, that had been expressed by scholars at academics conferences funded by Gulenist foundations. CIA National Intelligence Council former vice chairman Graham E. Fuller, former CIA official George Fidas and former US Ambassador to Turkey Morton Abramowitz wrote endorsement letters for Gülen's green card application in 2008.[89][90] The court ruled against the USCIS and in Gülen's favor, granting Gülen his green card.[91][92]

With the advent of Erdoğanist Turkey in the 2000s, structural impediments to Muslims' participation in civil life were gradually lifted. Many of those educated in institutions sponsored by participants in civil-society endeavors that Gülen had inspired ended up as members of the Turkey's judiciary, its governmental apparatus, and its military. In the build-up of societal conflicts in the period just prior to the 2016 Turkish coup d'état attempt, Erdoğanism changed in its perception of Gülenism from that of sometimes ally to a dangerous rival, attempting to construct a parallel state structure. Before and after the attempted putsch, Gülenists became the greatest portion of those caught up in the massive 2016–present purges in Turkey.[82]

On 19 December 2014, a Turkish court issued an arrest warrant for Gülen after over 20 journalists working for media outlets thought to be sympathetic to the Gülen movement were arrested. Gülen was accused of establishing and running an "armed terrorist group."[93]

As of 2018, Gülen resides at the Hizmet movement-affiliated Chestnut Retreat Center, a 25-acre wooded estate in the Poconos (within Ross Township, Monroe County, Pennsylvania, near Saylorsburg[94][95]).[96] About thirty people live and work on the estate, owned by the Golden Generation Foundation.[97] Never married, Gülen's own living quarters and study are within a pair of small rooms, whose rent he pays out of his publishing royalties and which contain a mattress on the floor, prayer mat, desk, bookshelves, and treadmill, within one of the estate's several structures, among which is a hall used as a mosque.[94][98][99] Gülen is reported to be in ill health. In 2017, reports identified four candidates to succeed Gulen, if necessary, in leadership of the Hizmet movement: Mehmet Ali Şengül, Cevdet Türkyolu, Osman Şimşek and Ahmet Kurucan.[100]

Influence in Turkish society and politics
Main article: Gülen movement

The Gülen movement, also known as Hizmet ('Service') or Cemaat (pronounced Jamaat and meaning 'Community'), has millions of followers, as well as many more abroad. Beyond the schools established by Gülen's followers, many Gülenists held positions of power in Turkey's police forces and judiciary.[101][102] Turkish and foreign analysts believe Gülen also has sympathizers in the Turkish parliament and that his movement controlled the widely read Islamic conservative Zaman newspaper, the private Bank Asya bank, the Samanyolu TV television station, and many other media and business organizations, including the Turkish Confederation of Businessmen and Industrialists (TUSKON).[103] All have been shut down following the coup attempt. In March 2011, the Turkish government arrested the investigative journalist Ahmet Şık and seized and banned his book The Imam's Army, the culmination of Şık's investigation into Gülen and the Gülen movement.[104]

Gülen taught a Hanafi version of Islam, deriving from Sunni Muslim scholar Said Nursî's teachings. Gülen has stated that he believes in science, interfaith dialogue among the People of the Book, and multi-party democracy.[55] He has initiated such dialogue with the Vatican[105] and some Jewish organizations.[106]

1970s, 1980s and 1990s

Gülen opened an ışık evler or "light houses" (students' hostel offering scholarships for poorer scholars[107]) in 1976, with there being informal sohbets (Quranic discussions) available there for the students as well. Gülen encouraged like-minded individuals to follow suit, which became the genesis of the Gülen movement.[108]

During the political violence in Turkey between the right and left in the 1970s, Gülen "invited people to practice tolerance and forgiveness."[109] Following the 1980 Turkish coup d'état, in which the military targeted communists, Gülen gave his "explicit assent" to the coup,[109] saying:

I want to also add that the architects of the coup also took some positive administrative decisions. They shook society to renew itself once again. They defeated the Communist movement which recruited some misguided youth who wanted Turkey to be under Soviet influence. They intentionally or unintentionally prevented our country from entering into quagmire and into a long bloody struggle. Moreover, they gave opportunities to some decent children of our homeland to serve our nation.[110]

Following the political violence of the preceding years, Gülen expected that the coup would reestablish stability and lead to a subsequent restoration of democracy. Gülen's assent to the coup later prompted criticism from Turkish liberals.[109]

Despite Gülen's support for the coup, the military authorities issued an arrest warrant against him, which was revoked by a "state security court" in 1986.[110]

In the 1980s and 1990s under Turgut Özal, Gülen and his movement benefited from social and political reforms, managing "to turn his traditional and geographically confined faith movement into a nationwide educational and cultural phenomenon" that "attempted to bring 'religious' perspectives into the public sphere on social and cultural issues."[111] The growth of the Gülen movement sparked opposition from both Kemalists, who perceived the movement as threatening to undermine secularism, and from more radical Islamists who viewed the movement as "accommodating" and "pro-American."[112]

Ergenekon Trials
Main article: Ergenekon (allegation)

In 2005, a man affiliated with the Gülen movement approached U.S. Ambassador to Turkey Eric S. Edelman during a party in Istanbul and handed him an envelope containing a document supposedly detailing plans for an imminent coup against the government by the Turkish military. However, the documents were soon found to be forgeries.[102] Gülen affiliates state that the movement is "civic" in nature and that it does not have political aspirations.[103] However, he was accused of being the mastermind behind the Ergenekon trials by secularists, who see the trial's objective as weakening of Turkish military. Those who publicly said that the trial was a sham were subject to harassment by Zaman, some examples being Dani Rodrik[113] and İlhan Cihaner.[114]

Split with Erdoğan
Main article: 2013 corruption scandal in Turkey
Fethullah Gülen Recep Tayyip Erdoğan

Despite Gülen's and his followers' statements that the organization is non-political in nature, analysts believed that a number of corruption-related arrests made against allies of Erdoğan reflect a growing political power struggle between Gülen and Erdoğan.[101][115] These arrests led to the 2013 corruption scandal in Turkey, which the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP)'s supporters (along with Erdoğan himself) and the opposition parties alike have said were choreographed by Gülen after Erdoğan's government came to the decision early in December 2013 to shut down many of his movement's private pre-university schools in Turkey.[116]

The Erdoğan government has said that the corruption investigation and comments by Gülen are the long term political agenda of Gülen's movement to infiltrate security, intelligence, and justice institutions of the Turkish state, a charge almost identical to the charges against Gülen by the Chief Prosecutor of Turkey in his trial in 2000 before Erdoğan's party had come into power.[103] Gülen had previously been tried in absentia in 2000, and acquitted of these charges in 2008 under Erdoğan's AKP government.[81][87]

In emailed comments to the Wall Street Journal in January 2014, Gülen said that "Turkish people ... are upset that in the last two years democratic progress is now being reversed", but he denied being part of a plot to unseat the government.[117] Later, in January 2014 in an interview with BBC World, Gülen said "If I were to say anything to people I may say people should vote for those who are respectful to democracy, rule of law, who get on well with people. Telling or encouraging people to vote for a party would be an insult to peoples' intellect. Everybody very clearly sees what is going on."[118]

According to some commentators, Gülen is to Erdoğan what Trotsky was to Stalin.[119] Ben Cohen wrote: "Rather like Leon Trotsky, the founder of the Soviet Red Army who was hounded and chased out of the USSR by Joseph Stalin, Gülen has become an all-encompassing explanation for the existential threats, as Erdogan perceives them, that are currently plaguing Turkey. Stalin saw the influence of "Trotskyite counter-revolutionaries" everywhere, and brutally purged every element of the Soviet apparatus. Erdogan is now doing much the same with the "Gülenist terrorists."[120]

Extradition request, U.S.–Turkey tensions
See also: 2016 Turkish coup d'état attempt, Turkish government–Gülen movement conflict, and 2016–17 purges in Turkey

Shortly after the botched coup attempt of 15 July 2016, the Turkish government stated that the coup attempt had been organized by Gülen and/or his movement. Turkish prime minister Binali Yıldırım in late July 2016 told The Guardian: "Of course, since the leader of this terrorist organisation is residing in the United States, there are question marks in the minds of the people whether there is any U.S. involvement or backing. So America from this point on should really think how they will continue to cooperate with Turkey, which is a strategic ally for them in the region and world."[121] Gülen, who denied any involvement in the coup attempt and denounced it,[122] has in turn accused Erdoğan of "turning a failed putsch into a slow-motion coup of his own against constitutional government."[123]

On 19 July, an official request had been sent to the U.S. for the extradition of Fethullah Gülen.[124][125][126][127] On 23 July 2016, Turkey formally submitted a formal extradition request accompanied by certain documents as supporting evidence.[124][128][129] Senior U.S. officials said this evidence pertained to certain pre-coup alleged subversive activities.[130]

On 19 September, Turkish government officials met with retired US Army Lt. General Mike Flynn, former CIA Director James Woolsey, and others to discuss legal and potentially illegal ways such as enforced disappearance for removing Gülen from the US.[131] In March 2017, Flynn registered as a foreign agent for his 2016 lobbying work on behalf of the government of Turkey.[132]

Rudy Giuliani privately urged Donald Trump in 2017 to extradite Gülen.[133]

In addition, the Turkish government reportedly sought to pressure a number of foreign governments into shutting down schools and medical facilities allegedly associated with the Gülen movement including in Pakistan, Somalia, Germany, Indonesia, Nigeria and Kenya.[134] In Somalia, two large schools and a hospital linked to the movement have been shut down following a request by the Turkish administration.[135] Albania and Bosnia have also seen requests by Turkey to close or investigate Gülen-linked schools.[136]

Egypt asylum proposal
See also: Egypt–Turkey relations

In Egypt, MP Emad Mahrous called on the Egyptian government to grant asylum to Gülen. In the request, sent to Speaker of the House of Representatives Ali Abdel-Aal, Prime Minister Sherif Ismail and Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry on 24 July 2016, Mahrous notes that "[Turkey] was a moderate Muslim country that has become an Islamist dictatorship at the hands of [Turkish president] Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his affiliated Muslim Brotherhood political party," arguing that it was highly distasteful that Erdoğan has requested Gülen's extradition from the United States while at the same time"... giving shelter to hundreds of leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood terrorist organisation and members of other bloody militant Islamist groups which attack Egypt by day and night."[137]

Mahrous argues that Erdoğan has not only accused Gülen of plotting the failed coup attempt, but also used this allegation as an excuse to engage in mass purges against public institutions allegedly loyal to Gülen—"but at the same time Erdoğan has decided to turn Turkey into a media battleground against Egypt, with Turkish intelligence providing funds for several Muslim Brotherhood TV channels to attack Egypt". Mahrous stated that his advice to Gülen is to not wait until his extradition, but instead leave the United States and obtain permanent asylum in Egypt. Former Egyptian President Anwar Sadat granted asylum to Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi following his arrival in Egypt from the US, regardless of the threats that were issued by Iran's ayatollahs during the Iranian Revolution.[137]

Continuing aftermath

In March 2017, former CIA Director James Woolsey told the Wall Street Journal that he had been at a 19 September 2016 meeting with then Trump campaign advisor Mike Flynn with Turkey's foreign minister, Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu, and energy minister, Berat Albayrak, where the possibility of Gulen's abduction and forced rendition to Turkey was discussed.[138][139] Although no concrete kidnapping plan was discussed, Woolsey left the meeting, concerned that a general discussion about "a covert step in the dead of night to whisk this guy away" might be construed as illegal under American law.[140] A spokesman for Flynn denied Woolsey's account, telling Business Insider that no nonjudicial removal had been discussed at the meeting.[141]

In July 2017, one year after the anti-Erdoğan putsch, Gülen wrote: "Accusations against me related to the coup attempt are baseless, politically motivated slanders."[142][143] In the 1990s Gulen had been issued a special Turkish passport as a retired holder of the religious post, in the Turkish state religion of Sunni Islam, of mufti; in 2017 this passport was revoked.[144] Unless Gulen travels to Turkey by the end of September 2017, he will be stateless.[145] On 26 September 2017, Gulen asked for a United Nations commission to investigate the 2016 coup attempt.[146]

Also, Gulen said in an interview with NPR: "To this day, I have stood against all coups. My respect for the military aside, I have always been against interventions. ...If any one among those soldiers had called me and told me of their plan, I would tell them, 'You are committing murder.' ... If they ask me what my final wish is, I would say the person [Erdogan] who caused all this suffering and oppressed thousands of innocents, I want to spit in his face."[147]

On 28 September 2017, Erdoğan requested the U.S. to extradite Gülen in exchange for American pastor Andrew Brunson, under arrest in Turkey on charges related to Brunson's alleged affiliation with "FETO" (the Gulen movement); Erdoğan said, "You have a pastor too. Give him to us.... Then we will try [Brunson] and give him to you...."[148][149][150][151] "You have a pastor too. ... You give us that one and we'll work with our judiciary and give back yours."[149] The Federal judiciary alone determines extradition cases in the U.S. An August 2017 decree gave Erdogan authority to approve the exchange of detained or convicted foreigners with people held in other countries. Asked about the suggested swap on 28 September 2017, U.S. State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said: "I can't imagine that we would go down that road. ... We have received extradition requests for him [Gulen]." Anonymous US officials have said to reporters that the Turkish government has not yet provided sufficient evidence for the U.S. Justice Department to charge Gulen.[152]

As of September 2017, what Turkey had provided the U.S. was information about Gulen dating to before the 2016 coup attempt and Turkey was in the process of compiling information allegedly linking Gulen to the coup attempt.[153]

In 2017, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch separately issued statements urging governments to avoid extraditions to Turkey.[154]

In November 2018, the Trump administration asked the U.S. Justice Department to explore what legal justifications could be used, should it decide to seek for Gulen to be deported.[155] On 17 December 2018, the US Department of Justice announced the indictment of two men, alleging that they acted "in the United States as illegal agents of the Government of Turkey" and conspired "to covertly influence U.S. politicians and public opinion against" Fetullah Gulen.[156] The two men, former associates of ex-US national security adviser Michael Flynn, used the now-dissolved Flynn Intel Group in an effort to discredit Gulen dating back to July 2016, according to the indictment.[157]

Thought and activism

Initiatives
Main articles: Gülen movement, Gülen movement schools, and Alliance for Shared Values

The Gülen movement is a transnational Islamic civic society movement inspired by Gülen's teachings. His teachings about hizmet (altruistic service to the "common good") have attracted a large number of supporters in Turkey, Central Asia, and increasingly in other parts of the world.[nb 1]

Education

In his sermons, Gülen has reportedly stated: "Studying physics, mathematics, and chemistry is worshipping God."[81] With regard to terrorism, Gülen believes "The antidote is a religious education program that teaches the tradition in a holistic and contextualized way. To be able to resist the deceits of radical ideologues, young Muslims must understand the spirit of their scripture and the overarching principles of their Prophet’s life".[158]

Gülen's followers have built over 1,000 schools around the world.[159] In Turkey, Gülen's schools are considered among the best: expensive modern facilities and English language is taught from the first grade.[81] However, former teachers from outside the Gülen community have called into question the treatment of women and girls in Gülen schools, reporting that female teachers were excluded from administrative responsibilities, allowed little autonomy, and—along with girls from the sixth grade and up—segregated from male colleagues and pupils during break and lunch periods.[160]

Interfaith and intercultural dialogue
Gülen with Pope John Paul II in 1998.
Further information: Interfaith dialogue and Galip Hassan Kuscuoglu

During the 1990s, he began to advocate interreligious tolerance and dialogue.[106] He has personally met with leaders of other religions, including Pope John Paul II,[105] the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I of Constantinople, and Israeli Sephardic Head Rabbi Eliyahu Bakshi-Doron.[161]

Gülen has said that he favors cooperation between followers of different religions as well as religious and secular elements within society. Among his strongest supporters and collaborators has been for years the Greek Orthodox Turcologist and professor at the University of Ottawa, Dimitri Kitsikis.

Gülen has shown sympathy towards certain demands of Turkey's Alevi minority, such as recognising their cemevis as official places of worship and supporting better Sunni-Alevi relations; stating Alevis "definitely enrich Turkish culture."[162][163][164]

Theology

Gülen does not advocate a new theology but refers to classical authorities of theology, taking up their line of argument.[165] His understanding of Islam tends to be moderate and mainstream.[166][167] Though he has never been a member of a Sufi tarekat and does not see tarekat membership as a necessity for Muslims, he teaches that "Sufism is the inner dimension of Islam" and "the inner and outer dimensions must never be separated."[168]

He teaches that the Muslim community has a duty of service (Turkish: hizmet)[169] to the "common good" of the community and the nation[170] and to Muslims and non-Muslims all over the world;[171] and that the Muslim community is obliged to conduct dialogue with not just the "People of the Book" (Jews and Christians), and people of other religions, but also with agnostics and atheists.

Gülen's Sufism is greatly influenced by Sufi Kurdish Quranic scholar Said Nursi (1877–1960), who advocated illuminating modern education and science through Islam. Gulen expands on Nursi to advocate what has been described as a "Turkish nationalist, state-centered and pro-business approach" centered on service (hizmet, in Turkish).[29] Some participants within Gülen's movement have viewed Nursi's or Gülen's works as that of mujaddids or "renewers" of Islam within their respective times.[172][173] Others have opined in more eschatological terms, equating Gülen's work as assistance toward the prophesized Mahdi to come,[174] albeit Gülen's spokespersons discourage broaching such speculation.[175] and an official gülenist website hosts an article entitled "Claiming to be the Mahdi is Deviation".[176] In 2016, Turkey's Religious Affairs Directorate (Diyanet), Mehmet Görmez, said Gülen's is a "fake Mahdi movement."[177]

Anatolian nationalism; Turkish Islam

Gülen defines Turkish nationalism by particular type of Anatolian Muslim culture that is at the roots of the modern Turkish nation state, rather than by any specific ethnicity. He believes Turkish Islam (meaning "Sufism") an especially legitimate, if not an exclusively valid expression of the Islamic faith, especially with concern individuals of a Turkish background. Albeit Gülen ascribes positive characteristics to various localized entities, overall the tenor of Gülen's teachings warn against the human tendencies toward insularity or discriminations against people of other ethnicities, other branches of Islam, or other faiths.

Kurdish issues

He was accused of being against the peace process which had aimed to resolve the long-running Kurdish-Turkish conflict. However, Gülen's supporters dismiss this claim, citing his work with many Kurds.[178][179][180][181][182]

Freedom of expression

Excerpt from Gülen-penned op-ed in the New York Times:

The core tenets of a functioning democracy – the rule of law, respect for individual freedoms – are also the most basic of Islamic values bestowed upon us by God. No political or religious leader has the authority to take them away ... Speaking against oppression is a democratic right, a civic duty and for believers, a religious obligation. The Quran makes clear that people should not remain silent in the face of injustice: "O you who believe! Be upholders and standard-bearers of justice, bearing witness to the truth for God’s sake, even though it be against your own selves, or parents or kindred".[183]

Secularism

Gülen has criticized secularism in Turkey as "reductionist materialism". However, he has in the past said that a secular approach that is "not anti-religious" and "allows for freedom of religion and belief, is compatible with Islam."[184]

According to one Gülen press release, in democratic-secular countries, 95% of Islamic principles are permissible and practically feasible, and there is no problem with them. The remaining 5% "are not worth fighting for."[185]

Turkish bid to join the EU

Gülen has supported Turkey's bid to join the European Union and has said that neither Turkey nor the EU have anything to fear, but have much to gain, from a future of full Turkish membership in the EU.[184]

Women's roles

According to Aras and Caha, Gülen's views on women are "progressive".[79] Gülen says the coming of Islam saved women, who "were absolutely not confined to their home and ... never oppressed" in the early years of the religion. He feels that extreme feminism, however, is "doomed to imbalance like all other reactionary movements" and eventually "being full of hatred towards men."[186]

Terrorism

Gülen has condemned terrorism.[187] He warns against the phenomenon of arbitrary violence and aggression against civilians and said that it "has no place in Islam". He wrote a condemnation article in the Washington Post on 12 September 2001, one day after the September 11 attacks, and stated that "A Muslim can not be a terrorist, nor can a terrorist be a true Muslim."[188][189] Gülen lamented the "hijacking of Islam" by terrorists.[106]

Gaza flotilla

Gülen criticized the Turkish-led Gaza flotilla for trying to deliver aid without Israel's consent to Palestinians in Gaza.[190] He spoke of watching the news coverage of the deadly confrontation between Israeli commandos and multinational aid group members as its flotilla approached Israel's sea blockade of Gaza. He said, "What I saw was not pretty, it was ugly." He has since continued his criticism, saying later that the organizers' failure to seek accord with Israel before attempting to deliver aid was "a sign of defying authority, and will not lead to fruitful matters."[191]

Syrian Civil War

Gülen is strongly against Turkish involvement in the Syrian Civil War.[192] While rejecting the Turkish government's desire to topple the Syrian government of President Bashar al-Assad, Gülen supports military intervention against ISIL.[193][194]

Armenian genocide

Addressing the Armenian genocide in a 6 May 1965 letter, Gülen wrote: "I have known Armenian families and individuals during my childhood and working positions. I will not stop cursing the Great Genocide committed against Armenians in 1915. I know that among the people killed and massacred were many highly respected individuals, for whose memory I bow with respect. I curse with great grief the massacre of the sons of the Great Prophet Christ by ignorant individuals who call themselves Muslims."[195]

Publications

Gülen's official website[196] lists 44 publications by him; these are, however, more akin to essays and collections of sermons than books on specific subjects with a specific thesis. He is also said to have authored many articles on a variety of topics: social, political and religious issues, art, science and sports, and recorded thousands of audio and video cassettes. He writes the lead article for The Fountain, Yeni Ümit, Sızıntı, and Yağmur Islamic philosophical magazines. Several of his books have been translated into English.[197]

  • The Messenger of God: Muhammad, Tughra Books, 2nd edition, 2008. ISBN 1597841374
  • Reflections on the Qur'an: Commentaries on Selected Verses, Tughra Books, 2012. ISBN 1597842648
  • Toward Global Civilization Love and Tolerance, Tughra Books, 2010.
  • From Seed to Cedar: Nurturing the Spiritual Needs in Children, Tughra Books, 2013. ISBN 1597842788
  • Terror and Suicide Attacks: An Islamic Perspective, Tughra Books, 2008. ISBN 1932099743
  • Journey to Noble Ideals: Droplets of Wisdom from the Heart (Broken Jug), Tughra Books, 2014. ISBN 1597843482
  • Speech and Power of Expression, Tughra Books, 2010. ISBN 1597842168
  • Selected Prayers of Prophet Muhammad, Tughra Books, 2012. ISBN 1597842265

Reception

Martin Luther King Jr. International Chapel at Morehouse College awarded its 2015 Gandhi King Ikeda Peace Award to Gülen in recognition of his lifelong dedication to promoting peace and human rights.[198][199][200]

Gülen topped the 2008 Top 100 Public Intellectuals Poll and came out as the most influential thinker.[201]

Gülen was named as one of TIME magazine's World's 100 Most Influential People in 2013.[202]

In 2015, Oklahoma City Thunder basketball player Enes Kanter said that he was excluded from the Turkish national basketball team for his public support of Gülen.[203] Kanter was disowned by his family in 2016 due to his support for Gülen.[204]

Gülen was listed as one of the 500 most influential Muslims by the Royal Islamic Strategic Studies Centre in Amman, Jordan.[205][206]

Gülen was listed on the Watkins' Spiritual 100 List for 2019 as one of the '100 Most Spiritually Influential Living People'.

Rise Up (Colors of Peace) album
Cover of album Rise Up (Colors of Peace)

Rise Up (Colors of Peace) was a musical project to turn Gülen's poems and writings in Turkish language into songs. A total of 50 poems were sent to various Muslim and non-Muslim artists from various countries, who were free to pick, and then compose and vocalize the poem chosen, record it in their own country and send it back for inclusion in the planned album. Reportedly, no restrictions were put on the artists in using instrumentation, despite reservations by stricter Muslim interpretations about music and use of musical instruments. The album Rise Up (Colors of Peace) turned into an album of world music encompassing various genres like jazz, pop, flamenco, rai, Indian music among others.[207] The artists appearing (in order of appearance on the track list) were: The Good Morning Diary, Maher Zain, Faudel, Cristelo Duo featuring Bruno Gouveia, Ryan Shaw, Natacha Atlas, Bon Bon, KK & Reet, Mazachigno featuring Ely Bruna, Bahroma, Carmen Paris, Kobi Farhi & Ruba Shamshoum. The project took more than two years to realize and the album was released in 2013 by Nil Production and Universal Music.

See also

Further reading

Notes
  1. In Lester Kurtz's (of University of Texas, Austin) words, "One of the most striking operationalizations of Gulen's fusion of commitment and tolerance is the nature of the Gulen movement, as it is often called, which has established hundreds of schools in many countries as a consequence of his belief in the importance of knowledge, and example in the building of a better world. The schools are a form of service to humanity designed to promote learning in a broader sense and to avoid explicit Islamic propaganda." Kurtz also cites in the same work the comments of Thomas Michel, General Secretary of the Vatican Secretariat for Inter-religious Dialogue, after a visit to a school in Mindanao, Philippines, where the local people suffered from a civil war, as follows: "In a region where kidnapping is a frequent occurrence, along with guerrilla warfare, summary raids, arrests, disappearances and killings by military and para-military forces, the school is offering Muslim and Christian Filipino children, along with an educational standard of high quality, a more positive way of living and relating to each other." Kurtz adds: "The purpose of the schools movement, therefore, is to lay the foundations for a more humane, tolerant citizenry of the world where people are expected to cultivate their own faith perspectives and also promote the well being of others... It is significant to note that the movement has been so successful in offering high quality education in its schools, which recruit the children of elites and government officials, that it is beginning to lay the groundwork for high-level allies, especially in Central Asia, where they have focused much of their effort." See, Lester R. Kurtz, "Gulen's Paradox: Combining Commitment and Tolerance," Muslim World, Vol. 95, July 2005; 379–381.

References

Specific citations:

  1. Horne, Matt (24 January 2013). "Reclaiming Tolerance: A. J. Conyers and Fethullah Gülen".
  2. jgibbs (23 April 2015). "Gandhi King Ikeda Award for Peace Ceremony". theatlanticinstitute.org. Archived from the original on 18 April 2018. Retrieved 18 April 2018.
  3. "Fethullah Gulen Awarded the 2015 Gandhi King Ikeda Peace Award – Rumi Forum". rumiforum.org.
  4. Erol Nazim Gulay, The Theological thought of Fethullah Gulen: Reconciling Science and Islam (St Antony's College Oxford University May 2007). p. 57
  5. Duderija, Adis (2014). Maqasid al-Shari'a and Contemporary Reformist Muslim Thought: An Examination. ISBN 9781137319418. Still, Gulen repeatedly states that he propagates neither tajdīd, nor ijtihād, nor reform and that he is just a follower of Islam, simply a Muslim. He is very careful about divorcing himself from any reformist, political, or Islamist discourse. Gulen's conscious dislike of using Islam as a discursive political instrument, which was a distinct trait in Nursi as well, indicates an ethicalized approach to Islam from a spiritual perspective.
  6. "It's Not Us—It's Him". 3 December 2019.
  7. Erol Nazim Gulay (May 2007). "The Theological thought of Fethullah Gulen: Reconciling Science and Islam" (PDF). St. Antony's College Oxford University. p. 56.
  8. "Fethullah Gülen : " L'échec de l'expérience démocratique turque n'est pas dû à l'adhésion aux valeurs islamiques mais à leur trahison "". Le Monde. 25 February 2019.
  9. "Coup plotter Gülen accuses Turkish gov't of turning its back on Islam's democratic principles". DailySabah.
  10. "Islam is compatible with democracy". The Nation.
  11. "Fethullah Gulen: Erdogan has destroyed Turkish democracy". english.alarabiya.net.
  12. AsiaNews.it. "Fetullah Gülen: Behind the failure of Turkish democracy is the betrayal of Islam". asianews.it.
  13. Peker, Emre. "Turkey's Recep Tayyip Erdogan Turns on Former Brother-in-Arms Fethullah Gulen". WSJ.
  14. Yeginsu, Ceylan (4 August 2016). "Turkey Issues a Warrant for Fethullah Gulen, Cleric Accused in Coup". The New York Times.
  15. "Fethullah Gülen". rlp.hds.harvard.edu.
  16. "Is Gulen a Turkish nationalist?". Gulen Movement. 7 January 2017.
  17. Analytica, Oxford. "Gulen Inspires Muslims Worldwide" Check |url= value (help). Forbes.
  18. "Fethullah Gülen's Official Web Site – Gülen's Works". En.fgulen.com. Archived from the original on 11 September 2014. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  19. Bilefsky, Dan; Arsu, Sebnem (24 April 2012). "Turkey Feels Sway of Fethullah Gulen, a Reclusive Cleric". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 8 March 2016.
  20. TM. "Turkey to revoke citizenship of 130 abroad including Gülen, HDP deputies – Turkish Minute".
  21. "Progressive Islamic Thought, Civil Society and the Gülen Movement in the National Context: Parallels with Indonesia – Fethullah Gülen's Official Web Site". fgulen.com.
  22. Helen Rose Fuchs Ebaugh, The Gülen Movement: A Sociological Analysis of a Civic Movement Rooted in Moderate Islam, p 26. ISBN 1402098944
  23. "Photos: Muslim retreat center in Saylorsburg". poconorecord.com. Retrieved 17 December 2018.
  24. Los Angeles Times (20 January 2014). "From his Pa. compound, Fethullah Gulen shakes up Turkey". latimes.com.
  25. Adam Taylor (18 December 2013). "Fethullah Gulen's Pennsylvania Home – Business Insider". Business Insider.
  26. "Turkey coup: What is Gulen movement and what does it want?". 21 July 2016 – via bbc.com.
  27. "Is Fethullah Gülen an Islamist?". Gulen Movement. 15 May 2012.
  28. "Turkey on Diplomatic Push to Close Schools Linked to Influential Cleric". Voanews.com. 1 September 2017. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
  29. "Real and imagined threats: the shared past of AKP and the Gülen movement | World | DW | 27.07.2016". DW. Retrieved 21 September 2017.
  30. Fabricius, Peter. "Turkey : Exiled cleric Gulen explains why he thinks Erdogan has branded him a terrorist". Daily Maverick.
  31. "The 'ally' to 'enemy # 1': Gülen Movement (1)". Ahval.
  32. The good, the bad and the Gülenists – via ecfr.eu.
  33. "The Turkish Coup Attempt: The Gülen Movement vs. the State | Middle East Policy Council". mepc.org.
  34. Balci, Bayram. "Turkey's Gülen Movement: Between Social Activism and Politics". Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
  35. Akkoc, Raziye (24 February 2015). "A parallel state within Turkey? How the country's democracy came under attack from two men's rivalry" – via telegraph.co.uk.
  36. Birnbaum, Michael (14 June 2013). "In Turkey protests, splits in Erdogan's base". The Washington Post. Retrieved 21 September 2017.
  37. "Turkey challenged by terror in 2015". TRT World (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 3 February 2016. Retrieved 28 January 2016.
  38. "Gulen faces life in prison on coup attempt charges". TRT World (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 3 February 2016. Retrieved 29 January 2016.
  39. "Turkey: Erdogan faces new protests over corruption scandal". Digital Journal. 28 December 2013. Retrieved 31 December 2013.
  40. "İstanbul'da yolsuzluk ve rüşvet operasyonu". 17 December 2013.
  41. "Profile: Fethullah Gulen's Hizmet movement". BBC News. 18 December 2013. Retrieved 31 December 2013.
  42. "Damaging Democracy: The U.S., Fethullah Gülen, and Turkey's Upheaval – Foreign Policy Research Institute". fpri.org/.
  43. "The Gulen movement: a self-exiled imam challenges Turkey's Erdoğan". The Christian Science Monitor. 29 December 2013. Retrieved 31 December 2013.
  44. "CIA collaborated with Gülen – Lobbyist". Ahval.
  45. Franks, Tim (27 January 2014). "Fethullah Gulen: Powerful but reclusive Turkish cleric". BBC News.
  46. "Cleric Accused of Plotting Turkish Coup Attempt: 'I Have Stood Against All Coups'". NPR.org.
  47. "Istanbul court issues new arrest warrant for Gulen". Anadolu Agency. Retrieved 29 January 2016.
  48. "Turkish Court accepts prosecutors request of arrest warrant for Fethullah Gülen". DailySabah. Retrieved 29 January 2016.
  49. "Turkey to demand extradition of Fethullah Gulen from US". TRT World (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 3 February 2016. Retrieved 29 January 2016.
  50. "Turkish prosecutors seek life sentence for Fetullah Gulen". Anadolu Agency. Retrieved 29 January 2016.
  51. "Prof. Dr. Henri Barkey: Nobody in Wash, DC believes that Gulen is terrorist". aktif haber. 9 March 2016. Archived from the original on 10 March 2016. Retrieved 10 March 2016.
  52. "How does Washington view Gulen group". medyascope.tv. 9 March 2016. Retrieved 10 March 2016.
  53. "Turkey challenged by terror in 2015". TRT World (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 10 March 2016. Retrieved 7 April 2016.
  54. "Fetullah Gülen: Behind the failure of Turkish democracy is the betrayal of Islam". asianews.it.
  55. "How far they have travelled". The Economist. 6 March 2008. Retrieved 2 May 2012.
  56. "Profile: Fethullah Gulen's Hizmet movement". BBC News. 18 December 2013.
  57. "Turkey officially designates Gulen religious group as terrorists". Reuters. 31 May 2016.
  58. "Pakistanis laud 'landmark' verdict on FETO terror group". aa.com.tr.
  59. "Organization of Islamic Cooperation declares FETÖ a terrorist group". DailySabah.
  60. "OIC lists Gulen network as 'terror group'". 19 October 2016.
  61. "GCC declare Gulen group a 'terrorist organisation'". 14 October 2016.
  62. "Muhammed Fethullah Gülen – Islamic Studies – Oxford Bibliographies – obo". Retrieved 15 January 2017.
  63. Valkenberg, Pim (2015). Renewing Islam by Service. CUA Press. p. 72. ISBN 978-0-8132-2755-9.
  64. Çelik, Gürkan (2010). The Gülen Movement: Building Social Cohesion Through Dialogue and Education. Eburon Uitgeverij B.V. p. 42. ISBN 978-90-5972-369-6.
  65. Marty, Martin E. (2015). Hizmet Means Service: Perspectives on an Alternative Path within Islam. University of California Press. p. 19. ISBN 978-0-520-96074-9.
  66. Wagner, Walter H. (2015). Beginnings and Endings. Işık Yayıncılık Ticaret. p. 11. ISBN 978-1-935295-70-9.
  67. Haynes, Jeffrey (2013). Religion and Democratizations. Routledge. p. 189. ISBN 978-1-317-98646-1.
  68. Hendrick, Joshua D. (2014). Gülen: The Ambiguous Politics of Market Islam in Turkey and the World. NYU Press. pp. 70–1. ISBN 978-1-4798-0046-9.
  69. Ebaugh, Helen Rose (2009). The Gülen Movement: A Sociological Analysis of a Civic Movement Rooted in Moderate Islam. Springer Science & Business Media. p. 23. ISBN 978-1-4020-9894-9.
  70. Ebaugh, Helen Rose (2009). The Gülen Movement: A Sociological Analysis of a Civic Movement Rooted in Moderate Islam. Springer Science & Business Media. p. 24. ISBN 978-1-4020-9894-9.
  71. Marty, Martin E. (2015). Hizmet Means Service: Perspectives on an Alternative Path within Islam. University of California Press. p. 20. ISBN 978-0-520-96074-9.
  72. "Gulen-Years of Education". fgulen.com. Retrieved 8 December 2014.
  73. "Who is Fethullah Gülen – His Life". Gulen Movement.
  74. "The Gulen Movement: Communicating Modernization, Tolerance, and Dialogue in the Islamic World". The International Journal of the Humanities. Ijh.cgpublisher.com. pp. 67–78. Archived from the original on 15 August 2014. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  75. "1941–1959 Hayat Kronolojisi – Fethullah Gülen Web Sitesi". fgulen.com.
  76. "The Influence of the Gülen Movement in the Emergence of a Turkish Cultural Third Way – Fethullah Gülen's Official Web Site". fgulen.com.
  77. "The Journalists and Writers Foundation". Archived from the original on 17 July 2016. Retrieved 1 January 2017.
  78. "About the Journalists and Writers Foundation". Archived from the original on 27 June 2016. Retrieved 1 January 2017.
  79. "Biu.ac.il". Archived from the original on 12 December 2004.
  80. "Clement M. Henry, Rodney Wilson, The politics of Islamic Finance, Edinburgh University Press (2004), p 236". Eupjournals.com. 2004. Archived from the original on 22 January 2013. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  81. "U.S. charter schools tied to powerful Turkish imam". 60 Minutes. CBS News. 13 May 2012. Retrieved 14 May 2012.
  82. "From ally to scapegoat: Fethullah Gulen, the man behind the myth – DW – 06.04.2018". DW.COM.
  83. "Turkish investigation into Islamic sect expanded". BBC News. 21 June 1999. Retrieved 2 May 2010.
  84. "Clement M. Henry, Rodney Wilson, The Politics of Islamic Finance, (Edinburgh University Press 2004), p. 236". Eupjournals.com. 2004. Archived from the original on 22 January 2013. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  85. "Gülen's answers to claims made based on the video tapes taken from some of his recorded speeches". En.fgulen.com. 24 September 2001. Archived from the original on 10 March 2016. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  86. Dogan Koc, Strategic Defamation of Fethullah Gülen: English Vs. Turkish, p. 24. ISBN 0761859306
  87. "Wwrn.org". Archived from the original on 27 September 2007.
  88. Filkins, Dexter. "Turkey's Thirty-Year Coup". The New Yorker.
  89. see Joshua D. Hendrick: Gülen: The Ambiguous Politics of Market Islam in Turkey and the World. New York University Press, 2013, 58–62.
  90. Hendrick, Joshua D. (22 October 2014). Gülen: The Ambiguous Politics of Market Islam in Turkey and the World. NYU Press. p. 61. ISBN 9781479800469.
  91. "Turkey's Thirty-Year Coup". The New Yorker. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
  92. Arango, Tim; Hubbard, Ben (19 July 2016). "Turkey Pursues Cleric Living in U.S., Blamed as Coup Mastermind". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 7 January 2017.
  93. "Turkey issues Fethullah Gulen arrest warrant". BBC. 19 December 2014. Retrieved 19 December 2014.
  94. https://www.poconorecord.com/news/20200825/chestnut-retreat-center-offers-look-inside-their-saylorsburg-facility-and-its-mission
  95. Misinco, Christina Tatu, John. "Guard at Fethullah Gulen's compound in Poconos fires warning shot to scare away intruder, prompting police response". themorningcall.com.
  96. "Turkey Blog: Turning Away From Gulen's 'Golden Generation'". RadioFreeEurope/RadioLiberty.
  97. "Coup plotter or moderate religious leader? Yle meets Turkey's most wanted man". Yle Uutiset.
  98. "Reconsidering Fethullah Gülen". Commentary Magazine. 20 May 2015.
  99. "Turkey's Thirty-Year Coup". The New Yorker. Retrieved 18 October 2017.
  100. "Followers discuss who will replace Gülen – LOCAL". Hurriyetdailynews.com. 13 September 2011. Retrieved 18 October 2017.
  101. "Profile: Fethullah Gulen's Hizmet movement". BBC News. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
  102. Arango, Tim (26 February 2014). "Turkish Leader Disowns Trials That Helped Him Tame Military". The New York Times. Retrieved 27 February 2014. In 2005, years before the trials, a man affiliated with the Gulen movement approached Eric S. Edelman, then the American ambassador, at a party in Istanbul and handed him an envelope containing a handwritten document that supposedly laid out a plan for an imminent coup. But as Mr. Edelman recounted, he gave the documents to his colleagues and they were determined to be forgeries.
  103. Dan Bilefsky; Sebnem Arsu (24 April 2012). "Turkey Feels Sway of Reclusive Cleric in the U.S." The New York Times. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
  104. Hurriyet Daily News, 16 November 2011, Banned book goes on sale in Istanbul book fair
  105. Helen Rose Fuchs Ebaugh, The Gülen Movement: A Sociological Analysis of a Civic Movement Rooted in Moderate Islam, p 38. ISBN 1402098944
  106. Fethullah Gulen (2010). Toward a Global Civilization of Love and Tolerance. Tughra Books. ISBN 978-1932099683.
  107. "A select biography of Fethullah Gülen". Gulen Movement. 20 July 2017.
  108. "US-Turkey Relations From a New Right Perspective – Conservative Daily News". 14 February 2019.
  109. Tamer Balci (2013). "Islam and Democracy in the Thought of Nursi and Gulen". In Christopher L. Miller (ed.). The Gülen Hizmet Movement: Circumspect Activism in Faith-Based Reform. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. p. 82. ISBN 9781443845076.
  110. M. Hakan Yavuz, Toward an Islamic Enlightenment: The Gülen Movement (Oxford University Press, 2013), p. 39.
  111. M. Hakan Yavuz, Toward an Islamic Enlightenment: The Gülen Movement (Oxford University Press, 2013), pp. 39–40.
  112. M. Hakan Yavuz, Toward an Islamic Enlightenment: The Gülen Movement (Oxford University Press, 2013), pp. 40–41.
  113. "Why do we accuse the Gülen movement?". 21 May 2012.
  114. "İlhan Cihaner: İntikam hisleri içinde değilim; cemaat silahlı terör örgütü değil, suç örgütü olabilir – Gündem". T24. Archived from the original on 7 September 2017. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
  115. Arango, Tim (26 February 2014). "Turkish Leader Disowns Trials That Helped Him Tame Military". The New York Times. Retrieved 27 February 2014. Whether the corruption charges are justified or not – there has been plenty of leaked evidence, especially wiretapped conversations, that appears incriminating – the corruption probe has laid bare the influence of the Gulen movement within the Turkish state, which had largely been suspected but hard to prove.
  116. "Turkey's Fethullah Gulen denies corruption probe links". BBC News. 27 January 2014. Retrieved 4 February 2014.
  117. Joe Parkinson; Ayla Albayrak (20 January 2014). "From His Refuge in the Poconos, Reclusive Imam Fethullah Gulen Roils Turkey". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 22 January 2014.
  118. Tim Franks (27 January 2014). "Fethullah Gulen: Powerful but reclusive Turkish cleric". BBC. Retrieved 5 February 2014.
  119. "Is Fethullah Gulen Turkey's own Trotsky?". New Europe. 20 July 2016.
  120. "Turkey After the Failed Coup: Fascism". The Algemeiner Journal. 21 July 2016.
  121. "Turkish PM: coup suspects' testimony points to Gülen's involvement". The Guardian. 26 July 2016.
  122. Amana Fontanella-Khan (16 July 2016). "Fetullah Gülen: Turkey coup may have been 'staged' by Erdoğan government". The Guardian. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
  123. "Gulen Accuses Erdogan of 'Slow-Motion Coup' in Turkey". VOA. 26 July 2016.
  124. "Turkish prosecutor falsely claimed Morton I. Abramowitz was former CIA director". 22 May 2019.
  125. "Turkey demands extradition of cleric Fethullah Gulen from U.S." USA Today. 19 July 2016.
  126. Daily Press Briefing by the Press Secretary Josh Earnest, 7/19/2016 The White House website.
  127. "Turkish Premier Demands U.S. Help With Gulen". The Wall Street Journal. 26 July 2016.
  128. "U.S. says evaluating new Turkish documents on alleged coup leader". Reuters. 5 August 2016.
  129. (www.dw.com), Deutsche Welle. "Turkey submits documents to US seeking Gulen extradition – News – DW.COM – 05.08.2016".
  130. "Washington Post: Turkish evidence for Gulen extradition pre-dates coup attempt".
  131. James V. Grimaldi, Dion Nissenbaum and Margaret Coker (24 March 2017). "Ex-CIA Director: Mike Flynn and Turkish Officials Discussed Removal of Erdogan Foe From U.S." The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 24 March 2017.
  132. "Former Trump aide Flynn says lobbying may have helped Turkey". The Big Story. Retrieved 9 March 2017.
  133. Leonnig, Carol D.; Nakashima, Ellen; Dawsey, Josh; Hamburger, Tom (15 October 2019). "Giuliani pressed Trump to eject Muslim cleric from U.S., a top priority of Turkish president, former officials say". The Washington Post.
  134. "Turkey's anti-Gulen crackdown ripples far and wide". Reuters. 30 July 2016.
  135. "In Debt to Turkey, Somalia Shuts Network Tied to Fethullah Gulen". The New York Times. 30 July 2016.
  136. "Attack on Gülen Movement Increasingly a Cornerstone of Turkey's Foreign Policy in the Balkans".
  137. Gamal Essam el-Din (25 July 2016). "'The govt should give asylum to Turkish opposition figure Gulen,' says Egypt MP". Ahram Online. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
  138. Grimaldi, James V.; Nissenbaum, Dion; Coker, Margaret (24 March 2017). "Ex-CIA Director: Mike Flynn and Turkish Officials Discussed Removal of Erdogan Foe From U.S." – via wsj.com.
  139. "What Mike Flynn Did for Turkey". The New Yorker. Retrieved 28 September 2017.
  140. "The Michael Flynn Scandal Just Got A Lot Worse". Fortune.com. Retrieved 28 September 2017.
  141. Politics (24 March 2017). "James Woolsey and Mike Flynn Turkey Gulen". Business Insider. Retrieved 28 September 2017.
  142. Fulya OZERKAN (14 July 2017). "New Turkey purge on eve of failed coup anniversary". Yahoo.com. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
  143. "Fethullah Gulen's Message on the Anniversary of the Coup Attempt in Turkey". Hizmetnews.com. 15 July 2017. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
  144. "Top court approves revoke of Gülen's 'special passport' – POLITICS". Hurriyetdailynews.com. Retrieved 14 September 2017.
  145. Hannah Lucinda Smith, Istanbul (6 September 2017). "Fethullah Gulen: Erdogan rival left stateless in passport purge". The Times. Retrieved 14 September 2017.
  146. "Gülen resorts to UN to investigate Turkey's coup". Hizmetnews.com. 15 July 2016. Retrieved 28 September 2017.
  147. "Fethullah Gulen, Exiled Cleric Accused of Turkey Coup Attempt Plot: 'I Have Stood Against All Coups' : Parallels". NPR. 11 July 2017. Retrieved 18 October 2017.
  148. "A pastor becomes a pawn in a spat between America and Turkey". The Economist. 30 September 2017. Retrieved 18 October 2017.
  149. "Turkey's Erdogan Suggests Swap: Jailed U.S. Pastor For Turkish Cleric : The Two-Way". NPR. Retrieved 2 October 2017.
  150. "Give us Gülen if you want arrested pastor Andrew Brunson to be freed: Erdoğan tells US". Hürriyet Daily News.
  151. https://nytimes.com: Turkey Rebuffs Trump, Won't Send Jailed US Pastor Back|
  152. "Erdogan suggests freeing imprisoned US pastor for Gulen extradition". Middle East Eye. 29 September 2017. Retrieved 18 October 2017.
  153. "In Turkey, The Man To Blame For Most Everything Is A U.S.-Based Cleric : Parallels". NPR. 4 September 2016. Retrieved 18 October 2017.
  154. TurkeyPurge (27 November 2017). "Gülen-linked businessman jailed after forced return from Sudan".
  155. "Trump administration officials last month asked federal law enforcement agencies to examine legal ways of removing exiled Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, according to two senior U.S. officials and two other people briefed on the requests. The effort includes directives to the Justice Department and FBI that officials reopen Turkey's case for his extradition, as well as a request to the Homeland Security Department for information about his legal status, the four people said". NBC News.
  156. "Two Men Charged with Conspiracy and Acting as Agents of a Foreign Government" (Press release). Washington, DC. US Department of Justice. 17 December 2018. Retrieved 17 December 2018.
  157. Winter, Tom; Ainsley, Julia; Williams, Pete; Schapiro, Rich (17 December 2018). "Two ex-associates of Michael Flynn charged with trying to influence U.S. politicians". NBCNews.com. Retrieved 17 December 2018.
  158. Gulen, Fethullah (11 June 2017). "Muslims' unique responsibility to fight terror". POLITICO.
  159. Ebaugh, Helen Rose (2009). The Gülen Movement: A Sociological Analysis of a Civic Movement Rooted in Moderate Islam. Springer Science & Business Media. p. 4. ISBN 978-1-4020-9894-9.
  160. Spiegelman, Margaret. "What Scares Turkey's Women?". The Daily Beast. Retrieved 28 November 2012.
  161. Ali Unal (Author) (1 October 2000). Advocate of Dialogue: Fethullah Gülen. ISBN 978-0970437013.
  162. "Gülen: Alevi-Sunni brotherhood should not be marred by bridge controversy". Today's Zaman. 19 June 2013. Archived from the original on 21 December 2014. Retrieved 21 December 2014.
  163. Elise Massicard (2013). The Alevis in Turkey and Europe: Identity and Managing Territorial Diversity (illustrated ed.). Routledge. pp. 109–10. ISBN 9780415667968.
  164. Greg Barton; Paul Weller; Ihsan Yilmaz (18 December 2014). The Muslim World and Politics in Transition: Creative Contributions of the Gulen Movement. A&C Black. p. 119. ISBN 9781441158734.
  165. Erol Nazim Gulay, The Theological thought of Fethullah Gulen: Reconciling Science and Islam (St. Antony's College Oxford University May 2007). p. 1
  166. "Schooling Islam". Princeton University Press. Archived from the original on 6 February 2010.
  167. "Portrait of Fethullah Gülen, A Modern Turkish-Islamic Reformist". Qantara.de. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  168. Guest Editor Zeki Saritoprak (Editor) (1 January 2005). "Thomas Michel S.J., Sufism and Modernity in the Thought of Fethullah Gülen, The Muslim World, Vol. 95 No. 3, July 2005, pp. 345–5". Retrieved 24 August 2014.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
  169. Kalyoncu, Mehmet (2008). Mehmet Kalyoncu, A Civilian Response to Ethno-Religious Conflict: The Gülen Movement in Southeast Turkey (Tughra Books, 2008), pp. 19–40. ISBN 9781597840255. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  170. Berna Turam. "Berna Turam, Between Islam and the State: The Politics of Engagement (Stanford University Press 2006) p. 61". Sup.org. Archived from the original on 11 June 2011. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  171. Guest Editor Zeki Saritoprak (Editor) (1 January 2005). "Saritoprak, Z. and Griffith, S. Fethullah Gülen and the 'People of the Book': A Voice from Turkey for Interfaith Dialogue, The Muslim World, Vol. 95 No. 3, July 2005, p.337-8". Retrieved 24 August 2014.CS1 maint: extra text: authors list (link)
  172. "The Role of the Spiritual Guide | Fethullah Gülen Hocaefendi'nin sohbetleri".
  173. Christopher L. Miller (2013). The Gülen Hizmet Movement: Circumspect Activism in Faith-Based Reform. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. p. 76. ISBN 9781443845076.
  174. Akyol, Mustafa (22 July 2016). "Opinion | Who Was Behind the Coup Attempt in Turkey?" – via NYTimes.com.
  175. "'Dear Muslims, don't wait for a savior' by Mustafa Akyol – Baraka Institute".
  176. "Claiming to be the Mahdi is Deviation – Fethullah Gülen's Official Web Site". fgulen.com.
  177. "Gülen movement is fake Mahdi, says Turkey's Religious Directorate head". Hürriyet Daily News.
  178. Mustafa Akyol (22 May 2013). "Is Gulen Movement Against Peace With PKK?". Al-monitor.com. Retrieved 7 September 2017.
  179. "What's behind AKP's allegations of Gulen-PKK ties?". Al-Monitor. 15 August 2016. Retrieved 10 January 2017.
  180. Nordland, Rod (10 December 2016). "As Turkey Cracks Down, Kurdish Mayors Pack Bags for Jail". The New York Times. Retrieved 10 January 2017.
  181. "What's behind AKP's allegations of Gulen-PKK ties?". Al-Monitor. 15 August 2016. Retrieved 13 December 2016.
  182. "Fetullah Gülen'in Kürt planı!". Rudaw. Retrieved 13 December 2016.
  183. Gulen, Fethullah (3 February 2015). "Opinion | Fethullah Gulen: Turkey's Eroding Democracy" – via NYTimes.com.
  184. skyron.co.uk. "European Muslims, Civility and Public Life Perspectives on and From the Gülen Movement". Continuumbooks.com. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  185. "Fethullah Gülen Web Sitesi – Devlet ve Şeriat". Tr.fgulen.com. 31 October 2006. Archived from the original on 13 August 2014. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  186. "Fethullah Gülen's Official Web Site – Women Confined and Mistreated". En.fgulen.com. 8 May 2008. Archived from the original on 17 September 2014. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  187. "Fethullah Gülen: A life dedicated to peace and humanity- True Muslims Cannot Be Terrorists". En.fgulen.com. 4 February 2002. Archived from the original on 17 September 2014. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  188. "Importance of Gulen Movement in the Post 9/11 Era: Co-existenceFethullah Gulen". Fethullah Gulen. Archived from the original on 22 October 2014. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  189. "A Real Muslim cannot be a Terrorist". Fethullah Gulen. 23 March 2004. Retrieved 20 October 2014.
  190. Günter Seufert (January 2014). "Is the Fethullah Gülen Movement Overstretching Itself?" (Research Paper). Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
  191. Lauria, Joe. "Reclusive Turkish Imam Criticizes Gaza Flotilla". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 4 June 2010.
  192. "Turkey and Syria: An explosive border". The Economist. 18 May 2013. Retrieved 24 August 2014.
  193. "Gülen warns against Turkey's unilateral war". TODAY'S ZAMAN. 7 October 2014. Archived from the original on 21 December 2014. Retrieved 21 December 2014.
  194. Halil Karaveli (12 November 2012). "Erdogan Pays for His Foreign Policy". The National Interest. Retrieved 21 December 2014.
  195. https://mirrorspectator.com/2020/05/18/turmoil-in-turkey-on-letter-by-gulen-recognizing-the-armenian-genocide/
  196. "Gulen's publications". tr.fgulen.com (in Turkish). Archived from the original on 11 March 2014. Retrieved 2 March 2014.
  197. "Gulen books in English". en.fgulen.com. Archived from the original on 11 September 2014. Retrieved 29 January 2014.
  198. "ZAMAN". Archived from the original on 16 April 2015.
  199. "Fethullah Gulen Awarded 2015 Gandhi King Ikeda Peace Award".
  200. "Link" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 13 May 2015.
  201. "2008 Oscar nominations – Prospect Magazine". Archived from the original on 24 April 2011.
  202. "Fethullah Gulen Named in TIME Magazine's "World's 100 Most influential people in the world" in 2013". Niagara Foundation.
  203. "Controversy looms as Gülen follower Enes Kanter left out of national team". Hürriyet Daily News. 24 June 2015. Retrieved 18 December 2015.
  204. "Symbol of a troubled Turkey, pro-Gulen NBA star splits with family". Reuters. 9 August 2016.
  205. "Gülen, Hodjaefendi Fethullah – The Muslim 500".
  206. Schleifer, Abdallah (2011). The Muslim 500: The World's 500 Most Influential Muslims, 2012. Amman, Jordan: The Royal Islamic Strategic Studies Centre. p. 55. ISBN 978-9957-428-37-2.
  207. Fethullah Gülen. "Fethullah Gülen's Official Web Site – Islamic scholar Gülen's poems turned into songs for international album". Archived from the original on 3 March 2016. Retrieved 20 January 2016.

General references:

Multi-media
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.